RefStripes.com

Football Officiating => National Federation Discussion => Topic started by: Bubba Ump on October 16, 2022, 11:43:31 PM

Title: So many things wrong here
Post by: Bubba Ump on October 16, 2022, 11:43:31 PM
Count the mistakes by the drew.   https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iotxlhBwGgs
I think the only person who try's to get it right is the LJ but he gets talked out of it by the HL.  The reaction by the U is classic.  I fell out of my chair watching him.
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: HLinNC on October 17, 2022, 06:52:40 AM
Whew.  I'm going to have to watch it again when I get home from work.
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: Lhaskins on October 17, 2022, 10:30:05 AM
I think you posted the wrong film clip. This is a film clip of a blocked FG.
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: Derek Teigen on October 17, 2022, 10:51:33 AM
well I think the crew got it right.  nobody blew the play dead and according to 6.2.3 any K player may catch or recover while it is in or behind the neutral zone and advance....yes the umpire thought the game was over and signaled no good like it was a try but everybody allowed the play to continue.

what crew errors do you see?
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: red viking on October 17, 2022, 11:02:00 AM
It's beyond the LOS but within the "expanded neutral zone." If it was a little farther downfield I'd definitely say he can't advance it but not sure about that particular location - about 1 yard beyond the LOS.
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: refjeff on October 17, 2022, 11:32:11 AM
well I think the crew got it right.  nobody blew the play dead and according to 6.2.3 any K player may catch or recover while it is in or behind the neutral zone and advance....yes the umpire thought the game was over and signaled no good like it was a try but everybody allowed the play to continue.

what crew errors do you see?
By the time K picked up the ball it was beyond the down box, which means it was beyond the neutral zone, which means it was dead. 
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: TxBJ on October 17, 2022, 11:39:02 AM
I'm glad this was posted.  I saw it this weekend in an article on the CBS Sports website that pointed to the video on Twitter.  Someone in the comments pointed out that the ball was recovered beyond the NZ and should have been dead (which is what I was thinking as an NCAA rules guy).  Someone else stated that the NZ is expanded 3 yards on kicks in NFHS so this was a legal recovery and advance.  Is that correct?
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: Derek Teigen on October 17, 2022, 11:40:53 AM
The neutral zone expands 2 yards beyond the LOS.  The ball was picked up within this area of the expanded neutral zone.  I don't see any problem here do you?
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: HLinNC on October 17, 2022, 12:01:21 PM
 (6-2-3) K can catch or recover a scrimmage kick while it is in or behind the neutral zone and advance, not the expanded neutral zone.
 
The ball appears to be beyond the down marker when K picks it up.    This would appear to be first touching by K as the blocked punt behind the line by R would be ignored.
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: dammitbobby on October 17, 2022, 01:28:39 PM
The only feedback I can offer, is mechanics - H should have held the line to definitely determine whether or not the ball crossed the LOS, instead of drifting away from the ball, and could have hustled more going to the goal line.  Immediately after signaling touchdown, he should have come racing in to discuss with other crew mates - huddle up, kick all the players and coaches out of the immediate area, and make a decision.

The other officials appear to have no idea what is going on, and need to officiate all the way to the end of the play.  When there's confusion like that, the worst thing you can do (IMO) is look like you don't know.

 I'm assuming it's standard mechanics for this association to just have one official under the goalposts.  The BJ should have moved up to the GL when it was obvious that something hinky was going on, and all the other officials (looks like 5-man crew) need to be vigilant and live ball AND dead ball officiate until it gets sorted out. 
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: PABJNR on October 17, 2022, 02:21:35 PM
6 man crew in that part of PA. SJ and FJ under posts


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: ncwingman on October 17, 2022, 02:26:48 PM
The neutral zone expands 2 yards beyond the LOS.  The ball was picked up within this area of the expanded neutral zone.  I don't see any problem here do you?

The expanded neutral zone does, but K may only recover in or behind the "normal" neutral zone.

The only feedback I can offer, is mechanics - H should have held the line to definitely determine whether or not the ball crossed the LOS, instead of drifting away from the ball, and could have hustled more going to the goal line.  Immediately after signaling touchdown, he should have come racing in to discuss with other crew mates - huddle up, kick all the players and coaches out of the immediate area, and make a decision.

The other officials appear to have no idea what is going on, and need to officiate all the way to the end of the play.  When there's confusion like that, the worst thing you can do (IMO) is look like you don't know.

