RefStripes.com
Football Officiating => National Federation Discussion => Topic started by: MClays99 on September 15, 2022, 09:29:00 AM
-
This question came up at our most recent local association meeting - Ohio. After a failed 4th down attempt - do you leave the ball where it lies and go the other way 1st & 10, or do you move the ball the length of the ball so the "nose" of the ball rests where the "nose" of the ball from the previous down ended and go the other way? We had a discussion about whether or not the "nose" of the ball matters when placing it for the next series of downs. I could not find anything in the NFHS books.
Thanks,
MClays99
-
If We are in a part of the field where "inches" don't matter, I am going to move it and have it on a hash if the field had yard line hash marks. If it ends on one side of a big line, I am moving it to the other side of the big line. There are general ways of doing it, but specific circumstances may change it.
-
The ball remains in place. What was the 'nose' of the ball is now the 'tail' of the ball. In pre-game you may wish to instruct the box guy to move downs marker by the length of the football on an incomplete 4th down pass.
-
We will move it backwards to a line. Always move it backwards, if you move it forward to the next line and that was the front stake, you may have to answer to a coach how its on the line and that was where the front stake was and its not a first down for him.
But, technically the ball stays still and the chains move. The front point become the back point.
-
We will move it backwards to a line. Always move it backwards, if you move it forward to the next line and that was the front stake, you may have to answer to a coach how its on the line and that was where the front stake was and its not a first down for him.
But, technically the ball stays still and the chains move. The front point become the back point.
I was always taught and by rule it is correct that the "spot" is the foremost part of the ball regardless of how it is facing when it is declared dead. That being said the correct location of the ball for the 1st down spot after change of possession should reflect that fact. ex: After a 4th down incomplete pass we put the ball on the box and the box does not move.
Additionally if we a starting that new series anywhere between the 25's we put the ball back to the nearest hash, effectively starting that series on a hash.
-
On a 4th down incomplete pass they gain the length of the ball. So the chain and box should move. I cannot find in the rules or the mechanics anything about moving the ball to a hash mark.
-
Thanks for the responses. One of our members is a "where is it in the rule book" kinda guy, so if anyone has any knowledge of whether or not guidance resides there it would be helpful.
-
On a 4th down incomplete pass they gain the length of the ball. So the chain and box should move. I cannot find in the rules or the mechanics anything about moving the ball to a hash mark.
Being ole' school, I agree, " moving the ball to a hash " ain't no where to be found. I realize that it makes our job a little easier, but IMHO, it should stay where it lay. I allow our guys to spot an interception or kick return on a hash, but on a turnover on downs, I feel it should stay where the play ended with the forward tip now becoming the rear tip. If we all agreed on everything, this would become more of a sewing circle than a forum.
hEaDbAnG :sTiR: pi1eOn
-
Being ole' school, I agree, " moving the ball to a hash " ain't no where to be found. I realize that it makes our job a little easier, but IMHO, it should stay where it lay. I allow our guys to spot an interception or kick return on a hash, but on a turnover on downs, I feel it should stay where the play ended with the forward tip now becoming the rear tip. If we all agreed on everything, this would become more of a sewing circle than a forum.
hEaDbAnG :sTiR: pi1eOn
Except that Rule 2-41-3 defines the DB spot as the foremost part of the ball when it is dead. :!#
-
I was always taught and by rule it is correct that the "spot" is the foremost part of the ball regardless of how it is facing when it is declared dead. That being said the correct location of the ball for the 1st down spot after change of possession should reflect that fact. ex: After a 4th down incomplete pass we put the ball on the box and the box does not move.
Sorry, no. The down box & chains move. RB 5.3.3 a & b. Case Book 5.5.3 Situation.
I understand that many officials, maybe most, do this incorrectly.
-
We will move it backwards to a line. Always move it backwards, if you move it forward to the next line and that was the front stake, you may have to answer to a coach how its on the line and that was where the front stake was and its not a first down for him.
I understand, and I don't want to belabor the point, but I also don't want to have to explain to a coach that the reason we moved the ball a couple of feet farther from the goalline was to make it easier for us. He will never understand that.
Like Mr. Damren, I am old school and started officiating when we had hash marks and no field had yard marks and I know the difference between the two and use the terms correctly. Which almost no one does.
-
This question came up at our most recent local association meeting - Ohio. After a failed 4th down attempt - do you leave the ball where it lies and go the other way 1st & 10, or do you move the ball the length of the ball so the "nose" of the ball rests where the "nose" of the ball from the previous down ended and go the other way? We had a discussion about whether or not the "nose" of the ball matters when placing it for the next series of downs. I could not find anything in the NFHS books.
5.3.3 rule book and case book.
I'm in NW Ohio
-
This question came up at our most recent local association meeting - Ohio. After a failed 4th down attempt - do you leave the ball where it lies and go the other way 1st & 10, or do you move the ball the length of the ball so the "nose" of the ball rests where the "nose" of the ball from the previous down ended and go the other way? We had a discussion about whether or not the "nose" of the ball matters when placing it for the next series of downs. I could not find anything in the NFHS books.
Thanks,
MClays99
A series after a turnover on downs is a specific exception to the idea that each series should start on a yard line. Thus, move the chains around the ball, so that the old front stake becomes the rear stake. If the ball was in a side zone at the end of the 4th down play, use the chains to move the ball to the nearest hash mark.
-
A series after a turnover on downs is a specific exception to the idea that each series should start on a yard line. Thus, move the chains around the ball, so that the old front stake becomes the rear stake. If the ball was in a side zone at the end of the 4th down play, use the chains to move the ball to the nearest hash mark.
If you had to measure, yes.
Otherwise, no.
-
The OP asks about a change of possession after an "failed 4th down attempt". Obviously the author is talking about a running/pass play - to which the Forum answered ad nauseum...
However, if this is an unsuccessful field goal attempt that becomes (1) dead in the field of play or (2) the end zone, the placement is (1) the spot where the ball becomes dead and (2) anywhere along the 20 yd line at team B/R's choice.
-
When the completion of a third down play allows for it, consider placing the ball for 4th down with its tail touching a line?
That way, should A fail to meet the line to gain via an incomplete pass, you get the ball right where you want it and you never moved it.
Old guys drool!
-
When the completion of a third down play allows for it, consider placing the ball for 4th down with its tail touching a line?
That way, should A fail to meet the line to gain via an incomplete pass, you get the ball right where you want it and you never moved it.
Old guys drool!
Again we are placing a team at a disadvantage to make it easier for us.
I don't get it.
-
…you get the ball right where you want it…
Wow. I missed the memo that told us that this is our game, not the players, and we get to do what we want for our personal expedience.
That is nothing less than simple selfish laziness, and anybody that condones this type of action should be ashamed. I’d like to say more, but I’ll leave it at that.
-
When I work H, after an incomplete 4th down pass, I will go to the down marker and tell the box man to move it from my heel to my toe going the new direction. My foot may not be the exact length of the football but it is close enough. I signal the U that I've already got the new spot ad we're off.
-
My opinion on using field marking are use them when you can. After kicks, Long first down, etc. critical spots such as near the LTG or inside the 10, coming in or going out should be placed exact. If a new series does not start “on a tick”, in these situations, so be it. Basically use the field markings to make the game run smoother where you can, but some spots are critical and a foot can be a really big deal.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
When I work H, after an incomplete 4th down pass, I will go to the down marker and tell the box man to move it from my heel to my toe going the new direction. My foot may not be the exact length of the football but it is close enough. I signal the U that I've already got the new spot ad we're off.
This is our mechanic
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
When the completion of a third down play allows for it, consider placing the ball for 4th down with its tail touching a line?
That way, should A fail to meet the line to gain via an incomplete pass, you get the ball right where you want it and you never moved it.
Old guys drool!
This is not well thought out at all.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
If you had to measure, yes.
Otherwise, no.
Chances are that there will be a measurement if it's 4th down and the play is extremely close to the line to gain. I described the case if there was a measurement. If for whatever reason there is no measurement, take one of the incoming team's balls and place it on a hash mark in line with the outgoing ball. Then return the outgoing ball.
-
On a 4th down incomplete pass they gain the length of the ball. So the chain and box should move. I cannot find in the rules or the mechanics anything about moving the ball to a hash mark.
Their is no mechanic to do it. It is done as a matter of convience and making things easier where the length of the football doesn't really matter.
-
I’m probably missing something, but it seems obvious to me that if A doesn’t reach the line to gain, the chains would have to be reset out of necessity. Because the front chain marks the line to gain. If team A doesn’t reach that point, then the chains would need to be moved back to the dead ball spot.
This seems like fly poop in the pepper shaker stuff to me.
Having said that, we leave the ball where it is and set the chains at the foremost point in the direction we are heading, which used to be the rearmost point in the Direction A was heading.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
I’m probably missing something, but it seems obvious to me that if A doesn’t reach the line to gain, the chains would have to be reset out of necessity. Because the front chain marks the line to gain. If team A doesn’t reach that point, then the chains would need to be moved back to the dead ball spot.
This seems like fly poop in the pepper shaker stuff to me.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
It's a question of whether to move the downbox or not. Rule book says yes.
-
... take one of the incoming team's balls and place it on a hash mark in line with the outgoing ball. Then return the outgoing ball.
I'm not saying that is wrong, but we don't spot the old ball per Ohio "Gold Book" mechanics. The bad ball is going out while the good ball is coming on.
-
It's a question of whether to move the downbox or not. Rule book says yes.
I agree with the rulebook.
-
I agree with the rulebook.
I try to but the folks behind me believe I am frequently wrong.
-
I try to but the folks behind me believe I am frequently wrong.
Join the crowd.
-
I was always taught and by rule it is correct that the "spot" is the foremost part of the ball regardless of how it is facing when it is declared dead. That being said the correct location of the ball for the 1st down spot after change of possession should reflect that fact. ex: After a 4th down incomplete pass we put the ball on the box and the box does not move.
Additionally if we a starting that new series anywhere between the 25's we put the ball back to the nearest hash, effectively starting that series on a hash.
Reffjeff provided the case book plays to illustrate that the ball doesn't move.
Think about it this way, if we spot the ball inches short of the goal line on 4th down, you can't pivot the ball on the foremost point and go the other way because then the back of the ball would be in the end zone, which we can't have.
-
The ball does not move forwards or backwards after a series ends. It may have to move sideways, because the ball can only be legally spotted on or inside a hash mark (more formally known as an inbounds mark). This is why a measurement conducted in a side zone where A fails to reach the line to gain will result in the officials using the chains to place the ball. This is the same reason why, in my high school games in the DC area and in my college games, I have seen the officials keep the old ball on the ground until the new ball has been spotted.
-
Again we are placing a team at a disadvantage to make it easier for us.
I don't get it.
Because your spots are so accurate that there is zero room for movement? You should ref every Superbowl and NCAA championship because every mere mortal who does this job is only trying their best to accurately estimate the spot on a series of plays and then accurately replicate those spots when we move back from outside the hash and then placing the ball perfectly every time leading up to that 4th down. All fiction. Start on a line except inside the 10!!!! Your games will be so much better.
-
I’m probably missing something, but it seems obvious to me that if A doesn’t reach the line to gain, the chains would have to be reset out of necessity. Because the front chain marks the line to gain. If team A doesn’t reach that point, then the chains would need to be moved back to the dead ball spot.
This seems like fly poop in the pepper shaker stuff to me.
Having said that, we leave the ball where it is and set the chains at the foremost point in the direction we are heading, which used to be the rearmost point in the Direction A was heading.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Sounds sensible. V. Lombardi suggested, "Perfection is not attainable, but if we choose to chase perfection, we might catch excellence". Good idea to shoo flies away any time you see them near pepper shakers.
-
Because your spots are so accurate that there is zero room for movement? You should ref every Superbowl and NCAA championship because every mere mortal who does this job is only trying their best to accurately estimate the spot on a series of plays and then accurately replicate those spots when we move back from outside the hash and then placing the ball perfectly every time leading up to that 4th down. All fiction. Start on a line except inside the 10!!!! Your games will be so much better.
Nonsense.
-
The theory is 'spotting on a tic' is that reduces the need for measurements. We use the 'stays where it lays' procedure. I'v e worked 6 games so far this year and have had only one measurement. That came on a field that didn't have the one yard increments. While spotting on a tic can speed thing up, it can git ya; into trouble. With the miracle of having cameras in our telephones and games showing up on our TV, and many other fancy gagets, some may notice and wonder. This occurred a few years back......
SCENE : 4TH & 3 FROM B'S 10.
ACT I : A1 is downed outside of B's 7;
ACT II : Measurement showed short by inches;
ACT III : ball then spotted with nose touching 7 and chains set accordingly.
SCENE II : MONDAY MORNING PHONE CALL.
ACT I : A's coach, " The ball was then spotted closer to B's goal, could I have asked for another measurement ??? ??? "
Me :o ::) " Err.... no, the turnover on downs had already occurred :P"
coach :" Then ,why was the ball moved further bacvk :!#"
Me : " Well.. hEaDbAnG it makes it easier for future spots... :!# "
ACT II : Coach : " >:( :o :-[ :-\ :puke:....."
Me : " Well, it did move the ball further from your endzone :-[ ."
SCENE III : CALLING ALL z^ z^ z^ z^ z^ z^ z^ z^ z^ z^ z^ z^ z^ z^ z^ z^ z^ z^ z^ z^ z^ z^ z^ z^ z^ z^
ACT I : Instructed all chapter interps. to request letting ball stay where it lay;
ACT II : On interceptions and kick returns , ball may be spotted on tic.
REMEMBER, GUYS, THAT IN THIS HI-TECH WORLD, BIG BROTHER (OR SISTER) IS WATCHING......
,,,,,ND SOME MAY BE WONDERING ??? ??? ???
-
Nonsense.
Actually, Common sense. Try it...
-
Actually, Common sense. Try it...
There's that expression again - "...common sense..." Whenever I ask, no one can tell me what that is. It dang sure ain't what most folks think it is. Most folks think it is some innate ability of a person to arrive at good decisions. Sorry to burst (or 'bust') your bubbles, but there is no such thing. The ability to make good decisions has two elements: 1) raw intellect, and 2) knowledge. Those things combine to allow a person to make good decisions. But, one without the other is meaningless.
The raw intellect part is what you are born with, and no one can improve that. It is what it is. It is your ability to process "knowledge," and to be able to apply that knowledge to a given situation.
Knowledge is gained in two ways: formal education, and experience. And everybody needs both. Academics give you factual information that can't be just magically absorbed. Experience shows you what academic elements look like, and how they work. Football example: We can, and must, teach everybody what a false start is. But, that, in itself, is not enough. When a person then witnesses a false start AFTER being taught what it is, the light bulb brightens, and suddenly, they can apply that situation to other similar, but not necessarily identical, situations, and, if they have enough raw intellect, they can analyze what they see to determine if they see a false start, or legal action.
Nobody is born with "...common sense..." as what most folks think it is. A guy with multiple doctorates, but no real experience, can't possibly make the best decisions. Likewise, a guy with no formal education, but who has been working and "out in the world" his whole life can't make the best decisions, either.
Abe Lincoln may be the most classic example of someone with both intellect and knowledge. Being a poor farm boy, he certainly had the experience of living off the land. But he also had the self-motivated desire to acquire academic knowledge. Thus, he had all of the tools to lead people reasonably well.
In my experience, every time somebody throws out the expression, "...common sense...," they are just covering and/or attempting to use that as an excuse for their lack or knowledge or experience. And, I have found that many of those folks lack one or the other, mostly out of simple laziness. As in this case. "Let's spot the ball on a yard line for every dead ball, then we'll never have to measure, because I'm way more important than the players, or the game itself, and I just want to get this game over as quickly as possible, so I can collect my check and go home. Actual rules aren't important. I've watched football on TV. We'll just use common sense."
Those that think this way should be ashamed of themselves, and should go find some other activity - one that doesn't expect effort and integrity.
-
There's that expression again - "...common sense..." Whenever I ask, no one can tell me what that is. It dang sure ain't what most folks think it is. Most folks think it is some innate ability of a person to arrive a good decisions. Sorry to burst (or 'bust') your bubbles, but there is no such thing. The ability to make good decisions has two elements: 1) raw intellect, and 2) knowledge. Those things combine to allow a person to make good decisions. But, one without the other is meaningless.
The raw intellect part is what you are born with, and no one can improve that. It is what it is. It is your ability to process "knowledge," and to be able to apply that knowledge to a given situation.
Knowledge is gained in two ways: formal education, and experience. And everybody needs both. Academics give you factual information that can't be just magically absorbed. Experience shows you what academic elements look like, and how they work. Football example: We can, and must, teach everybody what a false start is. But, that, in itself, is not enough. When a person then witnesses a false start AFTER being taught what it is, the light bulb brightens, and suddenly, they can apply that situation to other similar, but not necessarily identical, situations, and, if they have enough raw intellect, they can analyze what they see to determine if they see a false start, or legal action.
Nobody is born with "...common sense..." as what most folks think it is. A guy with multiple doctorates, but no real experience, can't possibly make the best decisions. Likewise, a guy with no formal education, but who has been working and "out in the world" his whole life can't make the best decisions, either.
Abe Lincoln may be the most classic example of someone with both intellect and knowledge. Being a poor farm boy, he certainly had the experience of living off the land. But he also had the self-motivated desire to acquire academic knowledge. Thus, he had all of the tools to lead people reasonably well.
In my experience, every time somebody throws out the expression, "...common sense...," they are just covering and/or attempting to use that as an excuse for their lack or knowledge or experience. And, I have found that many of those folks lack one or the other, mostly out of simple laziness. As in this case. "Let's spot the ball on a yard line for every dead ball, then we'll never have to measure, because I'm way more important than the players, or the game itself, and I just want to get this game over as quickly as possible, so I can collect my check and go home. Actual rules aren't important. I've watched football on TV. We'll just use common sense."
Those that think this way should be ashamed of themselves, and should go find some other activity - one that doesn't expect effort and integrity.
com·mon sense | ˌkämən ˈsens |
noun
good sense and sound judgment in practical matters: [as modifier] : a common-sense approach | use your common sense.
-
There's that expression again - "...common sense..." Whenever I ask, no one can tell me what that is. It dang sure ain't what most folks think it is. Most folks think it is some innate ability of a person to arrive a good decisions. Sorry to burst (or 'bust') your bubbles, but there is no such thing. The ability to make good decisions has two elements: 1) raw intellect, and 2) knowledge. Those things combine to allow a person to make good decisions. But, one without the other is meaningless.
The raw intellect part is what you are born with, and no one can improve that. It is what it is. It is your ability to process "knowledge," and to be able to apply that knowledge to a given situation.
Knowledge is gained in two ways: formal education, and experience. And everybody needs both. Academics give you factual information that can't be just magically absorbed. Experience shows you what academic elements look like, and how they work. Football example: We can, and must, teach everybody what a false start is. But, that, in itself, is not enough. When a person then witnesses a false start AFTER being taught what it is, the light bulb brightens, and suddenly, they can apply that situation to other similar, but not necessarily identical, situations, and, if they have enough raw intellect, they can analyze what they see to determine if they see a false start, or legal action.
Nobody is born with "...common sense..." as what most folks think it is. A guy with multiple doctorates, but no real experience, can't possibly make the best decisions. Likewise, a guy with no formal education, but who has been working and "out in the world" his whole life can't make the best decisions, either.
Abe Lincoln may be the most classic example of someone with both intellect and knowledge. Being a poor farm boy, he certainly had the experience of living off the land. But he also had the self-motivated desire to acquire academic knowledge. Thus, he had all of the tools to lead people reasonably well.
In my experience, every time somebody throws out the expression, "...common sense...," they are just covering and/or attempting to use that as an excuse for their lack or knowledge or experience. And, I have found that many of those folks lack one or the other, mostly out of simple laziness. As in this case. "Let's spot the ball on a yard line for every dead ball, then we'll never have to measure, because I'm way more important than the players, or the game itself, and I just want to get this game over as quickly as possible, so I can collect my check and go home. Actual rules aren't important. I've watched football on TV. We'll just use common sense."
Those that think this way should be ashamed of themselves, and should go find some other activity - one that doesn't expect effort and integrity.
Common sense
Not to be confused with Common knowledge.
For the American revolutionary war pamphlet by Thomas Paine, see Common Sense. For other uses, see Common sense (disambiguation).
Common sense (often just known as sense) is sound, practical judgment concerning everyday matters, or a basic ability to perceive, understand, and judge in a manner that is shared by (i.e. common to) nearly all people.[1]
The everyday understanding of common sense derives from historical philosophical discussion involving several European languages. Related terms in other languages include Latin sensus communis, Greek αἴσθησις κοινὴ (aísthēsis koinḕ), and French bon sens, but these are not straightforward translations in all contexts. Similarly in English, there are different shades of meaning, implying more or less education and wisdom: "good sense" is sometimes seen as equivalent to "common sense", and sometimes not.[2]
Aristotle, the first person known to have discussed "common sense", described it as the ability with which animals (including humans) process sense-perceptions, memories and imagination (φρονεῖν, phroneîn) in order to reach many types of basic judgments. In his scheme, only humans have real reasoned thinking (νοεῖν, noeîn), which takes them beyond their common sense.
"Common sense" has at least two specific philosophical meanings. One is as a capability of the animal soul (ψῡχή, psūkhḗ) proposed by Aristotle to explain how the different senses join together and enable discrimination of particular objects by people and other animals. This common sense is distinct from basic sensory perception and from human rational thought, but cooperates with both.
A second philosophical use of the term is Roman-influenced and is used for the natural human sensitivity for other humans and the community.[3] Just like the everyday meaning, both of these refer to a type of basic awareness and ability to judge that most people are expected to share naturally, even if they cannot explain why. All these meanings of "common sense", including the everyday ones, are interconnected in a complex history and have evolved during important political and philosophical debates in modern Western civilization, notably concerning science, politics and economics.[4] The interplay between the meanings has come to be particularly notable in English, as opposed to other western European languages, and the English term has become international.[5]
Since the Age of Enlightenment the term "common sense" has been used for rhetorical effect both approvingly, as a standard for good taste and source of scientific and logical axioms, and disapprovingly, as equivalent to vulgar prejudice and superstition.[6] It was at the beginning of the 18th century that this old philosophical term first acquired its modern English meaning: "Those plain, self-evident truths or conventional wisdom that one needed no sophistication to grasp and no proof to accept precisely because they accorded so well with the basic (common sense) intellectual capacities and experiences of the whole social body."[7] This began with Descartes's criticism of it, and what came to be known as the dispute between "rationalism" and "empiricism". In the opening line of one of his most famous books, Discourse on Method, Descartes established the most common modern meaning, and its controversies, when he stated that everyone has a similar and sufficient amount of common sense (bon sens), but it is rarely used well. Therefore, a skeptical logical method described by Descartes needs to be followed and common sense should not be overly relied upon.[8] In the ensuing 18th century Enlightenment, common sense came to be seen more positively as the basis for modern thinking. It was contrasted to metaphysics, which was, like Cartesianism, associated with the Ancient Régime. Thomas Paine's polemical pamphlet Common Sense (1776) has been described as the most influential political pamphlet of the 18th century, affecting both the American and French revolutions.[6] Today, the concept of common sense, and how it should best be used, remains linked to many of the most perennial topics in epistemology and ethics, with special focus often directed at the philosophy of the modern social sciences.
-
Actually, Common sense. Try it...
He does. Every time he leaves the ball where it is and moves the chains... That's the common sense approach.
-
I JUST NOTICED..............
THAT THE ACTION PIX ON THE ID SIDE OF MY POST SHOWS THE TIP OF THE BALL NOTSPOTTED ON A TIC !!!
???
:sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: