RefStripes.com
Football Officiating => National Federation Discussion => Topic started by: BIG UMP on November 23, 2022, 12:25:43 PM
-
https://www.nfhs.org/sports-resource-content/nfhs-sport-questionnaires/
-
A CHANCE TO HEAR / SEE YOUR VOICE / REPLY HEARD. .....
....,....WE DO LISTEN tiphat:
-
I took the survey. It would be interesting to see what actually happens as a result.
-
For the first time, I voted YES to all of them.
I've also bet my crew none will pass.
-
Getting closer to NCAA rules every year... pi1eOn
-
I think #2 (towels) and #4 (IG exception) have the best chance of passing.
-
I think #2 (towels) and #4 (IG exception) have the best chance of passing.
I agree, BTW, although I really think the clock starting on OOB on plays outside of 2 minutes is the one thing needed most. The length of games have increased dramatically in the last few years, with two of our 7PM games ending after 9:45PM. And maintaining pace of game is something we do as best as we can.
Outside that, I really think the first one (using the previous spot as the enforcement spot on most A fouls behind the line of scrimmage) would be a massive improvement. A single holding foul shouldn't be a drive killer, but it's almost impossible to come back from 1st and 28.
AFD on personal fouls? On DPI? I've never bought the whole "that affects the balance between offense and defense" thing. It's applied equitably for both teams - when both teams are on defense.
Honestly, I see nothing wrong with aligning more to some of the more "common sense" aspects of NCAA rules that don't compromise player safety or the educational aspect of NFHS games. There's already a ton of confusion between Friday/Saturday/Sunday rules and where we can eliminate that, the better for us as officials. The change with intentional grounding this year was amazing - all coaches we interacted with understood the Saturday rule and we had no arguments on any of our ING calls or no calls all season. With O2O, we were able to piece together the different aspects of the rule and communicate quickly. It was a great change, not just for player safety, but for administration of the game.
-
I think #2 (towels) and #4 (IG exception) have the best chance of passing.
I'd agree with this. I'm not sure when the last time anybody in my area actually enforced the towel rule if they were just plain colored towels. Somebody has a pink one in october, but not the whole team... that's not getting addressed at all. Although, the new hotness is using actual gatorade towels, usually cut down to be the correct size. They look terrible, being very ragged, and not legal since it's covered in a logo that's not the manufacturer. In any case, it's not gaining an advantage, a safety issue, being disrespectful or drawing attention to themselves.
The IG rule will address the chicken little scenario about "What happens when the RB throws the ball???" ... out of curiosity, how many times did that happen this year? I saw it a grand total of zero -- not even once where the RB thought about it, but didn't.
The AFD and timing on out of bounds plays are a solid maybe. I could make arguments for and against, but will leave that for everybody else to do. I think there's likely to be enough people hard against it to prevent it from passing, but maybe I'd be surprised. I'm not taking a stand on whether I agree with it -- just estimating what might happen from those who have a vote.
-
Based on the vote when AFD was removed from *both* DPI and OPI, I cant believe a change that only benefits the offense will pass. I’m certainly willing to be surprised, though.
-
I
Outside that, I really think the first one (using the previous spot as the enforcement spot on most A fouls behind the line of scrimmage) would be a massive improvement. A single holding foul shouldn't be a drive killer, but it's almost impossible to come back from 1st and 28.
Honestly, I see nothing wrong with aligning more to some of the more "common sense" aspects of NCAA rules that don't compromise player safety or the educational aspect of NFHS games. There's already a ton of confusion between Friday/Saturday/Sunday rules and where we can eliminate that, the better for us as officials.
Beg to disagree, eliminating "spot fouls" from behind the LOS enforcement will only ENCOURAGE more fouls, when the defense (legally) forces the offense to retreat. When the offense retreats, there's NO INCENTIVE for the offense NOT to foul, and negate the effort /advantage the defense has produced forcing the offense to retreat.
NFHS "adjustments" to rules are usually (hopefully) accommodations created to address the obvious differences in player/coach maturity, safety and logistics (TV required advertising breaks, crowd size, playing facilities, crowd control & behavior capabilities & rule complexity. "What's fine for the goose, doesn't ALWAYS apply as well for the gander."
-
My supervisor and I were talking about the length of the games. He is submitting a suggestion that we go back to rules from the early 80s and before where the clock starts on the RFP for changes of possession.
I don't think we'll get there but starting on OOB plays seems logical to cut down on time. AND, probably not much difference in time between the 2.
-
I-1. Never wanted the team box extended to begin with. Even in the post-Covid season the player still gaggle around the coaches or the 50 yl.
2. Changing the ball has been done forever- fine with actually codifying it.
3. Legal #0- meh. (Which brings me to a point- Friday night I did my first basketball broadcast of the season. The visiting team had a
#0 and a #00. Is that legal?)
4. Chop block redefined-ok.
5. Game clock options-ok.
6. Play clock exception- I do not see a need to have a :40 PC for A if the GC isn't running. I understand it if we're running. See this
coming season's proposal concerning length of games to point out the semi-hypocrisy in this.
7. Legal IG-wasn't a fan of the change but it turned out ok.
II- 1. Flashing LED's: we only have two schools we serve that presently do it and I've only worked one game at one of the schools that
did it but I sense some safety/security issues will arise out of it eventually if they don't get a grip on it.
2. Coaches are doing absolutely nothing about illegal/improper equipment. They weren't doing much before hand. The facepaint,
cards on the belt, and bicep bands were the worst I've seen in a while. Towel tails seemed to be a thing when we got to the
playoffs. I sent two kids off in the second round of the playoffs for nott having their mouthpiece in. Either put some teeth back in
the rule or get rid of it and let them do whatever the hell they want.
3. Substitution advantage-nothing out of the ordinary that I've seen here.
4. Unintentional contact- not a real problem that I've noted although I've moved off of the wing to R, primarily.
5. The rules are too complicated for coaches because they want to earn their knowledge by watching t.v. so have the NFHS put
together a weekly show they can watch. The rules are tough for newer officials and those officials who last cracked a rulebook
sometime in the 90's.
III 1. Leave it alone or just go to NCAA and get it over with.
2. Towels- for the love of all that is holy, yes! (Exception- penalty flag or ball colored) Include team names and/or logos as legal.
Who cares if they are pink, or white, or black, or camo?
3. Game clock- sure, but I think we can gain some time back on changes of possession without a kick and my radical plan to run
the clock post-TD through the end of the try too.
