I would love to see it implemented for the State Championship games at least. As someone who has been a victim of "The Screen of Doom", I would like the ability to get it right. Everyone and their dog can see it. I can look up and see it (I didnt at the time because I couldnt change it anyway). It is right there blatant as all get out that its wrong... but we cant do anything about it. I dont like that.
What was it, 3 years ago, Navasota vs Argyle, they could have really used it then.... Cost Argyle the game.
TexDoc laid out some arguments, but I really dont find most of them very persuasive. Mainly, these are veterans working these games, so i think the added twist of replay will not be too disruptive. People are going to mess up with or without replay, but it hurts our credibility (I think) when we cant correct something that is obviously wrong.
The one argument i did find persuasive was the R's (and everyone else) needs to bone up on Rule 12. Most of us ignore that if we arent on the college track.
That is my .02 worth.