RefStripes.com

Football Officiating => National Federation Discussion => Topic started by: J12 on July 22, 2014, 04:30:12 PM

Title: "Goaltending"
Post by: J12 on July 22, 2014, 04:30:12 PM
        As I understand it, it's a foul for Unsportsmanlike Conduct to position a man under the goalpost and have him leap and deflect back a field goal attempt or conversion.

         But what exactly is the penalty for this? Does the field goal or conversion count as good and then a 15 yard penalty is assessed? Is it simply a 15 yard penalty and replay the down?

         Furthermore, under Federation rules, I would assume the "goaltended" ball is dead in the endzone. But in NCAA or NFL, is a "goaltended" ball still in play in the endzone. Could the kicking team then recover the ball in the endzone and get a touchdown.
Title: Re: "Goaltending"
Post by: GA Umpire on July 22, 2014, 05:35:43 PM
I do not know where you heard this misinformation about it being Unsportsmanlike Conduct, but below is the approved ruling from the 2014 NFHS Casebook.



 6.3.1 SITUATION B:

During a field-goal attempt, R1, who is in the end zone, leaps up and blocks the ball away from the crossbar.

RULING: Touchback. The touching by R1 in the end zone causes the ball to become dead, unless the ball caroms through the goal, thus scoring a field goal. This is not illegal batting, as the touching caused the kick to fail. (4-2-2d(2); 6-3-1b)
Title: Re: "Goaltending"
Post by: VALJ on July 23, 2014, 07:20:26 AM
Might be illegal in the NFL.  Legal is HS for sure, as GA Ump noted.
Title: Re: "Goaltending"
Post by: Kalle on July 23, 2014, 07:53:59 AM
In NCAA this is simply illegal batting, as it is illegal to bat loose balls (other than passes) in the end zone. The ball does remain live. If team A ends up with the ball, the penalty is from the previous spot (most likely declined by team A), otherwise it will be a safety after PSK enforcement.
Title: Re: "Goaltending"
Post by: Rulesman on July 23, 2014, 08:05:16 AM
In NCAA this is simply illegal batting, as it is illegal to bat loose balls (other than passes) in the end zone.
Playing Devil's Advocate here since I can't get my arms around it. Maybe I haven't had enough morning coffee just yet.

By rule, is the ball in the end zone? In the OP, when the act occurs the ball has merely broken the plane of the goal line. Does that give it "end zone" status?
Title: Re: "Goaltending"
Post by: Ralph Damren on July 23, 2014, 08:35:30 AM
Playing Devil's Advocate here since I can't get my arms around it. Maybe I haven't had enough morning coffee just yet.

By rule, is the ball in the end zone? In the OP, when the act occurs the ball has merely broken the plane of the goal line. Does that give it "end zone" status?
Rule 8-5-3a-1 regarding TBs states :"Which IS NOT a scoring attempt...."; this keeps the ball alive until kick is no good. For those of you that are long of tooth (like me), you may remember 49ers R.C. Owens accomplishing this feat back in the 60's. I assume it's still legal in their code as on long FG attempts, there is often a R player under the pipes.
Title: Re: "Goaltending"
Post by: Legacy Zebra on July 23, 2014, 08:44:26 AM
Quote
By rule, is the ball in the end zone? In the OP, when the act occurs the ball has merely broken the plane of the goal line. Does that give it "end zone" status?

 The NCAA says yes, ARs 9-4-1-I through 9-4-1-V.
Title: Re: "Goaltending"
Post by: Kalle on July 23, 2014, 10:54:30 AM
I assume it's still legal in their code as on long FG attempts, there is often a R player under the pipes.

I think he's there to potentially return the kick, if it is about to land in the end zone. Goaltending is illegal in NFL, too (although, if I read the (2010) rules correctly, otherwise batting a non-grounded ball in the end zone isn't).
Title: Re: "Goaltending"
Post by: Atlanta Blue on July 23, 2014, 12:05:25 PM
What rule makes this illegal in the NFL?

The Illegal batting rule reads as follows:

12-4-1:
Illegal Bat. It is an illegal bat if:
(a) a player of either team bats or punches a loose ball in the field of play toward his opponent’s goal line; or
(b) a player of either team bats or punches a loose ball (that has touched the ground) in any direction, if it is in either end zone; or
(c) an offensive player bats a backward pass in flight toward his opponent’s goal line.

