Il a legal scrimmage kick is blocked (or some how remains in or behind the NZ) and the kick has not touched the ground when K illegally kicks the ball, the status of the ball is still a kick and could meet the requirement of a fair catch.
I learned this the hard way, by blowing a call the year after we changed the rule
...
(1) 3rd & 10 @ A's 5;
(2) A/K tries to quick kick;
(3) punt is blocked;
(4) the kicker's soccer skills returned and he illegally kicked the loose ball in the end zone
;
(5)the ball sailed OOB @ A's 8;
(6) thinking old rule and treating IK as a fumble, I ruled safety and gave no choice
;
(7) shortly thereafter I realized it should have been treated as a kick;
(8) B/R could have taken the ball at A/K's 8 if declined
.
There are game situations where 1st & goal @ 8 could be a better choice than 2 points and receiving a free kick. I didn't give them any.
Our rule change was prompted by a play occurring in the mid-west...
(1) A throws a forward pass;
(2) B-2, with great soccer skills, leaped and kicked the airborne pass to the ground for IK
;
(3) officials ruled incomplete pass & IK - common sense
;
(4) common sense ain't always right
- shoulda' been treated as a fumble (ole' rule)
;
(5) new rule now makes common sense.
[/LESSON LEARNED :
HUMANS MAKE MISTAKES..HUMANS LEARN FROM THEIR MISTAKES...AND DON'T MAKE THE SAME ONES AGAIN.b]