RefStripes.com

Football Officiating => National Federation Discussion => Topic started by: skt101 on October 04, 2021, 09:40:42 AM

Title: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: skt101 on October 04, 2021, 09:40:42 AM
On a missed fg (scoring attempt) is the succeeding spot the 20 yard line regardless where the kick occurred?
Example, kicking team attempts a fg from the 15 or the 30 yard line and the score attempt is no good. The kick goes through the endzone.
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: zebrastripes on October 04, 2021, 09:55:34 AM
Yes.
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: CalhounLJ on October 04, 2021, 10:13:04 AM
Just remember a field goal attempt is a scrimmage kick that can score. Anything that applies to a punt applies to a field goal attempt. If the attempt is short and rolls out at the 1, it’s R ball at the 1. If it breaks the plane of the end zone and doesn’t score, it’s a touchback at the 20.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: red viking on October 04, 2021, 04:00:11 PM
Remember to NOT blow the whistle until the ball crosses the goal-line (or until ball is otherwise dead such as going OOB, B recovering and gets tackled, etc). Not a big deal on an extra pt but you CANNOT do this on a FG attempt. Once had a ref blow the whistle as soon as it left the kicker's foot on a game-winning attempt on last play of the game. He was simply adamant that the FG was no good (it landed short of goal line and B recovered and started running with it) and time to move on to OT but a savy coach for team A would have called him out and then imagine if he then makes the field goal. It was the visiting team too. We would have been running for our lives to get out of the stadium.
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: Ralph Damren on October 05, 2021, 06:36:32 AM
….and don't forget the "tack-on" rule on missed field goals = FGA wide-right + K holding = R 1/10 @ R's 30.
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: dch on October 05, 2021, 12:42:10 PM
What about illegal position (K had 5 in backfield) on missed 3rd down field goal.  Is that penalty "tacked on" after the touchback?
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: Derek Teigen on October 05, 2021, 01:52:07 PM
What about illegal position (K had 5 in backfield) on missed 3rd down field goal.  Is that penalty "tacked on" after the touchback?

I think they would have to decline the penalty to take possession.
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: CalhounLJ on October 05, 2021, 01:56:49 PM
What about illegal position (K had 5 in backfield) on missed 3rd down field goal.  Is that penalty "tacked on" after the touchback?
Yes they may tack this penalty on. Any foul by K during a kicking down may be enforced from the succeeding spot.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: Derek Teigen on October 05, 2021, 02:04:43 PM
Yes they may tack this penalty on. Any foul by K during a kicking down may be enforced from the succeeding spot.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Calhoun, remember this is a 3rd down field goal kick.  Wouldn't the succeeding spot be the previous spot (LOS)?  accept penalty and push them back 5 yards or decline penalty and take the ball at their own 20?
Title: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: CalhounLJ on October 05, 2021, 02:08:11 PM
Calhoun, remember this is a 3rd down field goal kick.  Wouldn't the succeeding spot be the previous spot (LOS)?
No. Once the ball is kicked beyond the los and either touched by R or goes oob or becomes dead the series is over for K. The ball belongs to the team in possession at the end of the down. In this case it belongs to R at the 20 because the kick broke the plane of R’s goal line and failed to score.

If A fumbles the snap or or the kick is blocked behind the line and doesn’t cross the los, it’s fourth down. But otherwise it’s no different than a kick on 4th down.

But to clarify, the succeeding spot option is just that- an option. R can choose to go back to previous spot mark off 5 and replay the down. But the down doesn’t matter. They could do that on 4th down as well.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: Ralph Damren on October 05, 2021, 03:01:15 PM
Regardless of down, with a scrimmage kick you are giving up the ball. The fact of the tack-on is the unintended result of the rule.
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: AlUpstateNY on October 05, 2021, 05:43:52 PM
Here's hoping the Baseball Gods keep Fenway Park dry and playable tonight, so the "better team" can move on.
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: NVFOA_Ump on October 05, 2021, 05:56:39 PM
Wow, Al I didn't realize you're a Red Sox fan!   ;D
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: Ralph Damren on October 06, 2021, 04:28:26 AM
Here's hoping the Baseball Gods keep Fenway Park dry and playable tonight, so the "better team" can move on.
[/FENWAY PARK WAS VERY PLAYABLE AND THE BETTER TEAM (at least last night) DID WIN !b]
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: BetweenTheLines on October 06, 2021, 06:06:36 AM
Where this rule gets the most difficult would be enforcement in OT. Let's say the Home team misses a game winning FG as time runs out with 5 in the backfield. You would need to tell the visiting team that should they win the toss in order for them to take advantage of the rule they will need snap the ball first. Likewise you would have to explain to the home team if they win the toss and elect to go on defense first which is the norm that the visitors will start on the 5 yard line (under regular NFHS rules). Same thing over and over again if its the team who has the ball last trying to tie or win the game in OT. Remember all of that the next time you are in OT.
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: Ralph Damren on October 06, 2021, 06:25:47 AM
Where this rule gets the most difficult would be enforcement in OT. Let's say the Home team misses a game winning FG as time runs out with 5 in the backfield. You would need to tell the visiting team that should they win the toss in order for them to take advantage of the rule they will need snap the ball first. Likewise you would have to explain to the home team if they win the toss and elect to go on defense first which is the norm that the visitors will start on the 5 yard line (under regular NFHS rules). Same thing over and over again if its the team who has the ball last trying to tie or win the game in OT. Remember all of that the next time you are in OT.
Good point, BetweenTheLines, the unintended results of a rule change probably needs some intended tweaking. The author of the change is a sharp guy ( also authored the outlaw of the Oregonian flea flicker) and will probably be on it like a duck on a june bug (ole' Mainer saying).
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: CalhounLJ on October 06, 2021, 06:31:23 AM
Good point, BetweenTheLines, the unintended results of a rule change probably needs some intended tweaking. The author of the change is a sharp guy ( also authored the outlaw of the Oregonian flea flicker) and will probably be on it like a duck on a june bug (ole' Mainer saying).
It most certainly does need some tweaking because the author of the rule is adamant that this foul cannot be carried into overtime. We never did get an official ruling on that did we?


