RefStripes.com
Football Officiating => National Federation Discussion => Topic started by: Badger1 on April 12, 2019, 09:24:19 AM
-
This question is geared towards those officials who used the experimental rule regarding the 40 second play clock. I realize the NFHS Official's Manual will not be published this year so I am looking for the procedure that was used by crews to reset the play clock when a delay in getting the ball spotted ran the play clock below 25 seconds. I know the BJ is responsible for timing on a 5 man crew but how does he signal to the referee that the time has dropped below 25 seconds and the play clock needs to be reset? I wouldn't think that the R is also keeping time so how would he know to reset the clock. In resetting the play clock back to 25 seconds does the game clock get stopped to do this and then restarted? I don't expect to be on any field this year that has a 40 second play clock so all timing with be done on the field.
-
This question is geared towards those officials who used the experimental rule regarding the 40 second play clock. I realize the NFHS Official's Manual will not be published this year so I am looking for the procedure that was used by crews to reset the play clock when a delay in getting the ball spotted ran the play clock below 25 seconds. I know the BJ is responsible for timing on a 5 man crew but how does he signal to the referee that the time has dropped below 25 seconds and the play clock needs to be reset? I wouldn't think that the R is also keeping time so how would he know to reset the clock. In resetting the play clock back to 25 seconds does the game clock get stopped to do this and then restarted? I don't expect to be on any field this year that has a 40 second play clock so all timing with be done on the field.
I'll speak to visible play clocks first. If it's between 20 and 25 and the offense is ready to go don't worry about it. They aren't going to get close to 0 anyway so there is no point in affecting the flow of the game. If they are still huddled or not ready to go then you just give the play clock operator a pump signal (one arm up with palm open) to indicate resettting it back to 25. They can start it immediately once they do that. No need for a wind or whistle. In extreme cases where there is a serious delay in getting the ball in or something like that, you may want to stop the game clock as well, resolve whatever is holding up the situation, set the play clock to 25 and then start both. Those situations maybe happened 3 or 4 times per season so hopefully they will be rare.
Without a visible play clock I would assume the BJ could give the same signal to let everyone know he reset it to 25. He could either communicate it verbally to the R over the O2O or yelling it if he needs to know. Assuming you are already giving the QB a signal with 10 seconds remaining and then counting down from 5, they will still look for that.
-
Pump up with one arm (2 arms is for 40 seconds). If the referee sees the signal and decides to reset the play clock to 25, reset whatever timing device you are using to 25 seconds. This is why another official (LJ in a 5-man crew, SJ in a 7-man crew) is responsible for the game clock, to free the BJ to concentrate on the play clock and timing timeouts and/or intermissions.
-
Will this reset be included in the new rule? If so, what is the actual wording? Something like, “if the officials delay getting the ball ready for play and the play clock gets below 25, the clock operator will reset the play clock to 25?”
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
Granted we are fortunate in that coaches and ball boys learned to have balls readily available to the wings. I didn't reset the play clock a half dozen times last year.
If a team was running a no huddle and we set the ball with less than 25, on the O2O equipment I said reset or the B told me resetting. If the team huddled and was still in the huddle we probably don't reset, getting out of the huddle is on them.
-
Granted we are fortunate in that coaches and ball boys learned to have balls readily available to the wings. I didn't reset the play clock a half dozen times last year.
If a team was running a no huddle and we set the ball with less than 25, on the O2O equipment I said reset or the B told me resetting. If the team huddled and was still in the huddle we probably don't reset, getting out of the huddle is on them.
I would say if they are running a no-huddle and you put it down with 20 seconds left, they aren't likely going to get close to 0 anyway so there isn't a major need to reset. But you can if you just give it a quick pump and the play clock starts right away. Be careful though if you do it in a time critical situation and the game clock is running. You don't want to give them an advantage in consuming more time due to a delay on your part. We may have reset a play clock 5 or 6 times over the entire 3 year experiment. It was usually due to some delay in getting the ball spotted correctly that created confusion for the team (i.e. where is the ball spotted or complete vs. incomplete).
-
To take a derivative of this topic. - and perhaps Raplh's inside knowledge.
