I for one appreciate the contributions from the college officials who post on this board. I see value in their expertise and the level of training they receive. I also appreciate the insight into intent and advantage philosophy. However, sometimes it does portray a negative connotation. If not careful, posts can be taken as, "This is the way we do it UP here at the next level, and so this is the way you should do it DOWN there." Plus, not every high school association interprets mechanics and even the rules identically, so there is a tension between what should be done and what is required from us from our association. For example, in regard to the numbering exception situation we have beat to death, I agree with the college guys in that we should not have to require 5 ineligibles on the line during a 4th down kick/try. Only problem is, my assigner has made the decision that is to be a foul for illegal formation. So we have conflicting interpretations. That brings frustration, especially when we are being looked down upon by those in the college ranks. My two cents.
My challenge and advice - Let's move on. Everybody needs to get along.