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: NVFOA_Ump on October 06, 2021, 07:13:41 AM
It most certainly does need some tweaking because the author of the rule is adamant that this foul cannot be carried into overtime. We never did get an official ruling on that did we?
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

We have been told "unofficially" multiple times that this does not carryover into OT yet I have still not seen anything "official" that clarifies this.  The rules as currently written pretty clearly say that it does carry over and as of right now there is no exceptions that we have seen.
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: bama_stripes on October 06, 2021, 07:29:28 AM
We have been told "unofficially" multiple times that this does not carryover into OT yet I have still not seen anything "official" that clarifies this.  The rules as currently written pretty clearly say that it does carry over and as of right now there is no exceptions that we have seen.

I agree; however, in the the heat of the moment, it’s very likely that I would have a severe case of cranial flatulence and forget that obscure provision.  I can guarantee that no coach ‘round these parts would know differently.
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: Ralph Damren on October 06, 2021, 10:54:46 AM
After further review by the replay official (chatting with the rule's author) 3-3-3a would apply. If R chose to take the tack-on application, they would then have an untimed down. Declining the penalty would then bring on the OT, if needed. Remember, too, the tack-on can't apply if K is next to put the ball in play.
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: CalhounLJ on October 06, 2021, 11:07:02 AM
After further review by the replay official (chatting with the rule's author) 3-3-3a would apply. If R chose to take the tack-on application, they would then have an untimed down. Declining the penalty would then bring on the OT, if needed. Remember, too, the tack-on can't apply if K is next to put the ball in play.
Yes, and not to beat a dead horse, but this interpretation cannot be correct. The tack on is at the succeeding spot, and the succeeding spot on the last play of a tied game is the first play in overtime, not the R20. The definition of succeeding spot prohibits the spot from being the R20.

2-41-ART. 10 ... The Succeeding spot is where the ball would next be snapped or free kicked if a foul had not occurred.

If K does not foul on the last play of a game that is tied, the succeeding spot will always be the first play in overtime.

Can we not admit this basic fundamental?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: CalhounLJ on October 06, 2021, 12:50:21 PM
I understand this is a scoring play I’m about to post, but the comment specifically speaks to the point of the fundamental definition and understanding of succeeding spot:

10.4.5 SITUATION G:

A2 commits an unsportsmanlike dead-ball foul: (a) following a touchdown by A1; or (b) following a successful try.

RULING: In (a), B is given the option of accepting the penalty enforcement on the try or the subsequent kick. In (b), the succeeding spot is the kickoff.

COMMENT: If the try had been the last play of the game and the score was tied, the succeeding spot for enforcement of the penalty for the foul by A2 would be the start of the overtime procedure. If an overtime is not authorized, the foul cannot be penalized because there would be no succeeding spot. (2-15, 2-41, 8-2-4)


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: Ralph Damren on October 06, 2021, 02:00:00 PM
The key to succeeding spot enforcement on a tack-on is that is a live-ball foul. The Case 10.4.G deals with a dead ball foul which is always succeeding spot enforcement and would be carried over to the period/half/ overtime (3-3-4d). Some live ball fouls have succeeding spot enforcement, a:"tack-on" is one ,where an end of run enforcement may not be available as the kick may not have been fielded. KCI also comes to mind. Hope this helps .
Title: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: CalhounLJ on October 06, 2021, 02:26:58 PM
Yes I understand the implications of dead ball vs live ball. But the point I’m making is that to enforce the tack on foul after a scrimmage kick at the R20 we would have to set aside the definition of succeeding spot.

There are better ways to accomplish what the rules committee wants. For example, they could add simple language to the exception to read

EXCEPTION: The basic spot may, at the option of the offended team, be the succeeding spot for fouls by K during a legal free or scrimmage kick down (other than kick catch interference) prior to the end of the kick when K will not be next to put the ball in play AND TIME DOES NOT EXPIRE DURING THE PLAY. If time does expire, the only options for R will be to accept enforcement from the previous spot with an untimed down or decline the penalty.

They already had the wisdom to insert the KCI exception because of what you just posted. Doing the same for end of period fouls is not that big a jump.

IMO, that would be much better than having to create a succeeding spot the rules don’t allow for, or set aside the basic definition of succeeding spot.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: KWH on October 07, 2021, 04:12:00 PM

The members I have spoken with do not feel any additional wording is required AND that there is no conflict since we have Rule 3-3-3a with the only exceptions to Rule 3-3-3a listed in 3-3-4b.
Further, since 10-4-2 EXCEPTION is not included in the fouls listed in 3-3-4b, any 10-4-2 EXCEPTION foul occurring during a down in which time in the period expires, if accepted, shall be enforced as an extension of the same period.

I am aware there are those who won't believe this not matter what, so I will make my best attempt to get a Casebook Play added for 2022.
However, Casebook space for plays which occur less often than every third appearance of Haley's Commit are sometimes very difficult to justify!
This one might just be a little easier to sell if I go this route...