 I'm assuming it's standard mechanics for this association to just have one official under the goalposts.  The BJ should have moved up to the GL when it was obvious that something hinky was going on, and all the other officials (looks like 5-man crew) need to be vigilant and live ball AND dead ball officiate until it gets sorted out. 

I agree that the H should have held the line better here. However, I don't think I see anybody actually signal TD. H only makes it down to the 6 and whoever is in the back is just nonchalantly walking forward making no signals either. All officials just seem to be sauntering off with no purpose. Looks bad man.

I recognize this game as being in Pennsylvania, and I believe they use a six man crew -- so there's probably two deep wings under the goal posts (FJ/SJ, no BJ in 6 man) although I only see one come out from the end line. Or maybe, like the rest of us, an officiating shortage has reduced them to five?
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: dammitbobby on October 17, 2022, 02:31:14 PM
I agree that the H should have held the line better here. However, I don't think I see anybody actually signal TD. H only makes it down to the 6 and whoever is in the back is just nonchalantly walking forward making no signals either.
It's hard to tell but I thought the H held his hands up at the 6.
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: ncwingman on October 17, 2022, 02:42:01 PM
It's hard to tell but I thought the H held his hands up at the 6.

Which, personally... I think is even worse. You don't score points at the 6. You should only signal TD at the goal line or in the end zone. However, I'm not going to argue that point on the internet too much. That's a bit more of a subjective preference, so I'm not offended if people disagree.

I was also trying to see what happened when the whole team started celebrating, thinking somebody made a signal at that point, but the H had already turned back by then. I'm guessing somebody said something to the team rather than making an overt signal.
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: MAFBRef on October 17, 2022, 03:24:32 PM
It looked to me like the crew had a collective brain fart and defaulted into a failed extra point mode.  At least there was a little recognition, probably following an "oh s**t!" realization, and a weak attempt to get back into the play.  It's why we need to constantly communicate as crews to help and avoid these type of things.
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: Covid 22 on October 17, 2022, 04:09:22 PM
There are a number of bad looks in this play.  The crew did not look good.  However, the HL does hold his position and watches the ball until it is picked up (he does crawl down a couple of yards).   He then follows the BC and when the BC crosses the goal line the HL points at the official in the end zone letting him know that he stayed in bounds.  He wanted the BJ, S, F, whoever it was to make the TD signal.   Of course he was 8 yards deep and had no idea what was going on.   The HL did not bean bag the first touching which could have solved this problem real quick. 

I am amazed that they got it right.
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: refjeff on October 17, 2022, 04:41:42 PM
There are a number of bad looks in this play.  The crew did not look good.  However, the HL does hold his position and watches the ball until it is picked up (he does crawl down a couple of yards).   He then follows the BC and when the BC crosses the goal line the HL points at the official in the end zone letting him know that he stayed in bounds.  He wanted the BJ, S, F, whoever it was to make the TD signal.   Of course he was 8 yards deep and had no idea what was going on.   The HL did not bean bag the first touching which could have solved this problem real quick. 

I am amazed that they got it right.
Except they didn't get it right.
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: Covid 22 on October 17, 2022, 05:20:40 PM
What did I miss?  They didn't allow the score and ended the game. 
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: refjeff on October 17, 2022, 05:52:01 PM
What did I miss?  They didn't allow the score and ended the game.
I can't understand the last part of the referee's explanation, but the kids in white seem very happy about losing the game.
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: Bubba Ump on October 17, 2022, 06:22:46 PM
There is no expanded neutral zone.  The ball must be "in or behind" 6:2:3  I would agree that it can be clarified much better.  H needs to hold the LOS and everything past the LOS which the ball clearly is should be bagged and blown dead once it's possessed.  Tuff call but a good reminder to have a bean bag in hand on all scrimmage kicks.  Deeps need to bust BUTT to the Goal line.  U and R should give the "ball tipped" signal.  We can all learn from this and remind us ourselves that every play something crazy can happen. 
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: Covid 22 on October 17, 2022, 08:40:00 PM
All you have to do is look at the two coaches.  The one with the white jacket is despondent after the explanation.  The coach with the black jacket jumps with joy. 
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: ncwingman on October 17, 2022, 08:50:41 PM
All you have to do is look at the two coaches.  The one with the white jacket is despondent after the explanation.  The coach with the black jacket jumps with joy.