For NFL/NCAA who have the 40/25, the axiom for the 40 to start is when the hand goes up (play whistled dead) - actually I do remember ECP operators' instructions from NCAA a few years ago specifically telling the 40/25 operator to 'take a breath' before starting the clock after the hand goes up.
I'm assuming NFHS will adopt the mechanic of 'hand in the wir when the play is dead' mechanic too? - and if that's the case, fellas: just like we wait to blow the whistle when a play is dead, we dont need to toss that hand up the nano-second we have a dead ball.
-
To take a derivative of this topic. - and perhaps Raplh's inside knowledge.
For NFL/NCAA who have the 40/25, the axiom for the 40 to start is when the hand goes up (play whistled dead) - actually I do remember ECP operators' instructions from NCAA a few years ago specifically telling the 40/25 operator to 'take a breath' before starting the clock after the hand goes up.
I'm assuming NFHS will adopt the mechanic of 'hand in the wir when the play is dead' mechanic too? - and if that's the case, fellas: just like we wait to blow the whistle when a play is dead, we dont need to toss that hand up the nano-second we have a dead ball.
That's what we instructed the play clock operator to do in our experiment. We also told them if the game is in the 4th quarter and a blow out, NOBODY is going to complain if they take a couple deep breaths, make a sandwich, call their mother, and then start the play clock.
-
So.............
With Visible Clocks that all fine and good.
I live in Oregon and we have about 4 fields with play clocks statewide.
My question is this...We have a rule that states the Referee shall reset the play clock to 25 if the play clock gets under XX due to (insert any reason here)
The Back Judge is timing the play clock with his Ready Ref or his Ref Smart, BUT, they only Buzz him with 10 seconds remaining and that doesn't solve the problem.
How the HECK does the Referee know when there is less than XX on the play clock???
Perhaps, Only the Shadow knows???
-
So.............
With Visible Clocks that all fine and good.
I live in Oregon and we have about 4 fields with play clocks statewide.
My question is this...We have a rule that states the Referee shall reset the play clock to 25 if the play clock gets under XX due to (insert any reason here)
The Back Judge is timing the play clock with his Ready Ref or his Ref Smart, BUT, they only Buzz him with 10 seconds remaining and that doesn't solve the problem.
How the HECK does the Referee know when there is less than XX on the play clock???
Perhaps, Only the Shadow knows???
Unfortunately, the B can't rely solely on his DumbTimer for these situations. The B will just have to be aware of the situation, and be ready to signal to the R the time remaining, should it become critical. Of course, this is independent of the whether the play clock is 40 or 25 - the same process applies, if there are not field play clocks.
-
As critical as field clocks are for play clock timing, I'm surprised the NFHS didn't make field play clocks mandatory, but give schools a one or two-year period to procure field clocks before this rule change was implemented.
Working a varsity contest without visual play clocks would make me retire again. ;)
-
So.............
With Visible Clocks that all fine and good.
I live in Oregon and we have about 4 fields with play clocks statewide.
My question is this...We have a rule that states the Referee shall reset the play clock to 25 if the play clock gets under XX due to (insert any reason here)
The Back Judge is timing the play clock with his Ready Ref or his Ref Smart, BUT, they only Buzz him with 10 seconds remaining and that doesn't solve the problem.
How the HECK does the Referee know when there is less than XX on the play clock???
Back in the days prior to Back Judges, the Referee was responsible for monitoring the RFP duration, and had the ability to determine if "an interruption in the RFP interval" merited a simple appropriate (usually unannounced) extension, or a full resetting. Perhaps responsibility for monitoring the RFP interval should remain a factor practically affected by crew size, of the actual game being played.
-
As critical as field clocks are for play clock timing, I'm surprised the NFHS didn't make field play clocks mandatory, but give schools a one or two-year period to procure field clocks before this rule change was implemented.
Working a varsity contest without visual play clocks would make me retire again. ;)
I think in the last 3 years I have had 2 varsity games with field play clocks. There is no way the NFHS is going to mandate play clocks. Many schools do not have the money for that expense.
