RefStripes.com
Football Officiating => General Discussion => Topic started by: IrishGuard57 on January 30, 2021, 12:35:57 PM
-
So I am just starting out and want to ask all head linesman. Do you prefer the cloth chain clips or the plastic dials and why.
-
Cloth/ribbon type is just easier to keep in your bag and easier to keep in your pocket. That's why I like them.
-
Both work fine. The most important thing is to have two, and be sure the chain crew uses both correctly.
-
I make my own. Metal clips, nylon rope, and flourescent tape from the hardware store. I carry a few, leave them with schools if they don't have any or break. When I run low I make more.
-
That's a pretty darn good idea. :thumbup
-
I prefer the cloth for the exact same reason as others, but have been told that it's better to use the disc ones; apparently some people feel that the cloth ones can 'move' on their own too much. I give them two to use if I think the clip guy can manage it (assuming I even HAVE a clip guy)
-
I make my own. Metal clips, nylon rope, and flourescent tape from the hardware store. I carry a few, leave them with schools if they don't have any or break. When I run low I make more.
Then you have clips and rope to mend the chains! ;D
-
No, you carry a few zip-ties in your hat band to fix chains in distress.
-
you carry a few zip-ties in your hat band
Yep. I make sure to buy the flourescent colors.
-
I make my own. Metal clips, nylon rope, and flourescent tape from the hardware store. I carry a few, leave them with schools if they don't have any or break. When I run low I make more.
I'd love to see a pic of one of those.
-
https://ibb.co/54dSmxT
-
I keep a couple of these on every clip.
(I used to have just one, until the time both chain markers broke LOL)
https://www.lowes.com/pd/Nite-Ize-Stainless-Snap-Hook-Key-Ring/1000212599
-
No, you carry a few zip-ties in your hat band to fix chains in distress.
EVERY HL, at every level, should carry a couple of zip-ties inside their hatband. They're not heavy, and you'll likely forget they're even there UNTIL you need one.
You'll likely carry the same zip-ties as long as you keep that cap. Should a chain break, the game stops, and EVERYONE (Players, Coaches, Spectators, Administrators) immediately look to the HL for a solution, which those zip-ties will usually, and immediately, provide.
It's likely a smart crew mate, with an older cap, might find a pair of forgotten zip-ties from a previous HL assignment in his cap, that might serve as backup.
-
Nite Ize is the same company that made/distributed the cell phone holsters I bought at a Tractor Supply bargain bin for our walkies.
-
Yep. I make sure to buy the flourescent colors.
That way, the next crew can say, "Yep, HLinNC has been here before."
-
That way, the next crew can say, "Yep, HLinNC has been here before.
"
More like easier to see. Sometimes if the two inch thick wad of athletic tape on the chain is too dark to see or isn't really on the midpoint, I'll use the flourescent tie to mark with. But your theory works too.
-
Both work fine. The most important thing is to have two, and be sure the chain crew uses both correctly.
Uses both?
-
Uses both?
Yes. For the first scrimmage series of game, the clip person places a clip on the chain at the appropriate location. When the chains are relocated for the next series, the clip person leaves in place the clip already on the chain, and places the second clip on the chain at the appropriate location. Leaving the clip on the chain and using the second clip for the new series accomplishes two things: 1) the clip for the new series can be set very quickly (rather than having to take the time to remove the clip on the chain and reset it, and 2) more importantly, by leaving the clip for the previous series on the chain, you can easily reset the chains at the previous location, if needed (like, if the chain crew moves the chains before being instructed to do so, and there needs to be a penalty enforcement).
When the ball is snapped for the next (first) down, the clip person then removes the clip that was in place for the previous series, because, once the ball is snapped, by rule, we can’t go back and correct anything.
The clip person repeats this process for each new series.
-
That's not a bad idea, I have never heard of two clips being used.
