RefStripes.com
Football Officiating => National Federation Discussion => Topic started by: CalhounLJ on July 26, 2022, 02:52:15 PM
-
Understanding that while it is legal to ground the ball using this exception when all requirements are met, this is still technically an illegal forward pass. Do we still treat it as such? Specifically, if there are ineligibles downfield, do we penalize? What about pass interference?
-
I’m not sure it’s still an illegal forward pass as it is an exception to being considered a illegal forward pass, so if it is not illegal it is legal. That being said probably going to hold a flag on DPI , OPI unless it’s egregious. Ineligible down field, while being technically correct may not be a quality flag on a throw away, using advantage/disadvantage philosophies. Just my two cents for thought.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
I believe Ineligibles downfield should be penalized. The ineligible downfield creates an advantage for the offense and the defense should be able to pick if they want the down to count or take the five yard penalty and replay the down.
The play I see being most unfair if we don’t penalize ineligibles is the following.
A80 (a wideout) runs a jet sweep and after receiving the handoff, A67 is 5 yards downfield blocking (as he could for a designed run). A80 is bottled up 7 yards behind the line of scrimmage by a good defensive play after leaving the lateral boundary of the fbz and throws the ball away past the neutral zone to avoid losing 7 yards.
Why should we not flag A for ineligible downfield and let B choose what they want to do?
-
Understanding that while it is legal to ground the ball using this exception when all requirements are met, this is still technically an illegal forward pass. Do we still treat it as such? Specifically, if there are ineligibles downfield, do we penalize? What about pass interference?
IMHO I also agree that this is now a legal forward pass since it is a clear documented exception to the IFP rules. I also believe that the lack of guidance regarding ineligibles, DPI, and OPI on a "throw-away" is causing angst among us. It's already been posted in multiple arenas that individual states are publishing "guidelines" that on a legal dumped pass officials should keep their flag in their pocket while other states are mandating full enforcement of the rules as written (ie: if it's there flag it). That's not a good look IMHO.
And I'll add a further opinion in that by not limiting the description of the passer (ex. the player who receives the snap) we're potentially looking like backyard flag football if coaches pick up on this obvious oversight. The stated intent of allowing a legal throwaway is to protect the QB from taking a few unneeded hits during the course of a game and not to "save yardage" on a busted play.
IMHO these issues need to be addressed by NFHS to both clarify the rules and make the intended enforcement(s) of the rule clear. The fact that these same 3 or 4 issues are being discussed all over the internet on NFHS officiating boards says to me that they need to be addressed.
-
IMHO I also agree that this is now a legal forward pass since it is a clear documented exception to the IFP rules. I also believe that the lack of guidance regarding ineligibles, DPI, and OPI on a "throw-away" is causing angst among us. It's already been posted in multiple arenas that individual states are publishing "guidelines" that on a legal dumped pass officials should keep their flag in their pocket while other states are mandating full enforcement of the rules as written (ie: if it's there flag it). That's not a good look IMHO.
And I'll add a further opinion in that by not limiting the description of the passer (ex. the player who receives the snap) we're potentially looking like backyard flag football if coaches pick up on this obvious oversight. The stated intent of allowing a legal throwaway is to protect the QB from taking a few unneeded hits during the course of a game and not to "save yardage" on a busted play.
IMHO these issues need to be addressed by NFHS to both clarify the rules and make the intended enforcement(s) of the rule clear. The fact that these same 3 or 4 issues are being discussed all over the internet on NFHS officiating boards says to me that they need to be addressed.
I agree completely. Give us about 3 years…
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
I believe Ineligibles downfield should be penalized. The ineligible downfield creates an advantage for the offense and the defense should be able to pick if they want the down to count or take the five yard penalty and replay the down.
The play I see being most unfair if we don’t penalize ineligibles is the following.
A80 (a wideout) runs a jet sweep and after receiving the handoff, A67 is 5 yards downfield blocking (as he could for a designed run). A80 is bottled up 7 yards behind the line of scrimmage by a good defensive play after leaving the lateral boundary of the fbz and throws the ball away past the neutral zone to avoid losing 7 yards.
Why should we not flag A for ineligible downfield and let B choose what they want to do?
Agree this situation should be flagged. This is why I like the forum. This play A definitely gained an advantage by fouling. Probably also on an RPO that goes south, is another one that needs called.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
The issue I see with the "throw away" is if there is a defensive foul- IUH or potential DPI-that effects an eligible receivers route and the passer feels that their only remaining option is to legally chuck it away; do we need to be more expansive on our viewpoint of 7-5-11c? (Contact by B is obviously away from the direction of the pass.)
-
The issue I see with the "throw away" is if there is a defensive foul- IUH or potential DPI-that effects an eligible receivers route and the passer feels that their only remaining option is to legally chuck it away; do we need to be more expansive on our viewpoint of 7-5-11c? (Contact by B is obviously away from the direction of the pass.)
I think in what’s described it would probably be defensive holding as the pass came after the potential foul. DPI restrictions don’t start until the pass is in flight. If the QB is throwing it away I would personally have a hard time calling DPI….but I would call holding, UNR , etc. Again this is based on philosophy that my mentors have passed down. I’m not saying DPI is wrong, just giving thoughts how I will handle officiating the new rule exception.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
I think in what’s described it would probably be defensive holding as the pass came after the potential foul. DPI restrictions don’t start until the pass is in flight. If the QB is throwing it away I would personally have a hard time calling DPI….but I would call holding, UNR , etc. Again this is based on philosophy that my mentors have passed down. I’m not saying DPI is wrong, just giving thoughts how I will handle officiating the new rule exception.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I will go further. DPI is wrong.
You could definitely have a Defensive Hold before the pass is thrown. That may well be why the passer had to end up dumping the pass.
But DPI? No. Restrictions on the defense for PI begin when the pass is thrown. And he throws it away, so how could B possibly interfere with that pass?
You can have other fouls, but you just can't have DPI when the passer throws the ball away.
-
And I'll add a further opinion in that by not limiting the description of the passer (ex. the player who receives the snap) we're potentially looking like backyard flag football if coaches pick up on this obvious oversight. The stated intent of allowing a legal throwaway is to protect the QB from taking a few unneeded hits during the course of a game and not to "save yardage" on a busted play.
The "player that received the snap" exception only came into existence in NCAA rules about 2013. Before then there was no provision and it looked like the current NFHS rule. The rule has been in existence since 1994 in the NFL and probably a few years later in NCAA. Have you ever seen it abused from the 90s until 2013? No. They don't want to risk a fumble by having a RB switch hands and throw it. So I think we're worried about nothing.
-
The "player that received the snap" exception only came into existence in NCAA rules about 2013. Before then there was no provision and it looked like the current NFHS rule. The rule has been in existence since 1994 in the NFL and probably a few years later in NCAA. Have you ever seen it abused from the 90s until 2013? No. They don't want to risk a fumble by having a RB switch hands and throw it. So I think we're worried about nothing.
This was discussed in length at the rules meeting. The three states that ran this as an experiment reported that it never occurred. There a couple of coaches on the rules committee and they stated that a running back, taking a handoff, has only one thing in mind : gaining yardage, and would never consider dumping the ball. I agree with Bossman that this is not a worry. IF it should become one, a tweak can be made in the future to prevent it. Recalling PSK, I believe that there was three times that we tweaked that after it's initial passage.
-
So I think we're worried about nothing.
a) Yes, this is the internet.
b) I feel many recent rule changes came about over worries that coaches/players would exploit something, but it never really came to fruition. Or maybe, one coach did it once, but it wasn't a widespread problem. Barring some severe oversights, I think we need to let things become problems before trying to fix them. Sometimes I feel the rules committee changes a rule because the job of the rules committee is to change rules, not because there's a problem that needs addressed by the rule change. For example, reducing the illegal kicking penalty from 15 to 10 yards a few years ago.
-
a) Yes, this is the internet.
b) I feel many recent rule changes came about over worries that coaches/players would exploit something, but it never really came to fruition. Or maybe, one coach did it once, but it wasn't a widespread problem. Barring some severe oversights, I think we need to let things become problems before trying to fix them. Sometimes I feel the rules committee changes a rule because the job of the rules committee is to change rules, not because there's a problem that needs addressed by the rule change. For example, reducing the illegal kicking penalty from 15 to 10 yards a few years ago.
