RefStripes.com
Football Officiating => National Federation Discussion => Topic started by: BG5 on October 11, 2022, 09:07:48 AM
-
Quick question on all personal fouls by team B on scoring plays. It team B has a personal foul on a scoring play then team A has the choice to enforce the penalty on the attempt or Kickoff correct?
Its only personal fouls by team B on scoring plays that team A has the choice correct?
If team B were to have a defensive hold on a scoring play then team A would have to decline that penatly to keep the score right? Fouls like defensive holding would have to be declined to keep the score and cannot be added onto the try or kick right? Just personal Fouls are added onto the try or kick?
-
Under NFHS rules, all fouls committed by Team B on a touchdown scoring play may be enforced on the try or subsequent kickoff (8-2-2). If Team B scores a touchdown after a change of possession, any foul committed by A after the change of possession may be enforced on the try or subsequent kickoff (8-2-3). Finally, any unsportsmanlike conduct or nonplayer fouls by either team may be enforced on the try or subsequent kickoff (8-2-4).
This is different than the NCAA rules which require most fouls be declined on a scoring play.
-
These 'bridge fouls' were inserted to prevent a player from getting from a cheap shot on an obvious TD, knowing the penalty will be declined to keep the score. Some things to know/remember about 'bridge fouls'.....
* A foul by A prior to COP followed by a B TD, isn't one as A wouldn't have known that B was going to score.
* Dueling DB fouls cancel and not to worry about order of occurance.
* A live ball foul on a successful PAT by B/R can be bridged to KO, a foul by A/K on an unsuccessful PAT can't.
* A foul as game time expires on a TD can only be ridged to PAT, as PAT will determine need for overtime.
THERE ARE MANY MORE THINGS TO KNOW ABOUT BRIDGE FOULS, BUT WE'LL CROSS THAT BRIDGE WHEN WE GIT TO ER'. :)
-
The dumbest rule in FED.
-
The dumbest rule in FED.
Disagree. That would be intentional pass interference.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
intentional pass interference
Unicorn
-
I think the "free shot" on scoring plays theory is/was overblown.
-
I think the "free shot" on scoring plays theory is/was overblown.
I think, too, that I think like you do :thumbup , however, but NCAA & NFL have simular rules limited to personal fouls.
-
Unicorn
Lol. Correct
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
Disagree. That would be intentional pass interference.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
:thumbup
-
I think, too, that I think like you do :thumbup , however, but NCAA & NFL have simular rules limited to personal fouls.
And it should be the same in FED. But alas, I’m sure the rules makers think HS officials are too stupid to understand that only personal fouls carry over.
-
I’m sure the rules makers think HS officials are too stupid
Nah, the usual reasoning is "WE DON"T LIKE EXCEPTIONS."
But we have the numbering exception, the intentional grounding exception(s), the tack-on exception, the FBZ exception but I digress.
-
And it should be the same in FED. But alas, I’m sure the rules makers think HS officials are too stupid to understand that only personal fouls carry over.
I’m convinced there’s money involved. Why else would they ignore tried and proven rules from other codes, insisting on having to be different? There is an intentional effort to not be like the NCAA.
I get the need for different rules at the high school level. But then they try to adopt an NCAA rule to appease the coaches, while refusing to just adopt it wholesale, language and all, instead opting to tweak it so it will be different than the NCAA version. In the majority of cases, they end up getting it mixed up and messed up.
If we are going to have a different rule set, keep it totally different, because the merger isn’t working.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
Nah, the usual reasoning is "WE DON"T LIKE EXCEPTIONS."
But we have the numbering exception, the intentional grounding exception(s), the tack-on exception, the FBZ exception but I digress.
If they don't like "exceptions", why are there AT LEAST 190 CODIFIED "EXCEPTIONS" in the Rules Books. To show you how "exciting (not)" my life is these days, I counted the words "except when, except for, other than when, other than if, etc". It added up to 190 - and that doesn't include examples where there are multiple "examples" and exceptions to the exception within the initial exemption itself. hEaDbAnG cRaZy
-
A WORD (OR TWO) ABOUT DIFFERENCES IN CODES.....
"At the end of 1947 and early 1948 a tentative agreemant was reached to produce a joint high school/college code. This was done after negotiations and a great deal of give and take on the part of both rules committees. In 1948, agreement had been reached to publish identical rules books. The one published by NFHS contained the copy mutually agreed upon. At the last moment, the college committee withdrew their support and decided to publish their own rules book."
SOURCE: 2021-2022 NFHS Football Handbook