-
I think in the last 3 years I have had 2 varsity games with field play clocks. There is no way the NFHS is going to mandate play clocks. Many schools do not have the money for that expense.
The scene was the same in Texas when they adopted the 40-second PC. Very few high schools had field play clocks before then. Now, almost all of them have field play clocks. They aren't mandated, but even most of the smallest, least funded schools now have them. Very unusual to find a field that doesn't have them, now. They'll find the money.
Now, competent PC operators - that's another story.
Robert
-
So.............
With Visible Clocks that all fine and good.
I live in Oregon and we have about 4 fields with play clocks statewide.
My question is this...We have a rule that states the Referee shall reset the play clock to 25 if the play clock gets under XX due to (insert any reason here)
The Back Judge is timing the play clock with his Ready Ref or his Ref Smart, BUT, they only Buzz him with 10 seconds remaining and that doesn't solve the problem.
How the HECK does the Referee know when there is less than XX on the play clock???
Perhaps, Only the Shadow knows???
I guess I would ask if there is any reason for the referee to know how much time is left on the play clock? He's not doing anything different if there are 10 seconds left or 2 seconds left. It's more important for the coaches and QB to know if it's been reset. If you need to give a quick tweet a BJ with a signal indicating the play clock is being reset go ahead and do that. You'll only need to do this a few times per season at most. If you are doing it more than that your issue is likely with ball mechanics and not the play clock.
-
I guess I would ask if there is any reason for the referee to know how much time is left on the play clock? He's not doing anything different if there are 10 seconds left or 2 seconds left. It's more important for the coaches and QB to know if it's been reset. If you need to give a quick tweet a BJ with a signal indicating the play clock is being reset go ahead and do that. You'll only need to do this a few times per season at most. If you are doing it more than that your issue is likely with ball mechanics and not the play clock.
Your Q: Is there any reason for the Referee to know how much time is left on the play clock?
My A: YES there most certainly is! Simple because we now have a rule that says the R needs to take action and reset it to 25 if it gets below XX!
So, Brian, my original question remains:
How is the R supposed to know when the Play Clock has gone under XX when there are no visible clocks???
The Back Judge gets his/her first buzzed when there is 10 seconds remaining, that does me no good!
Brian, You work in a state where it is a rarity to ever NOT have visible play clocks. I work in a state that has no visible play clocks anywhere and it will likely stay that way for the foreseeable future.
All things considered, in my opinion, my question is very legitimate and also very timely!
Quite frankly is not a concern on fields that have visible clocks!
-
Just a thought, but where you have 5 or more on the crew, and the BJ has the Play clock, when the clock is interrupted below 25 seconds, he could signal the R, who could then start the new RFP with an (old) signal.
Where there's 4 (or God forbid) smaller crews (Sub-varsity, Youth Football), it might not be a bad idea to have the R handle the entire Play clock responsibility (which would avoid this problem and insure the Play clock is in the most experienced hands). If a crew mate is designated to handle the Play clock, same as above (the LJ, L or U) would alert the R who could generate a new RFP, or that official could signal a new RFP.
-
That's what we instructed the play clock operator to do in our experiment. We also told them if the game is in the 4th quarter and a blow out, NOBODY is going to complain if they take a couple deep breaths, make a sandwich, call their mother, and then start the play clock.
Pardon me, but doesn’t something like this defeat the purpose of the change? I thought the entire premise was to make play to play consistent.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
I think in the last 3 years I have had 2 varsity games with field play clocks. There is no way the NFHS is going to mandate play clocks. Many schools do not have the money for that expense.
You would be surprised at the businesses who will donate money to booster clubs just to get their name on or under the sign. That’s the way most of ours were funded.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
Pardon me, but doesn’t something like this defeat the purpose of the change? I thought the entire premise was to make play to play consistent.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
As we discovered in NCAA and Texas HS, it greatly increases consistency in the RFP period, but it doesn't make it 100% consistent. We'll probably never get to 100%. But I'd guess - strictly a gut feel guess based on experience, no science behind it - that consistency increased at least 75%. Certainly worth the effort. But as some have said, the PCOs do need to use a little "timing" in starting the play clock. See the signal, mentally confirm the signal, make sure there is no other superseding signal, then, if all checks out, start the play clock. That's the long way of saying, "Pause, take a breath and start the clock." That will probably take between 1 and 2 seconds. This will do two things: 1) prevent a percentage of unnecessary delays of game, 2) mitigate resets of the play clock (unilaterally by the PCO, or at the direction of the on-field crew).