4. Limiting the IG exception- I never understood all the hubbub this pre-season with so many officials not figuring out that when the
NFHS said passer, that is what they meant. Its bad enough the coaches want us to call NCAA rules but apparently a few officials
can't separate it either. Leave it be.
5. PF's and USC's AFD- sure, why not. However, I'm also an advocate for reducing the fouls on TD scoring plays back to declining
the penalty in the event of a score, unless it is a PF. I just don't see the "free shots" occurring that the Fed seemed to think were
going to happen on scoring plays.
-
My supervisor and I were talking about the length of the games. He is submitting a suggestion that we go back to rules from the early 80s and before where the clock starts on the RFP for changes of possession.
I don't think we'll get there but starting on OOB plays seems logical to cut down on time. AND, probably not much difference in time between the 2.
I've been a white hat for 20 years now and I simply don't see a situation where we'd have all kinds of intentional (or even more likely) fouling just cause they think they'll get a few yards out of the deal. Matter of fact, my flag is s-l-o-w when a sack is imminent and while one of the reasons is "material effect on the play," but another is tacking 10 yards onto an already 8-yard loss. I recognize I run the risk of a B foul that would offset, but then I go back to the first reason - there's no material effect on the play, so I don't throw it.
I'm not sure it changes my philosophy on these fouls if the yardage changes, but I see nothing wrong with having a different enforcement on these fouls.
As HLinNC said, I would immediately eliminate all non-PF foul enforcements on scoring plays. I know our crew's philosophy is to try to avoid things like DPI when it doesn't affect a scoring play, but frankly, that should be declined, as should most fouls on scoring plays. Kid made a great play on a deep pass in one of our state finals and because there was marginal interference not only does A score, but A then gets to either run the PAT from the 1.5 or kick from the B 45. Neither of those outcomes make sense.
-
3. Legal #0- meh. (Which brings me to a point- Friday night I did my first basketball broadcast of the season. The visiting team had a
#0 and a #00. Is that legal?)
2. Coaches are doing absolutely nothing about illegal/improper equipment. They weren't doing much before hand. The facepaint,
cards on the belt, and bicep bands were the worst I've seen in a while. Towel tails seemed to be a thing when we got to the
playoffs. I sent two kids off in the second round of the playoffs for nott having their mouthpiece in. Either put some teeth back in
the rule or get rid of it and let them do whatever the hell they want.
Basketball: 0 or 00, not both.
Our crew worked a state championship last year and through the state quarterfinal round this year and we've had to deal with facepaint every single varsity game the last 2 years. I'm tired of it. Coaches and players think we're being overly pedantic and I don't know if this means nobody else is handling it OR if it means they just roll the dice every week.
Either way, I deal with it with the captains before the coin toss (cause one of them is *always* an offender) and then I find an assistant coach and let the coaches know that way after the toss.
Last year, we had a non-clear eyeshield in Week 9 - kid wore it the entire season. They claimed they had a doctor's note, which means nothing here. They managed to change it out. At the scrimmage this year, we happened to have that team and, guess what - the visor was back.
I'll handle this stuff, but I wish I didn't have to every single week.
-
Basketball: 0 or 00, not both.
Our crew worked a state championship last year and through the state quarterfinal round this year and we've had to deal with facepaint every single varsity game the last 2 years. I'm tired of it. Coaches and players think we're being overly pedantic and I don't know if this means nobody else is handling it OR if it means they just roll the dice every week.
Either way, I deal with it with the captains before the coin toss (cause one of them is *always* an offender) and then I find an assistant coach and let the coaches know that way after the toss.
Last year, we had a non-clear eyeshield in Week 9 - kid wore it the entire season. They claimed they had a doctor's note, which means nothing here. They managed to change it out. At the scrimmage this year, we happened to have that team and, guess what - the visor was back.
I'll handle this stuff, but I wish I didn't have to every single week.
I agree, it can be a pain in the "ear", but the solution is STILL a simple & consistent one about prohibited/creative equipment During the pregame, tell the player, "You can't play with that "stuff" on your face" (no knee pads, arm bands or other creative decorations), or if it happens during the game, and you see it, send him back to the bench. Too many Coaches are slow /lazy to understand, but once they experience the consequence, they pick it up pretty quick. Of course the ENTIRE Crew needs to agree to enforce it (each game).
Not sure about ALL States, but in NY you're entitled to a copy of "The Doctor's Authorization" - or it's NOT allowed. If the Coach (or parents) complain, simply suggest they make copies for each of their remaining games to avoid similar problems, in the future.
It's not exciting reading, but being VERY familiar with the details of NFHS: 1-5-3, 4 & 5 can avoid a lot of unnecessary conversations. It's also not a bad idea to add a brief caution about "equipment nonsense" during the brief pre-game conference with each Head Coach. It doesn't happen often, but being a "nice, cooperative" guy will not offset YOUR liability if someone gets hurt because of participating with illegal or improperly worn equipment.
-
Thank you guys for your responses. The results and sources (official/coach/ admin./state) are provided and give us a feel for favoribility. While I'm happy on last year's changes (Part I) and didn't have any of the problems listed (Part II), I do have an opinion on several on Part III:
* We became the 'towel police' first in size - some snappers were wearing beach towels and draping them over the ball prior to the snap- and then color seeped in. IMHO< size restrictions made sense while color does not.
* IG modifications seemed to work, BP > FP on flea-flicker should still allow the passer ability to ditch pass.
* While previous spot for fouls by A behind LOS gives an unneaded advatage to A and require a laundry list of exceptions (IG/ in own EZ/IK & IB) I would compromise IF it included fouls by B if run ended behind LOS, thus providing both QB sack behind LOS from previous spot (removing the inequity of a fumble or pass -loose ball plays - bringing back to LOS and a D-hold on the prime reciever, resulting in a QB sack) .
Plenty of time (Jan. 8-10) for :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: let the debates begin ???
-
* IG modifications seemed to work, BP > FP on flea-flicker should still allow the passer ability to ditch pass.
You made me go double check the NCAA rule on that one... if it was just restricted to the player that received the snap, then the QB-RB-QB exchange on a flea flicker would result in the QB being allowed to ditch the pass, but not for the RB. However, that's not the NCAA rule -- once the player that receives the snap relinquishes possession, nobody is allowed to ditch the ball legally. I think the NCAA rules makes the most sense, as you don't really want the offense to go all Harlem Globetrotters in the backfield (or Keystone Cops, as the case may be) but allow the pass to be ditched as long as the QB is the last person with the hot potato. I feel that would make a mockery of the rule. It shouldn't be allowed after three fumbles.