SITUATION: With the score tied and the game clock running out in the 4th Period, Team K hustles to get a their Field Goal unit in place.
In their hurry to snap the ball they have two players still moving when the ball is snapped!  The kick sails wide right beyond the end line as time expires during the kick.
RULING: TBA

I believe the ruling on this Illegal Shift play should do it???

Thoughts?


Thoughts?
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: CalhounLJ on October 07, 2021, 04:25:39 PM
Ruling: R can decline this foul and go to overtime. Or they can accept the foul with enforcement from the previous spot and replay the down. Or they can accept the foul using the 10-4-2 exception with enforcement from the succeeding spot. Which is the first play in overtime. Which is in conflict with 3-3-3a


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: CalhounLJ on October 07, 2021, 04:31:06 PM
I’ve asked every one of the referees I’m my association what they would do in this situation. Every single one said to apply 10-4-2 would mean the first play in overtime. That’s what the clear common sense reading of 10-4-2 exception says. Clearly there’s confusion whether we want to admit it or not.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: KDJBBBJ on October 15, 2021, 06:26:30 PM
Why if R accepts the penalty do we not extend the period for an accepted penalty during the last timed down of the period?  They have three options. 
1)Decline the penalty go to OT
2)Accept the penalty at the succeding spot of the 20 one untimed down.

It has always been my understanding that the only penalties that go over to OT are dead ball or ones treated as dead ball.  Ones that would not extend the period. 
Title: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: CalhounLJ on October 16, 2021, 08:42:25 AM
There has been a lengthy discussion of this on a previous thread. My position is not the fact that we should play an untimed down. I agree with that completely.

My problem is the succeeding spot in that situation is not the R 20. The definition of succeeding spot is where the ball would next be put in play iIF THERE WAS NO FOUL. In this situation, that would be the first play in overtime, not the R20.

My opinion is that R does indeed have two VALID options.
1 decline and go to overtime.
2. Accept and replay from previous spot.

10-4-2 exception, 3-3-3a, and 2-41-10 are in conflict in this situation.

*A simple fix would be to change the language of 10-4-2 exception to read similar to the Roughing the passer enforcement.

EXCEPTION: The basic spot may, at the option of the offended team, be the DEAD BALL spot for fouls by K during a legal free or scrimmage kick down (other than kick catch interference) prior to the end of the kick when K will not be next to put the ball in play.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: ttown44 on November 15, 2021, 10:04:20 AM
Let's remember that carry over penalties apply when a foul is committed by the opponent of the scoring team.  Whereas this is a missed field goal, there is no scoring team and thus carrying over the penalty is not an option.  What we do have is a live ball foul.  Therefore, we have an untimed down (as Ralph stated) if accepted.  R could elect to have the penalty accessed on the succeeding spot, which would be the 20 yard line as the result of the play was a touchback.  This is a phenomenal play for preseason discussion as it incorporates three components of penalty enforcement:  Carry-over, Untimed down, and Kick Play enforcement.
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: CalhounLJ on November 15, 2021, 10:40:58 AM
Let's remember that carry over penalties apply when a foul is committed by the opponent of the scoring team.  Whereas this is a missed field goal, there is no scoring team and thus carrying over the penalty is not an option.  What we do have is a live ball foul.  Therefore, we have an untimed down (as Ralph stated) if accepted.  R could elect to have the penalty accessed on the succeeding spot, which would be the 20 yard line as the result of the play was a touchback.  This is a phenomenal play for preseason discussion as it incorporates three components of penalty enforcement:  Carry-over, Untimed down, and Kick Play enforcement.

You're way behind in the discussion. The issue is the succeeding spot. The rulebook definition of succeeding spot is where the ball would next be put in play IF THERE HAD BEEN NO FOUL. In this situation, that spot would be the first play in overtime, not the R20. And, this of course is in conflict with 3-3 and playing an untimed down.
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: NVFOA_Ump on November 15, 2021, 11:26:26 AM
Had some discussion on this with our "senior" R's on our board and the clear consensus here is that since we have a penalty to enforce that would trigger an untimed down then effectively we have not completed the 4th quarter yet and reading the language " ... if there had been no foul." to result in a carryover to OT would be inappropriate in this case. We would treat as any other play that still had time left, and enforce with the untimed down in this specific case.  By no means is that a definitive answer but seems to be a common sense approach to resolving the apparent rules conflict.  Certainly the wording could be improved but it appears to the majority here that we believe that the intent is clear enough.
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: CalhounLJ on November 16, 2021, 05:44:22 AM
Had some discussion on this with our "senior" R's on our board and the clear consensus here is that since we have a penalty to enforce that would trigger an untimed down then effectively we have not completed the 4th quarter yet and reading the language " ... if there had been no foul." to result in a carryover to OT would be inappropriate in this case. We would treat as any other play that still had time left, and enforce with the untimed down in this specific case.  By no means is that a definitive answer but seems to be a common sense approach to resolving the apparent rules conflict.  Certainly the wording could be improved but it appears to the majority here that we believe that the intent is clear enough.
Ok. Would we do that at the end of the first quarter as well? K misses a field goal and commits a foul. If R accepts the penalty we give R the ball on the 20 and play an untimed down in the first quarter? Because we wouldn’t do it with any other succeeding spot foul.