I think I prefer a more proactive/preventive approach. I would rather think through all the possible scenarios/ramifications, and try to write the rule as precisely as possible the first time around, rather than throw out a rough draft and fix the problems as they pop up. That's what frustrates me with these types of rules changes. This one in particular is modeled after the NCAA rule, which has been thoroughly thought out, vetted, and faced the rigors of actual game implementation. The refusal to adopt the NCAA version and instead go the route of reinventing the wheel is maddening...
As for the passer vs the player who initially received the snap discussion, I agree it's been a long time since I've seen a running back throw a pass, but it's legal, valid, and can happen. Why not just be prepared if/when it does?
-
I think I prefer a more proactive/preventive approach. I would rather think through all the possible scenarios/ramifications, and try to write the rule as precisely as possible the first time around, rather than throw out a rough draft and fix the problems as they pop up. That's what frustrates me with these types of rules changes. This one in particular is modeled after the NCAA rule, which has been thoroughly thought out, vetted, and faced the rigors of actual game implementation. The refusal to adopt the NCAA version and instead go the route of reinventing the wheel is maddening...
As for the passer vs the player who initially received the snap discussion, I agree it's been a long time since I've seen a running back throw a pass, but it's legal, valid, and can happen. Why not just be prepared if/when it does?
Agree 100% here. Why in any form or good rules change development could the NFHS ignore these issues that the NCAA has endured and resolved. We've got dozens of states working on their own "solutions" on this which is, sorry but simply absurd given how this rule evolved over time at both the NFL and NCAA levels.
Again, sorry, but IMHO on this one the NFHS rules committee flat out flunked the exam here. This borders on the absurd given the proven history on how to handle this.
-
The "player that received the snap" exception only came into existence in NCAA rules about 2013. Before then there was no provision and it looked like the current NFHS rule. The rule has been in existence since 1994 in the NFL and probably a few years later in NCAA. Have you ever seen it abused from the 90s until 2013? No. They don't want to risk a fumble by having a RB switch hands and throw it. So I think we're worried about nothing.
Exactly.
-
Realizing that NFHS Rules are used by a wide range of age groups and skill levels, I have no problem whatsoever with modifying NCAA rules language where player safety or competitive balance is concerned.
This is not one of those cases.
-
Realizing that NFHS Rules are used by a wide range of age groups and skill levels, I have no problem whatsoever with modifying NCAA rules language where player safety or competitive balance is concerned.
This is not one of those cases.
I agree with you all that it's frustrating when the NFHS quite often takes a rule they like from the NCAA and rewrite it with subtle (and perhaps unintended) differences for no more apparent reason than "It Wasn't Invented Here".
But I wonder if perhaps they had to do just that in this case in order to get it passed? I'm just speculating of course. But it's a rather large committee and if I recall correctly, requires some sort of super-majority to get something passed.
Their stated purpose for this rule is player safety. As opposed to just wanting the same rule as college and the pros. That might be how they finally got over the hump to get it passed, by convincing a few more committee members that it was a safety thing. Again, I'm totally speculating here and that might not be the case at all.
Anyway, if they say it's for safety, then I suppose that logically they needed to include anyone that ended up passing the ball, and not just the QB.
Ultimately, I don't think this new rule will be as hard to officiate as everyone seems to fear. And if it turns out to be, now that they've got this much in place, it should be easy for them to tweak it as needed. Or maybe I'm giving the committee too much benefit of the doubt here in my speculating. I do know that I very much appreciate the committee members who routinely post on here.
-
I agree with you all that it's frustrating when the NFHS quite often takes a rule they like from the NCAA and rewrite it with subtle (and perhaps unintended) differences for no more apparent reason than "It Wasn't Invented Here".
But I wonder if perhaps they had to do just that in this case in order to get it passed? I'm just speculating of course. But it's a rather large committee and if I recall correctly, requires some sort of super-majority to get something passed.