Granted, the way it is currently written allows for whoever to ditch the pass after three fumbles, so... maybe fix that too?
* While previous spot for fouls by A behind LOS gives an unneaded advatage to A and require a laundry list of exceptions (IG/ in own EZ/IK & IB) I would compromise IF it included fouls by B if run ended behind LOS, thus providing both QB sack behind LOS from previous spot (removing the inequity of a fumble or pass -loose ball plays - bringing back to LOS and a D-hold on the prime reciever, resulting in a QB sack) .
I had to read this three times, but I think you're saying you're okay with the basic spot being the previous spot for all runs that end behind the LOS -- and ABO doesn't apply to A fouls in that situation, except for IG, IK and IB?
I don't think the exception should just be IG in the end zone, as IG should just be a "spot foul" regardless of where it occurs. I'd also move that IG should *only* be loss of down at the spot of the foul, not an additional 5 yards.
-
2. Coaches are doing absolutely nothing about illegal/improper equipment. They weren't doing much before hand. The facepaint,
cards on the belt, and bicep bands were the worst I've seen in a while. Towel tails seemed to be a thing when we got to the
playoffs. I sent two kids off in the second round of the playoffs for nott having their mouthpiece in. Either put some teeth back in
the rule or get rid of it and let them do whatever the hell they want.
This...putting some teeth in it would be flagging the coach instead of sending them off if they don't have a mouthpiece. We asked them at pre-game if they are legally and properly equipped and they all say, "Yes".
What is the point of the rule, especially when you have officials stating "I don't care" or "I don't look for it once the game starts". Inconsistent administration is part of the problem.
-
You made me go double check the NCAA rule on that one... if it was just restricted to the player that received the snap, then the QB-RB-QB exchange on a flea flicker would result in the QB being allowed to ditch the pass, but not for the RB. However, that's not the NCAA rule -- once the player that receives the snap relinquishes possession, nobody is allowed to ditch the ball legally. I think the NCAA rules makes the most sense, as you don't really want the offense to go all Harlem Globetrotters in the backfield (or Keystone Cops, as the case may be) but allow the pass to be ditched as long as the QB is the last person with the hot potato. I feel that would make a mockery of the rule. It shouldn't be allowed after three fumbles.
Granted, the way it is currently written allows for whoever to ditch the pass after three fumbles, so... maybe fix that too?
I had to read this three times, but I think you're saying you're okay with the basic spot being the previous spot for all runs that end behind the LOS -- and ABO doesn't apply to A fouls in that situation, except for IG, IK and IB?
I don't think the exception should just be IG in the end zone, as IG should just be a "spot foul" regardless of where it occurs. I'd also move that IG should *only* be loss of down at the spot of the foul, not an additional 5 yards.
I was trying to say:
I'm happy the way the IG rule currently is.
Not happy, but accept previous spot for FOULS BY BOTH TEAMS when run ends behind LOS. Exceptions on A fouls IG, any play where foul occurrs in end zone (O-holding, etc.) IK and IB.
I'm trying to say :
The Patriots need to beat the Bills Thursday night to stay in the hunt.
GO PATS!!
-
Outside that, I really think the first one (using the previous spot as the enforcement spot on most A fouls behind the line of scrimmage) would be a massive improvement. A single holding foul shouldn't be a drive killer, but it's almost impossible to come back from 1st and 28.
In Ohio there is a growing trend to enforce offensive holding from, or near, the LOS to prevent the drive killing penalty. The justification is that the hold usually starts near the LOS when the blocker gets beat and the flag comes out later when the foul becomes obvious.
-
Beg to disagree, eliminating "spot fouls" from behind the LOS enforcement will only ENCOURAGE more fouls, when the defense (legally) forces the offense to retreat. When the offense retreats, there's NO INCENTIVE for the offense NOT to foul, and negate the effort /advantage the defense has produced forcing the offense to retreat.
Nonsense. 1. Most of them are offensive holding in pass protection when the technique is to kick back. They're not being "forced" back.
2. The 10 yard penalty is still a disincentive to foul.
3. When beat, no offensive lineman will ever stop to consider whether it is a spot foul or a previous spot foul before he reflexivley grabs the defender.
-
Nonsense. 1. Most of them are offensive holding in pass protection when the technique is to kick back. They're not being "forced" back.
2. The 10 yard penalty is still a disincentive to foul.
3. When beat, no offensive lineman will ever stop to consider whether it is a spot foul or a previous spot foul before he reflexivley grabs the defender.
Totally agree with both your assessments, however, the further behind the line the defense drives the play, the more critical the enforcement spot becomes and in depriving the defense of their accomplishment (in driving the action deeper) would clearly be an unfair advantage and provide additional incentive to the offense to avoid a more serious loss by fouling.
-
In my experience, 1st & 20 is just as much a “drive-killer” for HS teams as 1st & 28.
-
In my experience, 1st & 20 is just as much a “drive-killer” for HS teams as 1st & 28.
True, but that's on A for giving up the 8 yards. If they don't want 1st and 28, don't hold 8 yards deep.
-
There has been more than one occasion where the perception of what we're doing comes across poorly, even if we're doing things right -- mostly because we're not enforcing rules like the coaches/fans/players see on TV. Usually, we can explain to a coach the rule behind the call, but the one that's gotten the most pushback is when we seemingly mark off 12 yards on a 10 yard penalty.
Yes, the spot of the foul was 2 yards behind the LOS, but it just looks like we can't count to 10. We're doing it right, but it looks like we're doing it wrong - especially to every fan who can now clearly see that it's 1st and 22 after a 10 yard penalty.
I understand the arguments for and against it, but there's a couple things in this thread that really highlight the disparity of this. First, especially holding on the line can have a huge "window" for the spot of the foul. Ball snapped at the A20, first contact is made at the A19, the defender is grabbed at the A18, started to be pulled off balance at the A16 and hits the ground between the A15 and A13 (he's 6' tall, after all). Where's the "spot of the foul"? At our discretion, we can essentially add five yards to the penalty. Secondly, Al's point about it incentivizing fouling -- if you have a QB scrambling and a lineman realizes he can "help" by tackling the oncoming defender, he's not doing mental math to figure out how many yards the penalty will be. He's just hoping it won't get called at all.
-
There has been more than one occasion where the perception of what we're doing comes across poorly, even if we're doing things right -- mostly because we're not enforcing rules like the coaches/fans/players see on TV. Usually, we can explain to a coach the rule behind the call, but the one that's gotten the most pushback is when we seemingly mark off 12 yards on a 10 yard penalty.
