31
NCAA Discussion / Re: Shortening Periods
« Last post by bossman72 on Yesterday at 08:34:37 AM »No, no specific time. If you're making them zero minutes, that's the same as ending the game, which you are allowed to do by mutual agreement.
Recent Posts
32
National Federation Discussion / Re: Illegal substitution vs illegal participation
« Last post by lawdog on Yesterday at 08:33:50 AM »Concur. If the extra player is trying to get off but doesn’t, I’m fine with a live-ball illegal substitution foul. Otherwise, the defense deserves the big walkoff.
Agree and Disagree. The play should be shut down before the snap to avoid the big 15. But if we fail to do that, and they are on the field when snapped, ya then we have to go with the 15.
33
NCAA Discussion / Re: Ball State v. Missouri State confusion play
« Last post by bossman72 on Yesterday at 08:33:12 AM »Why would they ever make this ready for play? We've been taught since youth football that you don't let a team run an uncontested play.
I agree with Elvis. DOG if necessary, but the LOS should be telling them to get on the field. If they're defiant, then DOG.
I agree with Elvis. DOG if necessary, but the LOS should be telling them to get on the field. If they're defiant, then DOG.
34
NCAA Discussion / Re: Fans Subject to Rules?
« Last post by bossman72 on Yesterday at 08:30:38 AM »This was on a Shaw training tape in 2021. Beer cans were being chucked on the field and the visiting team was getting hit. The crowd was flagged for 15 and Shaw said we can't do that. It's up to game management. If game management isn't doing anything, then you have to live with the rain of beer cans and paper and tortillas and just play the game.
35
NCAA Discussion / Re: Foul sheet and codes
« Last post by bossman72 on Yesterday at 08:20:26 AM »Only 2 attachments allowed per post. Here's the foul codes.
36
NCAA Discussion / Re: Foul sheet and codes
« Last post by bossman72 on Yesterday at 08:18:29 AM »Here are a couple that I use. Print all of these double sided.
1) Foul codes listed both by category and alphabetical.
2) NCAA foul report with game info.
3) NCAA foul report without game info. More room for fouls since that's rarely the report handed in when it's with the chain crew.
1) Foul codes listed both by category and alphabetical.
2) NCAA foul report with game info.
3) NCAA foul report without game info. More room for fouls since that's rarely the report handed in when it's with the chain crew.
37
National Federation Discussion / Re: Illegal substitution vs illegal participation
« Last post by bama_stripes on Yesterday at 07:42:09 AM »Disagree. To be in formation at the snap is considered participating.
Concur. If the extra player is trying to get off but doesn’t, I’m fine with a live-ball illegal substitution foul. Otherwise, the defense deserves the big walkoff.
38
National Federation Discussion / Re: Why is a fumble behind the LOS not bean-bagged, but beyond LOS it is?
« Last post by bama_stripes on Yesterday at 07:34:39 AM »For years I refused to throw a bean bag on a fumble behind the LOS. This was partially because I knew there wouldnt be an enforcement spot there, and partially because I didn’t want to run back down the field to retrieve it if there was a long return.
Now I do. Not only does it stop complaining from the sidelines, as others have mentioned, but it might also possibly prevent an IW from a crewmate who didn’t see the ball become loose.
Now I do. Not only does it stop complaining from the sidelines, as others have mentioned, but it might also possibly prevent an IW from a crewmate who didn’t see the ball become loose.
39
Texas Topics / Re: Kickoff Tee
« Last post by Clear Lake ref on September 18, 2024, 08:47:44 PM »Similar vein tonight. On the try the tee was dropped at the 10, but a gate formation initially with no one even near the tee. Most of the attempts it just sat there.
40
Texas Topics / Re: Inadvertent Whistle and PF
« Last post by TxBJ on September 18, 2024, 08:31:47 PM »It is interesting that RR noted many years ago that the rule wasn’t clear, but it has never been fixed.