A scrimmage kick headed between the uprights doesn't fit any of those categories.  Is it specifically listed somewhere else?

And yes, the player under the uprights in the NFL is there for returns, not the rare cases of a "goaltend".  Missed FGs are still live balls in NCAA and NFL (FED too if they don't cross the goal line).  Best way to remember it:

"A field goal is just a punt that can score."
Title: Re: "Goaltending"
Post by: VALJ on July 23, 2014, 01:48:15 PM
AB - granted, it's not the rulebook, but as of two years ago goaltending was illegal in the NFL.  See the last bullet point: http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2012/09/14/nfl-details-key-officiating-issues-from-week-one/

EDIT: NFL rule 12-3 is "prohibited acts", including section R:

"(r) Goal-tending by a defensive player leaping up to deflect a kick as it passes above the crossbar of a goalpost. The referee may award three points for a palpably unfair act (12-3-3)."

http://static.nfl.com/static/content/public/image/rulebook/pdfs/2013%20-%20Rule%20Book.pdf
Title: Re: "Goaltending"
Post by: mbref on July 23, 2014, 01:55:05 PM
I have always had a problem with the ruling in the case book of touchback.  The result of the play is definitely a touchback.  However, it was an illegal bat that causes the kick to fail.  See rule 9-7-2  which clearly states this bat is not legal.
ART. 2 . . . No player shall bat a loose ball other than a pass or a fumble in flight, or a low scrimmage kick in flight which he is attempting to block in or behind the expanded neutral zone.
Rule 4-2-2 indicates this ball is dead when it touches an R player in the end zone unless it caroms through the upright.  If it is a bat these two rules are in conflict.  If this bat occurs on a low kick outside the endzone this would be a foul.
Title: Re: "Goaltending"
Post by: Curious on July 23, 2014, 04:01:30 PM
  If it is a bat these two rules are in conflict.  If this bat occurs on a low kick outside the endzone this would be a foul.

Welcome to FED rules.  Conflicting/contradicting interpretations abound!
Title: Re: "Goaltending"
Post by: Atlanta Blue on July 23, 2014, 06:00:16 PM
AB - granted, it's not the rulebook, but as of two years ago goaltending was illegal in the NFL.  See the last bullet point: http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2012/09/14/nfl-details-key-officiating-issues-from-week-one/

EDIT: NFL rule 12-3 is "prohibited acts", including section R:

"(r) Goal-tending by a defensive player leaping up to deflect a kick as it passes above the crossbar of a goalpost. The referee may award three points for a palpably unfair act (12-3-3)."

http://static.nfl.com/static/content/public/image/rulebook/pdfs/2013%20-%20Rule%20Book.pdf

Thanks.  I was looking for it under "batting", but they don't call it batting, they call it a palpably unfair act.  OK.

Never had it on one of my games.
Title: Re: "Goaltending"
Post by: VALJ on July 24, 2014, 07:04:08 AM
Hey, if I hadn't googled it, I would have thought it was perfectly legal, too!
Title: Re: "Goaltending"
Post by: Bwest on July 24, 2014, 09:26:38 AM
I have always had a problem with the ruling in the case book of touchback.  The result of the play is definitely a touchback.  However, it was an illegal bat that causes the kick to fail.  See rule 9-7-2  which clearly states this bat is not legal.
ART. 2 . . . No player shall bat a loose ball other than a pass or a fumble in flight, or a low scrimmage kick in flight which he is attempting to block in or behind the expanded neutral zone.
Rule 4-2-2 indicates this ball is dead when it touches an R player in the end zone unless it caroms through the upright.  If it is a bat these two rules are in conflict.  If this bat occurs on a low kick outside the endzone this would be a foul.

You can't illegally bat a dead ball. The ball is dead the second it is touched. Touching precedes batting.
Title: Re: "Goaltending"
Post by: Atlanta Blue on July 24, 2014, 10:01:52 AM
Touching precedes batting.
I don't think there is any rule support for that.  Batting is the striking of the ball.  Striking IS touching.

Touching precedes POSSESION, but I don't see anything that says touching precedes batting.
Title: Re: "Goaltending"
Post by: Bwest on July 24, 2014, 12:31:11 PM
I believe your support has to be derived from the case book ruling above.

Quote
6.3.1 SITUATION B:

During a field-goal attempt, R1, who is in the end zone, leaps up and blocks the ball away from the crossbar.