I agree the common sense solution is to play an untimed down, but this completely destroys the concept of succeeding spot enforcement.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: Ralph Damren on November 16, 2021, 07:36:49 AM
IMHO, while most succeeding spot enforcements are either dead ball or live-ball ,treated as dead ball, fouls with the rationale the act did not have a baring on the play. The tack-on rule is applied at the end of the play, as it is a live ball foul but without end-of-run potential ,as there may not be any return or possession by R to apply such. Every play has a succeeding spot and this is a rare live-ball enforcement.
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: bossman72 on November 16, 2021, 09:14:22 AM
IMHO, while most succeeding spot enforcements are either dead ball or live-ball ,treated as dead ball, fouls with the rationale the act did not have a baring on the play. The tack-on rule is applied at the end of the play, as it is a live ball foul but without end-of-run potential ,as there may not be any return or possession by R to apply such. Every play has a succeeding spot and this is a rare live-ball enforcement.

This is why I don't like it saying "succeeding spot" because that makes it seem like a live ball treated as dead ball foul, which these aren't.

I think that's why the NCAA rulebook says "where the subsequent dead ball belongs to Team B" instead of "succeeding spot" to avoid the potential confusion.  I'd like to see that as an editorial change.
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: KWH on November 16, 2021, 04:11:26 PM
This is why I don't like it saying "succeeding spot" because that makes it seem like a live ball treated as dead ball foul, which these aren't.

I think that's why the NCAA rulebook says "where the subsequent dead ball belongs to Team B" instead of "succeeding spot" to avoid the potential confusion.  I'd like to see that as an editorial change.

I like it. Only problem is the cut off date for rule changes is always November 1.
Too late for this year but certainly a good discussion topic for the January meeting.
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: CalhounLJ on November 16, 2021, 05:23:47 PM
Finally…


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: bossman72 on November 17, 2021, 08:41:35 AM
I like it. Only problem is the cut off date for rule changes is always November 1.
Too late for this year but certainly a good discussion topic for the January meeting.

Even for editorial changes?  This is definitely editorial.
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: NVFOA_Ump on November 17, 2021, 10:37:27 AM
Haven't had time to do a true detailed research project on this but it appears from a quick look that this issue basically evolved over time as sections of the rules were added and/or changed without putting all of the related pieces together to see what the "final result" would be.  What other problems would be introduced if we change the wording in the definition of succeeding spot to read "The succeeding spot is where the ball would next be snapped or free kicked prior to any penalty enforcement." ?
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: CalhounLJ on November 17, 2021, 02:07:13 PM
Haven't had time to do a true detailed research project on this but it appears from a quick look that this issue basically evolved over time as sections of the rules were added and/or changed without putting all of the related pieces together to see what the "final result" would be.  What other problems would be introduced if we change the wording in the definition of succeeding spot to read "The succeeding spot is where the ball would next be snapped or free kicked prior to any penalty enforcement." ?

Nothing really, except it wouldn't solve the problem in this instance. In the instance of a missed field goal during a tied game on the last play of regulation, the spot where the ball would next be snapped or free kicked prior to any penalty enforcement would still be the first play in overtime.
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: CalhounLJ on November 17, 2021, 02:11:35 PM
The simple solution is to change the wording in the 10-4-2 exception to read "where the subsequent dead ball belongs to Team B." Because the option at the end of a period cannot be the succeeding spot. I looked up every time the phrase "succeeding spot" came up in the case book, and every time it was the spot where the ball would next be put into play if there had been no foul. We go to that spot, and then, if applicable, enforce a penalty from that spot.
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: PABJNR on November 17, 2021, 03:01:13 PM
Ok. Would we do that at the end of the first quarter as well? K misses a field goal and commits a foul. If R accepts the penalty we give R the ball on the 20 and play an untimed down in the first quarter? Because we wouldn’t do it with any other succeeding spot foul.

I agree the common sense solution is to play an untimed down, but this completely destroys the concept of succeeding spot enforcement.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
It will be at least the 25.  10-4-2 exception.  I know that wasn’t the point of the post….but I couldn’t resist LOL.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: NVFOA_Ump on November 17, 2021, 03:13:48 PM
Nothing really, except it wouldn't solve the problem in this instance. In the instance of a missed field goal during a tied game on the last play of regulation, the spot where the ball would next be snapped or free kicked prior to any penalty enforcement would still be the first play in overtime.

But is it really the last play in regulation?  By rule the ball "belongs to B" when the whistle blows and don't the rules also say that a down has not "ended" until all penalties have been completed?
Title: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: CalhounLJ on November 17, 2021, 03:42:55 PM
"The succeeding spot is where the ball would next be snapped or free kicked prior to any penalty enforcement." ?
If we are talking succeeding spot, the answer is yes. Take a look at your suggestion and consider the play in question. Once the play was over, according to the present definition, the succeeding spot would be the first play in overtime, because that’s where the ball would next be snapped if there had been no foul. Using your suggestion, once the play was over, the spot would still be the first play in overtime., because that’s the spot where the ball would next be snapped prior to enforcement. There is no situation in which, after a missed field goal at the end of regulation in a tied game when we would ever spot the ball at the R20. It would always be at the succeeding spot, which would be the first play in OT.

If we go with the other suggestion, by rule the dead ball spot for a scrimmage kick in the end zone is the R20. So we place the ball at the dead ball spot with R in possession and play an untimed down. Problem solved. The succeeding spot philosophy is intact, and we have solved the untimed down issue. I like it.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: ncwingman on November 17, 2021, 10:24:35 PM
The simple solution is to change the wording in the 10-4-2 exception to read "where the subsequent dead ball belongs to Team B."

I don't disagree with what you're trying to do, but that wording sets up a bit of a timing problem.

When does Team B gain possession of a scrimmage kick that goes out of bounds or crosses the goal line? One could make an argument that when the ball becomes dead, it's still in Team A's possession and only becomes Team B ball after evaluation of the play. Therefore, the ball becomes dead in Team A possession and doesn't meet your criteria. It may be a bit of fly poop in the pepper, but I don't think it's as straightforward as you're hoping.
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: HLinNC on November 18, 2021, 05:31:32 AM
Perhaps just an added case play with a ruling, similar to or just use this example.
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: CalhounLJ on November 18, 2021, 06:21:02 AM
I don't disagree with what you're trying to do, but that wording sets up a bit of a timing problem.

When does Team B gain possession of a scrimmage kick that goes out of bounds or crosses the goal line? One could make an argument that when the ball becomes dead, it's still in Team A's possession and only becomes Team B ball after evaluation of the play. Therefore, the ball becomes dead in Team A possession and doesn't meet your criteria. It may be a bit of fly poop in the pepper, but I don't think it's as straightforward as you're hoping.
Not trying to pass the buck here, but that’s the actual language in the ncaa version of this rule, as suggested by bossman just a few posts earlier.  I’m assuming they have an answer to your proposed argument.

Additionally, I see your problem solved in much the same way as the philosophy behind PSK. Since a field goal is a scrimmage kick that can score, we consider possession changed for penalty enforcement as soon as the ball is in the air beyond the line. So technically, as far as penalty enforcement goes, it belongs to B/R at that point. That’s exactly how we would treat a foul by R in this case. Why not K?


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: CalhounLJ on November 18, 2021, 06:26:14 AM
Perhaps just an added case play with a ruling, similar to or just use this example.
This is not a solution. It’s simply ignoring the problem. I don’t know of any rule in the book that creates a situation where you have ignore one part of a rule to be able to enforce another. If we just say “ in this particular instance, ignore the last phrase of the definition of succeeding spot, put the ball on the R20, and run an untimed down,” we have ignored a significant portion of the definition of succeeding spot.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Title: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: CalhounLJ on November 18, 2021, 06:56:16 AM
I don't disagree with what you're trying to do, but that wording sets up a bit of a timing problem.

When does Team B gain possession of a scrimmage kick that goes out of bounds or crosses the goal line? One could make an argument that when the ball becomes dead, it's still in Team A's possession and only becomes Team B ball after evaluation of the play. Therefore, the ball becomes dead in Team A possession and doesn't meet your criteria. It may be a bit of fly poop in the pepper, but I don't think it's as straightforward as you're hoping.
You could also use this argument not to apply the exception. If, at the end of the down A/K is still technically in possession, then 10-4-2 exception would not apply, and B/R would have to accept a 5yd from previous spot with untimed down, or decline and go to overtime. Which would be ideal. 

But still, that wouldn’t work either,  because the exception states that k is not the next to put the ball in play. So, because R will be the next to put the ball in play, the exception still applies. But, where is R going to put the ball in play? If it’s the succeeding spot, it’s the first play in overtime, but that depends on how the coin toss plays out. So, technically we can’t even apply succeeding spot enforcement here because we don’t know who will have the ball. That’s why succeeding spot language is bad in the exception. Much better to use the language suggested.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: NVFOA_Ump on November 18, 2021, 08:53:22 AM
So back to a previously discussed question.  Isn't it correct under NFHS rules to say that a half cannot end until all live ball fouls have been completed? 
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: CalhounLJ on November 18, 2021, 08:57:36 AM
Yes. Which is why succeeding spot language in the exception is so bad.
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: CalhounLJ on November 18, 2021, 09:21:53 AM
My argument in a nutshell:

The play in question: K misses a field goal on the last play of regulation in a tie game. K commits a live ball foul (illegal formation) on this play.

The enforcement: Using the 10-4-2 exception, R has three options: 1. Decline and go to overtime. 2. 5yd penalty from the previous spot, with a replay of the down.  3. Tack on 5yds at the succeeding spot.

The problem: The definition of succeeding spot in the rulebook is: “The spot where the ball would next be snapped or free kicked if a foul had not occurred.” In this particular situation, the succeeding spot is the first play in overtime. Under no circumstances would the ball ever be snapped at the R20 after a missed field goal during the last play in regulation in a tied game if a foul does not occur. That spot would ALWAYS be the first play in overtime.

The other problem: 3-3 commands us to extend the period and play an untimed down on an accepted live ball foul by either team. We can’t do that at the succeeding spot, because the succeeding spot is the first play in overtime. So, we can’t go to overtime.

Solution: To be able to apply 10-4-2 exception to this play: 1. The succeeding spot language would have to be removed and other language added (similar or identical to the suggestion by bossman).  2. Rule that the exception cannot apply because we can’t end the period on an accepted foul, and to apply the exception we would have to end the period and go to the succeeding spot, which is the first play in overtime. So, in this situation, R would have to accept enforcement at previous spot or decline.
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: bossman72 on November 18, 2021, 09:47:29 AM
So, in this situation, R would have to accept enforcement at previous spot or decline.

In NCAA it's handled this way.
First, they don't allow tack-on penalties on field goals, so let's pretend this was a punt for a touchback. 
Their options would be to decline and go to OT, enforce 5 from previous and replay the down, or tack on 5 from the 20 and have 1st and 10 from the 25 with an untimed down, since it's an accepted live ball foul to extend the period.