Yes, the spot of the foul was 2 yards behind the LOS, but it just looks like we can't count to 10. We're doing it right, but it looks like we're doing it wrong - especially to every fan who can now clearly see that it's 1st and 22 after a 10 yard penalty.
I understand the arguments for and against it, but there's a couple things in this thread that really highlight the disparity of this. First, especially holding on the line can have a huge "window" for the spot of the foul. Ball snapped at the A20, first contact is made at the A19, the defender is grabbed at the A18, started to be pulled off balance at the A16 and hits the ground between the A15 and A13 (he's 6' tall, after all). Where's the "spot of the foul"? At our discretion, we can essentially add five yards to the penalty. Secondly, Al's point about it incentivizing fouling -- if you have a QB scrambling and a lineman realizes he can "help" by tackling the oncoming defender, he's not doing mental math to figure out how many yards the penalty will be. He's just hoping it won't get called at all.
It's really simple, with every RISK ventured, there's the potential for EITHER proscribed Benefit or Consequence to deal with.
-
If you are mic'd it's easy : "Holding- 10 yard penalty - enforced from the spot of the foul." Frenzed masses and coaches may think "...that ain't the way it was Sunday ??? " But then realize : " Ayuh, 'spect so".
IF you aren't mic'd, try YELLING (i believe I was a town cryer- the guy who yells 'TWO O'CLOCK &ALL IS WELL' in a previous life) : "HOLDING -10 YARD PENALTY --ENFORCED FROM THE SPOT OF THE FOUL". ^flag
-
If you are mic'd it's easy : "Holding- 10 yard penalty - enforced from the spot of the foul." Frenzed masses and coaches may think "...that ain't the way it was Sunday ??? " But then realize : " Ayuh, 'spect so".
IF you aren't mic'd, try YELLING (i believe I was a town cryer- the guy who yells 'TWO O'CLOCK &ALL IS WELL' in a previous life) : "HOLDING -10 YARD PENALTY --ENFORCED FROM THE SPOT OF THE FOUL". ^flag
Next point on the agenda: get high schools to pay for field microphones (or else have the association buy field mics to work with the school PA systems).
-
........ First, especially holding on the line can have a huge "window" for the spot of the foul. Ball snapped at the A20, first contact is made at the A19, the defender is grabbed at the A18, started to be pulled off balance at the A16 and hits the ground between the A15 and A13 (he's 6' tall, after all). Where's the "spot of the foul"? ....
The spot of the foul is the A18 - that's when the block morphed into a foul. How far further back a drags B has no bearing on the spot of the foul. This isn't rocket science and isn't intended to tag A with a "worst case scenario". If the hold starts at the A18 that's where my flag is. And IMHO I'd have no problem with all A fouls behind the LOS being spot fouls since the spot of the foul is where the illegal advantage actually began.
-
Next point on the agenda: get high schools to pay for field microphones (or else have the association buy field mics to work with the school PA systems).
Do you really think a detailed , verbal explanation of each penalty signal is actually necessary, and worth the expense of retrofitting thousands of HS football fields? Timely, well defined, properly executed signals (including the next down, or the LOD signal) have worked well and have been deemed acceptable for the VAST majority of Coaches, players, spectators for over 100 years. For those spectators needing additional detail, politely asking the nearest spectator, paying attention to the Referee's signal, seems a lot more cost effective means of providing such detail.
For televised games the expense for such additional service seems a matter of responsibility for TV providers.
-
Horses were deemed, for hundreds of years, as an acceptable and reliable means of transportation…then motor vehicles were invented.
Being miked up is better than not as not everyone knows all the signals including fans, coaches and announcers.
Two of many examples.
1 - I have never, and I mean never had an illegal formation been announced correctly, they have been announced as “illegal procedure”, false starts, etc.
2 - I have seen a disconcerting act called, announced as failure to wear proper equipment, coach hollers that’s not a foul anymore. Now the wings can get the correct info to the coach, but now he needs calmed down. When miked up the coach hears the foul…he may disagree but he gets the correct info immediately.
I’m guessing you likely don’t use O2O’s, or if you do it wasn’t as soon as we were permitted to use them.
I do understand why all schools don’t have the microphones as they can be expensive.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
At stadiums where the PA announcer is in close proximity to the game clock, our ECO will relay the foul and enforcement spot information to him. (“Holding. 10 yards from the spot of the foul. Repeat x down.”)
-
You made me go double check the NCAA rule on that one... if it was just restricted to the player that received the snap, then the QB-RB-QB exchange on a flea flicker would result in the QB being allowed to ditch the pass, but not for the RB. However, that's not the NCAA rule -- once the player that receives the snap relinquishes possession, nobody is allowed to ditch the ball legally.
For NCAA, that is incorrect. Any passer may throw the ball into an area occupied by an eligible Team A player, at any time. And any passer not "under duress" can throw the ball anywhere he wants. The provision about the player that receives the snap only applies to a passer being 'allowed' to throw the ball into an area not occupied by an eligible Team A player, as long as the passer has left the tackle box and the ball crosses the neutral zone (extended). That only applies to the receiver of the snap, who does not relinquish possession of the ball to any other player before throwing the forward pass.
(In a fantasy NCAA league)
Staubach could hand to Dorsett who, under pressure, throws it to the ground at the feet of Pearson - no foul.
Staubach hands to Dorsett who hands it back to Staubach (with no defender within 7 yards of him), who throws the ball 40 yards downfield, with nobody in the area at all - no foul.
Staubach can take the snap, run 7 yards to his right, and throw the ball into the 10th row of seats, but across the neutral zone - no foul.
Those were some better days.
-
Yes, anybody can throw a legal forward pass. I was intending to only discuss the exception for the passer to throw the ball to an area unoccupied by an A receiver -- the "get outside the tackle box and chuck it out of bounds beyond the LOS" play that just became legal in Fed rules.
As you noted, that only applies to the player that controls the snap and as long as they don't relinquish possession first. So if the QB gets the snap and they run a flea flicker (hand to RB who pitches back to QB), the QB is NOT allowed to use the exception to the rule to chuck the ball into an area unoccupied by an A receiver.
-
Yes, anybody can throw a legal forward pass. I was intending to only discuss the exception for the passer to throw the ball to an area unoccupied by an A receiver -- the "get outside the tackle box and chuck it out of bounds beyond the LOS" play that just became legal in Fed rules.
