If the day ever comes (highly unlikely) that the UIL no longer has any authority over officiating assignments, that is the day that TASO needs to develop an organization-wide assignment policy. IMH-but experienced-O, here what a policy would look like:
-Schools would still be allowed to have a limited number of PRE-SEASON 'scratches,' say, maximum 10% of a chapter. But, if a Chapter works set crews, scratching an individual on that crew scratches the entire crew, and those count toward the 10% total. There are to be NO 'preferred' lists, and there are no in-season 'scratches' (exceptions: documented bona-fide conflict of interest, documented abuse or gross unprofessionalism by an official). A school may request a crew from ANY TASO chapter, for any assignment. Home teams are responsible for requesting assignments for their home games. Schools MUST submit ALL requests for regular season assignments on, or before, March 31 of each year.
In addition to the restrictions imposed by the TASO Code of Ethics:
-No official shall receive more than one varsity assignment per week (including playoffs), unless all qualified officials/crews in that chapter have received an assignment. Assignments in excess of available officials/crews will be rotated among qualified officials/crews.
-No official shall be assigned to work the same team more than twice (once as the 'home' team, once as the visiting team) during the regular season.
-No official shall be assigned to work the same team in consecutive weeks during the regular season and playoffs.
The idea is to spread the games around. Nothing is more demoralizing, and counterproductive to "retention," than seeing the same crews getting multiple assignments per week, and getting the playoff games. Some folks say, "We need to put our best people out there for the "big" games and playoff games." Well, let's teach and train these guys to attain a level where they can work any assignment, and then share the wealth. (That was the Blackwood system, and it worked marvelously. I can say that, to a man, we all believed Mr. Blackwood's system was the fairest one ever put into practice. Thank you, Mr. Blackwood. Rest in Peace.)
We'd leave it to the Chapters to determine who makes the assignments, but an assignment committee comprised of members across all divisions would be most effective, even if they only review and approve assignments made by the chapter assigner. That would provide oversight and accountability to the membership.
As to what constitutes a qualified official or crew, I have thoughts on that, too. But that's for another day.
Just the thoughts of an old man. I do not intend to get into a lengthy debate about any of this.