RULING: Touchback. The touching by R1 in the end zone causes the ball to become dead, unless the ball caroms through the goal, thus scoring a field goal. This is not illegal batting, as the touching caused the kick to fail. (4-2-2d(2); 6-3-1b)

Touching causes the kick to become dead, and you can't bat a dead ball.
Title: Re: "Goaltending"
Post by: Atlanta Blue on July 24, 2014, 12:42:34 PM
I believe your support has to be derived from the case book ruling above.

Touching causes the kick to become dead, and you can't bat a dead ball.
You are correct, I think that supports your position.  But I think it is a convolution to get to the outcome they want.  The touching causes the ball to become dead, unless it doesn't (ball goes through the uprights).  They then say the touching caused the kick to fail, which is legal.

Why go through all of the convolution?  Why not just say it's legal to bat the ball in the end zone in an attempt to block the kick?
Title: Re: "Goaltending"
Post by: bkdow on July 28, 2014, 11:56:18 AM
In NFHS, doesn't the ball become "dead" when it is kicked and subsequently crosses the plane of the goaline?  So, if the attempt fell short of the goaline, it is treated like a punt and is returnable.  If it crosses the goaline, the only result can be a successful or unsuccessful field goal?
Title: Re: "Goaltending"
Post by: Atlanta Blue on July 28, 2014, 12:36:01 PM
In NFHS, doesn't the ball become "dead" when it is kicked and subsequently crosses the plane of the goaline? 

Unless it is a scoring attempt.

Quote
So, if the attempt fell short of the goaline, it is treated like a punt and is returnable.

Correct.  A FG is just a "punt that can score". 

Quote
If it crosses the goaline, the only result can be a successful or unsuccessful field goal?
So you are saying that the fact that it is unsuccessful makes it dead, not the touching?
Title: Re: "Goaltending"
Post by: bbeagle on July 29, 2014, 01:25:28 PM
Why go through all of the convolution?  Why not just say it's legal to bat the ball in the end zone in an attempt to block the kick?

I agree, except for the situation where a ball has reached the endzone is batted back to the 2 yard line. This kick is still a 'scoring attempt', and the grounded kick is in the field of play now, wouldn't the ball now be live, able to be advanced by the receivers, or recovered by the kickers?

They should just say, 'It's legal to bat the ball in the end zone in an attempt to block the kick. The ball becomes dead when it is apparent that the kick will not score.'
Title: Re: "Goaltending"
Post by: bkdow on July 30, 2014, 12:03:18 PM
It is a touchback if any free kick or scrimmage kick: (a) which is not a scoring attempt or which is a grounded three-point field-goal attempt, breaks the planof R's goal line, unless R chooses a spot of first touching by K. (b) Which is a three-point fieldgoal attmpt, in flight touches a K player inR's end zone, or after breaking the plan of R's goalline is unsuccessful."  Since we do not have a rule that says "goaltending" is illegal, then regardless of how it is unsuccessful after it breaks the plane, it is a touch back.  It would not matter where the ball comes to rest.
Title: Re: "Goaltending"
Post by: AlUpstateNY on July 30, 2014, 06:36:58 PM
Forgive me, but what is the problem with the current rule?  Any kick, with the lone exception of a scoring attempt, that is touched by a member of K, in the EZ and (somehow) caroms through the goal is dead, or a Touchback.

You could change the rule to suggest that any scoring attempt kick, that is touched by K, in the EZ, and caroms through the goal must be an act of divine intervention, and therefor is allowed, but that would likely cause some, very possibly the same few, to raise concerns on Constitutional grounds.
Title: Re: "Goaltending"
Post by: Atlanta Blue on July 30, 2014, 07:56:07 PM
Forgive me, but what is the problem with the current rule?  Any kick, with the lone exception of a scoring attempt, that is touched by a member of K, in the EZ and (somehow) caroms through the goal is dead, or a Touchback.

