RefStripes.com

Football Officiating => National Federation Discussion => Topic started by: SCHSref on December 14, 2022, 07:40:01 AM

Title: Something new to me...
Post by: SCHSref on December 14, 2022, 07:40:01 AM
R1 fair catches a scrimmage kick at K's 40. He then calls TO. After the TO, he informs white hat he wishes to put ball in play via snap. A1 passes to A2, but B1 interferes and pass is incomplete. After penalty administration, they decide they now want to free kick from K's 25. Apparently, this is permissible. I never knew...anyone ever see this?
Title: Re: Something new to me...
Post by: Ralph Damren on December 14, 2022, 08:08:20 AM
Electing to free kick after a fair catch is as rare as Halley's Comet. If B fouls on the first scrimmage down after a fair catch, it's sorta' like said comet landing in your back yard. But yes, they still have that option. This could also occur in reverse :
(1) Fair catch at K's 35-free kick option chosen;
(2) Kick is good while K player punches R player;
(3) bad kid gone and ball moved back to 50, out of kicking range;
(4) K can turn to A and take scrimmage downs.

While this is on my Bucket-list, I may kick the bucket before  tR:oLl tiphat:
Title: Re: Something new to me...
Post by: ttown44 on December 14, 2022, 10:10:56 AM
Key being "replay the down" which includes all of its options, including the placement of the ball between the hashes.
Title: Re: Something new to me...
Post by: CalhounLJ on December 14, 2022, 10:29:15 AM
Electing to free kick after a fair catch is as rare as Halley's Comet. If B fouls on the first scrimmage down after a fair catch, it's sorta' like said comet landing in your back yard. But yes, they still have that option. This could also occur in reverse :
(1) Fair catch at K's 35-free kick option chosen;
(2) Kick is good while K player punches R player;
(3) bad kid gone and ball moved back to 50, out of kicking range;
(4) K can turn to A and take scrimmage downs.

While this is on my Bucket-list, I may kick the bucket before  tR:oLl tiphat:

Had my first one this year.. after 30+ years of officiating. R fair caught the ball at the K 46 with :01 left in the half. Kick was right down the middle but short by 2 yards. Even though the ball was never touched, the clock operator ran off the :01. Nobody complained, so we went to halftime.
Title: Re: Something new to me...
Post by: ncwingman on December 14, 2022, 12:54:52 PM
Had my first one this year.. after 30+ years of officiating. R fair caught the ball at the K 46 with :01 left in the half. Kick was right down the middle but short by 2 yards. Even though the ball was never touched, the clock operator ran off the :01. Nobody complained, so we went to halftime.

As you noted, the game clock does not have to run on a free kick play (it would on a scrimmage play, since it would start with the snap). As a deviation from the original question, how many consecutive free kicks do you think you could have such that no time runs off the clock?

In theory, there could be an infinite chain -- if the fair catch kick is good, the ensuing kick off could end with a fair catch or awarded fair catch without the ball being touched by R (KCI, untouched by R), that team fair catch kicks, and the whole process just repeats forever.
Title: Re: Something new to me...
Post by: SCHSref on December 14, 2022, 02:01:46 PM
The fair catch after a free kick is not new to me...the running of a play and then free kicking IS. AS someone else pointed out...the "replay the down" is the caveat
Title: Re: Something new to me...
Post by: NVFOA_Ump on December 14, 2022, 02:03:09 PM
As you noted, the game clock does not have to run on a free kick play. ....

Don't want to be nit-picky here but shouldn't we say that the game clock does not start on a free kick until the ball is legally touched in the field of play?
Title: Re: Something new to me...
Post by: Ralph Damren on December 14, 2022, 03:55:15 PM
Don't want to be nit-picky here but shouldn't we say that the game clock does not start on a free kick until the ball is legally touched in the field of play?
We should, lt's a free kick. Differing from the free kick after a score, we would set the chains to mark the neutal zone and place R &  sNiCkErSU sNiCkErS to make the call.  ^good ^talk ^good   
Title: Re: Something new to me...
Post by: sczeebra on December 17, 2022, 07:25:47 AM
SCHSref, remember this twist from our rules interpreter Bruce a few years back where the offended team(penalty inside two minutes of the half or 4th) decided to hold off starting the clock until the snap. There was a play with an inadvertent whistle with a replay of the down and that offended team changes their mind and wants to have the clock start on the ready which was ruled acceptable. Merry Christmas!!!
Title: Re: Something new to me...
Post by: GA Umpire on December 17, 2022, 11:23:38 PM
While this is on my Bucket-list, I may kick the bucket before  tR:oLl tiphat:

Ralph:
I have had one in my long officiating life. 
Have had coaches ask in pregame meeting if it was still a rule and state they always have wanted to try it bur have not had the chance.