As you noted, that only applies to the player that controls the snap and as long as they don't relinquish possession first. So if the QB gets the snap and they run a flea flicker (hand to RB who pitches back to QB), the QB is NOT allowed to use the exception to the rule to chuck the ball into an area unoccupied by an A receiver.
That is correct (for NCAA).
A short story. Playoff game last week, after the shotgun snap, I am looking at line play as the QB is handing the ball to a running back. As the play develops, I see the ball carrier move across my face into the side zone. Near the sideline, he gets surrounded by opponents (still behind the NZ), and he throws the ball high and OB (and beyond the NZ extended). I think, "He wasn't the receiver of the snap. That's ING." I drop a flag, and begin announcing that he wasn't the player that received the snap. After a brief discussion with my H, I signal and announce ING, and am expecting my U to be spotting the ball at the spot of the foul, but there seems to be confusion. The team is claiming that the passer is their QB, and took the snap. Hmm. After a little more conversation with my H and U, we realize that, yeah, the passer was the QB and receiver of the snap. I just got fooled by a fake hand-off, and was so focused on blocking action that I lost track of who actually had the ball. Correction. There is no foul for ING.
Stuff happens.
-
For NCAA, that is incorrect. Any passer may throw the ball into an area occupied by an eligible Team A player, at any time. And any passer not "under duress" can throw the ball anywhere he wants. The provision about the player that receives the snap only applies to a passer being 'allowed' to throw the ball into an area not occupied by an eligible Team A player, as long as the passer has left the tackle box and the ball crosses the neutral zone (extended). That only applies to the receiver of the snap, who does not relinquish possession of the ball to any other player before throwing the forward pass.
(In a fantasy NCAA league)
Staubach could hand to Dorsett who, under pressure, throws it to the ground at the feet of Pearson - no foul.
Staubach hands to Dorsett who hands it back to Staubach (with no defender within 7 yards of him), who throws the ball 40 yards downfield, with nobody in the area at all - no foul.
Staubach can take the snap, run 7 yards to his right, and throw the ball into the 10th row of seats, but across the neutral zone - no foul.
Those were some better days.
(In a real NFL season)
Dandy Don Merdith fakes to Perkins, pitches to Renfro who passes to Bullit Bob Hayes..... ^good
Those were also good days ...until Jim Brown and the Cleveland Browns came to town :).
-
(In a real NFL season)
Dandy Don Merdith fakes to Perkins, pitches to Renfro who passes to Bullit Bob Hayes..... ^good
Those were also good days ...until Jim Brown and the Cleveland Browns came to town :).
Moved to Texas in 1965. New next to nothing about football in general before then. Got indoctrinated into Dallas Cowboys football immediately. Until about 1995, don't get between me and the TV when the 'Boys were playing. Great names: Lee Roy Jordan, Bob Lily, Chuck Howley, Robert Newhouse, Walt Garrison, Rayfield Wright, et al. Talented, civilized, and non-entitled. Not to mention Tom Landry (who, I am told didn't speak to officials much - didn't have much use for officials). Nowadays, I don't even know, or care, when they are playing. Time marches on.
-
Moved to Texas in 1965. New next to nothing about football in general before then. Got indoctrinated into Dallas Cowboys football immediately. Until about 1995, don't get between me and the TV when the 'Boys were playing. Great names: Lee Roy Jordan, Bob Lily, Chuck Howley, Robert Newhouse, Walt Garrison, Rayfield Wright, et al. Talented, civilized, and non-entitled. Not to mention Tom Landry (who, I am told didn't speak to officials much - didn't have much use for officials). Nowadays, I don't even know, or care, when they are playing. Time marches on.
I believe Chuck Howely was the only player on a losing Super Bowl team to be awarded the Super Bowl MVP. aWaRd
-
Moved to Texas in 1965. New next to nothing about football in general before then. Got indoctrinated into Dallas Cowboys football immediately. Until about 1995, don't get between me and the TV when the 'Boys were playing. Great names: Lee Roy Jordan, Bob Lily, Chuck Howley, Robert Newhouse, Walt Garrison, Rayfield Wright, et al. Talented, civilized, and non-entitled. Not to mention Tom Landry (who, I am told didn't speak to officials much - didn't have much use for officials). Nowadays, I don't even know, or care, when they are playing. Time marches on.
I wonder how many Dallas Cowboy loyal fans ever bother to recall that Tom Landry, their 1st Head Coach (father), brought with him all the experience, talents, skills, attitude he learned and developed as a HOF defensive back with the.....NY Giants?
-
Do you really think a detailed , verbal explanation of each penalty signal is actually necessary, and worth the expense of retrofitting thousands of HS football fields? Timely, well defined, properly executed signals (including the next down, or the LOD signal) have worked well and have been deemed acceptable for the VAST majority of Coaches, players, spectators for over 100 years. For those spectators needing additional detail, politely asking the nearest spectator, paying attention to the Referee's signal, seems a lot more cost effective means of providing such detail.
For televised games the expense for such additional service seems a matter of responsibility for TV providers.
They're becoming more common around here and and are not very expensive. Routine calls it doesn't matter, but for anything unusual I think it is helpful to be able to explain to everyone what is happening.
-
Do you really think a detailed , verbal explanation of each penalty signal is actually necessary, and worth the expense of retrofitting thousands of HS football fields?
Yes.
-
They're becoming more common around here and and are not very expensive. Routine calls it doesn't matter, but for anything unusual I think it is helpful to be able to explain to everyone what is happening.
But the root of the problem here is that even when the "fans" get a clear explanation of a penalty they still think that we are wrong due to the "football rules that they know" (ie: Saturday & Sunday). I've been at enough games with mic'ed up R's who give excellent announcements and still hear plenty of "that's not correct" from both coaches and fans. I don't see how hearing the announcement is going to help the fact that 90% of the people in the stadium don't know the rules, including in most cases the PA announcers.
-
But the root of the problem here is that even when the "fans" get a clear explanation of a penalty they still think that we are wrong due to the "football rules that they know" (ie: Saturday & Sunday). I've been at enough games with mic'ed up R's who give excellent announcements and still hear plenty of "that's not correct" from both coaches and fans. I don't see how hearing the announcement is going to help the fact that 90% of the people in the stadium don't know the rules, including in most cases the PA announcers.
I have season tickets to my favorite college games. You should hear the guys around me explaining how wrong “the refs” are. I can only imagine siting in the stands during a high school game.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
Flashing back to 1978, The University of Maine added ice hockey. I quickly became a fan, konwing little about the game oustide of watching the Boston Bruins on TV. we didn't know when to BOO. Our catalyst was our coach. Whwn he got 'excited' we would follow suit :puke: :puke: :puke: :puke: :puke: :puke: :puke:. I feel this still holds true today. When the coach starts screaming the fans will quickly follow. :!# = :!# :!# :!# :!# :!# :!# :!# :!# :!# :!# :!# :!# :!# :!# :!# :!# :!# :!# :!# :!# :!# :!# :!# :!# :!#
-
I have season tickets to my favorite college games. You should hear the guys around me explaining how wrong “the refs” are. I can only imagine siting in the stands during a high school game.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
If memory serves, there once was a time when those who didn't know what was going on, would simply (politely) seek guidance rather than publicly expressing their ignorance. Today, it's doubtful we really have that many more blatantly ignorant people, but we do seem to have a lot more, otherwise rational people, paying attention to the more ignorant among us. Some actually consider that progress.
-
Moved to Texas in 1965. New next to nothing about football in general before then. Got indoctrinated into Dallas Cowboys football immediately. Until about 1995, don't get between me and the TV when the 'Boys were playing. Great names: Lee Roy Jordan, Bob Lily, Chuck Howley, Robert Newhouse, Walt Garrison, Rayfield Wright, et al. Talented, civilized, and non-entitled. Not to mention Tom Landry (who, I am told didn't speak to officials much - didn't have much use for officials). Nowadays, I don't even know, or care, when they are playing. Time marches on.
In the pre-Falcons/Saints days, the Cowboys were the team of choice for many SEC fans. Lee Roy Jordan, D. D. Lewis, Dave Edwards, Perry Lee Dunn, Dennis Homan were some who played ‘round here on Saturdays.
-
Yes.
Counterpoint - No.
NFL and College are spectator sports. High school has spectators, but it's still for the kids, first and foremost. It's important to give the explanation to coaches and teams as to what the foul was and how it's enforced, but it's not strictly necessary to inform the fans.
Since higher levels exist to get the fans to spend money, then you develop procedures to keep the fans interested and informed about the game. That's not to say microphones are a bad thing in high school, but it's not worth forcing an investment for every school.
-
Counterpoints to your counterpoint:
1) it gives us the appearance of being more professional, especially if the R can give good announcements.
2)While it's not necessary to inform fans, it can certainly go a long way in at least offering a rationale for a ruling. I'd like to think that would appease at least some, who otherwise are just jumping on the 'the refs suck' bandwagon, that they have the capacity to think ok, that makes sense.' Referencing your comment From the NHFS Survey thread: 'Yes, the spot of the foul was 2 yards behind the LOS, but it just looks like we can't count to 10. We're doing it right, but it looks like we're doing it wrong - especially to every fan who can now clearly see that it's 1st and 22 after a 10 yard penalty.'
-
I didn't say that being mic'd up is a bad thing or there aren't positive reasons to do it. It's just not worth mandating it to enforce the expense for small schools that may not be able to afford it and would rather spend that money on teacher salaries or books -- actual educational expenses.
Maybe it's worth suggesting to do it if you can, but I wouldn't make it mandatory.
-
Counterpoint - No.
NFL and College are spectator sports. High school has spectators, but it's still for the kids, first and foremost. It's important to give the explanation to coaches and teams as to what the foul was and how it's enforced, but it's not strictly necessary to inform the fans.
Since higher levels exist to get the fans to spend money, then you develop procedures to keep the fans interested and informed about the game. That's not to say microphones are a bad thing in high school, but it's not worth forcing an investment for every school.
Some real-life reasons why “yes.”
1. Had a playoff game last week and we had a late-game situation that required the game clock to be re-set. No field mic. Had to try to show fingers to the CO. After three INCORRECT resets, and about 2 full minutes (a football eternity), the clock finally got reset correctly. With a field mic, as I have done dozens of times before when I had a field mic, I could have flipped on the mic, announced the time to the put on the clock, and we could have been back to play in maybe 10 seconds, total.
2. Had a playoff game yesterday, at the same location, and we had dead-ball UNRs by both teams, with one player being disqualified. Couldn’t make an announcement of the DQ’d player’s number and reason for the DQ. The fans, and everybody else, deserve to know what was going on. Even if I wanted to, I can’t yell loud enough to let folks in the stands and pressbox know what is going on.
3. When a player’s helmet comes off, it is infinitely better to offer an explanation to the masses as to why he is leaving the game for one down.
4. For fouls that use S19, it is infinitely better to be able to announce the specific foul.
5. For UNS and UNR fouls, it is infinitely better to be able to announce the nature of the foul, i.e., late hit, taunting, etc.
I could list a dozen more. But I’ll stop there.
The cost of a simple but good referee’s field mic system is less than $4,000. That is a very small investment that will yield great returns.
-
Some real-life reasons why “yes.” better to be able to announce the nature of the foul, i.e., late hit, taunting, etc.
I could list a dozen more. But I’ll stop there.
The cost of a simple but good referee’s field mic system is less than $4,000. That is a very small investment that will yield great returns.
Considering the "nature" of those complaining about anything/everything, it's still pretty lopsided that these complaints ONLY happen when they negatively affect "THEIR" team. As for better communication with the fans, sometimes yes, depending on the relevance of the detail, but most often most often it's not going to matter.
1. For timing adjustments, direct communication between Referee & Clock operator might help, but a simple signal for "Clock Adjustment" ( then everyone interested could simply watch the clock and see what happens, should suffice.
2. Disqualification signals when necessary after Signals 38 (or 27) when followed by a clear Signal 47, should send a clear signal of what is happening to anyone paying attention. Either a verbal, or hand gesture signal to the respective Head Coach would be helpful.
3. When a loss of a helmet causes a player to be removed, the result seems somewhat obvious.
4. For False Start &/or Illegal formation, Signal 19 seems adequate for spectators, an additional verbal clarification to the HC may be of value.
5. For UNS & UNR fouls the current signal seems adequate.
It's helpful if the game "announcer" is aware of each signal, to inform the spectators, but as we all know (at the NFHS level) that can often present additional confusion.
-
Some real-life reasons why “yes.”
1. Had a playoff game last week and we had a late-game situation that required the game clock to be re-set. No field mic. Had to try to show fingers to the CO. After three INCORRECT resets, and about 2 full minutes (a football eternity), the clock finally got reset correctly. With a field mic, as I have done dozens of times before when I had a field mic, I could have flipped on the mic, announced the time to the put on the clock, and we could have been back to play in maybe 10 seconds, total.
2. Had a playoff game yesterday, at the same location, and we had dead-ball UNRs by both teams, with one player being disqualified. Couldn’t make an announcement of the DQ’d player’s number and reason for the DQ. The fans, and everybody else, deserve to know what was going on. Even if I wanted to, I can’t yell loud enough to let folks in the stands and pressbox know what is going on.
3. When a player’s helmet comes off, it is infinitely better to offer an explanation to the masses as to why he is leaving the game for one down.
4. For fouls that use S19, it is infinitely better to be able to announce the specific foul.
5. For UNS and UNR fouls, it is infinitely better to be able to announce the nature of the foul, i.e., late hit, taunting, etc.
I could list a dozen more. But I’ll stop there.
The cost of a simple but good referee’s field mic system is less than $4,000. That is a very small investment that will yield great returns.
First, I like field mics. They help. But these reasons can be handled without them.
1. We have Midland 2 ways, and always make sure the clock operator has one. If we need to correct the clock we just talk to h8 or her.
2. Not sure the fans need to know every detail.
3. Most fans know by now that when a hat rolls somebody is leaving.
4. I agree we need more signals.
5. I agree. Hurdling comes to mind…
* Per the $4,000 comment, we officiate schools in our neck of the woods who can’t afford matching uniforms. They probably can’t invest in a field mic system. I suppose a corporation could donate one.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
1. Had a playoff game last week and we had a late-game situation that required the game clock to be re-set. No field mic. Had to try to show fingers to the CO. After three INCORRECT resets, and about 2 full minutes (a football eternity), the clock finally got reset correctly. With a field mic, as I have done dozens of times before when I had a field mic, I could have flipped on the mic, announced the time to the put on the clock, and we could have been back to play in maybe 10 seconds, total.
This is exactly why our ECOs have O2O capability.
-
This is exactly why our ECOs have O2O capability.
I agree. Why more crews don't have radios is beyond me. One of my college white hats does not have radios, so I asked my crew mates for that game to pitch in money to buy a set. 8 radios would be roughly $320, so it would be about $40 per person. Only one person seemed interested.
O2O is really helpful in communicating to the clock operator, but it only really works when the clock operator knows how to use it. If he is an official, it is more likely that he knows O2O etiquette. If not, I might have to spend time teaching him how to use the radio.
-
I never cease to be amazed at how we can lead a horse to water, but you can’t make ‘em drink.
As for providing an O2O radio to a clock operator(s), that would be OK, if operators were fellow officials who understand the other communications we may have, and they are the only ones that can hear our communications. But operators are School Board members, math teachers, other sport coaches, local farmers, etc., working for free. Even if schools would pay for officials to run the clocks, we don’t have enough folks to provide clock operators.
Can’t help those that won’t be helped.
-
Maybe this is a reason why the financial investment wouldn't be a problem in my parts, but it seems every school around me has a coach "in the booth" and a headset system for communication -- even for schools that are very rural and underfunded. Any time we've needed a clock adjustment and the clock operator either a) wasn't an official or b) didn't have the OTO radio, we relayed a message through the home team's coaches. The only time we've had to stand on the field looking dumb trying to give hand signals was when the clock operator puts the wrong time up for halftime and then immediately leaves so nobody's watching us at all.
Somewhat unrelated as a mechanics issue, this gets me thinking different white hats that do different things. In the likely case that you don't have a field mic, if the WH is giving a penalty signal, does the WH actually verbalize what you would be saying as if they were able to be heard, or just mime the signals?
Most WHs I work with say *something*, but very few make it sound like you hear on TV. Most are very informal about it -- rather than saying "Holding. Offense. Number 56. Ten yard penalty. Replay second down." they'd say "That's a hold on the offense, and it's still two". I kind of like the formal TV version because it makes you very deliberate and slow with the signals, whereas informal or nothing said can lead to being really fast and people miss what you did or it leads to mistakes.
-
I never cease to be amazed at how we can lead a horse to water, but you can’t make ‘em drink.
As for providing an O2O radio to a clock operator(s), that would be OK, if operators were fellow officials who understand the other communications we may have, and they are the only ones that can hear our communications. But operators are School Board members, math teachers, other sport coaches, local farmers, etc., working for free. Even if schools would pay for officials to run the clocks, we don’t have enough folks to provide clock operators.
Can’t help those that won’t be helped.
Our ecos are registered officials. They have to pay dues and attend meetings. Not all are on the field officials. All are instructed to use the earpiece. We’ve not had any problems.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Maybe this is a reason why the financial investment wouldn't be a problem in my parts, but it seems every school around me has a coach "in the booth" and a headset system for communication -- even for schools that are very rural and underfunded. Any time we've needed a clock adjustment and the clock operator either a) wasn't an official or b) didn't have the OTO radio, we relayed a message through the home team's coaches. The only time we've had to stand on the field looking dumb trying to give hand signals was when the clock operator puts the wrong time up for halftime and then immediately leaves so nobody's watching us at all.
Yes. We’ve done that hundreds of times. A) Move to the home sideline. B) Track down a cooperative coach that will communicate with a pressbox coach. C) Ask him to have his pressbox coach go tell the GCO to reset the game clock to mm:ss. D) Wait. E) Stare at the game clock and wait for the time to change. F) Wait. E) See the clock display go to 0:00. F) See the clock display go to 12:00. G) Hear the coach on the headphones say, “What time did you want?” H) Repeat the process. J) Finally see the clock display set to mm:ss. K) Move back to the field and get the game resumed. Elapsed time: 1:05.
With field mic: A) Switch on the mic. B) “Clock operator, please set the game clock to mm:ss; mm,ss.” C) Wait. D) See the clock display set to mm:ss. E) Say, “Thank you.” F) Resume the game. Elapsed time: 0:15.
Somewhat unrelated as a mechanics issue, this gets me thinking different white hats that do different things. In the likely case that you don't have a field mic, if the WH is giving a penalty signal, does the WH actually verbalize what you would be saying as if they were able to be heard, or just mime the signals?
Most WHs I work with say *something*, but very few make it sound like you hear on TV. Most are very informal about it -- rather than saying "Holding. Offense. Number 56. Ten yard penalty. Replay second down." they'd say "That's a hold on the offense, and it's still two". I kind of like the formal TV version because it makes you very deliberate and slow with the signals, whereas informal or nothing said can lead to being really fast and people miss what you did or it leads to mistakes.
Since my first FBS assignment as the Referee, I have always fully verbalized all announcements. Even when I don’t have a field mic (about 70% of the time nowadays, at HS stadia), much of the time, sideline personnel (and players on the field) can hear the announcement, and it helps tremendously in having the essential folks understand what is going on, whether a penalty, a time out, a helmet off, an injury, whatever. Then, when I do have a field mic, there is no stumbling for words. Everything stays seamless. I strongly recommend EVERY referee, with or without a field mic, fully verbalize every announcement.Then everything stays 100% natural when you DO have a field mic.
-
Maybe 10 years ago had a game, I was the LJ. The clock operator came down to the field to talk to me. He came with another man and said they had radios and if the clock needed to be changed he would be behind me so we could relay the correct time. Of course we didn't need to change the clock...
-
I never cease to be amazed at how we can lead a horse to water, but you can’t make ‘em drink.
As for providing an O2O radio to a clock operator(s), that would be OK, if operators were fellow officials who understand the other communications we may have, and they are the only ones that can hear our communications. But operators are School Board members, math teachers, other sport coaches, local farmers, etc., working for free. Even if schools would pay for officials to run the clocks, we don’t have enough folks to provide clock operators.
Can’t help those that won’t be helped.
I carry a spare radio (because we don't use crews, and every single week, there's 'that guy' who didn't bring his) but under no circumstances am I giving a radio to a non-official. We can barely fill the games our chapter gets, we just don't have the bodies to have an auxiliary clock or chain crews.
-
1. Basic Spot - No. Leave it alone. Offenses that don't like the way it is should avoid committing a foul.
2. Towels - Yes. Dear God, change it. Who cares what color they are.
3. Game Clock - No. Games were longer but the 25/40 change helped shave some of that time.
4. IG - No. The intent of the rule is safety, and that applies to anyone potentially throwing.
5. AFD on UNR/UNS - No. Changing it to be like NCAA in order not to confuse fans/coaches is not a good enough reason.
-
I have mixed feeling about O2O radios.
We have problems with the head sets. They are not very robust.
Crews stop using hand signals to each other (I shout) and preliminary signals. Not good.
Field mics are handy if there is something that needs to be explained. Few things do. I only have one a few times a year.
Earpiece and a switch on my collar, field mic on my collar or around my neck. On my belt two flags, one beanbag, O2O radio, field mic radio and separate on/off switch.
I am Batman.
-
O2O has variables - 1) radio brand, 2) earpiece/mic brand, 3) operator error.
I've used Baofengs, Motorolas, and Yapalongs. The earpiece mics that came with the Baofengs were trashed shortly after I opened the box. I tried to upgrade them a bit. Their quality is more important than the radio model IMO.
I find that the two biggest operator errors are 1) failing to pause after pushing the xmit button and 2) the security style mics have a very small opening that some users cover over with their finger while pushing xmit, which can muffle or eradicate their voice transmission.
I recommend the Klein Comfit boom mic. They come in both M1 and K1 2pin connectors.
The average price is about $70 but I did find a source, hightechwireless.com, that sells them for $43.
-
I've used Baofengs, Motorolas, and Yapalongs. The earpiece mics that came with the Baofengs were trashed shortly after I opened the box. I tried to upgrade them a bit. Their quality is more important than the radio model IMO.
Completely agree. In the UK most of us have either Baofeng or Retevis radios and my experience is also that the quality of the headset is way more important than the radio. We have a number of officials who use the stock headset that came with their radio and they are invariably the hardest to hear over O2O due to the (lack of) quality of the headset.
-
Completely agree. In the UK most of us have either Baofeng or Retevis radios and my experience is also that the quality of the headset is way more important than the radio. We have a number of officials who use the stock headset that came with their radio and they are invariably the hardest to hear over O2O due to the (lack of) quality of the headset.
IF you're going to drop $70 on a headset, I'd look at the goodcall officiating ones, that have the big PTT button on your waist, not your throat. It's MUCH easier to communicate with, when I can subtly say something on the radio, versus having to reach up, find it, hit the PTT, and hope you don't block the mic. Another point to consider is the style/quality of the mic itself. The goodcall ones blow the others out of the water in terms of quality. And quality mic = quality sound. It's literally night and day difference. When I'm crewed with guys who have the goodcall one, and some who have the out of the box one, I can easily understand what they are saying, while the standard ones still sound like a tin can in a hurricane.
I find I actually use the radio more when I don't have to reach up to hit the PTT, which IMO is a good thing. It doesn't replace preliminary signals for us, but it certainly makes foul reporting much easier, especially when everyone can actually understand what is being said.
-
IF you're going to drop $70 on a headset, I'd look at the goodcall officiating ones, that have the big PTT button on your waist, not your throat. It's MUCH easier to communicate with, when I can subtly say something on the radio, versus having to reach up, find it, hit the PTT, and hope you don't block the mic. Another point to consider is the style/quality of the mic itself. The goodcall ones blow the others out of the water in terms of quality. And quality mic = quality sound. It's literally night and day difference. When I'm crewed with guys who have the goodcall one, and some who have the out of the box one, I can easily understand what they are saying, while the standard ones still sound like a tin can in a hurricane.
I find I actually use the radio more when I don't have to reach up to hit the PTT, which IMO is a good thing. It doesn't replace preliminary signals for us, but it certainly makes foul reporting much easier, especially when everyone can actually understand what is being said.
I will second everything Bobby said about the GoodCall headsets/PTT buttons. SOOOOOOOOO much better than the tiny lapel buttons/mics.
-
The good calls connector won't work with the Motos that I have. I did look at them before. The big button would be nice to have.
These are lightweight. The PTT button is about the size of the first joint of my thumb and clips underneath my shirt near the collarbone joint.
https://www.hitechwireless.com/comfit-pro-audio-single-wire-boom-microphone-motorola-m1/ (https://www.hitechwireless.com/comfit-pro-audio-single-wire-boom-microphone-motorola-m1/)
(https://cdn11.bigcommerce.com/s-fda69/images/stencil/1280x1280/products/7800/13353/comfit_big__50269.1441826486.gif?c=2)
-
They won't work with your motorolas?
They're cheap, you can get a 2 pack for around $35 I think, for the XTalk radios.
-
Motorola Talkabouts use M6 - single pin. I was using the CLS 1110, which is M1 - 2 pin. I'll be switching to the digital DLR1020 (900 mhz) for next season, still use 2 pin so all our current sets will still work.