Consistency is everyone doing it the same way. If we get everyone to pause, take a breath, and start the clock, then we have consistency.
I am with you, though, on overtly extending the time taken to begin the play clock, regardless of the game situation. It is not our responsibility to ensure sportsmanship by the teams, outside of what is prescribed by the rules. If one team is completely overwhelming another team, then the superior team needs to show sportsmanship by taking action to abbreviate the game. They can consume every second of the play clock. They can stick to a running game, and run the simplest plays that gain only enough yards per down to earn a first down after three downs. They can play their lesser skilled players, making it more difficult and, thus, more time consuming, to earn a first down, or stop the opponent from earning a first down when on defense. Coaches need to take the lead on this. (Heaven forbid coaches should show some sportsmanship.)
When in question as whether a BC's progress is stopped inbounds or out of bounds, I am OK with ruling inbounds. But we shouldn't overtly steal the players' time, even if they are getting badly beaten. It is these situations in which the third string guard gets to play, and that may only happen a hand-full of times during a season. That is his time. Time he'll remember the rest of his life. I'm not stealing his time.
Robert
-
Where there's 4 (or God forbid) smaller crews (Sub-varsity, Youth Football), it might not be a bad idea to have the R handle the entire Play clock responsibility (which would avoid this problem and insure the Play clock is in the most experienced hands).
Unless you have a very inexperienced R, this is my suggestion too (and is how I do it with crews of four).
-
Unless you have a very inexperienced R, this is my suggestion too (and is how I do it with crews of four).
Should you have "a very inexperienced R" play clock timing problems may well be the easiest issues you have to deal with.
-
Should you have "a very inexperienced R" play clock timing problems may well be the easiest issues you have to deal with.
We all had to start somewhere.
-
How is the R supposed to know when the Play Clock has gone under XX when there are no visible clocks???
The Back Judge gets his/her first buzzed when there is 10 seconds remaining, that does me no good!
1) Use a stopwatch instead of Readyref.
2) BJ can pump when it's under and the R can echo it.
-
1) Use a stopwatch instead of Readyref.
2) BJ can pump when it's under and the R can echo it.
Bossman I agree with you completely, which leads to my next question.
Why does anyone need to purchase a Ready Ref OR a Ref Smart?
On a field with Visible Play Clocks, they are unneeded, AND;
On a field without Visible Play Clocks they are unable to notify the BJ that 15 seconds has elapsed????
-
I've been pondering this, as has the Manual Committee. In Maine, all of our schools have INvisible play clocks and my pondering possibility could be:
(1) If the game clock is running, R or BJ (whoever's facing the clock) would watch for 15" runoff;
(2) If the game clock isn't, the BJ would silently count to 15". With the clock frozen, split-second accuracy is not important.
Any of ye have a better mousetrap, please spring forward.....
-
I see this being pretty rare. If there's an unusual delay getting the ball spotted, you'll probably "feel" it.
-
Pardon me, but doesn’t something like this defeat the purpose of the change? I thought the entire premise was to make play to play consistent.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
I believe what Brian is saying is everyone, winning coach, losing coach, fans, players, EVERYONE wants to go home with no injuries, DO NOT have a DOG in a blow out in the 4th quarter.
-
Your Q: Is there any reason for the Referee to know how much time is left on the play clock?
My A: YES there most certainly is! Simple because we now have a rule that says the R needs to take action and reset it to 25 if it gets below XX!
So, Brian, my original question remains:
How is the R supposed to know when the Play Clock has gone under XX when there are no visible clocks???
The Back Judge gets his/her first buzzed when there is 10 seconds remaining, that does me no good!
Brian, You work in a state where it is a rarity to ever NOT have visible play clocks. I work in a state that has no visible play clocks anywhere and it will likely stay that way for the foreseeable future.
