Football Officiating > NCAA Discussion

UCF - Marshall

<< < (2/4) > >>

TXMike:

--- Quote from: Andrew McCarthy on October 14, 2010, 07:50:56 AM ---If this is what happened it should have been incomplete.  It says he hit the pylon as a result of being hit by the defender and he was "with the ball".  But we all know how those news reports are.

Hopefully we can get a video of it.

--- End quote ---

If they looked at it for 12 minutes (assuming no equip problems), they must have seen whether he had the ball while touching the pylon.

bushman:
The receiver did not have the ball when he hit the pylon. The question is was he forced OOB (into the pylon) or not. I did not think he was forced OOB. This is a reviewable play and a foul can be called by the replay official. Very good play for pregame topic.

pgh guy:
If the ruling on the field was that the WR stepped out, no matter how, then IR cannot involve itself with how the WR got out of bounds.  I did not see the play in questions, but if FJ/SL ruled OB, IR cannot determine whether he was forced out or if it was voluntary.

McRef77:
I don't get much work with instant replay, but can the IR official call a foul?  I'm unclear on this.  I can't find a reference in Rule 12 to support calling a foul and as pgh stated, I don't believe IR can determine whether a player was OOB or not unless he has the ball in his possession.  Perhaps some IR guys can clarify.  Thanks.

Fathead:
I didn't see the play, but was it literally 12 minutes ?

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page

[*] Previous page

Go to full version