This is one thing I don't like about the NFHS rule making process.  They copy a rule from NCAA but don't copy the rule book language just to be different... "because we're not NCAA".  They end up screwing it up and it takes 2 or 3 rule change cycles to correct it.
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: PABJNR on November 18, 2021, 09:47:34 AM
The way the rule is written one can argue in this case there is no succeeding spot.  For OT to be the succeeding spot, the 4th quarter has to have ended, which because of the foul it can’t end by rule.  By the definition of succeeding spot if the foul had not occurred, the period would have ended.

I would say in this case the basic spot would move to the 20 and there would be an untamed down after enforcement, which I believe would comply with the spirit of the rule.

Look at 10.4.4 Situation B in case book.  They say basic spot is 20, as the 20 is succeeding spot on a touchback.  If this play happened on the last play of a tied game would it be the same dilemma?

My opinion is the foul, the way the current rules are written and by the spirit of the rule is to have an untimed down following enforcement from the 20.  I just can’t get to an enforcement in OT as the period has not expired.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: NVFOA_Ump on November 18, 2021, 11:36:00 AM
I agree.  This cannot go to OT since IMHO that clearly violates the requirement that the game cannot end until the live ball penalties have been completed.  I would focus on revising the language in definition of succeeding spot since the added language, again IMHO, simply does not belong there.
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: KWH on November 18, 2021, 07:38:58 PM
So back to a previously discussed question.  Isn't it correct under NFHS rules to say that a half cannot end until all live ball fouls have been completed?

YES - NFHS Rule 3-3-3a
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: CalhounLJ on November 19, 2021, 06:13:22 AM
Yes. Which is why succeeding spot language in the exception is so bad.
Retweet


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: Ralph Damren on November 19, 2021, 09:59:59 AM
IMHO, succeeding spot is often synonymous with end of run, such as when big ole' Bubba wanders out on the field to git a better look while the play is still going but doesn't participate. That is a live ball foul with succeeding spot enforcement which will probably be the end of the run - unless it was a loose ball play via definition. It which case the succeeding spot would also be also be the preceding spot. With the tack-on rule, end of run couldn't be used as there might not be any run, just the kick rolling dead. The location of the kick becoming dead would be the succeeding spot.

While there may be fly=poop in the pepper shaker, it still tastes good  eAt& on my 'tatters and greens :).
Title: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: CalhounLJ on November 19, 2021, 11:17:11 AM
IMHO, succeeding spot is often synonymous with end of run, such as when big ole' Bubba wanders out on the field to git a better look while the play is still going but doesn't participate. That is a live ball foul with succeeding spot enforcement which will probably be the end of the run - unless it was a loose ball play via definition. It which case the succeeding spot would also be also be the preceding spot. With the tack-on rule, end of run couldn't be used as there might not be any run, just the kick rolling dead. The location of the kick becoming dead would be the succeeding spot.

While there may be fly=poop in the pepper shaker, it still tastes good  eAt& on my 'tatters and greens :).
Apply that same logic to a field goal that scores. If K kicks a field goal that ties the game on the last play of regulation, and R fouls, 8-4-3 states K can keep the score and have the penalty enforced at the succeeding spot. Where is that succeeding spot? At any other time in the game, the succeeding spot would be the kickoff, unless it’s the last play of the half. but not in this situation. In this situation the succeeding spot is the first play in overtime. Why? Because that’s the spot where the ball would next be put in play if no foul had occurred.

Which brings up another question. Why is it that on scoring plays we have no problem setting aside 3-3, but on the 10-4-2 exception it’s forbidden? It’s still an accepted live ball foul. Other than just because?


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: PABJNR on November 19, 2021, 02:15:52 PM
I think it comes down to spirit of the rule and philosophy.  On a made field goal, the philosophy is the foul to not go unpunished and the succeeding spot is clearly the next kickoff or OT.

With the play we are talking about, the spirit is to prevent a re-kick.  Also the 10-4-2 exception states when k will not be next to put the ball into play. We don’t know that if we move to OT.

I totally get where you are coming from though, but I think that is why the difference on the thought process. 


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: CalhounLJ on November 19, 2021, 02:41:11 PM
I agree with the philosophy and have no problem with the different enforcements. The issue is that at the present time we need two different definitions of succeeding spot to make it work.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: sczeebra on February 22, 2022, 06:17:23 PM
From what I can see, this dilemma was not cleared up with any changes to the Rules Book. Does anyone know if this has been addressed in the Case Book?
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: Ralph Damren on March 06, 2022, 12:37:50 PM
The dilemma is actually cleared by the statement under the title : RESOLVING TIED GAMES.

" This procedure may be accepted as written, amended, or rejected in whole or part, by each member state association."

One's state association could handle it as they choose. If it occurred in Maine, I would rule the tack-on foul was part of the 4th quarter and not to be carried into overtime.
Title: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: CalhounLJ on March 07, 2022, 07:09:12 AM
The dilemma is actually cleared by the statement under the title : RESOLVING TIED GAMES.

" This procedure may be accepted as written, amended, or rejected in whole or part, by each member state association."

One's state association could handle it as they choose. If it occurred in Maine, I would rule the tack-on foul was part of the 4th quarter and not to be carried into overtime.
Ralph, can you give any insight as to the reluctance of the rules committee to enforce a foul on a non scoring play in overtime, while allowing it on certain scores? If the play in question had been a foul by the defense on a score, we could move that to overtime, even though it would be live ball, but on this one we can’t. It has to be something philosophy related.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: Ralph Damren on March 07, 2022, 07:34:01 AM
Ralph, can you give any insight as to the reluctance of the rules committee to enforce a foul on a non scoring play in overtime, while allowing it on certain scores? If the play in question had been a foul by the defense on a score, we could move that to overtime, even though it would be live ball, but on this one we can’t. It has to be something philosophy related.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
When we put in the 'bridge' foul enforcement, we felt it would complicate matters for OT choices to bridge such fouls over, hence the term subsequent kickoff, as there aren't any kickoffs in OT. A dead ball foul has occurred after the PAT/FG occurred after the period had ended and would be enforced on the opening play of OT. Very important to notify both coaches of this as it may impact the decision on choice.
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: CalhounLJ on March 07, 2022, 08:22:25 AM
When we put in the 'bridge' foul enforcement, we felt it would complicate matters for OT choices to bridge such fouls over, hence the term subsequent kickoff, as there aren't any kickoffs in OT. A dead ball foul has occurred after the PAT/FG occurred after the period had ended and would be enforced on the opening play of OT. Very important to notify both coaches of this as it may impact the decision on choice.

Thanks. Using the terms "Kickoff" and "succeeding spot" was wise, because that's the way I learned to apply the various enforcements. I understand that a live ball foul by the defense on a touchdown scoring play cannot be bridged to overtime, because the language states "subsequent kickoff," and there is no kickoff in Overtime.

Also, as I understand the rule, a live-ball foul by the defense on a field-goal scoring play CAN be bridged to overtime though, because the language states "succeeding spot." I have always understood the term "succeeding spot" to be the same as the rule book states, "where the ball will next be put in play had there been no foul." That language fits the enforcement of a foul by the defense on a field-goal scoring play.

Example 1: K kicks a field goal to tie the game on the last play in regulation. R hurdles K in an attempt to block the field goal. Flag! Live ball foul for hurdling. If K chooses, they can take the field goal and have that penalty enforced at the succeeding spot, which is the first play in overtime, correct?

Now, turn the situation on its ear and consider this:

Example 2: K kicks a field goal to try and win a tied game on the last play in regulation. The field goal is no good. For some crazy reason, K hurdles R. Flag! Live ball foul for hurdling. If R chooses, they can accept the penalty, and according to 10-4-2 exception, have that penalty enforced at the succeeding spot, which is the first play in overtime.

The problem with Example 2 is we don't know whether K will be next to put the ball in play until we get there, so logically, we must deal with the penalty before we go. I understand that. But, we can't go to the succeeding spot to enforce it, because the definition of succeeding spot won't allow it.

Simple solution: The 10-4-2 exception can't apply because we don't know if K will be next to put the ball in play. Options for R: accept the penalty, enforce using all-but-one, make K rekick, or decline the penalty and go to overtime. Easy peasy.

Does that make any modicum of sense? If not, tell me where I'm wrong. I'm honestly trying to get this right in my head so I don't screw it up on Friday night.
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: Ralph Damren on March 07, 2022, 01:19:01 PM
I agree fully, Calhoun, with your 'easy peasey' choice. IMHO, only the  USC & DBPF fouls should carry over to OT . I suggest the following advice to the coaches :

Offending coach - "If you win the toss and choose offense, you will be goal to goal from the 25. If you choose defense, it will be goal to goal from the 5."

Offended coach- "If you win the toss and choose offense, you will be goal to goal from the 5. If you choose defense, it will be their ball, goal to go from the 25".

IMHO, its much better for the coaches to understand BEFORE the coin-toss than to argue about it after.  :)
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: NVFOA_Ump on March 07, 2022, 01:37:24 PM
So clear consensus on a few things here:

1.  Current rules require that a live ball foul penalty "be completed" PRIOR to a period ending.

2.  DB fouls may be carried over to OT depending on individual states options on how to handle this.

3.  We must know and be able to explain to "offended team" what options are in play here prior to the pre-OT meeting with the teams.

Still not sure that we have a definitive solution here?
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: KWH on March 07, 2022, 03:23:56 PM

3-3-3...A period shall be extended by an untimed down if one of the following occurred during a down in which time expired.
     a.   There was a foul by either team and the penalty is accepted, except for those fouls listed in 3-3-4b

3-3-4b  There was a foul by either team and the penalty is accepted for:
      1.  unsportsmanlike fouls,
      2.  nonplayer fouls,
      3.  fouls that specify loss of down,
      4.  fouls that are enforced on the subsequent kickoff as in Rule 8-2-2, 8-2-3, 8-2-4 or 8-2-5 or,
      5.  fouls for which enforcement, by rule, result in a safety.

The way I read these two rules if a fouls that qualifies for 10-4-2 EXCEPTION occurs, by rule, the period is not extended.

2-41-10...The succeeding spot is where the ball would next be snapped or free kicked if a foul had not occurred.


2-41-10 is NOT APPLICABLE in this situation.
Why? Because a foul did occur!
Title: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: CalhounLJ on March 07, 2022, 04:20:42 PM
2-41-10 is NOT APPLICABLE in this situation.
Why? Because a foul did occur!
[/quote]


This is completely wrong. I can list endless examples. But I will pick only one.

A USC foul is enforced from the succeeding spot every time. Where is that spot? Where the ball would next be put into play if there had been no foul.

Example: A ball 1st and 10 on the A10. A runs the ball 5 yds. During the play, B’s coach cusses an official. Flag! USC. Where will the penalty be enforced from? The A15. Why? Because that’s the succeeding spot. WHERE THE BALL WOULD NEXT BE PUT IN PLAY HAD THERE BEEN NO FOUL.

Even though a foul occurred, the definition of succeeding spot did not change.

This is the kind of interpretation that greatly disturbs me, especially concerning the future direction of the NFHS rules committee.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: CalhounLJ on March 07, 2022, 04:23:13 PM
I agree fully, Calhoun, with your 'easy peasey' choice. IMHO, only the  USC & DBPF fouls should carry over to OT . I suggest the following advice to the coaches :

Offending coach - "If you win the toss and choose offense, you will be goal to goal from the 25. If you choose defense, it will be goal to goal from the 5."

Offended coach- "If you win the toss and choose offense, you will be goal to goal from the 5. If you choose defense, it will be their ball, goal to go from the 25".

IMHO, its much better for the coaches to understand BEFORE the coin-toss than to argue about it after.  :)
Thanks Ralph.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: KWH on March 07, 2022, 07:40:15 PM
CalhounLJ -
Here is what I will do. The NFHS Rules Interpreter meeting this July in San Antonio, TX. and I will pose your play situation on the floor.
Now, this meeting is supposed to have the SRI (or his/her designee) from every member state.
Do they all show up?  Nope? 
Hopefully there will be a good turnout as allowing the passer to throw the ball away is a BIG BIG change. It would be nice if everyone at least started out of the same page.  I believe this will be a ZOOM meeting along with an in person meeting.
Some of you may wish to contact your SRI and see if they will be attending, if not, volunteer your services.

Remember this is a rules interpreter meeting so no rules will be changed, rather they will be interpreted.


 CalhounLJ - Please let me know which member state you are from? PM me if you would like!

Thank you
Title: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: CalhounLJ on March 08, 2022, 05:55:19 AM
CalhounLJ -
Here is what I will do. The NFHS Rules Interpreter meeting this July in San Antonio, TX. and I will pose your play situation on the floor.
Now, this meeting is supposed to have the SRI (or his/her designee) from every member state.
Do they all show up?  Nope? 
Hopefully there will be a good turnout as allowing the passer to throw the ball away is a BIG BIG change. It would be nice if everyone at least started out of the same page.  I believe this will be a ZOOM meeting along with an in person meeting.
Some of you may wish to contact your SRI and see if they will be attending, if not, volunteer your services.

Remember this is a rules interpreter meeting so no rules will be changed, rather they will be interpreted.


 CalhounLJ - Please let me know which member state you are from? PM me if you would like!

Thank you
Mississippi.

Thanks. This feels somewhat like the Prosecutor presenting the case for the defense, but I do appreciate the effort.  Hopefully you can get clarification on this. I do appreciate the effort. Thanks again.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: ElvisLives on March 08, 2022, 06:26:17 AM
CalhounLJ -
Here is what I will do. The NFHS Rules Interpreter meeting this July in San Antonio, TX. and I will pose your play situation on the floor.


Is this meeting for multiple sports? Or just football? If this is just football, I find it very interesting that the NFHS would choose the only state in the country that doesn't use NFHS rules to host this meeting. I wonder why?
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: NVFOA_Ump on March 08, 2022, 06:28:40 AM
Current wording:  2-41-10...The succeeding spot is where the ball would next be snapped or free kicked if a foul had not occurred.

What new problem(s) would revising the specific wording create?  2-41-10...The succeeding spot is where the ball would next be snapped or free kicked prior to penalty enforcement(s).

Given the previous discussion that we agree that a period cannot end prior to completion of all live ball fouls, I believe that this works and would/could be considered a simple "editorial change" since it does not really change the intent of the rule IMHO.
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: CalhounLJ on March 08, 2022, 06:42:05 AM
Current wording:  2-41-10...The succeeding spot is where the ball would next be snapped or free kicked if a foul had not occurred.

What new problem(s) would revising the specific wording create?  2-41-10...The succeeding spot is where the ball would next be snapped or free kicked prior to penalty enforcement(s).

I believe that this would/could be considered a simple "editorial change" since it does not really change the intent of the rule IMHO.
At first glance, it wouldn’t be a problem. It also wouldn’t solve this problem though.  The spot would still be where the ball would next be snapped or free kicked. Which in this case would be the first play in overtime. 

IMHO, the most effective way to rectify this situation is to Simply rule that the 10-4-2 exception doesn’t apply because at the time the ball becomes dead we don’t know whether K will be the next to put the ball in play. This could be done at the rule interpreters meeting. And administered by a case play.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: CalhounLJ on August 07, 2022, 09:19:18 PM
CalhounLJ -
Here is what I will do. The NFHS Rules Interpreter meeting this July in San Antonio, TX. and I will pose your play situation on the floor.
Now, this meeting is supposed to have the SRI (or his/her designee) from every member state.
Do they all show up?  Nope? 
Hopefully there will be a good turnout as allowing the passer to throw the ball away is a BIG BIG change. It would be nice if everyone at least started out of the same page.  I believe this will be a ZOOM meeting along with an in person meeting.
Some of you may wish to contact your SRI and see if they will be attending, if not, volunteer your services.

Remember this is a rules interpreter meeting so no rules will be changed, rather they will be interpreted.


 CalhounLJ - Please let me know which member state you are from? PM me if you would like!

Thank you
Any word on how this came out?


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: KWH on August 08, 2022, 12:31:13 PM

Sorry Calhoun - I had a family situation which unfortunately kept me from going to San Antonio

But, I have not forgotten you or your play, believe me my friend.
Title: Re: scrimmage kick--fg attempt
Post by: CalhounLJ on August 08, 2022, 02:14:01 PM
Sorry to hear about that. no problem.