All things considered, in my opinion, my question is very legitimate and also very timely!
Quite frankly is not a concern on fields that have visible clocks!
It's probably making the assumption there are visible play clocks which is why it references the R. But as Al says you could have the BJ signal or communicate to the R via O2O if you have that and he can give the actual signal. As long as someone is signalling the play clock has been reset they should be fine. But for something that should only happen 2 or 3 times over the course of the season I wouldn't be too concerned about it. If it does happen more than that your issue is probably with ball boys/chain crew or crew ball mechanics and the new play clock is just exposing those issues.
-
I believe what Brian is saying is everyone, winning coach, losing coach, fans, players, EVERYONE wants to go home with no injuries, DO NOT have a DOG in a blow out in the 4th quarter.
Correct. I don't think we had too many instances where the play clock operator actually did this, but if he did nobody would complain. We have less control over it on the field since we don't run the play clock like we could with the 25-second clock (i.e. delay the start of the 25). We had several blow outs last year but if it's really bad most states have a formal or informal mercy rule with running clocks anyway.
-
My opinion.....
If the 40" clock reaches 25" before the ball is ready for play, the often cause is a long incomplete pass or the ball going out of bounds. If a new ball is requested from the ball boy, we should apply 3-5-7f and call an official's time out to replace the ball. This administrative time out would re-set the play clock to 25" and have no impact on the game clock that was stopped by the play action. If the game clock is running, the back judge or referee should make a mental note of time elapsing. If the game clock is stopped for other reasons ,such as a new series, the back judge should quietly count to 15. the recommendation of more gadgets for these hopefully rare situations will even make our new rule more complex.
Your opinion on my opinion, please.......
-
Those of us, "with field play clocks at every field" may feel blessed (or not), but really shouldn't assume everyone else is similarly blessed (or somehow soon will be). The same holds true for those (relatively few) of us fortunate to work, consistently, in 6, or 7, man crew situations. The presumption that the addition of 40 second play clocks will somehow "simplify" time management for EVERYONE and will automatically achieve play cycle consistency seems, at best, somewhat premature.
Ralph, your suggestions for monitoring the play time cycle, with 5 man crews playing on fields without visible play clocks, seems practical and logical, but unfortunately limited (by harsh reality). Today's actual reality remains a bit more complex for those games THAT WILL CONTINUE TO BE PLAYED with fewer than 5 man crews (occasional Varsity and majority of sub-Varsity games), and/or on fields without visible play clocks and will likely boil down to the same, limited, but the practical and conceivable choices you suggest.
Try, as we might, finding the ever elusive, "one size that truly fits all" (about anything) remains a challenge.
-
Those of us, "with field play clocks at every field" may feel blessed (or not), but really shouldn't assume everyone else is similarly blessed (or somehow soon will be). The same holds true for those (relatively few) of us fortunate to work, consistently, in 6, or 7, man crew situations. The presumption that the addition of 40 second play clocks will somehow "simplify" time management for EVERYONE and will automatically achieve play cycle consistency seems, at best, somewhat premature.
Ralph, your suggestions for monitoring the play time cycle, with 5 man crews playing on fields without visible play clocks, seems practical and logical, but unfortunately limited (by harsh reality). Today's actual reality remains a bit more complex for those games THAT WILL CONTINUE TO BE PLAYED with fewer than 5 man crews (occasional Varsity and majority of sub-Varsity games), and/or on fields without visible play clocks and will likely boil down to the same, limited, but the practical and conceivable choices you suggest.
Try, as we might, finding the ever elusive, "one size that truly fits all" (about anything) remains a challenge.
This sums up my feelings as well.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
My opinion.....
If the 40" clock reaches 25" before the ball is ready for play, the often cause is a long incomplete pass or the ball going out of bounds. If a new ball is requested from the ball boy, we should apply 3-5-7f and call an official's time out to replace the ball. This administrative time out would re-set the play clock to 25" and have no impact on the game clock that was stopped by the play action. If the game clock is running, the back judge or referee should make a mental note of time elapsing. If the game clock is stopped for other reasons ,such as a new series, the back judge should quietly count to 15. the recommendation of more gadgets for these hopefully rare situations will even make our new rule more complex.
Your opinion on my opinion, please.......
You could do that, but I bet you eventually realize you are unnecessarily extending the game, especially without a visible play clock. You have so much more flexibility than those of us with visible play clock. If the play clock hit 21 before we spot the ball and step away we may get the offense screaming at us to reset the clock. They are just breaking the huddle and want the full 25 seconds from that point so they can burn more game clock even if they still have plenty of time to get into position, do their checks, run motion, etc. But if you stop it at 25 and hold up until the ball is ready you add another 4-5 seconds plus whatever confusion is created by what you are doing. Your delay had no impact on the offense calling their next play and making substitutions and still have plenty of time to do what they need to do. If they are in hurry up mode they aren't going to care if there are 35 seconds left on the play clock or 10 seconds as they are going to snap it fairly quickly regardless. They will be upset it took you that long, but they aren't worried about a potential DOG because of your delay. If you just flow through and start whatever mechanic you do to signal to the QB he has 10 seconds left, 5 seconds, etc. He will have no idea if you spotted it with 26 seconds or 21 seconds left.
As I've stated before the only time we've reset it is when there was a significant delay in getting a ball either the one used or a new one. Or if there was some confusion over the result of the previous play (i.e. complete/incomplete, pass/fumble) and the location of the next play. That's what happens 2-3 times per season.
It's good to talk about these situations so you are more prepared when they arise, but unless you have issues with the clock operators (which won't necessarily be any better or worse than last year) you likely won't have issues. If you have other issues (i.e. slow ball boys, chain crew, officials) they exist no matter what play clock you have. If I had to guess the #1 reason the coaches love it is they very consistently have the same time from dead ball to DOG regardless of crew. It really has little to do with how much time the ball is actually ready for play.
-
As I've stated before the only time we've reset it is when there was a significant delay in getting a ball either the one used or a new one. Or if there was some confusion over the result of the previous play (i.e. complete/incomplete, pass/fumble) and the location of the next play. That's what happens 2-3 times per season.
It's good to talk about these situations so you are more prepared when they arise, but unless you have issues with the clock operators (which won't necessarily be any better or worse than last year) you likely won't have issues. If you have other issues (i.e. slow ball boys, chain crew, officials) they exist no matter what play clock you have.
That pretty much sounds like the way things were (supposed to be) handled before we got all worked up about chasing the illusion about "perfection" in consistency (in the Interscholastic environment, either on the field or off, perfect consistency is universally non-existent, and has best been handled by appropriate adaption and necessary control.)
Where ineffective and/or inconsistent management and control of standard (timing) mechanics has reached a problematic level, individual correction (remedial training, observation and appropriately targeted correction) tailored for specific problem situations has proven a more likely effective, and immediate, remedy.
-
That pretty much sounds like the way things were (supposed to be) handled before we got all worked up about chasing the illusion about "perfection" in consistency (in the Interscholastic environment, either on the field or off, perfect consistency is universally non-existent, and has best been handled by appropriate adaption and necessary control.)
Where ineffective and/or inconsistent management and control of standard (timing) mechanics has reached a problematic level, individual correction (remedial training, observation and appropriately targeted correction) tailored for specific problem situations has proven a more likely effective, and immediate, remedy.
No, it's still different than before. You'll still have flexibility and a little more than those of us with visible play clocks. The difference is if one play it takes you 11 seconds to get the ball ready thus giving the offense only 36 seconds before a DOG and the next play for whatever reason it takes 22 seconds thus giving the team 47 seconds (both completely reasonable in the normal flow of a game), now they will get 40-42 seconds in both cases. You've narrowed the range significantly. Nothing you did in either case allowed or prevented them from working at a normal pace. Under the old rule if they are a team that likes to run the play clock down you have cheated the defense out of seconds they may need in the latter play. If the offense is in a normal rhythm and snapping the ball with 3-5 seconds you have now rushed them and caused a potential DOG in the former play. Every play will be roughly 40 seconds.
The point of the latest discussion is whether or not you have to reset the play clock if you happen to not get it set until it say 21 seconds. My point is you definitely could and by rule would be supported, but there is no point. You have still given the offense the full 40 seconds to snap the ball if they want to use the full play clock. If they are in hurry up they will snap it long before it gets to 0. So stopping the game to set the play clack back to 25 does no good for anyone. You are getting hung up in something that doesn't happen.
Once you start using it I'm pretty confident the guys on the field will realize they are worried about something that won't be an issue. I understand because I went through the same thing 10 years ago when we started doing it in NCAA and again 3 years ago when we started the experiment. It's normal and natural. I'm just trying to share my experience to calm those concerns so you can feel confident this really will be better. The idea of the change will be significantly harder than the actual change. Watch the NCAA guys. Do they look like they are running around like chickens with their heads cut off? Are the chain crews sprinting down the sideline for the next play? Not at all.
-
To your last point, Magician - You are correct. The NCAA crews seem to handle the 40 second with ease. But I'm wondering how many hours of clinics and training were invested in the crews (including ball boys and chain crews) to get them to this point? Guys like me and maybe more on this site do not have the benefit of access to this training. We are "winging it" on our own, and it seems like learning on the fly to me. That's why I keep harping on an extended trial or some kind of official training seminar to address our concerns. The last thing I want to do is to show up on the first Friday night looking like a rookie simply because I don't know what I don't know about all these concerns people keep posting here. This rule change may be the most complex and comprehensive I have encountered in 30 years of officiating, mainly because it involves EVERY play. It's not like simply tacking on a penalty after a TD. (Which I thought was a big deal when it was implemented.)
-
To your last point, Magician - You are correct. The NCAA crews seem to handle the 40 second with ease. But I'm wondering how many hours of clinics and training were invested in the crews (including ball boys and chain crews) to get them to this point? Guys like me and maybe more on this site do not have the benefit of access to this training. We are "winging it" on our own, and it seems like learning on the fly to me. That's why I keep harping on an extended trial or some kind of official training seminar to address our concerns. The last thing I want to do is to show up on the first Friday night looking like a rookie simply because I don't know what I don't know about all these concerns people keep posting here. This rule change may be the most complex and comprehensive I have encountered in 30 years of officiating, mainly because it involves EVERY play. It's not like simply tacking on a penalty after a TD. (Which I thought was a big deal when it was implemented.)
All fair points. When I did the transition in NCAA as a D3 official we didn't have extensive clinics and training and our ball boys and chain crews definitely didn't have any training other than what we told them in pre game. The same was true when we did the experiment in HS. We have intra squad scrimmages and intersquad scrimmages the two weeks before the season started so we used it there if the school was willing.
It's ultimately not that complicated. Do what you do today and possibly a little more consistent movement by ball boys and chain crews. But one less thing you have to do is start the play clock. If there is an administrative stop (penalty, score, change of possession, etc.) you do what you do today;
-
There seems to be one underlying reality that some are reluctant to consider, or determined to ignore. Although there have been many practices, policies, mechanics that have originated at "higher" levels that have proved to be helpful, beneficial and positive when applied to "basic" levels of our sport. Fixation that "One size ALWAYS fits all" sometimes still fails.
Sometimes what seems to work in environments tailored and designed for mature ADULTS simply doesn't convert as well when applied to developing CHILDREN, no matter how well they're concealed by the same equipment. It would be wonderful if "ball boys" and "chain crews" were equally effective, attentive and capable at all levels, or that Coaches, players, spectators were equally attentive and resistant to distractions.
Maybe someday.
-
There seems to be one underlying reality that some are reluctant to consider, or determined to ignore. Although there have been many practices, policies, mechanics that have originated at "higher" levels that have proved to be helpful, beneficial and positive when applied to "basic" levels of our sport. Fixation that "One size ALWAYS fits all" sometimes still fails.
Sometimes what seems to work in environments tailored and designed for mature ADULTS simply doesn't convert as well when applied to developing CHILDREN, no matter how well they're concealed by the same equipment. It would be wonderful if "ball boys" and "chain crews" were equally effective, attentive and capable at all levels, or that Coaches, players, spectators were equally attentive and resistant to distractions.
Maybe someday.
And what you are ignoring is nearly every official and coach involved in the experimental states (which had no issues implementing this with or without visible play clocks) is very supportive of the 40/25 second play clock over the 25. An official poll wasn't done but any mention of us reverting was met with major concern. It's not a 60/40 split in favor or "yeah I guess it's OK." It was, "OMG...I really hope they pass it because it would suck to have to go back to the old way." Every official I know from the other states has stated they much preferred it once they started using it. I have never seen or heard one negative comment from any coach or official who has been a part of an experimental state who regrets it. And people like to complain about change so it must work pretty well.
I can guarantee you our state commissioner who championed the original experiment 4 years ago (we had to wait a year to get it approved) doesn't care what is done at higher levels. He gets on us if we try to apply anything from the college level to HS officiating even if he only perceives it as a college thing (i.e. starting a new series on a line).
It will likely be even easier for you because you don't have to keep an eye on the referee as much between plays. Start the play clock after the previous play ends. The game clock operator will have to do what they always do for starting the clock after a first down in bounds. They'll get to do that 5-10 seconds faster because it's not tied to when the play clock starts any longer.
Good luck! I promise you it will be better. I know you may not believe me now and I understand why there is anxiety because it seems like a major change.
-
Good luck! I promise you it will be better. I know you may not believe me now and I understand why there is anxiety because it seems like a major change.
I certainly hope you are absolutely correct, as the "dye has been cast".
-
I certainly hope you are absolutely correct, as the "dye has been cast".
Me too! Based on going through it twice myself and the success others have had, if it doesn't work in other areas it's either because they have issues that go beyond play clocks or they are so opposed to trying it they sabotage it in some way. Time will tell!
-
Me too! Based on going through it twice myself and the success others have had, if it doesn't work in other areas it's either because they have issues that go beyond play clocks or they are so opposed to trying it they sabotage it in some way. Time will tell!
I was the most vocal opponent to this rule change, but it got changed. hEaDbAnG pi1eOn
It's now our rule and we need to work with it to the best of our ability. We have advised the coaches that we are in the learning stage with this, too, and please have patience. We have informed them that, even on dry sunny days, we will need two ball boys on each sideline with game acceptable balls. They have voiced their support. We will be following the Indiana guidelines that states not to be used in sub varsity by crews less than 5 officials. We will make it work.
tiphat:
-
In the UK we introduced the 40s play clock around 10 years ago when IFAF adopted it following the NCAA. We usually work crews of 4 (R has the play clock) or 5 (BJ has the play clock), one (hopefully vaguely aware and interested, but not always) ball person on each sideline, and no visible play clocks (they're something we normally only see when watching games on television!). Many of the players we officiate, although older, have less football experience than the average HS player. It's worked fine for us. It took the teams a few games to adapt to no RFP whistle when it first came in, but now it's second nature to everyone.
There are a couple of differences. One is that both teams use the same set of footballs. Standard practise is that the home team provides the balls for the game. The other is that IFAF has kept the old NCAA 20s cutoff for a reset as it was felt that moving to the 15s cutoff may not be realistic for the level we are at. I'll be honest, I don't remember the last time I actually did a reset (I'm usually R or BJ), as we don't have too many hurry up teams and, as Magician posted earlier in the thread, if the ball gets to the spot before the offense do, we just let things keep moving along. To be fair, 20s is actually a very long time, even when you have to find the ball person and first distract them from using social media on their phone to get the ball from them.
-
I certainly hope you are absolutely correct, as the "dye die has been cast".
“Alea iacta est.” (Julius Caesar upon crossing the Rubicon, 49 BC)
-
Despite years of forced Latin study, all my fading memory seems to recall is "Gaul was divided into 3 parts...."
-
We were informed here in SC. last evening that if there is a need to reset the play clock the backjudge will signal time out thereby having an administrative timeout where the referee will in turn start everything back up with a new 25. No arbitrary pumping up a new 25.
-
RefSmart does have a buzzer at 25 seconds to remind the back judge. It's a shame ReadyRef doesn't, though.