You could change the rule to suggest that any scoring attempt kick, that is touched by K, in the EZ, and caroms through the goal must be an act of divine intervention, and therefor is allowed, but that would likely cause some, very possibly the same few, to raise concerns on Constitutional grounds.
The issue is if it's touched by R, not K.  Can R jump up and block a FG attempt at the crossbar?
Title: Re: "Goaltending"
Post by: Ralph Damren on July 31, 2014, 07:09:18 AM
Should we raise the crossbar to 12' to keep R players from reaching it ??? ????....Whoops, that would make it harder for the kicker pray:; :!# ::)... Should we make it illegal ??? ???? ....I've never seen any kid try it ::) ::) ( other than RC Owens when it was apparently legal in NFL)...Should the Red Sox trade away their starting rotation now that they have sold out for the rest of the home season :o :( ???....             things to ponder as I sip my lobster flavored coca. 8]
Title: Re: "Goaltending"
Post by: AlUpstateNY on July 31, 2014, 08:44:01 AM
The issue is if it's touched by R, not K.  Can R jump up and block a FG attempt at the crossbar?

Apologies for confusing  R and K, answer to your question; Yes (some divine assistance appreciated)
Title: Re: "Goaltending"
Post by: Ralph Damren on July 31, 2014, 09:17:37 AM
Thursday Trivia Teaser.....  At R's 10 ,Hans, the placekicker, kicks (1) a "pop up" on a short FG attempt; (1a) "Springs", Hans' teammate and allstate volleyball player, races to R's 3 and bats the ungrounded kick thru the pipes. ..or... (2) a "low liner" on a short FG attempt; (2a) ungrounded kick strikes Bubba - the snapper @ the LOS - in his butt region; (2b) kick then sails thru the pipes. ...Things to ponder : Is Bubba guilty of the seldom called butt blocking ????....Should the Prom Queen date either Hans or Springs ??? ?...Would Bubba get credit for the FG if the kick is ruled good ??? or would he only get an assist ??? or is that only in other sports ??? ????
Title: Re: "Goaltending"
Post by: bkdow on July 31, 2014, 11:08:22 AM
Thursday Trivia Teaser.....  At R's 10 ,Hans, the placekicker, kicks (1) a "pop up" on a short FG attempt; (1a) "Springs", Hans' teammate and allstate volleyball player, races to R's 3 and bats the ungrounded kick thru the pipes. ..or... (2) a "low liner" on a short FG attempt; (2a) ungrounded kick strikes Bubba - the snapper @ the LOS - in his butt region; (2b) kick then sails thru the pipes. ...Things to ponder : Is Bubba guilty of the seldom called butt blocking ????....Should the Prom Queen date either Hans or Springs ??? ?...Would Bubba get credit for the FG if the kick is ruled good ??? or would he only get an assist ??? or is that only in other sports ??? ????
OK:  I'll bite on this.  1.  Illegal Batting on the 3 yard line as he may only bat the ball back toward his own goalline.  The penalty is enforced from the 20 yard line because the play ended in a touchback.  It would be R's ball 1-10 on the 35 yard line.

2. The "Butt Blocking" is ignored because it occurred in the or behind the expanded neutral zone.  Bubba's touching is ignored so not credit or assist is awarded officially but he would still be the hero and should get a date with someone in the court.  Hans and Springs will be sitting alone sipping bad punch in the corner of the gym watching others dance.
Title: Re: "Goaltending"
Post by: VALJ on July 31, 2014, 12:08:20 PM
OK:  I'll bite on this.  1.  Illegal Batting on the 3 yard line as he may only bat the ball back toward his own goalline.  The penalty is enforced from the 20 yard line because the play ended in a touchback.  It would be R's ball 1-10 on the 35 yard line.

bkdow - two things to think about:

A) The foul for the illegal bat happens during a loose ball play, does it not?  What's the basic spot for a foul during a loose ball play?
B) What's the status of the ball after the bat?  Has the kick ended yet?  Is this still a scrimmage kick than can score points?

I'm coming up with two choices for R:

1 - Decline the foul for illegal batting.  Since the ball is still loose as a kick, the result of the play is a kick going through the uprights over the crossbar, resulting in a field goal.  Since that's the case, R is not going to decline this foul, meaning we look at door number 2...

2 - Accept the foul for the illegal bat, which occurs during a loose ball play, meaning it's enforced from the previous spot.  March them back 15, and replay the down.  Not only does Springs not get a date with a member of the homecoming court, but he might well find himself running the steps or doing a crab walk across the field the next day.
Title: Re: "Goaltending"
Post by: Atlanta Blue on July 31, 2014, 12:29:33 PM
Hans and Springs will be sitting alone sipping bad punch in the corner of the gym watching others dance.
Kickers NEVER sit alone and drink bad punch.  Chicks dig kickers.
Title: Re: "Goaltending"
Post by: Ralph Damren on July 31, 2014, 12:36:47 PM
Good try guys, but read Rule 8-4-1b and remember what a respected coach from the state with red clay once said : "A field goal is like a punt that can score". Chicks dig kickers with foreign accents.
Title: Re: "Goaltending"
Post by: Tom.OH on July 31, 2014, 12:40:49 PM
Kickers NEVER sit alone and drink bad punch.  Chicks dig kickers.

At least that's what AB tells his kickers! ;D
Title: Re: "Goaltending"
Post by: HLinNC on July 31, 2014, 01:22:42 PM
Quote
I sip my lobster flavored coca

Uh Ralph, Crockett & Tubbs of Northwoods Law are gonna be paying you a little visit. P_S
Title: Re: "Goaltending"
Post by: Ralph Damren on July 31, 2014, 01:45:12 PM
 ^no Sorry,guys, time's up ^flag! While there's a flag for an illegal bat, the kick remains a kick and the result of the play is a touchback. Per 8-4-1b, it is now a kick that CANNOT score. R's best choice is to decline the foul and take the touchback then to give K another play. In Bubba's butt block, the kick would be good BUT if Bubba had waddled downfield and this occurred, 8-4-1b would apply with no foul. HL in NC - up here they are known as Forest Rangers (not to be confused with Texas Rangers). Their most swashbuckling activity is ending a rabid skunk. They are sorta' like the side judge on a 7 man crew during a PAT kick----with nothing to do. :)
Title: Re: "Goaltending"
Post by: VALJ on July 31, 2014, 01:58:58 PM
^no Sorry,guys, time's up ^flag! While there's a flag for an illegal bat, the kick remains a kick and the result of the play is a touchback. Per 8-4-1b, it is now a kick that CANNOT score. R's best choice is to decline the foul and take the touchback then to give K another play.

Dang it, that's what I had originally, and then I got lost with the touching of the kick changing it so that the kick couldn't score.  Shucks.

And Hans and Springs won't be sitting alone.  They'll have each other to commiserate with, while the homecoming queen is hanging out with the quarterback.
Title: Re: "Goaltending"
Post by: bkdow on July 31, 2014, 03:11:07 PM
But wait, if the new rule says than an illegal bat does not change the original force and the original force was the kick, would it not be a touchback?  The Basic Spot for penalty enforcement on kicking plays that end in a touchback is the succeeding spot, so wouldn't it make R's ball on the 35 yardline after the 15 yard penalty is enforced?  (I can't get into Aribitor at this point)
Title: Re: "Goaltending"
Post by: bkdow on July 31, 2014, 03:17:30 PM
 tiphat:
Title: Re: "Goaltending"
Post by: bkdow on July 31, 2014, 03:52:37 PM
I withdraw my comments... :bOW
Title: Re: "Goaltending"
Post by: ECILLJ on August 05, 2014, 11:31:36 AM
Thursday Trivia Teaser.....  At R's 10 ,Hans, the placekicker, kicks (1) a "pop up" on a short FG attempt; (1a) "Springs", Hans' teammate and allstate volleyball player, races to R's 3 and bats the ungrounded kick thru the pipes. 

Why illegal batting and not kick catching interference?
Title: Re: "Goaltending"
Post by: bkdow on August 05, 2014, 11:35:29 AM
Someone has to be in position to field it for there to be KCI.  The assumption, since Ralph didn't mention someone being in position, is that there is no one in position.
Title: Re: "Goaltending"
Post by: ECILLJ on August 05, 2014, 11:55:38 AM
Someone has to be in position to field it for there to be KCI.  The assumption, since Ralph didn't mention someone being in position, is that there is no one in position.

Understood that the covering official would need to have all the information before making this call.

My assumption is a pop up kick that only carries seven yards and is kicked high enough for a K player to get under will probably also draw a crowd from R. The kick is being batted only five yards from the free blocking zone. KCI seems like the better call if any R players are near the play.
Title: Re: "Goaltending"
Post by: Ralph Damren on August 05, 2014, 12:18:04 PM
If a R receiver was in position it would be KCI , probably on a short FG attempt all R would be trying to block the kick. If KCI was called, it probably would be declined as the penalty would only bring the ball out to R's 18 where taking the play would bring the ball to the 20.