Their stated purpose for this rule is player safety. As opposed to just wanting the same rule as college and the pros. That might be how they finally got over the hump to get it passed, by convincing a few more committee members that it was a safety thing. Again, I'm totally speculating here and that might not be the case at all.
Anyway, if they say it's for safety, then I suppose that logically they needed to include anyone that ended up passing the ball, and not just the QB.
Ultimately, I don't think this new rule will be as hard to officiate as everyone seems to fear. And if it turns out to be, now that they've got this much in place, it should be easy for them to tweak it as needed. Or maybe I'm giving the committee too much benefit of the doubt here in my speculating. I do know that I very much appreciate the committee members who routinely post on here.
The thread has wandered from the original question. I can understand the player vs QB difference and really don’t have a problem with it. The frustration I’m having is that while the rule serves a purpose, the introduction of the rule and the information provided was not comprehensive enough for us to adequately officiate it on the field. We just got the exception in the rule book with no explanation on what to do if the pass is tipped, or we have a foul, etc.
It’s been the same with the last couple rules changes and or additions.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
The thread has wandered from the original question. I can understand the player vs QB difference and really don’t have a problem with it. The frustration I’m having is that while the rule serves a purpose, the introduction of the rule and the information provided was not comprehensive enough for us to adequately officiate it on the field. We just got the exception in the rule book with no explanation on what to do if the pass is tipped, or we have a foul, etc.
It’s been the same with the last couple rules changes and or additions.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Sure, I understand. I mostly work games with other rules. But I do observe and also work a few subvarsity games when I can. So I understand your frustration.
Sooner or later, you should get official guidance from your state/interpreter/etc. In the meantime, here's how I propose handling this new rule:
- You can't have DPI when the passer throws the ball away. You can have one or the other. It was DPI or else he threw it away.
- However, you can certainly have a Defensive Hold before the ball is thrown.
- If the pass gets within a half yard or so of the LOS, then it's made it. (You will see this called much tighter in college though this year. Due to Replay and all of the cameras, they have to make the line.)
- And in 5-man mechanics, when in doubt, it's made it.
- If an offensive player is clearly blocking downfield, then you could go with OPI. But an IDP (ineligible downfield) might be more appropriate since they ended up dumping it, and that would be my recommendation.
- If somebody other than the QB throws it away, and you have ineligibles downfield, call them for that IDP.
- If the QB legally throws it away, and you have ineligibles downfield, then you have a decision that is going to require a consensus in your state or area. In college, if the QB dumps it out of bounds or near the sideline, IDP is ignored. I like that. But others might disagree for the high school game and say make them do everything legal.
- Remember that if the passer legally throws it away, it doesn't have to go out of bounds. If he gets outside the free blocking zone, he can dump it 40 yds straight downfield.
Well, those are my suggestions. Like I said, sooner or later you're bound to get some official guidance.
-
I just received the attached Intentional Grounding Guidance document from the Michigan High School Athletic Association in an email to all their football officials.
I haven't reviewed it yet. Wanted to post it though so everyone can see what one state association's guidance is.
[attachment deleted by admin]
-
I just received the attached Intentional Grounding Guidance document from the Michigan High School Athletic Association in an email to all their football officials.
I haven't reviewed it yet. Wanted to post it though so everyone can see what one state association's guidance is.
Well there you go. Now that I've read it, in Michigan this year, if the passer throws it away near the sideline, we are not to call IDP. Even if it wasn't the QB.
Agree or not, at least we have guidance here in Michigan.
-
I just received the attached Intentional Grounding Guidance document from the Michigan High School Athletic Association in an email to all their football officials.
I haven't reviewed it yet. Wanted to post it though so everyone can see what one state association's guidance is.
That’s perfect. Imagine how consistent it would be if the NFHS would put out guidelines like this. Also, it didn’t take Michigan 3 years to figure it out either.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
That’s perfect. Imagine how consistent it would be if the NFHS would put out guidelines like this. Also, it didn’t take Michigan 3 years to figure it out either.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
It's long been understood that rational decisions will NEVER be able to address EVERY CONCEIVABLE "What if" question or idea. The existing exception "SPIKING" contained specific details, and has rejected efforts to expand (confuse) applicability, and has worked well for multiple decades. The current rule refers to "A pass thrown INTENTIONALLY into an area not occupied by an eligible offensive receiver" (as judged by a "game field official". Common sense would suggest that would NOT apply to a pass touched, blocked or the passer contacted in any way to cause a pass to be misdirected away from it's intended destination.
My understanding has been that this rule was designed and intended to prevent an Offense from benefitting from a potential UNFAIR ADVANTAGE when the defense has FAIRLY negated the potential advantage of the (passing) challenge chosen by the Offense, who bears full responsibility for successfully allowing their passer adequate time to select an eligible receiving target to successfully complete an intended pass, despite all the legal efforts of the defense to prevent that from happening.
-
The play I see being most unfair if we don’t penalize ineligibles is the following.
A80 (a wideout) runs a jet sweep and after receiving the handoff, A67 is 5 yards downfield blocking (as he could for a designed run). A80 is bottled up 7 yards behind the line of scrimmage by a good defensive play after leaving the lateral boundary of the fbz and throws the ball away past the neutral zone to avoid losing 7 yards.
Why should we not flag A for ineligible downfield and let B choose what they want to do?
A67 isn't just an ineligible downfield, if he is blocking 5 yards downfield it is OPI, 15 yards.
My rule of thumb on OPI, if A drives his man from the LOS more than 2 yards upfield I may flag for ineligible downfield, but not OPI. If A is downfield 5 yards blocking a LB or DB, well that pulls that defensive player out of pass coverage and I will flag for OPI.
-
That’s perfect. Imagine how consistent it would be if the NFHS would put out guidelines like this. Also, it didn’t take Michigan 3 years to figure it out either.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Gee whiz, what a novel idea! Cover the inter-related rules at the SAME TIME that you post a rules change. What a creative thought!
-
Gee whiz, what a novel idea! Cover the inter-related rules at the SAME TIME that you post a rules change. What a creative thought!
But there were no inter-related rules to cover since there were no inter-related rules which changed.
Ineligible receiver downfield Intentional grounding was discussed on many occasions and it was determined it shall be called; however, in most cases, it will be declined anyway.
Unfortunately the Michigan document also talks about a QB being under duress, however, this statement is NOT supported by NFHS which clearly state "whether or not under defensive pressure"[/i].
I agree DPI may be difficult (but not impossible) to call.
-
So, do you have an answer to my question that started this topic? Is this still an Illegal forward pass? Do we still treat it as such? Do we flag ineligible downfield?
Those are the “inter-related rules” that need to be addressed with this rule change.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
But there were no inter-related rules to cover since there were no inter-related rules which changed.
Intentional grounding was discussed on many occasions and it was determined it shall be called; however, in most cases, it will be declined anyway.
Unfortunately the Michigan document also talks about a QB being under duress, however, this statement is NOT supported by NFHS which clearly state "whether or not under defensive pressure"[/i].
I agree DPI may be difficult (but not impossible) to call.
This topic is dealing with intentional grounding NOT being called. That’s the point of the exception. I’m not sure what you mean by “it was determined it shall be called.” I certainly don’t understand what you mean by “in most cases it will be declined anyway.”
The question I posted is that while it is now legal to throw a pass that by definition is still an illegal forward pass, do we treat it as an illegal forward pass? If we do, we can’t call DPI, or ineligibles downfield, because those only apply to a LEGAL forward pass.
That’s the guidance we wish for from the NFHS. To leave that up to each state association is careless, and leads to errors, such as the Michigan document you pointed out.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
This topic is dealing with intentional grounding NOT being called. That’s the point of the exception. I’m not sure what you mean by “it was determined it shall be called.” I certainly don’t understand what you mean by “in most cases it will be declined anyway.”
The question I posted is that while it is now legal to throw a pass that by definition is still an illegal forward pass, do we treat it as an illegal forward pass? If we do, we can’t call DPI, or ineligibles downfield, because those only apply to a LEGAL forward pass.
That’s the guidance we wish for from the NFHS. To leave that up to each state association is careless, and leads to errors, such as the Michigan document you pointed out.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
1) If the passer meets both the requirements of 7-5-2d EXC 2 he/she has performed a LEGAL ACT. Restated, YES, this is a legal forward pass.
2) If an ineligible A player advances beyond the expanded neutral zone on a legal forward pass play before a legal forward pass that crosses the neutral zone is in flight he/she has committed IDP and this act shall be flagged per 7-5-12
3) Additionally, in the vast majority of cases, B will likely decline the IDP and take the result of the play simply because A/K has lost a down. (No rule - common sense)
4) There is intentionally no rules book support which requires the passer to be "under duress" for the passer to utilize 7-5-2d EXC 2
5) There is intentionally no rules book support for the passer to be the player which received the snap to utilize 7-5-2d EXC 2
6) There is intentionally no rules book support for NOT Calling IDP on A when they clearly commit 7-5-12
I hope that makes sense.
-
1) If the passer meets both the requirements of 7-5-2d EXC 2 he/she has performed a LEGAL ACT. Restated, YES, this is a legal forward pass.
2) If an ineligible A player advances beyond the expanded neutral zone on a legal forward pass play before a legal forward pass that crosses the neutral zone is in flight he/she has committed IDP and this act shall be flagged per 7-5-12
3) Additionally, in the vast majority of cases, B will likely decline the IDP and take the result of the play simply because A/K has lost a down. (No rule - common sense)
4) There is intentionally no rules book support which requires the passer to be "under duress" for the passer to utilize 7-5-2d EXC 2
5) There is intentionally no rules book support for the passer to be the player which received the snap to utilize 7-5-2d EXC 2
6) There is intentionally no rules book support for NOT Calling IDP on A when they clearly commit 7-5-12
I hope that makes sense.
It makes perfect sense. this is the type guidance we at the grass roots level are craving. Any chance it makes its way into the rule book? or casebook?
-
It makes perfect sense. this is the type guidance we at the grass roots level are craving. Any chance it makes its way into the rule book? or casebook?
I hear you loud and clear
With the help of my esteemed brethren from the land of down east, (Maine), We shall give it our best shot.
-
Situation 1 -
Prior to the snap, B12 immediately attempts to leave the field when he is substituted for. When the ball is snapped B12 is on the field 3 yards from B's sideline and on B's side of the NZ. B12 exits the field and does not participate in or affect the play.
What's the call? This is illegal substitution per the rules book 3-7-3 and the case book 3.7 Comment #1. The foul occurs simultaneous with the snap.
Situation 2 -
Prior to the snap, B12 immediately attempts to leave the field when he is substituted for. When the ball is snapped B12 is on the field 3 yards from B's sideline and on B's side of the NZ. B12 exits the field and does not participate in or affect the play. A1 receives the snap and runs outside the FBZ. From behind the LOS A1 throwns a forward pass out of bounds to an area not occupied by an eligible receiver. When the pass is released A77 is 5 yards beyond the NZ (3 yards beyond the expanded NZ). The ball lands beyond the neutral zone extended.
- Doesn't A77 presumably know the play and therefore shouldn't A77 know not to go beyond the ENZ?
- Is it fair if only the B12 foul is called?
- If the pass is considered an illegal forward pass, then in addition to DPI and IDF not being applicable, wouldn't Roughing The Passer also not be applicable? And wouldn't the inapplicability of RTP be contrary to reasoning for the new rule?
What's the call? It seems to me this is a legal forward pass, and there is a foul on each team which would offset. The down is replayed.
A final situation to think about -
- Ten seconds remaining in the game. A is losing 21-20.
- A's ball 3rd and 15 at B's 20-yard line.
- A attempts a pass play. A1 receives the snap and runs outside the FBZ. From behind the LOS A1 throwns a forward pass out of bounds to an area not occupied by an eligible receiver. When the pass is released A77 is 5 yards beyond the NZ (3 yards beyond the expanded NZ). The ball lands beyond the neutral zone extended. There are 3 seconds remaining in the game.
- If IDF is not called, it will be 4th down and 15, and A will have time for one more play from the B 20-yard line. A play option would be a FG try of 37 yards.
- If IDF is called, it will be 3th down and 20, and A will have time for one more play from the B 25-yard line. A play option would be a FG try of 42 yards.
Under NFHS Rules, I don't see the justification for ignoring IDF (and not giving B the option to accept or decline the penalty). The guidance by KWH is spot on.
The previously provided and future feedback and commentary on this topic is very much appreciated. Thank you.
-
But there were no inter-related rules to cover since there were no inter-related rules which changed.
Intentional grounding was discussed on many occasions and it was determined it shall be called; however, in most cases, it will be declined anyway.
Unfortunately the Michigan document also talks about a QB being under duress, however, this statement is NOT supported by NFHS which clearly state "whether or not under defensive pressure"[/i].
I agree DPI may be difficult (but not impossible) to call.
Am I missing something?
It's 5 yards from the spot of the foul and loss of down.
-
Am I missing something?
It's 5 yards from the spot of the foul and loss of down.
Yes I wrote intentional grounding when i meant to write Ineligible downfield - Sometimes it sux to get old.
Corrected statement:
Ineligible receiver downfield Intentional grounding was discussed on many occasions and it was determined it shall be called; however, in most cases, it will be declined anyway.
-
LOL you did it again, but we get what you are saying.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Yes I wrote intentional grounding when i meant to write Ineligible downfield - Sometimes it sux to get old.
Corrected statement:
Ineligible receiver downfield Intentional grounding was discussed on many occasions and it was determined it shall be called; however, in most cases, it will be declined anyway.
I'm with ya' brother.
-
While NCAA & NFL have 7/8 officials with strong weekly training, NFHS ,for the most part, has 4/5 officials with -maybe- a one per week meeting. Our rules committee takes that into consideration when proposing new rules. The more complex the rule, the more of a challange it becomes to both teach and apply. Points as such on this rule change are : (1) NO requirements that only the QB can pass; (2) NO requirements that the passer has to be within the FBZ guideline when recieving the snap; (3) NO requirement that a running back can't become said passer.
I didn't vote for this rule change, but will do my best to get our officials all on the same page. I've always felt that keeping a change as simple as possible always seems to work best.
-
While NCAA & NFL have 7/8 officials with strong weekly training, NFHS ,for the most part, has 4/5 officials with -maybe- a one per week meeting
I don’t have a dog in this hunt, but this is a pretty weak argument when you consider that Texas applies NCAA rules just fine with 4 or 5 man crews every week.
-
I don’t have a dog in this hunt, but this is a pretty weak argument when you consider that Texas applies NCAA rules just fine with 4 or 5 man crews every week.
I have no doubt that you totally misunderstood Ralphs point
-
I don’t have a dog in this hunt, but this is a pretty weak argument when you consider that Texas applies NCAA rules just fine with 4 or 5 man crews every week.
Are you suggesting these 3-4 additional field officials don't make a coverage difference?
-
Official Ohio Interpretation; Week 1 Bulletin
New Intentional Grounding (ING) Rule (7-5-2): If in doubt, the pass has reached the neutral zone. If in doubt, the passer is beyond the lateral boundary of the Free Blocking Zone (FBZ). Once You Are Out You Are Out – If the passer runs beyond the lateral boundary of the FBZ & then returns inside the FBZ, he/she can legally throw a pass that reaches the neutral zone (NZ) with no receiver in the area. If, in the opinion of the officials, a pass would have reached the NZ or NZ extended, but the pass is hit by someone & knocked down short of the NZ or NZ extended, it has reached the NZ. Yes, Ineligibles Illegally Downfield (Rule 7-5-12) still applies to the new ING Rule.
-
Official Ohio Interpretation; Week 1 Bulletin
New Intentional Grounding (ING) Rule (7-5-2): If in doubt, the pass has reached the neutral zone. If in doubt, the passer is beyond the lateral boundary of the Free Blocking Zone (FBZ). Once You Are Out You Are Out – If the passer runs beyond the lateral boundary of the FBZ & then returns inside the FBZ, he/she can legally throw a pass that reaches the neutral zone (NZ) with no receiver in the area. If, in the opinion of the officials, a pass would have reached the NZ or NZ extended, but the pass is hit by someone & knocked down short of the NZ or NZ extended, it has reached the NZ. Yes, Ineligibles Illegally Downfield (Rule 7-5-12) still applies to the new ING Rule.
I'm assuming the "someone" in the "hit by someone and knocked down" phrase is a defensive someone? Because if it's offense, we either have illegal touching of a forward pass, or legal touching by an eligible, which would negate the need for the exception...
-
Ralph said that the NFHS rules committee thinks that HS officials cannot adequately apply a rule similar to NCAA (original controller of the snap etc.) because of crew size or limited training opportunities. And my point was that HS officials in Texas do it every week in crews of 4 and 5 (and sometimes 3 in subvarsity).
And no, Al, I’m not saying having 7 or 8 doesn’t help. Obviously 8 is better than 5. But 4 and 5 man crews can still officiate this rule just fine. That would be like saying NFHS shouldn’t have a defensive holding rule because a 5 man crew can’t cover eligible receivers the same way an 8 man crew can do you might as well not even try.
Again, if y’all don’t like the rule because you don’t like how it changes the balance of the game that’s one thing. But to say you don’t like it because it can’t be officiated is just false.
-
Again, if y’all don’t like the rule because you don’t like how it changes the balance of the game that’s one thing. But to say you don’t like it because it can’t be officiated is just false.
I don't like it because I find it unnecessary and it does put one more thing on the plate of the R.
-
Ralph said that the NFHS rules committee thinks that HS officials cannot adequately apply a rule similar to NCAA (original controller of the snap etc.) because of crew size or limited training opportunities. And my point was that HS officials in Texas do it every week in crews of 4 and 5 (and sometimes 3 in subvarsity).
And no, Al, I’m not saying having 7 or 8 doesn’t help. Obviously 8 is better than 5. But 4 and 5 man crews can still officiate this rule just fine. That would be like saying NFHS shouldn’t have a defensive holding rule because a 5 man crew can’t cover eligible receivers the same way an 8 man crew can do you might as well not even try.
Again, if y’all don’t like the rule because you don’t like how it changes the balance of the game that’s one thing. But to say you don’t like it because it can’t be officiated is just false.
I agree with KWH. I am confident you misunderstood the intent of Ralph’s post. He never said it couldn’t be done. He said that due to the limitations he posted, NFHS felt the need to tweak an NCAA rule to make it simpler to officiate. I happen to agree with him, generally speaking.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Ralph said that the NFHS rules committee thinks that HS officials cannot adequately apply a rule similar to NCAA (original controller of the snap etc.) because of crew size or limited training opportunities. And my point was that HS officials in Texas do it every week in crews of 4 and 5 (and sometimes 3 in subvarsity). And no, Al, I’m not saying having 7 or 8 doesn’t help. Obviously 8 is better than 5. But 4 and 5 man crews can still officiate this rule just fine. That would be like saying NFHS shouldn’t have a defensive holding rule because a 5 man crew can’t cover eligible receivers the same way an 8 man crew can do you might as well not even try. Again, if y’all don’t like the rule because you don’t like how it changes the balance of the game that’s one thing. But to say you don’t like it because it can’t be officiated is just false.
Actually, Legacy, I understood Ralph's input apparently a little different than you. As I understood his concerns, the ever presence difference between NCAA & NFHS rules relevant to differing participant maturity, experience and crew size, in addition to the added components Ralph itemized unique to NFHS 7-5-2 (Exception 2; (1) NO requirements that only the QB can pass; (2) NO requirements that the passer has to be within the FBZ guideline when receiving the snap; (3) NO requirement that a running back can't become said passer.) may well add additional concern as to appropriate coverage coverage challenges in 4/5 man crew assignments.
I seems logical that the expansion to 7/8 man crew configurations, in all levels and aspects of officiating, is desirable, where feasible. However, adding ANY significant rule expansion, at ANY level of football is subject to observation, review and when subsequently deemed appropriate, or beneficial, to revision and/or modification, which is always a distinct possibility at ANY level of football based on the actual experience and feedback any "new rule/adjustment" may provide.
-
X
-
Yes I wrote intentional grounding when i meant to write Ineligible downfield - Sometimes it sux to get old.
But it sure beats the alternative yEs: