RefStripes.com

Football Officiating => National Federation Discussion => Topic started by: juxone on October 06, 2022, 09:44:36 AM

Title: Free Kick Muffed?
Post by: juxone on October 06, 2022, 09:44:36 AM
Remembering an earlier conversation in here Where Calhoun said "Yes. Muffing doesn’t equal possession and a kick remains a kick until it’s possessed or becomes dead by rule. The only thing muffing does is allow K the opportunity to recover the kick in the field of play." 

So then in a case where Team K kicks to start a period AND the ball travels well beyond R’s free-kick but is grounded at Rs35, if the ball is muffed by both teams several times, but K is the last to muff the ball out of bounds the ball still belongs to R at the point it went out of bounds, regardless of who touched it last?
Title: Re: Free Kick Muffed?
Post by: Ralph Damren on October 06, 2022, 10:05:46 AM
If you have travelled back to the last century, it would have been a foul if LAST touched by K. In 2000, we tweaked 6-1-8 to only make it a foul if UNTOCHED by R.
Title: Re: Free Kick Muffed?
Post by: juxone on October 06, 2022, 10:46:58 AM
If you have travelled back to the last century, it would have been a foul if LAST touched by K. In 2000, we tweaked 6-1-8 to only make it a foul if UNTOCHED by R.

Sorry, I guess was not clear.. So yes the ball is grounded, R attempts to pick it up, and muffs the ball which in turn is muffed several times by both and K with K being the last to touch the ball where it goes out of bounds at the R 35, it would be Rs ball at R35, because possession was never gained by either team and the ball remained a kick.
Title: Re: Free Kick Muffed?
Post by: juxone on October 06, 2022, 11:57:42 AM
If you have travelled back to the last century, it would have been a foul if LAST touched by K. In 2000, we tweaked 6-1-8 to only make it a foul if UNTOCHED by R.
 

Just an added thought, doesn't Rule 6-1-6 also say that K may recover a Free Kick so long as it Both a) touches the ground b) goes beyond the R's free-kick line and those two things can occur in any order?  :sTiR:
Title: Re: Free Kick Muffed?
Post by: NVFOA_Ump on October 06, 2022, 12:39:33 PM
So then in a case where Team K kicks to start a period AND the ball travels well beyond R’s free-kick but is grounded at Rs35, if the ball is muffed by both teams several times, but K is the last to muff the ball out of bounds the ball still belongs to R at the point it went out of bounds, regardless of who touched it last?

That is correct.  The quantity of muffs has no bearing on who will snap next.  If K does not actually possess (possession + control) the free kicked loose ball in the field of play then R will be next to snap.