-
Our Umpire was a machinist and made aluminum plate discs with holes stamped for 50, 45, 40, 35 etc. I then used a double hasp clip from Home Depot and carried a spare in my pocket. Around the spare clip was a rubber band with ten florescent zip ties about four inches long each. Those were life savers multiple times. Then I got wise and moved to the other sideline ....
-
My son has a 3D printer. I may see what he can create.
-
I have kept a lot of stuff over the years (red/white foul marker, etc.), but I probably gave away the old plastic ‘phone dial’ style clips we used in my earlier years. I don’t exactly remember, but I guess they had 10 dial holes, with yard line numbers printed at each hole (5 yard increments). The holes were large enough to let the clip hook (on a chain) pass thru the appropriate hole, and then hook to the clip. Slightly easier than having a double clip hook, and un-hook/re-hook to the dial (before or after clipping to the chain). Then, somebody invented the far-more-convenient rotating dial clip that is most common today, making the phone-dial style a relic.
-
I loaned mine to a young official that was working L. He looked at me like “ what is this”?
-
but I probably gave away the old plastic ‘phone dial’ style clips we used in my earlier years.
I bought one back in the 90's after I started and it looked like HL was the position for me. At some point it "wandered off."
When my son started playing HS FB, I took a quasi-sabbatical and helped the booster club with team stuff. We got the chain set out of the room in the concession stand for a scrimmage one day. There was my old rotary disc clip with my name and old home phone number on it. I guess I had loaned it out to some crew there and forgot it.
It is now safe and sound in my "throwback bag" with a white beanbag and metal Acme Thunderers.
-
I always have a nylon tie wrap in my hat. Chain breaks you have it for a quick repair.
-
I always have a nylon tie wrap in my hat. Chain breaks you have it for a quick repair.
I'll wager, it's also magically protected you from ever having to deal with a broken chain.
-
https://ibb.co/54dSmxT
Certainly economical and convenient to carry. If you have a 'stat' guy that is logging down-distance-location for every down, then you can get away without having a clip that identifies the yard line. But, for lower level (HS, etc.) you really need a more affirmative way - other than our memories - to know the yard line on which the clip is placed. Even during my FBS days, when we quite often had 'stat' guys, our H's still always had clips that had yard-line indicators. We could never be too careful. (Side note: We also almost always had a guy logging clock stoppages, too, so we could reset the game clock accurately, when needed (and we did need them on a few occasions). A decent 'stat' guy could do all of that. And, we had a foul recorder, logging period, time, foul, player, team, and calling official(s) for every foul. Made life much easier when completing post-game reports. I miss that part of those days.)
-
We're lucky if we have a 4th to be the "clip guy" on Fridays.
I'm 2 for 2 in give-aways so far this "spring season". Week 1- they were using a scrawny whistle lanyard. Week 2- looked like one of the slider ribbon style that had worn off to just a scrap of fabric below the clip and had faded to white.
I may have to head back down to the hardware store at this rate.
-
I'll wager, it's also magically protected you from ever having to deal with a broken chain.
It didn't for me. I kept a zip tie in my hat and one weekend had to use them 2 straight games, Friday night varsity game and a Saturday JV game...
-
I'll bet you were really glad you were smart enough to replace the one in your hat band after your Friday Night experience. Something must have really ticked off the football Gods, in your area, that weekend.
-
A couple of HL duties :
(1) Be sure the clip-man (gender-neutral) understands where to clip and to clip in a link (4-man chain crew), DBG (down box guy in a 3-man crew).
(2) Check for tape or some marker on the 5 yard section on the chain,as this can aid in penalty enforcement.
-
…...another HH (helpful hint) is on measurements, have your DBG (down-box guy) go to lead pole before bringing chains in. If the measurement is short, send the FPG & BPG (Front Pole Guy & Back Pole Guy) back to the sidelines with the chains and instruct them to reset off DBG, then signal DBG how much to back off FPG. Saves on shoe leather ;)!
NOTE: "Guy" is considered gender neutral.
-
NOTE: "Guy" is considered gender neutral.
Yeah, I would have left my wife for our foul recorder "guy" in San Jose, if she would have only asked. Wisely, for both of us, she didn't ask. BTW, I told my wife about her (some years later, of course). Still married - 41 years, now. (And Happily, I will add. :) )
-
So I am just starting out and want to ask all head linesman. Do you prefer the cloth chain clips or the plastic dials and why.
I prefer the dial type, because they are conspicuous, can easily be set to the proper number, and can't be mistaken for anything else. It is also easy to grab onto the dial when moving the chains to the new location.
-
I prefer the dial type, because they are conspicuous, can easily be set to the proper number, and can't be mistaken for anything else. It is also easy to grab onto the dial when moving the chains to the new location.
Don't just grab the dial - grab the chain, itself, with the clip of the dial firmly inside your fist, to ensure the clip doesn't slip off while you move to the measurement location. That has happened, and you can not accurately put the clip back on the chain if that happens. And the teams will notice. Oh! They will notice.
-
grab the chain, itself,
Goes for dial, strap, lanyard, key fob- whatever they've got hanging on there.
-
I grab onto the attached clip with my middle and 4th fingers, and the dial with my thumb. I also like that it's big enough to feel in my pocket, and can't be confused for a down indicator.
-
I also like that it's big enough to feel in my pocket, and can't be confused for a down indicator.
Are you saying it is in your pocket during the game? It should be connected to the chain, at all times during the game...
***Well, one of the two should be connected to the chain at all times during the game - sometimes both (briefly). But, you should never have one in your pocket, unless it is truly a 'spare.'***
-
I'm talking about before and after the game. Of course it's on the chains during the game.
-
I'm talking about before and after the game. Of course it's on the chains during the game.
Yeah, in the pocket before/after the game is not time critical, so no disaster if you can’t recognize it tactily.
-
Don't just grab the dial - grab the chain, itself, with the clip of the dial firmly inside your fist, to ensure the clip doesn't slip off while you move to the measurement location. That has happened, and you can not accurately put the clip back on the chain if that happens. And the teams will notice. Oh! They will notice.
THE SCENE : I was a rookie HL, Nixon was in the White House, and the game field had only lines every 10 yards resulting in plenty of measurements....
(1) Early in the game the R called for the chains;
(2) I went racing to the sidelines :o - we used to play just off the end then - while pulling out my oversized clip as the chain crew appeared to be drunk and didn't want to bother with it;
(3) In error, I clipped over the chain AND NOT INTO A LINK;
(4)as the pole guys staggered out onto the field, I felt the chain slide thru my hands & the clip pi1eOn ;
(5) when we reached the ball, the lead pole had advanced a couple of feet thru my hands;
(6) the R said : "GEEZ, I thought it was closer than that...".
EPILOGUE : The game wasn't close, so I didn't feel my goof-up had any impact. I kept my goof-up to myself until we were safely in the ref's car. When :-[ I explained my goof to my partners, the ref pulled his car over at the closest store , and gruffly announced : "YOU'RE BUYING >:( !" My game fee was $12 back then. A 6-pack of PBR was $3 back then. I HAD LEARNED MY LESSON. BE SURE THAT YOUR CLIP IS SECURE BEFORE YOUR JOURNEY TO THE BALL...
-
Early in my career many many moons ago, I was told by the White Hat, if I signal 1st down and the coach requests a measurement, you better ball up enough chain in your hand to ensure it is a first down. I thought he was joking but he was serious.
Most of these games were in small town Mississippi. Poor lights, wavy markings and who knows what chain crew you were going to get. I never did it but he did chastise me a time or two when he was wrong.
-
Early in my career many many moons ago, I was told by the White Hat, if I signal 1st down and the coach requests a measurement, you better ball up enough chain in your hand to ensure it is a first down. I thought he was joking but he was serious.
Most of these games were in small town Mississippi. Poor lights, wavy markings and who knows what chain crew you were going to get. I never did it but he did chastise me a time or two when he was wrong.
If/when I signal first down, all opportunities for measurement have passed. Just saying.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
If it is close, but I can see it will/won't be, I'll usually bring the captain of the team which my call is not going n favor of and say : "Captain .as you can see, the lead pole is just short of ( just in advance of) the yard on the sideline, where the ball is just beyond of (just short of) the hash mark....". He will usually agree and if the coach will yell for a measurement, the captain will respond : "Na, it's short (he's got it), coach..". IMHO, it's always good to have opposing captains watch if we do bring chains it. If the play ended with the ball not pointing up the field ,you may want to adjust it before the chains arrive. A suggestion is for the white hat to place his hat at the foremost point of the ball and adjust it. Those watching will realize that you are not advancing the ball, just adjusting it. Ask your wing officials to run all the way in, when they know it's going to be close, so you can spot it on their foot, not trying to line it up with them in the side zone....
DISCLAIMER :These are merely the mutterings of a grumpy ole' umpire awaiting for his first game of corona baseball and not those of NFHS, NCAA, MPA, AFL/CIO and the like
:sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR:
-
Ask your wing officials to run all the way in, when they know it's going to be close, so you can spot it on their foot,
Good advice but I hand the ball, not toss it, to the wing official and let them spot the ball.
-
Good advice but I hand the ball, not toss it, to the wing official and let them spot the ball.
Good point, Jason, if the play ends in a side zone I'd do that,too. If the measurement was shot, we would bring the chains & ball in to the hash for spotting. If the play ended in the center zone having the wing run up to the ball for spotting. This would prevent the need to re-spot the ball and chains.
-
Absolutely, whenever a 'spot' is close for a first down, the wing official(s) (including F and S on crews of 7 & 8, on occasion) must charge to the dead-ball spot, and call for the ball to be tossed/handed to him/her, and personally spot the ball. And that may mean charging beyond mid-field, if his/her cross-field partner does not have a good look at the spot. Absolutely, DO NOT hold a spot yards away from the dead-ball spot, and spot the ball there, and then measure there - even if that happens to be inside the hash marks. Get to the actual dead-ball spot and spot the ball there! You will catch enough flak about the spot being a 'bad spot' without having to listen to the legitimate complaint that your spot way over there wasn't even close to the real spot way over here.
Yeah, it takes hustle. Nobody said this was a lounge chair activity. :)
-
This works on a turf field. On a grass field I always had my wings get a spot and stay there. One of the other officials would bring the ball to the wing man in whose side the ball became dead. When inches matter, moving into the field gives the possibility of error. When the wing marks the spot like a bird dog and waits for the ball, there is less fuel for one of the coach's complaints.
-
This works on a turf field. On a grass field I always had my wings get a spot and stay there. One of the other officials would bring the ball to the wing man in whose side the ball became dead. When inches matter, moving into the field gives the possibility of error. When the wing marks the spot like a bird dog and waits for the ball, there is less fuel for one of the coach's complaints.
Just for my understanding, why would grass make a difference? Our crew has always worked it like the others posted, grass or turf. If the wing runs to the spot there is no chance of error. It became dead where it became dead.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
I receive dozens of calls from coaches every season. I try to mentally separate them into gripes/rules. The majority of gripes are regarding "bad spots" and I politely explain that is a judgement call and I can only help you with a rule. We need to stress to our wings to stay focused on forward progress as that can be easily picked out of a game film and griped about. They need to HUSTLE into a spot and clearly mark it.
PS: If the coach had a question on a rule, I would correct him if the crew got it right. If it sounded like it was misapplied, I'll tell the coach that I'll contact the crew before we discuss it further and call him back. I'll call the crew's white hat and get his application explained. Either way, I will respond to the coach and explain that it was/wasn't handled correctly. Seems fair.
-
Completely fair. This is the way our assignor handles questions and complaints.