RefStripes.com

Football Officiating => National Federation Discussion => Topic started by: Fatso on August 25, 2022, 09:58:54 AM

Title: Defensive Offsides. Is a play ever allowed to go live or is it ALWAYS killed?
Post by: Fatso on August 25, 2022, 09:58:54 AM
New official here so bear with me.

Watching NFL preseason game and d end came across just before the snap.  He was flagged and play was allowed to develop.  O tackle was later flagged for holding during the play.  Result was offsetting penalties, replay the down.  Is this same for NFHS or would the play be killed immediately for encroachment? 

Thx
Title: Re: Defensive Offsides. Is a play ever allowed to go live or is it ALWAYS killed?
Post by: sir55 on August 25, 2022, 10:06:23 AM
This is encroachment under NFHS rules. It is a flag and kill the clock.
Title: Re: Defensive Offsides. Is a play ever allowed to go live or is it ALWAYS killed?
Post by: Fatso on August 25, 2022, 10:13:01 AM
thanks  FlAg1
Title: Re: Defensive Offsides. Is a play ever allowed to go live or is it ALWAYS killed?
Post by: TampaSteve on August 25, 2022, 11:58:00 AM
NFL & NCAA: remember too if the defender is unabated, the play is shut down. - doesnt happen much but still sometimes.
Title: Re: Defensive Offsides. Is a play ever allowed to go live or is it ALWAYS killed?
Post by: HLinNC on August 25, 2022, 12:57:03 PM
Welcome to Fb officiating.  One of the biggest mistakes new officials make is transferring what they watch on Saturday & Sunday to Thursday and Friday.  It can be difficult to remove that from your mind early on.  I always suggest that when watching the pros or college, when there is a foul, look up what it would be under NFHS rules.  That helps you to study and helps you begin to learn the difference.
Title: Re: Defensive Offsides. Is a play ever allowed to go live or is it ALWAYS killed?
Post by: KWH on August 25, 2022, 01:53:50 PM

HL in NC is right on the money.  I strongly suggest you heed his advice!

Nuff said
Title: Re: Defensive Offsides. Is a play ever allowed to go live or is it ALWAYS killed?
Post by: refjeff on August 25, 2022, 07:32:17 PM
New official here so bear with me.


1.  No apologies are ever necessary by any official trying to improve.

2.  There are a lot of differences on penalty enforcement between pro, college, and high school.

3.  I don't know how it is wherever you are, but if you're not doing varsity games see if you can shadow a varsity crew.  Watch, listen, ask questions.  Just a suggestion.
Title: Re: Defensive Offsides. Is a play ever allowed to go live or is it ALWAYS killed?
Post by: ElvisLives on August 25, 2022, 08:25:38 PM
Basic lesson. If the rule code has Offside as a foul (as opposed to “encroachment”), it is “Offside” (singular), not ‘offsides’ (plural).
Title: Re: Defensive Offsides. Is a play ever allowed to go live or is it ALWAYS killed?
Post by: Fatso on August 26, 2022, 07:32:22 AM
Welcome to Fb officiating.  One of the biggest mistakes new officials make is transferring what they watch on Saturday & Sunday to Thursday and Friday.  It can be difficult to remove that from your mind early on.  I always suggest that when watching the pros or college, when there is a foul, look up what it would be under NFHS rules.  That helps you to study and helps you begin to learn the difference.
Yep, that's what I've been doing. thx
Title: Re: Defensive Offsides. Is a play ever allowed to go live or is it ALWAYS killed?
Post by: bossman72 on August 26, 2022, 09:46:43 AM
NFL and NCAA have offside.
NFHS has encroachment.

Offside = live ball.
Encroachment = dead ball.
Title: Re: Defensive Offsides. Is a play ever allowed to go live or is it ALWAYS killed?
Post by: ElvisLives on August 26, 2022, 10:23:40 AM
NFL and NCAA have offside.
NFHS has encroachment.

Offside = live ball.
Encroachment = dead ball.

Can't speak for the NFL, but "Offside" in NCAA can also be dead-ball, 1) if there is contact before the ball is snapped, 2) if the offside defender is 'unabated', or 3) a defender causes a reaction by 'protected' offensive linemen. (Announcements: "Offside with contact; number...;" "Offside; number 99; defense; unabated toward a back...;" "Offside; number 99; defense; movement that caused an offensive reaction.")

But, whenever/wherever it is a foul, it is singular, "Offside." (No matter how many folks may be offside.) And, that is despite what you may here from even some FBS referees. They are simply wrong. Just ask Shaw, Redding, Adams, or Nelson (rest his soul). Or, just check the rule book.
Title: Please delete me
Post by: KWH on August 26, 2022, 01:04:47 PM
delete me
Title: Re: Please delete me
Post by: ElvisLives on August 26, 2022, 01:46:48 PM
:puke:

Yes. But anywhere incorrect, or potentially confusing, information regarding NCAA is offered, I feel an obligation to offer correction/clarification. I have never claimed to know anything about NFHS, or NFL, and am always careful to disclaim such.
Regardless of rule set, I was simply making the point that offside is "OFFSIDE" (not 'offsides').
Title: Re: Defensive Offsides. Is a play ever allowed to go live or is it ALWAYS killed?
Post by: AlUpstateNY on August 26, 2022, 03:52:23 PM
Can't speak for the NFL, but "Offside" in NCAA can also be dead-ball, 1) if there is contact before the ball is snapped, 2) if the offside defender is 'unabated', or 3) a defender causes a reaction by 'protected' offensive linemen. (Announcements: "Offside with contact; number...;" "Offside; number 99; defense; unabated toward a back...;" "Offside; number 99; defense; movement that caused an offensive reaction.")

But, whenever/wherever it is a foul, it is singular, "Offside." (No matter how many folks may be offside.) And, that is despite what you may here from even some FBS referees. They are simply wrong. Just ask Shaw, Redding, Adams, or Nelson (rest his soul). Or, just check the rule book.

Ah, Rule differences.  Some time ago, when working both NFHS and NCAA games in the same season, as a LJ at a NFHS game, A Defensive Lineman clearly stepped into the NZ before the snap, I threw my flag, unfortunately that's all I did.  The play continued and a runner dodged and weaved his way 40-50 yards for an apparent TD.  After which the R (a good friend) asked me what I had.  As I stared to respond I remembered this was an NFHS game, and the flag for a dead-ball foul actually killed the play.  My "friend" looked at me and said, "YOU have some explaining to do to the Offensive HC" to which I responded (something along the lines of) "Oh sugar".

I did, explaining the rule difference between NFHS & NCAA, as carefully as possible, and the result that the Def encroachment, killed the play and his runner advanced a dead ball.  The fact that he could repeat the down after a 5 yard advance, failed to adequately balance my explanation, but my explanation held and the down was replayed, with the apparent score eliminated. 

I forget the exact amount of the post-game review meeting bill, but thankfully I had my credit card available  This thread brought back vivid memories of the "scar tissue" I've carried since, but prevented me from EVER coming close to repeating that mistake.  Actively working multi level Rule codes is a special challenge.