Are you being serious here? I can't tell if you're taking the joke a little too far or not. Central Catholic, the away team wearing white, won the game having scored the touchdown (https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/high-school-football/2022/10/16/central-catholic-wild-finish-wpial-football-penn-hills-anthony-shovlin-blocked-field-goal/stories/202210160150)
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: Lhaskins on October 17, 2022, 09:15:22 PM
Yes Many issues that we can learn from !!  It looks like the ball is at the 32 yardline. - U - Signals -- NO GOOD !!! not sure if he is putting air in his Whistle. The R does nothing.   The L - works his way down the field and now has to look back at the ball.  It looks like the the K player picks up the ball at the 31. I personal think that when K picked up the ball it should have been blown dead. TUFF ONE for Sure!!!!!
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: NVFOA_Ump on October 18, 2022, 06:20:57 AM
Here's the "official" result:  https://www.cbssports.com/general/news/watch-pennsylvania-hs-football-game-ends-wildly-as-team-advances-own-blocked-field-goal-for-game-winning-td/

Although the result is not really the point here. As has been noted no one stays at the LOS (the 32) to rule on the location of the ball in relation to the NZ. Also, no one bags the point of first touching or recovery, two of the most critical mechanics items on a scrimmage kick.  Also, it's obvious that we need to get into the rule book more since in relation to the position of a loose ball from a scrimmage kick the NZ is not "expanded".  If the L had stayed at the line a bit longer and bagged the spot where A picked up the ball this would have looked much better.
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: ElvisLives on October 18, 2022, 10:07:17 AM
If the L had stayed at the line a bit longer and bagged the spot where A picked up the ball this would have looked much better.

I ask this question because I believe there may be a common thread here between NCAA and NFHS rules on this issue. I believe the consensus is that, for NFHS, the ball crossed the actual neutral zone, and was possessed by a kicking team player, which makes the ball dead. If that is correct, then what is the point of dropping a spot marker (bean bag) at that spot? Spot markers are used to mark certain spots on the field, when the ball will remain alive after some event has occurred (such as a fumble, illegal touching, end of a scrimmage kick, or where possession is gained with a potential 'momentum' ruling). If the ball becomes dead at the moment of possession, then the covering official should simply signal for the clock to stop and mark the dead-ball spot with his foot, as we do for every dead-ball between the goal lines. What does dropping a spot marker at a dead-ball spot accomplish?
OK, if the covering official is uncertain if the ball should be declared dead, and he wants to allow play to continue, sure, drop a bean bag at the spot where possession was gained, and continue to officiate. Then, you can come back to that spot, if needed (although we all need to be better than that). 

My point is that, since we first got bean bags in the late 70's, 1) many Bs (in particular) still hold them in their hands on punts, and 2) bean bags get dropped at dead-ball spots frequently, both nonsensically. When we first got bean bags, NCAA officials were so afraid of NOT getting the bag down on the end of a kick, in particular, they decided to hold them in their hands on punts. That was understandable, since most officials at that level had been officiating for many years, and those guys were not at all accustomed to getting a bean bag down for ANYTHING, and certainly didn't want their jobs jeopardized because they forgot to mark the end of a kick. But, let's see....2022 minus 1978 (or so) = 44 years. Ain't many folks around that officiated football during the days before bean bags - certainly not at the NCAA level. Everybody working today - NCAA and NFHS - have had plenty of experience with bean bags. Just like your foul marker (flag), it is a tool to be used at the proper moment. Anybody holding their flag in their hand when a down starts? Anybody? Anybody? Bueller...?
What is still happening when an official carries his bean bag in his hand - NCAA and NFHS - is that, when some other event happens, for a which a bean bag is totally inappropriate, the official 'reacts' and drops/tosses his bean bag for that other event, and then he doesn't have his primary bean bag available when he does need it.
Example 1: Kicking team player commits KCI on a punt receiver. The B (with bean bag already in hand) reacts and throws his bean bag at the spot. He realizes he needs to get his flag down, so he begins grabbing for his flag, gets it out, and throws it at the spot, too. Meanwhile, the ball is bouncing around, gets touched by a kicking team player, and then recovered by a receiving team player, who begins to advance. No bean bag for either the illegal touch or the end of the kick.
Example 2: Punt receiver signals for a fair catch and makes the catch, no issues. B sounds his whistle, signals for the clock to stop, and moves to the dead-ball spot (progress being marked by a sideline official) and drops his bean bag. Why? What good does the bean bag do at that point? What's that you say? It indicates illegal touching? S16 does a much better job of that.

I see both happen frequently, every year.

Put your tools on your belt, know when and how to use your tools, and use the appropriate tool when you need it.
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: HLinNC on October 18, 2022, 10:25:21 AM
Quote
sure, drop a bean bag at the spot where possession was gained, and continue to officiate. Then, you can come back to that spot, if needed (although we all need to be better than that).

I imagine that is exactly why the bean bag was dropped in this instance; as a reaction to the thought that this will be a reference point for whichever way this got screwed up so maybe "we" can go back and try to fix it.

In reality there should have been no beanbag and H should have killed it as soon as K picked it up.  Unfortunately, when things go to $#!+, it takes an official a moment to shake out the right result.  I would submit that only a rare few HS officials react 100% correctly in that kind of moment.  I am willing to put myself in that category of not being in that group.

We all talk about how "if its gonna go bad, it will happen on a kick".  You can keep that fact in the back of your mind but it still doesn't stop it from occurring.

There but by grace go we all.
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: AlUpstateNY on October 18, 2022, 10:34:03 AM
I

Put your tools on your belt, know when and how to use your tools, and use the appropriate tool when you need it.

Not only an important tool, but a bean bag can STOP needless arguments (ie, offensive player steps OOB, then returns and participates in play) the bean bag, where he stepped out is evidence the flag, where/if he participated, is valid.  If "O" doesn't participate, no flag-no harm, pick up the bag (afterwards) and play on.  Also marks the spot if the runner steps OOB and play continues down field (despite your TO signal) should you need to follow.
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: HLinNC on October 18, 2022, 01:38:14 PM
 Brian Sakowski has this play and the sequence of plays leading up to it on his PA weekly training tape on YT.  It begins at the 10:00 mark.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U32WlLZSXrA
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: NVFOA_Ump on October 18, 2022, 02:13:55 PM
While I agree that in this play, loose kick beyond the NZ, it's a dead ball when recovered by K but look at the video carefully.  It's on the HL side and the box is BEHIND him.  The bag would simply and importantly mark the spot so that if the HL is "not sure" he can let the play go and recheck later.  Also, if the K player doesn't come up with the ball cleanly and muffs it around R can pick it up and potentially advance the ball or come back and accept the spot of first touching.  IMHO there should be a bag down on virtually all scrimmage kick plays because you really can't fix it later without one.  I see no down side to having the bag at the spot but there's a big one not having it.
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: ElvisLives on October 18, 2022, 03:34:49 PM
While I agree that in this play, loose kick beyond the NZ, it's a dead ball when recovered by K but look at the video carefully.  It's on the HL side and the box is BEHIND him.  The bag would simply and importantly mark the spot so that if the HL is "not sure" he can let the play go and recheck later.  Also, if the K player doesn't come up with the ball cleanly and muffs it around R can pick it up and potentially advance the ball or come back and accept the spot of first touching.  IMHO there should be a bag down on virtually all scrimmage kick plays because you really can't fix it later without one.  I see no down side to having the bag at the spot but there's a big one not having it.

No, in, and of, itself, there is no 'down' side to dropping a bag if you let the play go, even though it should stop. But, there could easily be consequences if we allow a play to continue that should have stopped. Personal fouls, UNS fouls, injuries, etc.
The great Tim Millis taught us that we need to know what we are doing, stay focused, and put our talent and training to work. This would be a case where top level officiating would have the wing official on the NZ until the ball is possessed, to positively rule on the touching/possession, live-ball/dead-ball. There would be no need for a bean bag, because we wouldn't let the play continue, because we would know the ball is dead.
But we do what we must.
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: bama_stripes on October 18, 2022, 05:03:37 PM
Could the above post please be moved to the General Discussion board?
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: NVFOA_Ump on October 18, 2022, 05:17:53 PM
Could the above post please be moved to the General Discussion board?
IMHO it belongs here where we are discussing NFHS mechanics on a scrimmage kick play.
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: AlUpstateNY on October 19, 2022, 08:12:57 AM
While I agree that in this play, loose kick beyond the NZ, it's a dead ball when recovered by K but look at the video carefully.  It's on the HL side and the box is BEHIND him.  The bag would simply and importantly mark the spot so that if the HL is "not sure" he can let the play go and recheck later.  Also, if the K player doesn't come up with the ball cleanly and muffs it around R can pick it up and potentially advance the ball or come back and accept the spot of first touching.  IMHO there should be a bag down on virtually all scrimmage kick plays because you really can't fix it later without one.  I see no down side to having the bag at the spot but there's a big one not having it.

ABSOLUTELY AGREE. "An ounce of prevention, is worth (often WAY more) than a pound of cure". The only harm, that results from picking up a bean bag that was subsequently proven to be "not needed" is a little wasted effort retrieving it, where as not marking a spot that is proven to be needed, can be a DISASTER.
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: TxBJ on October 19, 2022, 08:50:00 AM
While I agree that in this play, loose kick beyond the NZ, it's a dead ball when recovered by K but look at the video carefully.  It's on the HL side and the box is BEHIND him.  The bag would simply and importantly mark the spot so that if the HL is "not sure" he can let the play go and recheck later.  Also, if the K player doesn't come up with the ball cleanly and muffs it around R can pick it up and potentially advance the ball or come back and accept the spot of first touching.  IMHO there should be a bag down on virtually all scrimmage kick plays because you really can't fix it later without one.  I see no down side to having the bag at the spot but there's a big one not having it.

Yes, the box was behind him, but he never should have left the LOS.  Then he would know the ball was beyond and would not have allowed the advance after the recovery.  (I'm making the assumption that that is the NFHS mechanic, for H to stay on the LOS until the ball crosses.)
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: NVFOA_Ump on October 19, 2022, 12:11:21 PM
Yes, the box was behind him, but he never should have left the LOS.  Then he would know the ball was beyond and would not have allowed the advance after the recovery.  (I'm making the assumption that that is the NFHS mechanic, for H to stay on the LOS until the ball crosses.)

Actually, most R's prefer the line judge to "stay" on scrimmage kick plays, so they are looking directly across at the b for the ball crossing. In any case IMHO there is no downside to dorpping a bag when a scrimmage kick is is touched and/or possessed by K.  That can help resolve the question here.
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: refjeff on October 19, 2022, 12:29:50 PM
To me it looks like the ball was past the down box by inches.  Is the HL going to be able to drop his bean bag at the exact spot of the back point of the ball?  Because that is where it is going to have to be to be any help.
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: ElvisLives on October 19, 2022, 12:48:19 PM
To me it looks like the ball was past the down box by inches.  Is the HL going to be able to drop his bean bag at the exact spot of the back point of the ball?  Because that is where it is going to have to be to be any help.

Different philosophies and approaches, I suppose.
After throwing his flag for a DPI, a fellow official questioned Tim Millis if the pass was catchable. Millis' response was something like, "If it wasn't catchable, I wouldn't have thrown my flag." Same thing here. Use your training. Be in the right spot. See what you need to see. Know the rules, and confidently make the appropriate and right ruling.
I try to do things the Tim Millis way. Hasn't led me astray, yet. Give it a try.
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: refjeff on October 19, 2022, 04:30:44 PM
Different philosophies and approaches, I suppose.
After throwing his flag for a DPI, a fellow official questioned Tim Millis if the pass was catchable. Millis' response was something like, "If it wasn't catchable, I wouldn't have thrown my flag." Same thing here. Use your training. Be in the right spot. See what you need to see. Know the rules, and confidently make the appropriate and right ruling.
I try to do things the Tim Millis way. Hasn't led me astray, yet. Give it a try.
I still don't believe that a beanbag in the general location of the ball would have helped on this particular play.
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: CalhounLJ on October 19, 2022, 05:08:48 PM
I still don't believe that a beanbag in the general location of the ball would have helped on this particular play.
Me either. The wing staying put would have solved the issue.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: AlUpstateNY on October 19, 2022, 09:31:31 PM
Me either. The wing staying put would have solved the issue.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

The bean bag would have confirmed that the ball had been considered "first touched" (beyond the NZ), ending the play giving the team defending the kick possession at the spot.  If time was determined to have remained at that point, it would be R's ball, at the spot of "First touching", 1st & 10, clock starting on the subsequent snap .
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: refjeff on October 19, 2022, 09:49:02 PM
The bean bag would have confirmed that the ball had been considered "first touched" (beyond the NZ), ending the play giving the team defending the kick possession at the spot.  If time was determined to have remained at that point, it would be R's ball, at the spot of "First touching", 1st & 10, clock starting on the subsequent snap .
If the play is ended he should blow his whistle.
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: AlUpstateNY on October 20, 2022, 07:35:16 AM
If the play is ended he should blow his whistle.

