RefStripes.com
Football Officiating => National Federation Discussion => Topic started by: HLinNC on August 19, 2022, 08:47:36 AM
-
This might be helpful-
https://youtu.be/bzsNU1fzP58
-
This might be helpful-
https://youtu.be/bzsNU1fzP58
Excellent, and thorough, presentation about all the aspects of the 2022 Intentional Grounding revision. Thanks.
-
AGREE!!!!
-
Amazing number of assumptions and interpretations in the video and as the speaker notes 'you won't find that in the rules'. What's wrong with this picture?
-
Amazing number of assumptions and interpretations in the video and as the speaker notes 'you won't find that in the rules'. What's wrong with this picture?
Which "assumptions and interpretations" are you referring to?
-
Which "assumptions and interpretations" are you referring to?
We'll start with the ad hoc definition of passer @ 2:23 in the video. The presenter specifically states that there is no specific rule language backing up this "clarification". Gee, in my book that's a biggie.
-
excellent summary and video well presented. I especially liked LA interpretation of IDP. I need to get guidance from our association on IDP as this is one of the murky areas.
-
excellent summary and video well presented. I especially liked LA interpretation of IDP. I need to get guidance from our association on IDP as this is one of the murky areas.
Another biggie " ..... IDP as this is one of the murky areas."
-
We'll start with the ad hoc definition of passer @ 2:23 in the video. The presenter specifically states that there is no specific rule language backing up this "clarification". Gee, in my book that's a biggie.
As you may note the NFHS 7-5-2-Exception 2a specifically refers to "the passer" (being beyond the lateral boundary of the free-blocking zone as established at the snap;) and NFHS 2-32-11 continues to define "A passer is a player who throws a legal forward pass. He continues to be a passer until the legal forward pass ends, or until he moves to participate in the play.", which may cause some confusion/concern as it may differ from, and is more inclusive than, other Rule Codes dealing with Illegal Forward Passes. and is unique to the NFHS code.
-
As you may note the NFHS 7-5-2-Exception 2a specifically refers to "the passer" (being beyond the lateral boundary of the free-blocking zone as established at the snap;) and NFHS 2-32-11 continues to define "A passer is a player who throws a legal forward pass. He continues to be a passer until the legal forward pass ends, or until he moves to participate in the play.", which may cause some confusion/concern as it may differ from, and is more inclusive than, other Rule Codes dealing with Illegal Forward Passes. and is unique to the NFHS code.
I can read Al, but it fails to state " .... when he releases the ball". I really dislike assuming missing language when trying to explain a flag to the coach. The "That's what was intended" doesn't cut it.
-
I can read Al, but it fails to state " .... when he releases the ball". I really dislike assuming missing language when trying to explain a flag to the coach. The "That's what was intended" doesn't cut it.
I would suggest the answers to ancillary questions may currently exist in associated and/or related rules. The new Exception defined in 7-5-2 is a modification/expansion of 7-5-2-d, which defines a pass INTENTIONALLY THROWN [/i]into an area not occupied by an eligible receiver or THROWN incomplete to save yardage or conserve time, as Illegal. It appears somewhat obvious that a "Pass thrown", whether Legal or Illegal must have been "RELEASED".
The new exception expands instances where previously considered Illegal passes are now exempt, and are now considered Legal defining where a passer must be, or has been (the lateral boundary of the Neutral Zone) and where the thrown pass must reach (the Neutral Zone and/or it's extension beyond the sideline.)
As with any reversal/modification (even partial) of an existing rule additional review can be helpful in understanding and comprehension, and I would not be surprised if such additional explanations /examples were forthcoming. Until such additional assistance is rendered, it may well be necessary to refresh and refine understanding of related rules including those words and phrases specifically defined in Rule 2.
-
Wow, lots of words to avoid answering a SPECIFIC question. Well done!
-
Wow, lots of words to avoid answering a SPECIFIC question. Well done!
Sorry, perhaps you could rephrase your question, a little clearer, and I'll try again.
-
Ineligible Receiver Downfield is a foul in NFHS play anytime it occurs during a play in which a legal forward pass is thrown.
Stating otherwise IS NOT SUPPORTED ANYWHERE BY NFHS RULE and there is no justification anywhere in the NFHS rules for not throwing a flag for a clear violation of a rule.
Why? What if the defense fouls during the play? Normally we would have an offset. What line of bullsh*t do you tell the coach of the defense?
99.9% of the time the coach will decline the penalty and take the result of the play since taking the result of the play the down counts.
This was not an oversight! Rather this is NCAA telling us how they ignore the IG rule.
Sorry, but if we don't want IG called, then we propose it, get it passed, put it in the Rules book and we write a case play or two. Until that time, it is illegal regardless of what one guy in Louisiana and another guy in Michigan thinks.
-
Ineligible Receiver Downfield is a foul in NFHS play anytime it occurs during a play in which a legal forward pass is thrown.
Stating otherwise IS NOT SUPPORTED ANYWHERE BY NFHS RULE and there is no justification anywhere in the NFHS rules for not throwing a flag for a clear violation of a rule.
Why? What if the defense fouls during the play? Normally we would have an offset. What line of bullsh*t do you tell the coach of the defense?
99.9% of the time the coach will decline the penalty and take the result of the play since taking the result of the play the down counts.
This was not an oversight! Rather this is NCAA telling us how they ignore the IG rule.
Sorry, but if we don't want IG called, then we propose it, get it passed, put it in the Rules book and we write a case play or two. Until that time, it is illegal regardless of what one guy in Louisiana and another guy in Michigan thinks.
I think you mean IRD instead of IG?
As for the “regardless of what one guy ….thinks” comment, that’s what happens when you guys are not comprehensive and complete in your interpretations.
The states have to step in and make interpretations. So don’t be so critical about what the guy in LA and the guy in MI say. They are doing the best they can to fill in the blanks y’all left in the rule change.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
I think you mean IRD instead of IG?
As for the “regardless of what one guy ….thinks” comment, that’s what happens when you guys are not comprehensive and complete in your interpretations.
The states have to step in and make interpretations. So don’t be so critical about what the guy in LA and the guy in MI say. They are doing the best they can to fill in the blanks y’all left in the rule change.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
If this "rule" was even close to comprehensive and complete we would not have individual states scrambling to come up with a way to officiate this mess. The only time were 100% sure we've got it right is when the player that receives the snap, while still in possession of the ball, is outside the FBZE and he is the "passer" who dumps the ball. That 100% addresses the original reason for this change to begin with, and gee it reads like some other codes rule regarding protecting the QB. Let's keep track and see how many years it take to fix this.
-
Let's keep track and see how many years it take to fix this.
I seem to recall three for the HCT.
-
I think you mean IRD instead of IG?
As for the “regardless of what one guy ….thinks” comment, that’s what happens when you guys are not comprehensive and complete in your interpretations.
The states have to step in and make interpretations. So don’t be so critical about what the guy in LA and the guy in MI say. They are doing the best they can to fill in the blanks y’all left in the rule change.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Yes I clearly meant IDP rather than IG - My mistake for which I most humbly apologize.
The experimental states did not have one problem enforcing this rule! Restated, two state accumlating two years of snaps with no issues. NONE!
Yes the wording may cause confusion if you prefer to create confusion.
A simple wording change resolves the issue and cuts all the water bucket plays off at the knees.
7-5-2d EXCEPTION 2a... The ball passer has been beyond the lateral boundary of the FBZ...
For those who contend the only fix is to simply follow the NCAA rule of "the player who receives the snap" it was certainly discussed but it just doesn't fit as it causes an issue in 6-player football
which the fix would be to create "an exception to this exception" in 6-player game. Not a popular idea.
The coveted NCAA Rules Book do not address 6, 8, nor 9-player rule modifications as quite simply there are none.
As for the two states issuing there own interpretations, neither is doing that, rather, both are CHANGING RULES and that error will being corrected.
-
Yes I clearly meant IDP rather than IG - My mistake for which I most humbly apologize.
The experimental states did not have one problem enforcing this rule! Restated, two state accumlating two years of snaps with no issues. NONE!
Yes the wording may cause confusion if you prefer to create confusion.
A simple wording change resolves the issue and cuts all the water bucket plays off at the knees.
7-5-2d EXCEPTION 2a... The ball passer has been beyond the lateral boundary of the FBZ...
For those who contend the only fix is to simply follow the NCAA rule of "the player who receives the snap" it was certainly discussed but it just doesn't fit as it causes an issue in 6-player football
which the fix would be to create "an exception to this exception" in 6-player game. Not a popular idea.
The coveted NCAA Rules Book do not address 6, 8, nor 9-player rule modifications as quite simply there are none.
As for the two states issuing there own interpretations, neither is doing that, rather, both are CHANGING RULES and that error will being corrected.
Can you please explain the issue with 6 man and the wording “the player who receives the snap”? How would that language be a problem in 6 man?
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
I would say that the passer is the player who receives the snap, and then put in a note that "The above does not apply to 6-player football. For the appropriate rule in 6-player football, please see page XXX".
6-person football does not exist in my area, so let anyone who is more versed in that code comment on that.
-
Passer is defined in Rule 2 and says nothing about the snap and thus the alleged quandary.
-
I would say that the passer is the player who receives the snap, and then put in a note that "The above does not apply to 6-player football. For the appropriate rule in 6-player football, please see page XXX".
6-person football does not exist in my area, so let anyone who is more versed in that code comment on that.
We already have a section on 6 player differences. If restricting the IG exception to the player who receives the snap affects 6 man p, I agree, fix it there.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
The experimental states did not have one problem enforcing this rule! Restated, two state accumlating two years of snaps with no issues. NONE!
As for the two states issuing there own interpretations, neither is doing that, rather, both are CHANGING RULES and that error will being corrected.
Except what has been posted by others over the last two years including officials in those "experimental states" the "experimental rule" only applied to the player who received the snap. It's been clearly stated by multiple posters on multiple websites that the rule as implemented is not what was "tested". Why is there so many questions regarding this??? ???
-
Except what has been posted by others over the last two years including officials in those "experimental states" the "experimental rule" only applied to the player who received the snap. It's been clearly stated by multiple posters on multiple websites that the rule as implemented is not what was "tested". Why is there so many questions regarding this??? ???
Isn’t that interesting.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk