RefStripes.com
Football Officiating => National Federation Discussion => Topic started by: Derek Teigen on August 07, 2022, 11:54:25 AM
-
Hello everyone I'm really looking forward to a more normal year this year!! In our exam this year we got tripped up on a couple of questions about fouls that carry over to extra time and they dealt with penalties by B during a play that results in a touchdown as time expires. As I'm reading it there is no option to accept the penalty on the try or carry it over to extra time and that only penalties during the try can be carried over to extra time. Is my understanding on this correct and if so what is the philosophy on that? thank you.
-
Simply put, if during the down when time expires, there is a foul that can carry succeeding spot enforcement, it can be enforced at the beginning of overtime ONLY if there is no option to enforce it during regulation time (i.e., an untimed down). If the foul CAN be enforced on an untimed down, there is no option for the offended team and it must be enforced on the untimed down (or declined).
In other words -- if there is an untimed down at the end of the fourth quarter, there exists the possibility of scoring points and therefore overtime is not assured. The offended team cannot assume overtime is a possibility for penalty enforcement until there are no more downs to play.
-
I'm not sure I understand your reply because I am talking about a play that scores a touchdown as time expires so any penalty by B normally would be enforced on the try or the ensuing kickoff but in reading the overtime rules it seems that only fouls on the try can carry over. I am wondering why that is and maybe I am reading this wrong?
-
I'm not sure I understand your reply because I am talking about a play that scores a touchdown as time expires so any penalty by B normally would be enforced on the try or the ensuing kickoff but in reading the overtime rules it seems that only fouls on the try can carry over. I am wondering why that is and maybe I am reading this wrong?
You’re not reading it wrong. The language is intentional. Notice that on touchdown scoring plays, the options are on the try, or on the ensuing kickoff. The reason overtime is not an option on touchdown scoring plays is we don’t know if there will be an overtime until the try. So, if B fouls on a touchdown scoring play on the last play of the game and the score is not tied at that point, A cannot get the ensuing kickoff option, because there will not be another kickoff.They can take the penalty on the try or decline.
Also, notice that on field goals and tries, the language says “succeeding spot.” This is also intentional because on those plays we know there will be an overtime. For example, If B scores a field goal to tie the game on the last play in regulation, we are going to overtime. The definition of succeeding spot is the spot where the ball would next be put in play if there was no foul. In this situation, the succeeding spot would be the first play in overtime. Since we know that spot exists, we can give A that option. Same way on a try. The language is succeeding spot on purpose because if A ties the game on the try, we have a succeeding spot in overtime already known.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
thank you Calhoun and I see now that you explained the same as NCwingman but just different enough that it clicked for me. Thank you to both of you for the explanation!!
-
Here is a chart that may help you:
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1xcoPfzCkGIx2s-vFTpwPsCcZ2GEQCWHuNnAQMZTIFcA/edit?usp=sharing
-
Here is a chart that may help you:
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1xcoPfzCkGIx2s-vFTpwPsCcZ2GEQCWHuNnAQMZTIFcA/edit?usp=sharing
thanks Bossman. Very helpful resources as always.
-
The Chart furnished was very helpful but in the actual overtime play I have a question.. in our last game that went to overtime in their 1st OT possession, team A scored a touchdown on a play and team B was flagged for a live-ball holding foul. Team A wanted to keep the 6 points and have this penalty enforced on the 1st play of the other team’s OT possession NOT on the try. The coach was upset because it was enforced on the try, if he wanted to keep the 6 points. Did we get this wrong? ^TD
-
The Chart furnished was very helpful but in the actual overtime play I have a question.. in our last game that went to overtime in their 1st OT possession, team A scored a touchdown on a play and team B was flagged for a live-ball holding foul. Team A wanted to keep the 6 points and have this penalty enforced on the 1st play of the other team’s OT possession NOT on the try. The coach was upset because it was enforced on the try, if he wanted to keep the 6 points. Did we get this wrong? ^TD
No you got it right. The rule is written intentionally specific. The options for a foul by B during a touchdown scoring play are either on the KICKOFF or the try. Since there is no kickoff in overtime, the only option is on the try.
-
Simply put, if during the down when time expires, there is a foul that can carry succeeding spot enforcement, it can be enforced at the beginning of overtime ONLY if there is no option to enforce it during regulation time (i.e., an untimed down). If the foul CAN be enforced on an untimed down, there is no option for the offended team and it must be enforced on the untimed down (or declined).
In other words -- if there is an untimed down at the end of the fourth quarter, there exists the possibility of scoring points and therefore overtime is not assured. The offended team cannot assume overtime is a possibility for penalty enforcement until there are no more downs to play.
Fouls during a touchdown cannot carry over to OT. Fouls during a try or FG can. (if I'm not mistaken)
-
Simply put, depending on the results of the PAT depends as to if there will be an overtime. Therefore, the only choice for the TD scoring team is the PAT enforcement.
-
Fouls during a touchdown cannot carry over to OT. Fouls during a try or FG can. (if I'm not mistaken)
Correct. Fouls during a TD can be penalized either on the try or the ensuing kickoff. Since there are no kickoffs in OT, they must be penalized on the try.
Fouls during a successful FG or try can be penalized either from the previous spot (and replay the down) or from the succeeding spot.
-
Correct. Fouls during a TD can be penalized either on the try or the ensuing kickoff. Since there are no kickoffs in OT, they must be penalized on the try.
Fouls during a successful FG or try can be penalized either from the previous spot (and replay the down) or from the succeeding spot.
Other rule sets are very different. So, if you are in a position to work across different rule sets, be sure you know the rules for that particular game.