CORRECTION, The presence of the bean bag COULD HAVE could have been extremely helpful in determining WHETHER the subsequent contact by K was, or was not established behind/beyond the NZ in determining whether the play HAD/HAD NOT ended when K touched the blocked kick.  Deploying the bean bag was a prudent action by the wing official to help determine that fact for consideration in the final evaluation of the review of the play.  As suggested, the whistle is a conclusion.
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: bama_stripes on October 20, 2022, 07:52:08 AM
Brian Sakowski has this play and the sequence of plays leading up to it on his PA weekly training tape on YT.  It begins at the 10:00 mark.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U32WlLZSXrA

Brian’s take is that the ball was still in/behind the NZ when recovered, thus the TD stands.  He also advocates for a live-ball Illegal Participation foul for R’s team coming onto the field while the ball is still live.
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: dammitbobby on October 20, 2022, 08:34:44 AM
Even though it seems like an obvious foul, I don't think it would be correct to have a foul for them coming onto the field, given that an official clearly gave a signal indicating that the play was over (the U signaling that the try scrimmage kick was no good.)
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: NVFOA_Ump on October 20, 2022, 12:30:18 PM
Even though it seems like an obvious foul, I don't think it would be correct to have a foul for them coming onto the field, given that an official clearly gave a signal indicating that the play was over (the U signaling that the try was no good.)
This was not a try but a field goal attempt (a scrimmage kick). IMHO a not good signal does not kill the play on a field goal attempt.
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: dammitbobby on October 20, 2022, 12:55:03 PM
While technically you wouldn't be wrong, how would you explain that to a coach who sent his offense immediately on the field after seeing that the U signaled the kick no good, to try to throw a hail Mary pass to win the game?  I just can't see penalizing a team for a mistake the officials made, and it was the basis of action by that team.
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: AlUpstateNY on October 20, 2022, 04:12:37 PM
While technically you wouldn't be wrong, how would you explain that to a coach who sent his offense immediately on the field after seeing that the U signaled the kick no good, to try to throw a hail Mary pass to win the game?  I just can't see penalizing a team for a mistake the officials made, and it was the basis of action by that team.

Like Game Officials, School Coaches are EXPECTED to add mature composure to volatile/emotional situations involving Interscholastic athletic events. Especially in situations that may create unexpected and/or highly emotional instantaneous reactions, Coaches reactions are critical to the maintenance of composure among their charges and opponents.  There is never a valid excuse for any Coach to act irrationally or direct, allow, condone those under his supervision, to act irrationally.

Unfortunately, such circumstances can challenge situations, for both Game Officials and/or Coaches, but BOTH are REQUIRED to maintain composure , as necessary,  to prevent ANY situation from escalating to a point of "Loss of control".
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: refjeff on October 20, 2022, 06:20:58 PM
While technically you wouldn't be wrong, how would you explain that to a coach who sent his offense immediately on the field after seeing that the U signaled the kick no good, to try to throw a hail Mary pass to win the game?  I just can't see penalizing a team for a mistake the officials made, and it was the basis of action by that team.
NO ONE in the stadium was watching the umpire.
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: Curious on October 21, 2022, 02:24:46 PM
Before we even start to talk about this, we should remember: this all happened on 2nd down with about a yard and a half to go! 

It was close, but I see the ball was beyond the Neutral Zone when it was picked up by K after rolling between the LOS and the line to gain; so K could not advance it - and the play should have been blown dead when he possessed it. The K player simply advanced a dead ball.

SO, ASSUMMING TIME COULD STILL BE ON THE CLOCK, WHOSE BALL IS IT (OR SHOULD IT BE)? K's ball 4th down and a half yard to go; or R's ball at the dead ball spot???????

Rules 5-1-3g and 5-1-4 speak to this issue: 5-1-3g says: The ball belongs to R at the spot of first touching by K if K is first to touch the kicked ball beyond the Expanded Neutral Zone before it is touched beyond this zone by R and before it has come to rest". 

