RefStripes.com

Football Officiating => National Federation Discussion => Topic started by: jfoote on October 22, 2022, 08:22:56 PM

Title: Double Foul and Multiple Change of Possession
Post by: jfoote on October 22, 2022, 08:22:56 PM
Thinking about the situation below. Our R says the penalties have to offset. Since B isn't the next team to put the ball in play they can't decline the holding by A. But I can't find anything in the book that states that.

Thinking through this situation, if both teams decline the penalty A would start 1st and 10 at their own 15. Instead of replaying 1st and goal. With is beneficial for B if they decline.

B declines the hold so the interception stands, A then is going to decline the block in the back so they retain possession via B's fumble.

Situation:
1 and goal from B's 10

A10 drops back to pass and prior to the pass A77 if flagged for holding. Pass is thrown and intercepted by B8 in the endzone. B8 runs the ball out and during the return B16 is flagged for a block in the back.

B8 fumbles the ball at the A 20-yard line and A recovers the ball at the A 15-yard line.
Title: Re: Double Foul and Multiple Change of Possession
Post by: GA Umpire on October 22, 2022, 08:54:50 PM
Thinking about the situation below. Our R says the penalties have to offset. Since B isn't the next team to put the ball in play they can't decline the holding by A. But I can't find anything in the book that states that.

Thinking through this situation, if both teams decline the penalty A would start 1st and 10 at their own 15. Instead of replaying 1st and goal. With is beneficial for B if they decline.

B declines the hold so the interception stands, A then is going to decline the block in the back so they retain possession via B's fumble.

Situation:
1 and goal from B's 10

A10 drops back to pass and prior to the pass A77 if flagged for holding. Pass is thrown and intercepted by B8 in the endzone. B8 runs the ball out and during the return B16 is flagged for a block in the back.

B8 fumbles the ball at the A 20-yard line and A recovers the ball at the A 15-yard line.

jfoote:
See 10-2-1b, 2.
The penalties cancel and the down is replayed
Title: Re: Double Foul and Multiple Change of Possession
Post by: jfoote on October 22, 2022, 09:12:12 PM
I did find that and it most cases it makes sense. But I guess my question is, does it HAVE to be replayed?

Doesn't 10-2-2 make is sound like the offset doesn't have to happen?
Title: Re: Double Foul and Multiple Change of Possession
Post by: GA Umpire on October 22, 2022, 11:39:22 PM
I did find that and it most cases it makes sense. But I guess my question is, does it HAVE to be replayed?

Doesn't 10-2-2 make is sound like the offset doesn't have to happen?
You are overlooking the provision in 10-2-2a.
"The foul by the team last gaining possession is not prior to the final change of possession."

According to the play as stated, Team A fouled before gaining final possession, the hold on A77.
Title: Re: Double Foul and Multiple Change of Possession
Post by: jfoote on October 22, 2022, 11:46:54 PM
I completely agree that right thing to happen is the down will be replayed - I just don't think it is automatic in NFHS.

I mean it is basically automatic, but A would have the option to decline B's foul if they wanted to - and then B would have an option.

10-1 does show that any penalty can be declined.

It isn't a double foul until A accepts B's foul on the play... which they will do because if they don't accept it'll be negative outcomes for them. So they'll accept and we replay the down.

Since A is last team in possession they get first choice to accept/decline.
Title: Re: Double Foul and Multiple Change of Possession
Post by: CalhounLJ on October 23, 2022, 06:56:00 AM
Thinking about the situation below. Our R says the penalties have to offset. Since B isn't the next team to put the ball in play they can't decline the holding by A. But I can't find anything in the book that states that.

Thinking through this situation, if both teams decline the penalty A would start 1st and 10 at their own 15. Instead of replaying 1st and goal. With is beneficial for B if they decline.

B declines the hold so the interception stands, A then is going to decline the block in the back so they retain possession via B's fumble.

Situation:
1 and goal from B's 10

A10 drops back to pass and prior to the pass A77 if flagged for holding. Pass is thrown and intercepted by B8 in the endzone. B8 runs the ball out and during the return B16 is flagged for a block in the back.

B8 fumbles the ball at the A 20-yard line and A recovers the ball at the A 15-yard line.

Because the team in FINAL possession fouled before gaining FINAL possession, there is no option, the down must be replayed.
10.2.1 Situation B in the case book. I emphasized "final possession," because it's important.

As to the ability to decline the foul, it's true a team can always decline a foul. But, as this situation clearly shows, there are rare times when a team cannot always accept a penalty. In fact, these penalties automatically cancel and nobody gets to accept either one...
Title: Re: Double Foul and Multiple Change of Possession
Post by: bama_stripes on October 23, 2022, 07:01:15 AM
“The penalties cancel and the down is replayed.”
Black letter law — no options for either team.
Title: Re: Double Foul and Multiple Change of Possession
Post by: jfoote on October 23, 2022, 01:50:27 PM
Thanks everyone for the feedback
Title: Re: Double Foul and Multiple Change of Possession
Post by: bossman72 on October 23, 2022, 05:55:17 PM
Thinking about the situation below. Our R says the penalties have to offset. Since B isn't the next team to put the ball in play they can't decline the holding by A. But I can't find anything in the book that states that.

Thinking through this situation, if both teams decline the penalty A would start 1st and 10 at their own 15. Instead of replaying 1st and goal. With is beneficial for B if they decline.

B declines the hold so the interception stands, A then is going to decline the block in the back so they retain possession via B's fumble.

Situation:
1 and goal from B's 10

A10 drops back to pass and prior to the pass A77 if flagged for holding. Pass is thrown and intercepted by B8 in the endzone. B8 runs the ball out and during the return B16 is flagged for a block in the back.

B8 fumbles the ball at the A 20-yard line and A recovers the ball at the A 15-yard line.


This is an automatic offset, no options.

The logic I uses helps when there is a change of team possession.  This is kind of a flow chart without the chart.  I should make one.

1) Did the team that ended up with the ball get the ball with clean hands?
No.  Team A committed holding prior to gaining possession.
2) Did the other team foul too?
Yes.
Then automatic offset.
Title: Re: Double Foul and Multiple Change of Possession
Post by: dammitbobby on October 23, 2022, 08:16:32 PM
Yes make a flowchart, and make one for NCAA rules too.  :)

Title: Re: Double Foul and Multiple Change of Possession
Post by: bossman72 on October 23, 2022, 10:34:33 PM
Yes make a flowchart, and make one for NCAA rules too.  :)

I'll try to make one with characters/indentations.  Tried to make this as simple as possible.  It's the same for both rule sets.

Did the team in possession at the end of the down get the ball with clean hands?
Title: Re: Double Foul and Multiple Change of Possession
Post by: Ralph Damren on October 24, 2022, 05:51:42 AM
Once upon a time.......

A =illegal formation (6 man line-back then)

B= roughing the passer, pass complete 30 yard gain
B=15 yd PFFM

RESULTS = offsetting fouls
Title: Re: Double Foul and Multiple Change of Possession
Post by: ncwingman on October 24, 2022, 11:40:31 AM
Once upon a time.......

A =illegal formation (6 man line-back then)

B= roughing the passer, pass complete 30 yard gain
B=15 yd PFFM

RESULTS = offsetting fouls

You say "once upon a time" as if that's no longer the case... made me really question myself there for a moment.
Title: Re: Double Foul and Multiple Change of Possession
Post by: SCHSref on October 24, 2022, 12:19:31 PM
And we are going on the ready
Title: Re: Double Foul and Multiple Change of Possession
Post by: Ralph Damren on October 25, 2022, 06:07:33 AM
You say "once upon a time" as if that's no longer the case... made me really question myself there for a moment.
Its no longer a foul to have a six -man line, just can't have a 5-man backfield.
Title: Re: Double Foul and Multiple Change of Possession
Post by: dammitbobby on October 27, 2022, 07:45:17 AM
I'll try to make one with characters/indentations.  Tried to make this as simple as possible.  It's the same for both rule sets.

Did the team in possession at the end of the down get the ball with clean hands?
  • Yes
          
    • Did the other team foul too?
                  
      • Yes
                          
        • Decline the other team's fouls and enforce fouls against the team in possession and they get to keep the ball.
                               
                       
      • No
                          
        • Enforce the foul against the team in possession and they get to keep the ball.
                               
                       
               
       
  • No
          
    • Did the other team foul too?
                  
      • Yes
                          
        • Automatic Offset.  Replay the down.
                               
                       
      • No
                          
        • Enforce the foul against the team in possession (or decline it if they wish).  They get to keep the ball.
                               
                       
               
       

Thank you, this is very helpful as a study tool/explanation.
Title: Re: Double Foul and Multiple Change of Possession
Post by: ncwingman on October 27, 2022, 08:26:43 PM
Its no longer a foul to have a six -man line, just can't have a 5-man backfield.

Ah, okay. I was wondering if they somehow didn't offset, but two or more live ball fouls, at least one by each team...
Title: Re: Double Foul and Multiple Change of Possession
Post by: bossman72 on October 27, 2022, 10:48:47 PM
Thank you, this is very helpful as a study tool/explanation.

Made a slight correction.  Last sentence should be "Team A keeps the ball" instead of "They get to keep the ball".