Rule 5-1-4 says: "Unless touched by R beyond the Neutral Zone, if the kickers recover the scrimmage kick in or behind the neutral zone, the ball remains live and the down counts". In this play, K appears NOT to have recovered the kick in or behind the NZ and R never touched the ball, so K's possession of the kick should have ended the play.

So, since all this happened on 2nd down, and the officials recognized what happened, is it now 3rd down for K/A at the recovery spot; or is the series concluded? Also, since we don't know how much time, if any, still remained on the clock.  The announcers suggested this would be the last play. 

Reddings clarifies this by asking: "...Is the scrimmage kick beyond the Neutral Zone when it is touched? If "yes", which is the case here:
>there is no longer a line to gain (the continuity of downs is broken). Therefore,
>>If untouched by R after the kick crossed the expanded neutral zone (which was not the case) and the ball is declared dead (which it wasn't - is it      R's ball at the dead ball spot or at the spot of first touching by K (which IS where K picked it up and is short of the line to gain)
>>if R is first to touch the kick (which they didin't), team K may catch or recover the kick (but not advance) and retain possession

>The expanded neutral zone extends two yards beyond the defensive LOS in the field of play (where it was when K picked it up) and disintegrates when the kick has crossed the expanded neutral zone; so...

If, as (incorrectly) ruled, the ball was still live after the K player picked it up, all the R players (technically substitutes) being on the field during a live ball would be guilty of Illegal Substitution - as it could be argued that they really never participated in the play. Since Illegal substitution (no participation) is, by rule, a succeeding spot foul (where the K player possessed it), the play would not have resulted in a new series for K; and, since R was ahead as time expired, the game should have been declared over.

It is also not insignificant that the entire Team K bench was out of the team box, but not on the field, nor did they participate, during a live ball. However, Rule 9-8-1k says being out of the Team Box during a live ball is a WARNING for the first offense; therefore no penalty is enforced.

One way or the other, BOTH teams had too many players on the field (Red) or out of the team box (White).  I think all that should "offset"!
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: CalhounLJ on October 21, 2022, 04:49:28 PM
I didn’t even attempt to read all that, but it would be R’s ball where K picked it up. Any flags thrown for players/coaches on the field would be dead ball UNS so no replay. If time is gone, game over. If there’s still time on the clock, deal with the dead ball fouls and play.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: KDJBBBJ on October 21, 2022, 05:50:20 PM
But by definition first touching occurs after the ball has crossed the expanded neutral zone.  Both 2-12-2 and 6-2-5 tell us this.  But 6-2-3 says "while it is in or behind the neutral zone" k may catch or recover and advance. Nothing about expanded  Does this mean the expanded neutral zone is no mans land? K can touch or recover the ball but not advance, but it is not first touching? 
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: ncwingman on October 24, 2022, 11:53:27 AM
Before we even start to talk about this, we should remember: this all happened on 2nd down with about a yard and a half to go! 

It was close, but I see the ball was beyond the Neutral Zone when it was picked up by K after rolling between the LOS and the line to gain; so K could not advance it - and the play should have been blown dead when he possessed it. The K player simply advanced a dead ball.

SO, ASSUMMING TIME COULD STILL BE ON THE CLOCK, WHOSE BALL IS IT (OR SHOULD IT BE)? K's ball 4th down and a half yard to go; or R's ball at the dead ball spot???????

Forgive me for snipping a lot of that text -- but assuming there was time remaining, R is awarded the ball at the spot of first touching, 1st and 10. The fact that K attempted the kick on 2nd down and not 4th has no bearing.

If K had recovered behind the LOS and not made the line to gain, it would be 3rd down for K.

For ultra fun fun goodie pot stirring time, did K still have at least 4 players numbered 50-79 on the line of scrimmage during that play? I actually think they do (#50, #52, #54 and #56 with long snapper #31 in under the exception). However, who just realized they should have thought of that because it was 2nd down?

Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: animalspooker on November 21, 2022, 02:51:20 PM
ncwingman?  If they kicked a FG to win with no time on the clock and you flagged them for illegal formation (not 4 good numbers), because it was 2nd down....well lets just say your posting days on REFSTIPES would be over!
Title: Re: So many things wrong here
Post by: PABJNR on November 21, 2022, 03:38:48 PM
Not over as quick than if the team who lost complained to a commissioner that he lost a game because his opponent was in an illegal formation on the game winning scoring play.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk