RefStripes.com

Football Officiating => National Federation Discussion => Topic started by: Ralph Damren on December 17, 2022, 10:14:21 AM

Title: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: Ralph Damren on December 17, 2022, 10:14:21 AM
Santa has plenty of gifts (new rules proposals) for the upcoming year. I value your opinions and would enjoy hearing from them.

(1) Failure to wear proper equipment = 1st, warning > 2nd  = 5 yards > 3rd = 15 yards USC > 4th & more = 15 yards USC + Disq.

(2) Any colored towels = OK

(3) Expand list of illegal equipment.

(4) Leaping OOB player is still OOB until landing IB.

(5) Clock starts on RFP after OOB unless under 2 min. in half.

(6) If K/A subs, R/B can sub prior to snap.

(7) Forward fumble > OOB > spot of fumble.

(8) Only the player that takes snap can legal IG.

(9) After ball goes beyond LOS, can't have forward pass.

(10) IG only LOD at spot.

(11) Legalize 'pushing the pile'.

(12) Legalize hurdling.

(13) Strengthen 'defenseless player'.

(14) Hands to the face = 15 yards.

(15) AFD/LOD if PF.

(16) AFD if USC by B.

(17) Coaches bail moat on RFP

(18) Previous spot if foul by A behind LOS or by B if run ends behind LOS.

Please let me know your opinions. Thank you  tiphat:

 :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR:
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2022 VERSION
Post by: Rob S on December 17, 2022, 10:40:44 AM
So a lot of college rule adoptions - I generally support. Some thoughts:

(1) Failure to wear proper equipment = 1st, warning > 2nd  = 5 yards > 3rd = 15 yards USC > 4th & more = 15 yards USC + Disq.
  Is this by team or player? By player would be impossible to track (or really slow game). By team we're going to be tossing a lot of coaches.

(2) Any colored towels = OK
  Sure - honestly its not enforced well anyways (especially with some pink towels in October)

(3) Expand list of illegal equipment.
   What would be added?

(4) Leaping OOB player is still OOB until landing IB.
   I like this

(5) Clock starts on RFP after OOB unless under 2 min. in half.
   No big difference - I see a lot more incompletes stopping the clock than runs OOB. Poor passing teams run up game times more than anything. But I'd have no complaints if we did it.

(6) If K/A subs, R/B can sub prior to snap.
   Indifferent - would like consistency with other levels, but also not really a problem needing fixed from what I see.

(7) Forward fumble > OOB > spot of fumble.
   Sure

(8) Only the player that takes snap can legal IG.
   Indifferent

(9) After ball goes beyond LOS, can't have forward pass.
   Indifferent, just doesn't happen often enough to worry about

(10) IG only LOD at spot.
   Not really a fan, but if QBs learned it might help with safety to avoid QB hits

(11) Legalize 'pushing the pile'.
   No - seems like more risk for injury

(12) Legalize hurdling.
   No - wrong way for safety for sure

(13) Strengthen 'defenseless player'.
   Not sure what this entails. If it's better definition/examples, sure.

(14) Hands to the face = 15 yards.
   Rare call, but I support

(15) AFD/LOD if PF.
   No more LODs - AFD, I could live with

(16) AFD if USC by B.
   I support. I'd rather have non-football acts convert from PF to UNS like college, but this at least punishes one team more for UNS.

(17) Coaches bail moat on RFP
    Finally figured this out - I support being able to tell coaches they need to be out of the box sooner. "Snap is eminent" is pretty vague.

(18) Previous spot if foul by A behind LOS or by B if run ends behind LOS.
    I like this, to me seems more fair all around
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2022 VERSION
Post by: AlUpstateNY on December 17, 2022, 10:42:49 AM
Santa has plenty of gifts (new rules proposals) for the upcoming year. I value your opinions and would enjoy hearing from them.

(1) Failure to wear proper equipment = 1st, warning > 2nd  = 5 yards > 3rd = 15 yards USC > 4th & more = 15 yards USC + Disq.

(2) Any colored towels = OK

(3) Expand list of illegal equipment.

(4) Leaping OOB player is still OOB until landing IB.

(5) Clock starts on RFP after OOB unless under 2 min. in half.

(6) If K/A subs, R/B can sub prior to snap.

(7) Forward fumble > OOB > spot of fumble.

(8) Only the player that takes snap can legal IG.

(9) After ball goes beyond LOS, can't have forward pass.

(10) IG only LOD at spot.

(11) Legalize 'pushing the pile'.

(12) Legalize hurdling.

(13) Strengthen 'defenseless player'.

(14) Hands to the face = 15 yards.

(15) AFD/LOD if PF.

(16) AFD if USC by B.

(17) Coaches bail moat on RFP

(18) Previous spot if foul by A behind LOS or by B if run ends behind LOS.

Disagree:1, 2, 7, 11, 12, 15, 16,
Agree: 4, 5, 8, 9, 14, 16. 17
Possible(with clarification): 3, 10, 13.

#1 suggest making 1st warning MANDATORY part of "Pre Game Conference with each HC.
#2 never underestimate the creativity of the American teenager (of NFHS Head Coach)
#11 Consider Forward Progress ENDED when "Pushing the Pile" begins.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2022 VERSION
Post by: Ralph Damren on December 17, 2022, 11:33:20 AM
Thanks, Rob & Al, for your responses.
Rob- I agree with you on #1, tracking this would be a challange.
Al- You both agreed & disagreed with #16, I assume one was for 18.
I agree with both of you on pushing the pile and hurdling not being allowed for safety. We had an interp this fall in Maine that once pushing the pile started, forward progress had stopped. The coaches were well advised of it and the season went smoothly.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2022 VERSION
Post by: bossman72 on December 17, 2022, 12:05:28 PM
Santa has plenty of gifts (new rules proposals) for the upcoming year. I value your opinions and would enjoy hearing from them.

(1) Failure to wear proper equipment = 1st, warning > 2nd  = 5 yards > 3rd = 15 yards USC > 4th & more = 15 yards USC + Disq.
No, because then people will REALLY never call it.
(2) Any colored towels = OK
Sure
(3) Expand list of illegal equipment.
Not sure what this is about.  I think everything that's illegal now is fine.
(4) Leaping OOB player is still OOB until landing IB.
Yes definitely.  Then maybe we can get rid of that stupid IP rule about being OOB and "otherwise participating".
(5) Clock starts on RFP after OOB unless under 2 min. in half.
I'm all for quicker games.  lol.
(6) If K/A subs, R/B can sub prior to snap.
Is this a problem?  I'm ok with it if we need to.
(7) Forward fumble > OOB > spot of fumble.
Eh, do we need it?  I'm ok if we change it.
(8) Only the player that takes snap can legal IG.
Yeah that's probably for the best.
(9) After ball goes beyond LOS, can't have forward pass.
I'm good with that, but do we need to change it?
(10) IG only LOD at spot.
No, 5 yards is fine and no need to make an exception.
(11) Legalize 'pushing the pile'.
I'm good with that because we never call it.  Pulling/lifting would still be illegal.
(12) Legalize hurdling.
No, keep it illegal.
(13) Strengthen 'defenseless player'.
No, it's fine the way it is.
(14) Hands to the face = 15 yards.
Yes definitely.  This is poorly codified in the current rules and this would be great for clarification.
(15) AFD/LOD if PF.
No if LOD is mandated to be married with it.
(16) AFD if USC by B.
I'm fine with no automatic first downs, honestly.
(17) Coaches bail moat on RFP
I'm not sure what this means.  Is this Maine slang?  lol.
(18) Previous spot if foul by A behind LOS or by B if run ends behind LOS.
I think so.  I had the proposal where the run ends behind makes the basic spot the previous spot.  Offensive fouls would still be spot fouls.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2022 VERSION
Post by: HLinNC on December 17, 2022, 04:48:47 PM
(1) Failure to wear proper equipment = 1st, warning > 2nd  = 5 yards > 3rd = 15 yards USC > 4th & more = 15 yards USC + Disq.
Difficult to track, would slow the game down
(2) Any colored towels = OK
All but yes.
(3) Expand list of illegal equipment.
If they mean define more specific examples, sure
(4) Leaping OOB player is still OOB until landing IB.
As long it is along the lines of "a player who has gone out of bounds is not considered in bounds until his/her body has totally returned within the field of play or end zone(s)" ]
(5) Clock starts on RFP after OOB unless under 2 min. in half.
Sure
(6) If K/A subs, R/B can sub prior to snap.
See no need
(7) Forward fumble > OOB > spot of fumble.
Nah, if he throws an IFP, flag it.  Otherwise leave it be.
(8) Only the player that takes snap can legal IG.
I see no need.  Passer is fine.  It hasn't come up otherwise."
(9) After ball goes beyond LOS, can't have forward pass.
Not sure how I feel on this one.
(10) IG only LOD at spot.
Sure.  That's been my biggest mistake as a new WH, enforcing from previous spot.
(11) Legalize 'pushing the pile'.
First we would have to define what a pile is and so forth.  Nah.
(12) Legalize hurdling.
I thought the Fed was about safety?
(13) Strengthen 'defenseless player'.
Perhaps they ought to put some recommended language out on that one.
(14) Hands to the face = 15 yards.
The definitions under IUH or Personal Foul already cover this.  No
(15) AFD/LOD if PF.
Most PF's tend to be dead balls where the down has counted anyway. No
(16) AFD if USC by B.
Another exception by those who claim not to like exceptions.  No
(17) Coaches bail moat on RFP
With the :40, there is no audible signal for the RFP.  Coaches are not looking for the ball down and U moving away.  No
(18) Previous spot if foul by A behind LOS or by B if run ends behind LOS.
Bye bye ABO.  Just swapping another exception to an exception.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2022 VERSION
Post by: GA Umpire on December 17, 2022, 11:18:38 PM
Santa has plenty of gifts (new rules proposals) for the upcoming year. I value your opinions and would enjoy hearing from them.

(1) Failure to wear proper equipment = 1st, warning > 2nd  = 5 yards > 3rd = 15 yards USC > 4th & more = 15 yards USC + Disq. 

(2) Any colored towels = OK

(3) Expand list of illegal equipment.

(4) Leaping OOB player is still OOB until landing IB.

(5) Clock starts on RFP after OOB unless under 2 min. in half.

(6) If K/A subs, R/B can sub prior to snap.

(7) Forward fumble > OOB > spot of fumble.

(8) Only the player that takes snap can legal IG.

(9) After ball goes beyond LOS, can't have forward pass.

(10) IG only LOD at spot.

(11) Legalize 'pushing the pile'.

(12) Legalize hurdling.

(13) Strengthen 'defenseless player'.

(14) Hands to the face = 15 yards.

(15) AFD/LOD if PF.

(16) AFD if USC by B.

(17) Coaches bail moat on RFP

(18) Previous spot if foul by A behind LOS or by B if run ends behind LOS.

Please let me know your opinions. Thank you  tiphat:

 :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR:

1.  Present Rule is sufficient as the rule is rarely enforced.
2.  Please.  That is the way it is enforced now.  See #1.
3.  ??????
4.  OK
5.  OK 
6.  NO!
7.  No.  Have not seen abuse of the present rule.
8.  OK
9.  OK
10. OK
11. OK. That is the way it is called now.
12. NO!
13. As already asked, how?
14. OK
15. OK
16. OK
17. OK
18. NO!  The present rule (ABO) is easier.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2022 VERSION
Post by: Ralph Damren on December 18, 2022, 06:37:25 AM
Yo, Bossman, thanks for your replies. #13 would be a foul if a D-back did more than play the ball or wrap-up tackle the reciever. We've added the  blindside block and targeting as fouls in our game without any noted change. I've proposed your suggestion that we've tried before that treats fouls by B that occur when the run ends behind the LOS as previous spot fouls. It may pass incoperated with fouls by A behind the LOS as previous spot also.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2022 VERSION
Post by: Ralph Damren on December 18, 2022, 06:58:38 AM
Thanks, GA Umpire & HLinNC, for your rsponses. To provide 'one limers' for each proposal  is sometimes a challange ,as to #13. The concern is that recievers are still being lit-up by d-backs as the pass arrives. This would allow only a wrap-up tackle for contact.

PS: We Mainers call the Restricted Area the 'moat' in memory of the moats that used to surround medieval castles. Moats we often filled with 'gaters,crocs' and the like, keeping bad knights away. Coaches moat can be filled with  ^flag ^flag ^flag ^flag ^flag penalty flags to keep wandering coaches away. :)
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2022 VERSION
Post by: HLinNC on December 18, 2022, 07:27:20 AM
#13- ok, got it now Ralph.  That detail helps.  I would agree that DB's are still intent on "separating the receiver from the ball" as our defensive minded friends would tell us.  They are going to argue back that puts the DB into a choice of trying to knock down the pass or make a tackle.

I'd be in favor of it but I foresee opposition.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2022 VERSION
Post by: NVFOA_Ump on December 18, 2022, 07:46:02 AM
(1) Failure to wear proper equipment = 1st, warning > 2nd  = 5 yards > 3rd = 15 yards USC > 4th & more = 15 yards USC + Disq.
     My preference - simply invite player to leave the field until problem addressed
(2) Any colored towels = OK
      OK
(3) Expand list of illegal equipment.
      Don't see real need
(4) Leaping OOB player is still OOB until landing IB.
      Yes
(5) Clock starts on RFP after OOB unless under 2 min. in half.
      OK but not much impact
(6) If K/A subs, R/B can sub prior to snap.
       Yes, "planned" late subs are an issue
(7) Forward fumble > OOB > spot of fumble.
       Yes
(8) Only the player that takes snap can legal IG.
      Yes
(9) After ball goes beyond LOS, can't have forward pass.
      Yes
(10) IG only LOD at spot.
        Yes
(11) Legalize 'pushing the pile'.
       No
(12) Legalize hurdling.
       No
(13) Strengthen 'defenseless player'.
        Could be improved
(14) Hands to the face = 15 yards.
        Yes, so we can call it what it is
(15) AFD/LOD if PF.
        No
(16) AFD if USC by B.
        No
(17) Coaches bail moat on RFP
        Yes
(18) Previous spot if foul by A behind LOS or by B if run ends behind LOS.
        No, I prefer the current rule or alternately make it Previous Spot but w/LOD
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2022 VERSION
Post by: refjeff on December 18, 2022, 02:34:35 PM
Santa has plenty of gifts (new rules proposals) for the upcoming year. I value your opinions and would enjoy hearing from them.

(1) Failure to wear proper equipment = 1st, warning > 2nd  = 5 yards > 3rd = 15 yards USC > 4th & more = 15 yards USC + Disq.

KISS  Stop the clock.  Send them out.  Let the coach handle it.

(2) Any colored towels = OK

No thank you. 

(3) Expand list of illegal equipment.

(4) Leaping OOB player is still OOB until landing IB.

(5) Clock starts on RFP after OOB unless under 2 min. in half.

Sure.  Speed it up.

(6) If K/A subs, R/B can sub prior to snap.

No.  1. Play defense with who you have on the filed.  2.  We don't have the extra eyes needed to track every offensive substitution.

(7) Forward fumble > OOB > spot of fumble.

I understand why, but this is so rare.  KISS

(8) Only the player that takes snap can legal IG.

Yes, if that is the same as other levels

(9) After ball goes beyond LOS, can't have forward pass.

(10) IG only LOD at spot.

No, leave it alone.

(11) Legalize 'pushing the pile'.

It's legal by interpretation in our state now.  Assisting the runner should be called a lot more though.

(12) Legalize hurdling.

Is it no longer a safety concern?

(13) Strengthen 'defenseless player'.

Not needed with BSB & UNR.

(14) Hands to the face = 15 yards.

As long as the ruling includes a forceful push not just touching.

(15) AFD/LOD if PF.

Not needed & not equitable.

(16) AFD if USC by B.

Not needed & not equitable.

(17) Coaches bail moat on RFP

There is no RFP signal on most plays and on many plays coaches are still calling the next play when the ball is spotted..

(18) Previous spot if foul by A behind LOS or by B if run ends behind LOS.

So if the runner is tackled by the face mask 5 yds. behind the LOS it becomes a 20 yd. penalty?  No thank you.

Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2022 VERSION
Post by: bossman72 on December 18, 2022, 07:55:51 PM
Yo, Bossman, thanks for your replies. #13 would be a foul if a D-back did more than play the ball or wrap-up tackle the reciever. We've added the  blindside block and targeting as fouls in our game without any noted change. I've proposed your suggestion that we've tried before that treats fouls by B that occur when the run ends behind the LOS as previous spot fouls. It may pass incoperated with fouls by A behind the LOS as previous spot also.

Ok, thanks for clarification on #13.  I don't think we should add a UNR to hitting a receiver from the blindside.  I think they are protected enough with the UNR, targeting, and blindside block rules.  We shouldn't try to legislate out all hard hits in the game.  It's impossible.  I think adding more to this rule will create many extra, unnecessary personal fouls and would likely not be uniformly enforced.  I can see this causing more confusion than the years where we added defenseless player definition with no penalty or rule associated to it.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2022 VERSION
Post by: dammitbobby on December 18, 2022, 10:41:50 PM
I'm obviously not NFHS, but I fully agree with bossman's reasoning on 13, and in facebook officiating groups, there are a great deal of NFHS officials who mistakenly believe this rule is already in place, from the number number of video posts and comments.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2022 VERSION
Post by: HLTN on December 19, 2022, 07:23:34 AM
1. Get rid of 5 yard face mask.
2. Fouls by A behind LOS enforced from previous spot.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2022 VERSION
Post by: Ralph Damren on December 19, 2022, 07:36:46 AM
Thanks for imput, Jeff, Bobby,Ump and HLTN. Removing the 5 yard FM isn't on the docket. Fouls by A behind the LOS and fouls by B when run ends behind the LOS is on the docket with a strong probably of passing. IMHO.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: SCHSref on December 19, 2022, 08:44:11 AM
(1) Failure to wear proper equipment = 1st, warning > 2nd  = 5 yards > 3rd = 15 yards USC > 4th & more = 15 yards USC + Disq.
I can ,live with this as long as it is equally enforced by all officials on the field and consistently throughout the year

(2) Any colored towels = OK
No. No yellow towels

(5) Clock starts on RFP after OOB unless under 2 min. in half.
Too much to keep up with in a 5 man crew

(6) If K/A subs, R/B can sub prior to snap.
WE don't have someone dedicated to that and if we did, the U would have to be quick to do this. Extremely difficult to faciliate in 5 man crew

(7) Forward fumble > OOB > spot of fumble.
NO

(8) Only the player that takes snap can legal IG.
I like it

(10) IG only LOD at spot.
Sure

(11) Legalize 'pushing the pile'.
This is currently done anyway with no calls. The rule is helping the runner with his initial charge

(14) Hands to the face = 15 yards.
We already call this as a PF in my state


(17) Coaches bail moat on RFP
YES YES YES...but there will be a huge learning curve...this is a safety issue

(18) Previous spot if foul by A behind LOS or by B if run ends behind LOS.
I'd be good either way
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2022 VERSION
Post by: AlUpstateNY on December 19, 2022, 02:48:27 PM
Thanks for imput, Jeff, Bobby,Ump and HLTN. Removing the 5 yard FM isn't on the docket. Fouls by A behind the LOS and fouls by B when run ends behind the LOS is on the docket with a strong probably of passing. IMHO.

Thinking about "motivation/encouragement" what would motivate an Offence blocker NOT to foul, if fouls committed deeper into the offensive backfield were enforced from the previous spot?  The consequence for fouling, further behind the line (when the defense is successfully causing retreat) is depriving the defense of successfully doing their job, and ENCOURAGING fouling.

5 yards and LOD is a misdemeanor, rather than 5, 10, 15, 20 yd loss FELONY (unless you're not caught).
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2022 VERSION
Post by: refjeff on December 19, 2022, 04:58:44 PM
Thinking about "motivation/encouragement" what would motivate an Offence blocker NOT to foul, if fouls committed deeper into the offensive backfield were enforced from the previous spot?  The consequence for fouling, further behind the line (when the defense is successfully causing retreat) is depriving the defense of successfully doing their job, and ENCOURAGING fouling.

5 yards and LOD is a misdemeanor, rather than 5, 10, 15, 20 yd loss FELONY (unless you're not caught).
No it's not.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2022 VERSION
Post by: AlUpstateNY on December 19, 2022, 06:53:02 PM
No it's not.

OK, what would you call minimizing/eliminating ADDITIONAL consequences for specific fouls?
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: Rich on December 19, 2022, 11:09:14 PM
Santa has plenty of gifts (new rules proposals) for the upcoming year. I value your opinions and would enjoy hearing from them.

(1) Failure to wear proper equipment = 1st, warning > 2nd  = 5 yards > 3rd = 15 yards USC > 4th & more = 15 yards USC + Disq.

No.  My God, no. I like the rule change that just went in here.  Send them off.

(2) Any colored towels = OK

Except flag and football colored, of course.

(3) Expand list of illegal equipment.

Not sure what this means.

(4) Leaping OOB player is still OOB until landing IB.

Yes.

(5) Clock starts on RFP after OOB unless under 2 min. in half.

Yes, please. This is easy to manage - wing stops clock, R starts it.  No different than a first down.

(6) If K/A subs, R/B can sub prior to snap.

Going to be hard to handle in 5-official crews. We already have the B doing the play clock, so a wing would likely have to signal the R here. I'd vote no.

(7) Forward fumble > OOB > spot of fumble.

Yes, and also run the clock here as it provides an advantage, potentially, to the offense.

(8) Only the player that takes snap can legal IG.

Solution in search of a problem.

(9) After ball goes beyond LOS, can't have forward pass.

Solution in search of a problem.

(10) IG only LOD at spot.

Difference between a 5 yard penalty and only LOD is minor.  Either is fine.

(11) Legalize 'pushing the pile'.

I don't see why not - it's already hard to get this called if a player isn't obviously pushing directly into the runner's back.

(12) Legalize hurdling.

No. A good safety rule that doesn't need to be altered.

(13) Strengthen 'defenseless player'.

Current definitions are fine.

(14) Hands to the face = 15 yards.

Yes, please. If not, please specifically consider a hands to the face penalty anyway, even if the yardage doesn't change.

(15) AFD/LOD if PF.

(16) AFD if USC by B.

Yes to the AFD, but no to LOD.  There's no reason these two provisions have to balance. A 15 yard penalty against the offense is a drive killer as it is.

(17) Coaches bail moat on RFP

(18) Previous spot if foul by A behind LOS or by B if run ends behind LOS.

Yes. I don't get why any official would think this would encourage more fouling. This assumes that kids actually do more than just play and try to block, which I don't believe.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: bama_stripes on December 20, 2022, 07:52:55 AM
(1) Failure to wear proper equipment = 1st, warning > 2nd  = 5 yards > 3rd = 15 yards USC > 4th & more = 15 yards USC + Disq.  No.  Current rule is sufficient.

(2) Any colored towels = OK.  Yes

(3) Expand list of illegal equipment.

(4) Leaping OOB player is still OOB until landing IB.  YES, YES, YES!

(5) Clock starts on RFP after OOB unless under 2 min. in half.  Yes

(6) If K/A subs, R/B can sub prior to snap.  NO! This would be a nightmare in a 5-man crew.

(7) Forward fumble > OOB > spot of fumble.  No

(8) Only the player that takes snap can legal IG.  Yes

(9) After ball goes beyond LOS, can't have forward pass.

(10) IG only LOD at spot.  No.

(11) Legalize 'pushing the pile'. No.

(12) Legalize hurdling.  NO. Safety rule.

(13) Strengthen 'defenseless player'.

(14) Hands to the face = 15 yards.  No. Already a PF.

(15) AFD/LOD if PF.  No

(16) AFD if USC by B.  No

(17) Coaches bail moat on RFP.  No

(18) Previous spot if foul by A behind LOS or by B if run ends behind LOS. YES YES YES
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2022 VERSION
Post by: refjeff on December 20, 2022, 08:21:38 AM
OK, what would you call minimizing/eliminating ADDITIONAL consequences for specific fouls?
Fair and reasonable.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: riffraft on December 20, 2022, 10:25:23 AM
(1) Failure to wear proper equipment = 1st, warning > 2nd  = 5 yards > 3rd = 15 yards USC > 4th & more = 15 yards USC + Disq.
too hard to track
(2) Any colored towels = OK
Sure
(3) Expand list of illegal equipment.
No thanks
(4) Leaping OOB player is still OOB until landing IB.
Would clear up an issue
(5) Clock starts on RFP after OOB unless under 2 min. in half.
Would rather have clock starts on the ready after an incomplete pass
(6) If K/A subs, R/B can sub prior to snap.
Doesn't seem to be an issue that I've seen
(7) Forward fumble > OOB > spot of fumble.
In my years haven't seen it as an issue
(8) Only the player that takes snap can legal IG.
Yes
(9) After ball goes beyond LOS, can't have forward pass.
Solution looking for a problem
(10) IG only LOD at spot.
sure
(11) Legalize 'pushing the pile'.
Not being called anyway
(12) Legalize hurdling.
No, player's safety
(13) Strengthen 'defenseless player'.
Not necessary
(14) Hands to the face = 15 yards.
Good clarification
(15) AFD/LOD if PF.
NO
(16) AFD if USC by B.
NO
(17) Coaches bail moat on RFP
In AZ coaches are good to get out of the moat before snap because we enforce the moat strictly, not necessary
(18) Previous spot if foul by A behind LOS or by B if run ends behind LOS.
No
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2022 VERSION
Post by: AlUpstateNY on December 20, 2022, 12:06:20 PM
Fair and reasonable.

REALLY? By any chance would you be a "woke" Public Defender?
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: dch on December 20, 2022, 01:23:49 PM
Thank you Ralph for giving us the opportunity to comment on potential Rules changes.

1.  Sounds complicated. I would like to see a P.O.E. to help re pants and pads covering the knees.  In Southern California this is totally ignored in high profile games by high profile officials.

2.  any colored towels -- yes.  would prefer a minimum of 6" width and a P.O.E. to get rid of streamers.  What about words, emblems pictures, logos, etc on the towel?

4.  Yes Please !!!  Players status re O.B. should be where he last touched the ground.  Just like basketball.

5.  No

6.  No  (difficult for officials to manage consistently re the play clock)

7.  I don't think bringing a fumble back to the spot is a necessary change.  What about fumble in the field of play into end zone and then OB? 

8.  Yes

9.  OK

10. --

11. Legalize pushing the pile.  An emphatic NO from me.  I don't like legalizing blasting opponents in the back.  If we are not going to call Helping the Runner (Rule 9-1) or Blocking in the Back (9-3-5) then we should mandate blowing it dead when and where the push begins.

12. Hurdling === Why?

13. No

14.  ---

15 & 16   No.    First downs should be earned not given.

17. Good luck enforcing that.  Do we want the flanks looking away from the field when the ball is ready for play.

18. No.

Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: Ralph Damren on December 20, 2022, 01:25:57 PM
While NCAA has had the RFP on OOB rule on starting the clock for several years with little or no problems, they also experimented for a short while with also cranking on RFP for incomplete passes. I'm a ECO at some D3 schools and worked that short try with glitches such as 4th down incomplete > COP > clock starting on RFP. Any of you working NCAA back then may thinck of more. IMHO, the NCAA track record on OOB>RFP shows it to be workable. It has been on the docket before but fell to those that felt the 2 minute timing adjustment might be too much of a problem. We've lived with 3-4-7 (offended team's clock choice w/i 2) for several years now, and haven't found a problem.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: ElvisLives on December 20, 2022, 02:38:37 PM
While NCAA has had the RFP on OOB rule on starting the clock for several years with little or no problems, they also experimented for a short while with also cranking on RFP for incomplete passes. I'm a ECO at some D3 schools and worked that short try with glitches such as 4th down incomplete > COP > clock starting on RFP. Any of you working NCAA back then may thinck of more. IMHO, the NCAA track record on OOB>RFP shows it to be workable. It has been on the docket before but fell to those that felt the 2 minute timing adjustment might be too much of a problem. We've lived with 3-4-7 (offended team's clock choice w/i 2) for several years now, and haven't found a problem.

I was on the field in FBS when the OOB / Start on the RFP signal change occurred. No, we had no issue making the transition, with respect to the 2-minute mark. We used the old baseball "two-out time play" signal - tapping the shoulder with two fingers, to remind ourselves we are under 2-minutes in the half, and to use 2-minute timing rules. Especially easy nowadays, with O2O.
The biggest problem you will have is the NCAA influence on re-starting the clock. Due to pressure from TV to fit games into their magic maximum 3-hour window, conferences are pressured to speed up games, and that pressure flows downhill to the coordinators, to make sure their officials are being as "efficient" as possible. As a result, you see dang near simultaneous stop/wind signals with OOB situations, and First Down situations.
The biggest 'optics' issue is that far too many sub-NCAA umpires simply do not hustle like they need to do to make working with a 40-second play clock work correctly. Team A has the right to snap the ball as quickly as the ball is made ready-for play (ball spotted, and officials in officiating position). If an umpire is taking his sweet time to wander over to the dead-ball spot, then take several seconds to spot the ball, the R may have already wound the clock before the ball is spotted. You shouldn't let that happen. You should issue strict instructions to your U's to HUSTLE, and strict instructions to your R's not to wind the clock until the ball is spotted and the U is out of the way.
Not sure what is prompting you to consider winding on the RFP after an OOB. Like NCAA, is this being prompted by TV? I just hope it isn't being pushed by officials that just want to the games to end more quickly. That's wrong.
The other problem you will have, if you do adopt the 'Wind on the RFP' is whether to 'wind AND whistle', or just 'wind.' For NCAA, Redding issued a bulletin back around 2012, when this started, that the R is to WHISTLE AND WIND. But, somewhere along the line, the cool kids elected to only wind (no whistle). For consistency, you will need to grab that bull by the horns, decide how you want this done, and issue a statement on that subject right from the beginning. Personally, I like a sharp, but quick, tweet, to let everybody know the ball is ready, because they won't necessarily be looking at me. However you choose to do it, make it clear in your manuals how you want it done, and get everybody doing it the same way.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2022 VERSION
Post by: refjeff on December 20, 2022, 05:41:12 PM
REALLY? By any chance would you be a "woke" Public Defender?

Ohhhh, so close.

Among other things, I'm an ultra-MAGA retired American History teacher.





Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: bossman72 on December 21, 2022, 09:18:20 AM
But, somewhere along the line, the cool kids elected to only wind (no whistle).

I think it was more to not draw attention to the fact that we are winding the clock before the U/C puts the ball down.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: bossman72 on December 21, 2022, 09:21:26 AM
For those of you saying some of these rule changes would be "not workable with a 5 man crew", mind you many of these are NCAA rules, which is what Europe uses.  They primarily work with 5 officials and have no problems administering these rules.  This is the same argument I got in a few years ago about the 40 sec clock.  Crew size has nothing to do with it.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2022 VERSION
Post by: AlUpstateNY on December 21, 2022, 09:45:38 AM
Ohhhh, so close.

Among other things, I'm an ultra-MAGA retired American History teacher.

You must have been one of those EXTREMELY FORTUNATE  teachers whose (every) students complete ALL their assignments "on time", alone, without EVER relying on unauthorized assistance, or short cuts. You might be surprised how focused, cunning and creative the average American teenager (athlete and/or Coach) has become, over the last 100+, or so, years.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: peterparsons on December 21, 2022, 09:52:57 AM
For those of you saying some of these rule changes would be "not workable with a 5 man crew", mind you many of these are NCAA rules, which is what Europe uses.  They primarily work with 5 officials and have no problems administering these rules.  This is the same argument I got in a few years ago about the 40 sec clock.  Crew size has nothing to do with it.

As a European official, I can confirm this. In fact, it's not uncommon in some countries to work crews of 4 (we do in the UK) and it's still not a problem.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: AlUpstateNY on December 21, 2022, 11:06:11 AM
As a European official, I can confirm this. In fact, it's not uncommon in some countries to work crews of 4 (we do in the UK) and it's still not a problem.

The reality is, that "crew size" is related to "level" , availability and "necessity".  8 man is more effective than 7,  7 man more effective than 6, all the way down to 4 man more effective than 3.  However, when circumstances dictate, even 2 man might become necessary, although awkward and far more ineffective, but depending on situation, preferable to cancellation. 

Eons ago, working Pop Warner games in Long Island (Nassau, Queens & Bklyn) when scheduled Sunday double headers were common.  Waiting in LI, for an official who had a morning game in Queens, and was late.  A game Commissioned started complaining about a missing official, I responded, "I hope he wasn't killed in a traffic accident rushing to get here" and suggested waiting a little longer.  After waiting a bit longer, we began with 3 men.  #4 showed up a little later, apologized stating traffic was horrible and we finished the game with 4. Weekend Long Island traffic has always sucked.

The world kept spinning on it's axis, there were no "calamities" in the game, which ended a few minutes later than expected, one team won and one team lost and "The beat went on" and we all went home to finish their weekend thankful for the experience.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: TampaSteve on December 21, 2022, 12:35:54 PM
most everything on the list I'm "yeah sure, I can work with that"
But number 5  I feel strongly about:
(5) Clock starts on RFP after OOB and INC unless under 2 min. in half.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: Ralph Damren on December 21, 2022, 01:16:23 PM
Steve : #5 is only for OOB plays, NCAA experimented with RFP on incomplete passes several years ago and it failed. ^no

Jeff : Being a former history teacher, they are five colleges that have in their alumni base both a U.S. President and a Super Bowl championship QB, I bet you can name 'em all  aWaRd :patrioticon: :).
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: PABJNR on December 21, 2022, 02:54:54 PM
Santa has plenty of gifts (new rules proposals) for the upcoming year. I value your opinions and would enjoy hearing from them.

(1) Failure to wear proper equipment = 1st, warning > 2nd  = 5 yards > 3rd = 15 yards USC > 4th & more = 15 yards USC + Disq.

     Are these assessed to the coach or the player? I like the send him off rule as it is currently

(2) Any colored towels = OK

Except yellow, I am not sure what the point is regarding the current rule that they all have to match


(3) Expand list of illegal equipment.
Not in favor, while we are at it can we loosen up the eye black rule, as long as nothing is written in or derogatory about the eye black

(4) Leaping OOB player is still OOB until landing IB.

In favor of this.

(5) Clock starts on RFP after OOB unless under 2 min. in half.

I'd be in favor of this

(6) If K/A subs, R/B can sub prior to snap.

I'd be in favor of this, but I understand this would be tougher to officiate in 5 man crews.

(7) Forward fumble > OOB > spot of fumble.

I would be in favor of this

(8) Only the player that takes snap can legal IG.

I'd be in favor of this, although I don't know how often this situation happened....this one wouldn't be high on my wish list

(9) After ball goes beyond LOS, can't have forward pass.

Don't think there is a need for this

(10) IG only LOD at spot.

Opposed to this change.

(11) Legalize 'pushing the pile'.

I can see more issues caused than solved with this rule change.

(12) Legalize hurdling.

No, if a player want to hurdle, they can run track in the spring.

(13) Strengthen 'defenseless player'.
IMHO the definition is strong enough already.

(14) Hands to the face = 15 yards.
Would like to see this specifically addressed as its own foul so there is not a debate between illegal use of hands or UNR.

(15) AFD/LOD if PF.
 I would be okay with this change for AFD, but please add clarity for what happens on a dead ball late hit following a 4th down play short of LTG. Would this proposed change be AFD or B's ball and penalty in this situation?  I would strongly be against LOD on the offense.

(16) AFD if USC by B.

Wouldn't care either way on this one, as long as question regarding what happens after 4th down is addressed.

(17) Coaches bail moat on RFP

If you're going to do this, just make it illegal for coaches to be in the white at all except for TO. With 40 second clock, the ball an be RFP really quick at times.

(18) Previous spot if foul by A behind LOS or by B if run ends behind LOS.

I'd be in favor of this

Please let me know your opinions. Thank you  tiphat:

 :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR:
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: Ralph Damren on December 21, 2022, 03:09:58 PM
Thanks, the colored towell is regarding matching with teammates. The AFD after a failed 4th down is challanging. To apply AFD after series will certainly be a strong discussion. Cinsidering AFD & LOD equal is a falsehood as AFD is not needed in 85% of the yime as the 15 yard penalty takes care of that while LOS is ALWAYS a los of down. Currently AFD penalties are only for roughing a defensless player (passer.kicker.snapper,holder). I would perfer to keep it like that.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: AlUpstateNY on December 21, 2022, 06:31:20 PM


Regarding #3, and amending the restrictions on "eye black", the current rule language applies "KISS" (Keep it simple, stupid) rather than deal with the "creativity" of the American teenager, which is boundless.

NFHS equipment rules apply to players between the age of 11/12 and 18/19, and rather than separate consideration for Freshman, Modified, JV and Varsity a single standard seems logical and practical.  Those athletes that pass on to higher levels are mature enough to assess risk and adapt as they decide (and higher level rules provide). 
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: bama_stripes on December 22, 2022, 07:38:42 AM
To apply AFD after series will certainly be a strong discussion.

Currently, once a series is over, possession changes and any DB PF or USC fouls are assessed as part of the new series.  I don’t see a need to change or clarify, but the rule could specify “live-ball personal fouls” if necessary.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: bossman72 on December 22, 2022, 09:00:10 AM
Thanks, the colored towell is regarding matching with teammates. The AFD after a failed 4th down is challanging. To apply AFD after series will certainly be a strong discussion. Cinsidering AFD & LOD equal is a falsehood as AFD is not needed in 85% of the yime as the 15 yard penalty takes care of that while LOS is ALWAYS a los of down. Currently AFD penalties are only for roughing a defensless player (passer.kicker.snapper,holder). I would perfer to keep it like that.

NCAA makes it a turnover on downs just like we do for NFHS.  So if on 4th down, the runner runs OOB short of the sticks and is late hit OOB, it's 1st and 10 for Team B and then Team B is penalized.  So, no real discussion to have.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: ElvisLives on December 22, 2022, 09:23:08 AM
NCAA makes it a turnover on downs just like we do for NFHS.  So if on 4th down, the runner runs OOB short of the sticks and is late hit OOB, it's 1st and 10 for Team B and then Team B is penalized.  So, no real discussion to have.

Let's be more accurate. When 4th down is over and Team A has failed to make the line to gain, the ball belongs to Team B at the dead-ball spot. If there is a dead-ball foul by Team B before the ball is declared ready-for-play for the next down, the distance penalty is enforced, and then the line-to gain is established, for Team B's series (1/10) at that point.
I've had this happen about 6 times in my career. And, on almost every one, Team A thinks they should keep the ball with a new first down after the penalty. Sorry. It doesn't work that way. You didn't make the line-to-gain. Next down. Team B would next put the ball in play, with or without the dead-ball foul. With the dead-ball foul, they'll simply put it in play 15 yards behind the dead-ball spot, 1/10.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: Ralph Damren on December 22, 2022, 01:34:21 PM
A simplistic way of looking at it is: The legal play had ended before the illegal act had begun.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: refjeff on December 22, 2022, 04:24:00 PM
Steve : #5 is only for OOB plays, NCAA experimented with RFP on incomplete passes several years ago and it failed. ^no

Jeff : Being a former history teacher, they are five colleges that have in their alumni base both a U.S. President and a Super Bowl championship QB, I bet you can name 'em all  aWaRd :patrioticon: :).
GREAT trivia question.

Three I knew right away.

Stanford - Herbert Hoover, John Elway, Jim Plunkett

Naval Academy - Jimmy Carter & Roger Staubach

MIchigan -Gerald Ford & Tom Brady


One I had to figure out.  Who went to the same college as Big Ben?

Miami (of Ohio)  Ben Roethlisberger & Benjamin Harrison


This one I had to look up.

Delaware - Joe Biden & Joe Flaco

Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: Ralph Damren on December 23, 2022, 06:52:51 AM
GREAT trivia question.

Three I knew right away.

Stanford - Herbert Hoover, John Elway, Jim Plunkett

Naval Academy - Jimmy Carter & Roger Staubach

MIchigan -Gerald Ford & Tom Brady


One I had to figure out.  Who went to the same college as Big Ben?

Miami (of Ohio)  Ben Roethlisberger & Benjamin Harrison


This one I had to look up.

Delaware - Joe Biden & Joe Flaco

GREAT JOB, JEFF aWaRd , The challanging ones were "Big Ben'" and "Little Ben" (Harrison was only 5"4') and "Old Joe" and   Joe. tiphat:
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: refjeff on December 23, 2022, 09:59:15 AM
Regarding #3, and amending the restrictions on "eye black", the current rule language applies "KISS" (Keep it simple, stupid) rather than deal with the "creativity" of the American teenager, which is boundless.

NFHS equipment rules apply to players between the age of 11/12 and 18/19, and rather than separate consideration for Freshman, Modified, JV and Varsity a single standard seems logical and practical.  Those athletes that pass on to higher levels are mature enough to assess risk and adapt as they decide (and higher level rules provide).
Never mind.

It's the Christmas season.

I'll let it go.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: CalhounLJ on December 23, 2022, 03:41:59 PM
Never mind.

It's the Christmas season.

I'll let it go.
(https://media4.giphy.com/media/8cuRGf4TVrTLSGo2Gl/giphy.gif)


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: JasonTX on December 23, 2022, 07:19:52 PM
Keep going and we'll need to merge this section with the NCAA section.   ;D
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: AlUpstateNY on December 24, 2022, 09:41:04 AM
Keep going and we'll need to merge this section with the NCAA section.   ;D

No matter how hard we may try, Apples are always going to taste different than Cheese Cake, which may be why a lot of great chefs started learning to bake Apple pies before progressing to fancy Cheese Cakes.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: Rich on December 26, 2022, 02:41:30 PM
You should issue strict instructions to your U's to HUSTLE, and strict instructions to your R's not to wind the clock until the ball is spotted and the U is out of the way.

This is what we do on first downs, although I will adjust during wet weather to when the U is holding the ball under a towel (which we will do until the offense comes up to the line).

Not sure what is prompting you to consider winding on the RFP after an OOB. Like NCAA, is this being prompted by TV? I just hope it isn't being pushed by officials that just want to the games to end more quickly. That's wrong.
The other problem you will have, if you do adopt the 'Wind on the RFP' is whether to 'wind AND whistle', or just 'wind.' For NCAA, Redding issued a bulletin back around 2012, when this started, that the R is to WHISTLE AND WIND. But, somewhere along the line, the cool kids elected to only wind (no whistle).

We've had more than a third of our games exceed 2:45 the last two seasons. Frankly, I think most of this is due to more passing and incomplete passes, but even if this helps a little.....many teams have kids playing both ways and there's little desire to play almost 3 hour games.

Currently, mechanics call for a whistle-less wind after a first down with the 40 second play clock, but the truth is, I assess the ability of the clock operator -- we have so many that simply aren't paying attention or they're focused on adjusting the down/distance/yard line that they aren't looking at me. For them, it's a short blast on the wind and me trying to have patience with the clock operator.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: ilyazhito on December 26, 2022, 04:46:19 PM
NCAA makes it a turnover on downs just like we do for NFHS.  So if on 4th down, the runner runs OOB short of the sticks and is late hit OOB, it's 1st and 10 for Team B and then Team B is penalized.  So, no real discussion to have.
I agree. That is why the automatic first down provision has the caveat "if not in conflict with other rules". In most cases, a defensive penalty does result in an automatic first down in NCAA rules (e.g. DPI on an interception, RPS on an incomplete pass, FMM on a run). If there is a conflict in rules (one penalty with an automatic first down occurs together with a penalty by the offense (RPS and OH)), then the appropriate rules are followed, such as offsetting penalties in the example above. If NFHS was to incorporate similar language (Automatic first down for B and R fouls if not in conflict with other rules), then we would have an easy way to implement them without devolving into casuistry.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: HLinNC on December 27, 2022, 08:27:21 AM
Quote
Currently, mechanics call for a whistle-less wind after a first down with the 40 second play clock, but the truth is, I assess the ability of the clock operator -- we have so many that simply aren't paying attention or they're focused on adjusting the down/distance/yard line that they aren't looking at me. For them, it's a short blast on the wind and me trying to have patience with the clock operator.

This  ^^^^^

2021- working p/t as a WH, late season game, a little bit of a breeze and light rain showers, could have been much colder than it was.  PCO isn't starting play clock until the umpire puts the ball down.  Fine, we'll live with it....until we have an incomplete pass.  "Oh good Lord, we'll never get out of here."  I finally realized that if I chopped and tooted, he would run it on me so I had to revert back to old clock mechanics.

2022- now a f/t WH, back at the same school in September.  Lo and behold, we have the same play clock issues.  I go over to the home coach/AD - "Geez, we're never going to get out of here at this rate."  HC- "I know.  My regular clock guy went to Florida"  I started to ask if he only went to Florida when I was assigned as R but thought better of it.  I went back to old clock mechanics and we survived.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: CalhounLJ on December 27, 2022, 08:39:54 AM
This  ^^^^^

2021- working p/t as a WH, late season game, a little bit of a breeze and light rain showers, could have been much colder than it was.  PCO isn't starting play clock until the umpire puts the ball down.  Fine, we'll live with it....until we have an incomplete pass.  "Oh good Lord, we'll never get out of here."  I finally realized that if I chopped and tooted, he would run it on me so I had to revert back to old clock mechanics.

2022- now a f/t WH, back at the same school in September.  Lo and behold, we have the same play clock issues.  I go over to the home coach/AD - "Geez, we're never going to get out of here at this rate."  HC- "I know.  My regular clock guy went to Florida"  I started to ask if he only went to Florida when I was assigned as R but thought better of it.  I went back to old clock mechanics and we survived.
I always make it a point during pregame to talk to both clock operators. Have not had a problem getting them on board.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: AlUpstateNY on December 27, 2022, 10:07:52 AM
I always make it a point during pregame to talk to both clock operators. Have not had a problem getting them on board.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Don't mean to be redundant, but more than 60 years ago, when Field clocks were a shiney new gadget, our Officials org decided maintaining game time was an Official's responsibility and refused to relinquish that control.  Despite a lot of growling, we've maintained responsibility for that function ever since, and it has proved to be a blessing and has avoided a lot of needless nonsense since.  We are ever grateful to those "old timers".

Now, it's really simple a trained member of CDFOA runs the game clock, either from the booth, or from the field. Same is now true, with the advent of the "Play clock", which if associated with a field Play clock is run by a 2nd Clock, which is operated by a 2nd Official (either on the field or in the booth.  Neither Clock Operator is responsible for other Field Clock operations (although we'll maintain display of score).  Most schools provide their own scoreboard operator to handle down/distance and other features for Team/Spectator benefit.

We are truly blessed, and thankful, for/by those predecessors who decided "that was the way it WILL BE, and dealt with complaints during those early years, although the addition of a visible "Play Clock" has resurrected some whining.  In the grand scheme of things, issues, complaints, problems with timing factors are minimal, if not virtually nonexistent.  Our "Clock Operators" are part of the Official Crew, dress like the rest of the crew, arrive & depart from the field together. 

An "Official" Clock Operator/Timer is standard for all HS levels (Modified/Freshman, JV, Varsity) if a scoreboard clock is to be used, or time is maintained on the field by a member of the crew.  The same holds true for the various "Youth Level" leagues (although those complaints/arguments lasted a bit longer than HS's).

In addition to eliminating a basket full of complaints, handling "Timing" responsibilities as an Officiating Crew duty, it also provides terrific training opportunity for new(er) Officials, as well as extended career opportunity for senior officials.

Old habits are ALWAYS harder to break, and we are truly grateful to those former members who had the vision to anticipate unnecessary problems,  and the backbone to face them, long ago.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: BIG UMP on December 27, 2022, 01:55:18 PM
(1) Failure to wear proper equipment = 1st, warning > 2nd  = 5 yards > 3rd = 15 yards USC > 4th & more = 15 yards USC + Disq.
No too much to keep up with

(2) Any colored towels = OK
Yes

(3) Expand list of illegal equipment.
No

(4) Leaping OOB player is still OOB until landing IB.
Just clarify definition

(5) Clock starts on RFP after OOB unless under 2 min. in half.
Fine cuts game time

(6) If K/A subs, R/B can sub prior to snap.
No, too many would miss this and cause all kinds of problems

(7) Forward fumble > OOB > spot of fumble.
I can live with this

(8) Only the player that takes snap can legal IG.
Either is good.

(9) After ball goes beyond LOS, can't have forward pass.
Leave it alone

(10) IG only LOD at spot.
NF is fine.

(11) Legalize 'pushing the pile'.
Define assisting the runner, where it is legal

(12) Legalize hurdling.
No

(13) Strengthen 'defenseless player'.

(14) Hands to the face = 15 yards.
Illegal use of hands, add it

(15) AFD/LOD if PF.
No

(16) AFD if USC by B.
No

(17) Coaches bail moat on RFP
Define eminent snap at coaches meeting, then enforce.

(18) Previous spot if foul by A behind LOS or by B if run ends behind LOS.
Yes
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: jason on December 28, 2022, 10:52:04 AM
(1) Failure to wear proper equipment = 1st, warning > 2nd  = 5 yards > 3rd = 15 yards USC > 4th & more = 15 yards USC + Disq.
No. Put this responsibility on coaches, not officials.

(2) Any colored towels = OK
Yes, please.

(3) Expand list of illegal equipment.
No

(4) Leaping OOB player is still OOB until landing IB.
Yes. Tired of the what-if questions.

(5) Clock starts on RFP after OOB unless under 2 min. in half.
No. The 25/40 change made a big enough impact.

(6) If K/A subs, R/B can sub prior to snap.
No. There are maybe 1% of HS teams that have the specialized players and roster size for this to be impactful. For HS it doesn't make sense.

(7) Forward fumble > OOB > spot of fumble.
No. "That's the way the ball bounces."

(8) Only the player that takes snap can legal IG.
No. The point of the rule is safety, and it applies to all potential passers.

(9) After ball goes beyond LOS, can't have forward pass.
Yes. Close the loop-hole.

(10) IG only LOD at spot.
No. If the offense doesn't like it, don't commit the foul.

(11) Legalize 'pushing the pile'.
Yes. Change the definitions to make it fit.

(12) Legalize hurdling.
No. Safety.

(13) Strengthen 'defenseless player'.
No.

(14) Hands to the face = 15 yards.
No. It's already implied.

(15) AFD/LOD if PF.
No

(16) AFD if USC by B.
No

(17) Coaches bail moat on RFP
No. The coaches play a game with this rule because they know we don't want to flag it, but won't leave until we do flag it. Then they yell, "Watch the game!" or something similar, when the entire time they knew they weren't supposed to be there.

(18) Previous spot if foul by A behind LOS or by B if run ends behind LOS.
No
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: Ralph Damren on December 28, 2022, 12:54:05 PM
Thanks to the 15 guys that have responded. Note, not all questions were answered by everyone. Here are the current results :
                               
(1)  1-14
(2) 11-4
(3)  2-7
(4) 12-0
(5) 12-3
(6)  2-10

(7) 6-8
(8) 9-4
(9) 5-6
(10) 5-7
(11) 4-11
(12) 0-15

(13) 3-7
(14) 11-3
(15) 2-13
(16) 5-9
(17) 6-5
(18) 7-8

Numbers 7, 9, 10, 17, and 18 are within 2 votes of an opinion change. Any further comments on these ? Our meeting is Jan. 8-10 and I'll print and bring your responses as they come in hany by providing valid responses during the debates. Thanks again, and please keep responding.

 tiphat:
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: tankferguson on December 29, 2022, 09:44:40 AM
Hi Ralph,
No for numbers 1, 5,6, 9,10,11,12,14,15,16,17, and 18

Yes for numbers 2, 4, 7, 8, 13

Thanks for asking, and Happy New Year!  Ferg
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: Ralph Damren on December 29, 2022, 09:47:11 AM
Hi Ralph,
No for numbers 1, 5,6, 9,10,11,12,14,15,16,17, and 18

Yes for numbers 2, 4, 7, 8, 13

Thanks for asking, and Happy New Year!  Ferg
Thanks for answering, and Happy New Year ! Ralph
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: Ralph Damren on December 29, 2022, 09:51:19 AM
AND, OH BY THE WAY....

HAPPY NEW YEAR, ONE AND ALL  tiphat:

((I,LL BE AWAY FROM MY TRUSTY DESK TOP OLE' DELL UNTIL 2013  eAt& yEs: :thumbup


OLE' MAINER NEW YEAR'S EVE SAYING: " 'Tis better to have a bottle in front of me that a frontal lobotomy, ayuh 'spect so "  pi1eOn
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: bama_stripes on December 29, 2022, 05:28:29 PM

((I,LL BE AWAY FROM MY TRUSTY DESK TOP OLE' DELL UNTIL 2013  eAt& yEs:

Goin’ somewhere in your Wayback Machine?  nAnA
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: Ralph Damren on January 04, 2023, 07:00:01 AM
Felt you guys might find interest in some info from the questionnaire......

The majority of officials were happy with all of last year's  changes. (Part I)

45% of officials felt that running into a coach was still a problem (Part II)

All new proposals were favored by officials. Coaches didnt always agree...Starting clock on RFP after OOB = Coaches 25% YES, 75% NO; Officials 76% YES, 24% NO.

Scoreboard on # of officials responding from states...

OHIO  1124    aWaRd aWaRd aWaRd aWaRd
IL.       674      aWaRd aWaRd aWaRd
MICH.  663          aWaRd aWaRd
FL.       559                aWaRd           

....Maine  38                  pi1eOn


Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: bama_stripes on January 04, 2023, 07:21:23 AM
The coaches’ responses bear out what I’ve thought for a long time:  Coaches and players don’t give a fig about how long a game lasts.  It’s (usually) Friday, and there’s no school the next day.  This is their time on the big stage and a chance to show off their talents.

I hate a 3-hour game as much as the next guy, but I’m not sure they’re wrong.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: AlUpstateNY on January 04, 2023, 12:32:48 PM
The coaches’ responses bear out what I’ve thought for a long time:  Coaches and players don’t give a fig about how long a game lasts.  It’s (usually) Friday, and there’s no school the next day.  This is their time on the big stage and a chance to show off their talents.

I hate a 3-hour game as much as the next guy, but I’m not sure they’re wrong.

The same limited culprits have usually been responsible for unusually long, or slow moving games, at the HS level,: player injuries, unnecessary delays after COP, post scoring KO setup delay situations, assorted issues with game management (slow chain relocation, game ball retrieval, excessive charged TO duration, totally unique, whacky (game specific) situations.  The "play clock" solutions, although incorporating correction/adjustment of these, sometimes persistent issues, in and of itself, hasn't accomplished all that much (at the HS level) that couldn't have been directly and effectively addressed by instituting/managing those "game management" problems, alone, at FAR LESS cost & confusion than updating a zillion HS scoreboards.

Aside from field injuries legitimately requiring sometimes (necessary) lengthy interruptions, the accompanying adjustments applied to "game management" corrections seem far more responsible for maintaining consistent overall length of game time, than the visible necessity of "play timing".
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: Snapper on January 05, 2023, 07:15:30 AM
Santa has plenty of gifts (new rules proposals) for the upcoming year. I value your opinions and would enjoy hearing from them.

(1) Failure to wear proper equipment = 1st, warning > 2nd  = 5 yards > 3rd = 15 yards USC > 4th & more = 15 yards USC + Disq.
No

(2) Any colored towels = OK
OK, don't care.  Just not ball colored.

(3) Expand list of illegal equipment.
No.  Not sure what else needs covering?  Half the rule changes always seem to be about uniforms or numbers anyway.

(4) Leaping OOB player is still OOB until landing IB.
Yes.  Make it like NCAA and basketball, your status in or out is where you left the ground until you reestablish.

(5) Clock starts on RFP after OOB unless under 2 min. in half.
I'm OK with that, but don't feel strongly that it's needed.  High school games seem a bit long nowadays, so some timing adjustment is probably ok.

(6) If K/A subs, R/B can sub prior to snap.
No, not necessary for most high school games.

(7) Forward fumble > OOB > spot of fumble.
Yes

(8) Only the player that takes snap can legal IG.
A very firm YES.  Should have been written that way in the first place.

(9) After ball goes beyond LOS, can't have forward pass.
Yes

(10) IG only LOD at spot.
Yes

(11) Legalize 'pushing the pile'.
Yes

(12) Legalize hurdling.
Yes.  But then put in the college "leaping" rule.

(13) Strengthen 'defenseless player'.
Unsure what they mean by strengthening it?  To be totally honest, I don't know what the high school defenseless player rule states.  I just use the college's if I work or observe a game.  And then I just keep in mind that TGT is not an automatic DQ in HS.

(14) Hands to the face = 15 yards.
Yes, absolutely.

(15) AFD/LOD if PF.
Yes to AFD.  No to LOD.

(16) AFD if USC by B.
Yes

(17) Coaches bail moat on RFP
No.

(18) Previous spot if foul by A behind LOS or by B if run ends behind LOS.
Yes.  A hold behind the line in high school most times kills a drive, and I don't think that's fair.  There should be a chance to dig themselves out of a 10 yd hole.

Please let me know your opinions. Thank you  tiphat:

 :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR:

Thanks Ralph.  Travel safe to your meeting!
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: ncwingman on January 05, 2023, 12:18:32 PM
(1) No.
(2) Yes.
(3) Is there something specific that's not being called? If so add that, but don't make the list longer just for something to do.
(4) Yes.
(5) No. In areas without officials as clock operators, it's already a fight to get them to stay with the current rules. I don't want to make things more complicated.
(6) No. Solution in search of a problem. It's not an issue that I've seen.
(7) Sure, why not. Not urgent to fix, but I understand why.
(8) Yes.
(9) No.
(10) Yes.
(11) Yes? Pushing the pile is never called as assisting the runner anyway.
(12) No.
(13) Eh, how? It might be better served as a POE, reminding people that "Hey, these scenarios are defenseless players, so you should be calling it that way"
(14) Yes. The lack of any explicit "Hands to the face" penalty is a bit odd, in my mind.
(15) LOD for PF? No. No. No. You want to skip a down? That's how you'll get people skipping downs. I get AFD for PF makes things "inequitable", but what of a dead ball PF? After 3rd down, A50 punches B56. A50 is ejected, 15 yards back, 3rd down counts since dead ball... and loss of down, so they lose 4th and it's a turnover on downs? Of course not, but somebody's going to enforce it that way. In my mind, LOD should be restricted to illegally advancing the ball (illegal touching, IFP, handing).
(16) AFD for PF/USC by B? I'd be okay with yes, but I'm not going to lobby hard for it.
(17) Sure, but it's another rule that won't be enforced consistently. Around me, there's a bunch of coaches that aren't in the restricted area then because they're on the field... but that's a different rant.
(18) Yes, yes, yes.

Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: Ralph Damren on January 06, 2023, 07:04:32 AM
Thanks again, guys, for your imput. They've expanded my ability to debate the proposals as they are presented. I authored one change : If B fouls on running plays that end behind the LOS the previous spot would be the enforcement spot. It may end up tied to previous spot enforcement of A fouls behind the LOS (excepting IG, in EZ, IK & IB). I'll also propose two POEs : "Who put the free-kick OOB ??"- a debate that we've have had here several times and " Don't smile on pushing the pile" -forward progress stops when the push begins. A laundry list of POEs are presented and a show of hands picks the three most popular. I would welcome any thoughts you may have on those two topics.

 :bOW :thumbup :thumbup :thumbup :thumbup :thumbup :bOW  tiphat: Ralph
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: AlUpstateNY on January 06, 2023, 10:17:17 AM
Thanks again, guys, for your imput. They've expanded my ability to debate the proposals as they are presented. I authored one change : If B fouls on running plays that end behind the LOS the previous spot would be the enforcement spot. It may end up tied to previous spot enforcement of A fouls behind the LOS (excepting IG, in EZ, IK & IB). I'll also propose two POEs : "Who put the free-kick OOB ??"- a debate that we've have had here several times and " Don't smile on pushing the pile" -forward progress stops when the push begins. A laundry list of POEs are presented and a show of hands picks the three most popular. I would welcome any thoughts you may have on those two topics.

 :bOW :thumbup :thumbup :thumbup :thumbup :thumbup :bOW  tiphat: Ralph

I know this is redundant, but please express the UNFAIR DISADVANTAGE to "B" who has created the need for "A" to choose fouling, because they (A) have been unable to thwart "B's" legitimate effort in forcing "A" to retreat to be able to continue the play they (A) chose to execute.

Changing the enforcement to previous spot, will ONLY encourage "A" to continue retreating (endlessly) by removing the consequence of doing so, while encouraging "A" to foul (without ANY additional consequence) for doing so. 

It was ENTIRELY "A's" choice to call a play that provided an escape plan when their designed action failed, providing "B" with an UNFAIR disadvantage created by ignoring their legitimate effort to redirect/negate the original plan CALLED FOR by "A".
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: Rich on January 06, 2023, 03:24:54 PM
I know this is redundant, but please express the UNFAIR DISADVANTAGE to "B" who has created the need for "A" to choose fouling, because they (A) have been unable to thwart "B's" legitimate effort in forcing "A" to retreat to be able to continue the play they (A) chose to execute.

Changing the enforcement to previous spot, will ONLY encourage "A" to continue retreating (endlessly) by removing the consequence of doing so, while encouraging "A" to foul (without ANY additional consequence) for doing so. 

It was ENTIRELY "A's" choice to call a play that provided an escape plan when their designed action failed, providing "B" with an UNFAIR disadvantage created by ignoring their legitimate effort to redirect/negate the original plan CALLED FOR by "A".

10 yards is a consequence. Declining the penalty on a play that loses more than 10 yards is a consequence.

The one that I have always believed needed fixed is the play where A is pulled down behind the line by the facemask.  Allowing B to keep that yardage before enforcement of the penalty has never seemed right to me.

So I would be very happy to see both A and B fouls use the previous spot as an enforcement spot.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: refjeff on January 06, 2023, 03:43:44 PM
Thanks again, guys, for your imput. They've expanded my ability to debate the proposals as they are presented. I authored one change : If B fouls on running plays that end behind the LOS the previous spot would be the enforcement spot. It may end up tied to previous spot enforcement of A fouls behind the LOS (excepting IG, in EZ, IK & IB). I'll also propose two POEs : "Who put the free-kick OOB ??"- a debate that we've have had here several times and " Don't smile on pushing the pile" -forward progress stops when the push begins. A laundry list of POEs are presented and a show of hands picks the three most popular. I would welcome any thoughts you may have on those two topics.

 
I see no reason to end pushing the pile.  Forward progress hasn't stopped and I've never seen anyone get hurt. 

If there is statistical evidence of increased injury let's see it.

And I see no way of calling it without being completely arbitrary.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: AlUpstateNY on January 06, 2023, 03:56:16 PM
I see no reason to end pushing the pile.  Forward progress hasn't stopped and I've never seen anyone get hurt. 

If there is statistical evidence of increased injury let's see it.

And I see no way of calling it without being completely arbitrary.

Forward progress applies to the RUNNER's progress, "Pushing the pile" suggests to motion being provided by others (often lots of people).  If the force advancing the runner is judged to be provided by the runner, it's still FP,  if not, the play has ended, and the continued force being applied can be very dangerous.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: refjeff on January 06, 2023, 04:17:56 PM
Forward progress applies to the RUNNER's progress, "Pushing the pile" suggests to motion being provided by others (often lots of people).  If the force advancing the runner is judged to be provided by the runner, it's still FP,  if not, the play has ended, and the continued force being applied can be very dangerous.
2.15.1 says advancement of the ball ... in a runner's possession. It doesn't say anything about who is supplying the locomotion.

We could make something up and say the runner has to be supplying the force, but it doesn't say that, and there's really no reason to make it up.

 "is judged to be provided by the runner,"  Like I said, completely arbitrary, and thus causing no end of complaints.  For what purpose?

"Could be very dangerous." If there is statistical evidence of increased injury let's see it.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: bama_stripes on January 06, 2023, 07:18:01 PM
The one that I have always believed needed fixed is the play where A is pulled down behind the line by the facemask.  Allowing B to keep that yardage before enforcement of the penalty has never seemed right to me.

Especially when you consider the big difference in enforcement if it’s a running play vs a loose-ball play.  Makes no sense whatsoever.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: Ralph Damren on January 07, 2023, 07:12:21 AM
Especially when you consider the big difference in enforcement if it’s a running play vs a loose-ball play.  Makes no sense whatsoever.
I've been a strong proponnent of this and have submitted a change (with Bossman's help)  several times. My interest was kindled late last centuary by this event.....

SCENE: Brunswick Dragons were coming up to play the Bangor Rams. The Dragon coach had spent a couple of years on the NY Giant taxi squad.
ACT I : Early in the game the Dragon QB was scrambling and tackled by FM 18 yds. behind LOS.

ACT II : After  sNiCkErS ump's stroll, ball was placed 3 yds. behind LOS  :o ???

ACT III :   :!# the giant Dragon coach  :!# called TO to  :puke: to ask : "THAT CAN'T BE RIGHT ???
            I explained : "Well, you got the down back, and only lost 3 in lieu of 18  ::)" :-[

ACT IV : In the 2nd half Ram QB was scrambling , was tackled 10 yds. behind LOS AND FUMBLED. The defense recovered  but knew they couldn't keep the ball. Being a loose ball play , I sent  sNiCkErS Mr. Umpire  sNiCkErS on his journey from the previous spot.  ::)

ACT V : I felt the giant Dragon coach  would need an explaination and approached...
             ME : "I want to explain the difference.... yEs: "
             COACH : " ;D I know the difference , this is the HOME QB  ;D "
             ME : " ;) Not really, on  hEaDbAnG this play, the fumble made it.....  hEaDbAnG "
             COACH : " Would you agree that it's a lousy rule  ???. "
             ME: "Yes, in this situation it is  yEs: ."
             COACH : "Well, we're behind 30-0 because we can't tackle, block, run, pass or kick...not because of a lousy rule.
             You guys are doing a good job, keep it up  :thumbup."

FOOTNOTE : In my daze of youth, mom said one could get away with saying things with a smile  ;D, that you couldn't  if said with a frown or growl  >:( :puke:.

EPILOGUE : Over the next few years, at our coaches clinic the giant Dragon coach would ask : "  YOU FIXED THAT LOUSY RULE YET  ;) ?" I would reply : " NOT YET COACH, still trying  8] "

FORCAST : I feel it will pass this year, but the giant Dragon coach has retired.  :sTiR:
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: CalhounLJ on January 07, 2023, 08:34:39 AM
10 yards is a consequence. Declining the penalty on a play that loses more than 10 yards is a consequence.

The one that I have always believed needed fixed is the play where A is pulled down behind the line by the facemask.  Allowing B to keep that yardage before enforcement of the penalty has never seemed right to me.

So I would be very happy to see both A and B fouls use the previous spot as an enforcement spot.
I’ve never understood why allowing B to keep the yardage he has caused A to lose is a big deal. With the ABO, we let A do it all the time.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: dammitbobby on January 07, 2023, 10:23:33 AM
Because B's foul almost, if not always deprives A of the opportunity to gain some of those yards back.
Title: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: CalhounLJ on January 07, 2023, 10:24:58 AM
Because B's foul almost, if not always deprives A of the opportunity to gain some of those yards back.
But they get the yardage back on the penalty enforcement. No? Plus A gets the down back.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: CalhounLJ on January 07, 2023, 10:32:12 AM
But they get the yardage back on the penalty enforcement. No? Plus A gets the down back.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Take a facemask 10yds deep as an example. To bring that up to previous spot and mark it off from there gives A a 25 yard gain plus a new set of downs in most cases. Marking it off from the spot of foul or end run only gives the 15 and a replay, while still giving B credit for causing the 10 yd loss.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: dammitbobby on January 07, 2023, 11:32:12 AM
I definitely see your point.  But, it becomes a question of, what would A have gotten, had they not been fouled?  I'm not Fed (obviously) but one common refrain I have seen in this discussion (and others) is giving B credit for a good play behind the line, but when there's a foul involved, IMO that 'good play' gets wiped out.  You don't get 10 yards of yardage credit for a facemask foul 10 yards behind the line, because you didn't get that yardage cleanly.  JMO.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: Ralph Damren on January 07, 2023, 11:56:25 AM
IMHO, the ABO application will still be alive and kicking (flagging) on running plays BEYOND the LOS and after COP. I've proposed the previous spot enforcement on fouls by B when the run ends behind the LOS , this time it will be considered along with A fouls behind the LOS which has strong support. IMHO, it defies logic to give a better result to a QB who fumbles the ball than one who hangs onto it. Our NY Giant taxi-squad Dragon coach
(from above war story) also agrees  yEs: yEs:
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: CalhounLJ on January 07, 2023, 07:43:32 PM
I definitely see your point.  But, it becomes a question of, what would A have gotten, had they not been fouled?  I'm not Fed (obviously) but one common refrain I have seen in this discussion (and others) is giving B credit for a good play behind the line, but when there's a foul involved, IMO that 'good play' gets wiped out.  You don't get 10 yards of yardage credit for a facemask foul 10 yards behind the line, because you didn't get that yardage cleanly.  JMO.
Yeah I get it, but why didn’t B get the ten yard loss before the foul cleanly? A retreated 10 yards behind the line either under duress or voluntarily BEFORE B fouled. That’s on them. Why give them the extra benefit? It’s like we bail A out of a bad play and then tack the foul yardage on.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: bossman72 on January 07, 2023, 10:25:42 PM
IMHO, the ABO application will still be alive and kicking (flagging) on running plays BEYOND the LOS and after COP. I've proposed the previous spot enforcement on fouls by B when the run ends behind the LOS , this time it will be considered along with A fouls behind the LOS which has strong support. IMHO, it defies logic to give a better result to a QB who fumbles the ball than one who hangs onto it. Our NY Giant taxi-squad Dragon coach
(from above war story) also agrees  yEs: yEs:

I think an important part of this rule is to make runs that end behind the LOS have the basic spot as the previous spot.  So essentially, the end of the run (or basic spot) can never be behind the LOS.
This could also clean up definitions and therefore make loose ball plays only happen during a legal pass or kick.  Simple.  Easy.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: NVFOA_Ump on January 08, 2023, 08:10:21 AM
I think an important part of this rule is to make runs that end behind the LOS have the basic spot as the previous spot.  So essentially, the end of the run (or basic spot) can never be behind the LOS.
This could also clean up definitions and therefore make loose ball plays only happen during a legal pass or kick.  Simple.  Easy.

I've got no problem with this but my thought would be that we should not replay the down if the foul is by team A behind the line.  As part of the penalty enforcement let the down count and IMHO that better balances out the interplay between B potentially being denied a significant loss of yardage play and A having an insurmountable line to gain distance if enforced from the spot of the foul.  IMHO that's a fair tradeoff.  :sTiR:
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: AlUpstateNY on January 08, 2023, 10:14:42 AM
I think an important part of this rule is to make runs that end behind the LOS have the basic spot as the previous spot.  So essentially, the end of the run (or basic spot) can never be behind the LOS.
This could also clean up definitions and therefore make loose ball plays only happen during a legal pass or kick.  Simple.  Easy.

But not "fair" to B.

1. A CHOSE to design & run a play, that involved retreating, to counter B.
2. the chosen play FAILED as B was able to contact A behind the line.
3. to prevent, or avoid, loss from that contact, A CHOSE to foul.
4. B achieved 2 goals; thwarting the design/intent of A's decision to gain advantage by retreat, to avoid B, and having A foul B to avoid loss of yardage.

A made two mistakes; (but only 1 foul)
1. Designing a play that failed to counter B's pursuit.
2. Fouling to prevent B's pursuit from causing (further) loss.

What did B to wrong?

If B were guilty of fouling;

1. B still achieved it's goal in breaching A's plan by contacting A where they chose to retreat,
2. However, B chose to foul in order to end the play, at some point BEHIND the previous spot.

Both A and/or B's fouls happened at a "Succeeding spot", which is where either is enforced.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: TSHunt on January 08, 2023, 07:26:22 PM
A bit late to the party but I figured I'd share with the class.
Santa has plenty of gifts (new rules proposals) for the upcoming year. I value your opinions and would enjoy hearing from them.

(1) Failure to wear proper equipment = 1st, warning > 2nd  = 5 yards > 3rd = 15 yards USC > 4th & more = 15 yards USC + Disq.
This seems a little messy to enforce. Trying to keep track of everything could be problematic.
(2) Any colored towels = OK
Sure
(3) Expand list of illegal equipment.
I'm not sure what exactly you'd be looking to add.
(4) Leaping OOB player is still OOB until landing IB.
Yes
(5) Clock starts on RFP after OOB unless under 2 min. in half.
Would very much like this for pace of play, but I understand the coach perspective on this.
(6) If K/A subs, R/B can sub prior to snap.
I don't have a big push for or against this. Would be fine either way.
(7) Forward fumble > OOB > spot of fumble.
Yes. Yards gained on a fumble feels like the fumble is being rewarded, which IMO should not be the case.
(8) Only the player that takes snap can legal IG.
This cuts out the hypothetical "HB Toss throw away" and would likely be rarely needed like in the college game. Sure.
(9) After ball goes beyond LOS, can't have forward pass.
Yes
(10) IG only LOD at spot.
50/50 on this. If I had to choose I'd say the 5 is fine.
(11) Legalize 'pushing the pile'.
No, this seems like a safety issue where a kid gets injured by being pushed by opposing players
(12) Legalize hurdling.
No, not worth safety risk
(13) Strengthen 'defenseless player'.
How so?
(14) Hands to the face = 15 yards.
Yes, bring in line and make it a PF
(15) AFD/LOD if PF.
LOD seems too much for an O that just got pushed back 15+, and just having AFD seems unbalanced.
(16) AFD if USC by B.
See above, just having an AFD feels unbalanced. Fine with the 15 and in most cases that's a 1st anyways.
(17) Coaches bail moat on RFP
Fine with this. Restricted area is a tough cookie to deal with regardless.
(18) Previous spot if foul by A behind LOS or by B if run ends behind LOS.
Would really like this. Ends the plays where fumbling gets an offense more yards. Could see some issue with gifting free yards to A on holds/Illegal blocks behind LOS.
Please let me know your opinions. Thank you  tiphat:

 :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR:

Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: AlUpstateNY on January 09, 2023, 02:56:07 PM
A bit late to the party but I figured I'd share with the class.

May well be that, some time ago, Pass Interference efforts were getting a little too intense, so IPI, with it's EXTRA 15 yards, was introduced to temper the progress.  The lack of seeing it applied very often, suggests it was a rational idea, that helps prevent such behavior.  Like keeping a big stick available in the front of a closet, with the door left ALWAYS open.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: PABJNR on January 09, 2023, 06:16:26 PM
May well be that, some time ago, Pass Interference efforts were getting a little too intense, so IPI, with it's EXTRA 15 yards, was introduced to temper the progress.  The lack of seeing it applied very often, suggests it was a rational idea, that helps prevent such behavior.  Like keeping a big stick available in the front of a closet, with the door left ALWAYS open.
Much like someone entering your house would likely not know there is a big stick in your closet, most players and coaches do not know there is such a thing as IPI. 


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: AlUpstateNY on January 10, 2023, 10:47:13 AM
Much like someone entering your house would likely not know there is a big stick in your closet, most players and coaches do not know there is such a thing as IPI. 


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Why should ignorance be considered a valid excuse for stupidity? (for either IPI or burglary)
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: bbeagle on January 10, 2023, 12:37:31 PM
Take a facemask 10yds deep as an example. To bring that up to previous spot and mark it off from there gives A a 25 yard gain plus a new set of downs in most cases. Marking it off from the spot of foul or end run only gives the 15 and a replay, while still giving B credit for causing the 10 yd loss.

What about the play where the QB is in the pocket and sacked by pulling him down by his facemask? Why should B get credit for an illegal tackle?
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: AlUpstateNY on January 10, 2023, 03:08:46 PM
What about the play where the QB is in the pocket and sacked by pulling him down by his facemask? Why should B get credit for an illegal tackle?

It was "A's" decision to retreat, in able to better complete THEIR designed play, "B", unfortunately, fouled in making his tackle & will be penalized accordingly, however "B" did nothing wrong by causing "A" to decide to retreat.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: dammitbobby on January 10, 2023, 04:25:20 PM
Al, can you give a single instance of a (legal)play that doesn't involve the ball being somewhere behind the LOS? 

It's not that A chose to retreat necessarily, there's literally no play option (that I can think of) that doesn't put the ball somewhere behind the line - therefore, not their choice.

The foul shouldn't award B the yardage A retreated, because A was deprived of the right to advance the ball, without being fouled.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: CalhounLJ on January 10, 2023, 07:04:19 PM
What about the play where the QB is in the pocket and sacked by pulling him down by his facemask? Why should B get credit for an illegal tackle?
He doesn’t. He gets credit for A retreating. Then he gets penalized for the facemask. Plus A gets to replay the down.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: AlUpstateNY on January 10, 2023, 09:28:12 PM
Al, can you give a single instance of a (legal)play that doesn't involve the ball being somewhere behind the LOS? 

It's not that A chose to retreat necessarily, there's literally no play option (that I can think of) that doesn't put the ball somewhere behind the line - therefore, not their choice.

The foul shouldn't award B the yardage A retreated, because A was deprived of the right to advance the ball, without being fouled.

Perhaps I misunderstood the original question.  I thought it related to A being pressured, and retreating deeper behind the LOS (like in a passing, or retreating running play - AWAY from the LOS (which is usually A CHOICE, caused by defensive pressure).

I understood the inference suggesting the "A" was being "deprived of the right to advance" DIRECTLY BECAUSE OF THE EFFORT BY "B", and is therefore RESPONSIBLE for their choice of fouling, rather than otherwise avoiding "B's" pressure.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: Ralph Damren on January 11, 2023, 01:52:49 PM
Back from Indy with the new rules, as in the past , they remain top-secret until the NFHS press release. The timeframe is usually around 3 weeks. You then will able to tell us how S/S (smart/stupid) we were  :)

Thank you, again, for your opinions . That was valuable.  :)
                                                                                       Ralph  tiphat:

 :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: (50 voting members)
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: GA Umpire on January 11, 2023, 02:16:59 PM
Back from Indy with the new rules, as in the past , they remain top-secret until the NFHS press release. The timeframe is usually around 3 weeks. You then will able to tell us how S/S (smart/stupid) we were  :)

Thank you, again, for your opinions . That was valuable.  :)
                                                                                       Ralph  tiphat:

 :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: :sTiR: (50 voting members)

I can't wait.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: PABJNR on January 11, 2023, 05:52:45 PM
Why should ignorance be considered a valid excuse for stupidity? (for either IPI or burglary)
Not the point. My point was the IPI foul does not stop IPI because players and coaches in general DO NOT KNOW THE RULE EXISTS, as it does not get called very often if at all.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: AlUpstateNY on January 12, 2023, 10:36:04 AM
Not the point. My point was the IPI foul does not stop IPI because players and coaches in general DO NOT KNOW THE RULE EXISTS, as it does not get called very often if at all.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Disqualification (formerly Ejection) is, thankfully, rarely necessary, not because "players & coaches" aren't aware of it, rather because there are "potentially" serious consequences, BEYOND, the proscribed penalty either will likely have to deal with after the fact.

Of course, there are always a few who don't bother to think about the potential damage a "big stick laying in a closet" might cause, but most understand, and appreciate, what damage it "might" do, if used.  The same is true, thus far, for IPI, except for really STUPID non-believers, who insist on seeing for themselves.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: NVFOA_Ump on January 12, 2023, 01:47:01 PM
Much like someone entering your house would likely not know there is a big stick in your closet, most players and coaches do not know there is such a thing as IPI. 
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I would disagree with that statement.  Additionally, even if they did not know, it is an attempt to put a stop to intentionally tackling a receiver when it was obvious to the defender that he's been beat him for a big play, maybe even a touchdown. 
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: CalhounLJ on January 12, 2023, 02:38:22 PM
I would disagree with that statement.  Additionally, even if they did not know, it is an attempt to put a stop to intentionally tackling a receiver when it was obvious to the defender that he's been beat him for a big play, maybe even a touchdown.
Not trying to pick a fight here, but I would love to hear how many of you have ever thrown this flag.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: NVFOA_Ump on January 12, 2023, 04:05:01 PM
I've never thrown it (U or R).  I've been in games twice where we've had it.  One HS and one youth.  As it was described to me they were both flagrant takedown "tackles".
Title: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: PABJNR on January 12, 2023, 05:38:29 PM
I've never thrown it (U or R).  I've been in games twice where we've had it.  One HS and one youth.  As it was described to me they were both flagrant takedown "tackles".
And how long have you been officiating and how many games? It’s been called twice. 

I only ask how long because from you other posts it seems like you have been at it for a while.

It would be interesting to pool players and coaches to see if they are aware the rule exists. 


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: PABJNR on January 12, 2023, 05:46:00 PM
I would disagree with that statement.  Additionally, even if they did not know, it is an attempt to put a stop to intentionally tackling a receiver when it was obvious to the defender that he's been beat him for a big play, maybe even a touchdown.
I get the intent, but I think it’s so rare because if the balls in the air and a defender is close enough to tackle he usually doesn’t or it is so close to the arrival of the ball it is judged ordinary DPI.  My opinion is the egregious Stuff happens on plays where the defender gets beat early such as a double move before ball gets in the air and the defender doesn’t know whether to keep chasing the receiver or to pick up his jock.

Just giving my opinion on this one. 


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: PABJNR on January 12, 2023, 05:47:49 PM
Disqualification (formerly Ejection) is, thankfully, rarely necessary, not because "players & coaches" aren't aware of it, rather because there are "potentially" serious consequences, BEYOND, the proscribed penalty either will likely have to deal with after the fact.

Of course, there are always a few who don't bother to think about the potential damage a "big stick laying in a closet" might cause, but most understand, and appreciate, what damage it "might" do, if used.  The same is true, thus far, for IPI, except for really STUPID non-believers, who insist on seeing for themselves.
I wish I had a way to say it slower


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: TSHunt on January 12, 2023, 07:19:02 PM
Not trying to pick a fight here, but I would love to hear how many of you have ever thrown this flag.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Have never and would never throw it unless it's a blatant takedown like NVFOA described.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: jason on January 13, 2023, 08:25:40 AM
If the early voting held true through the meeting, and if I'm interpreting correctly, some of this is disappointing.

(1) [VOTES 1-14] Failure to wear proper equipment = 1st, warning > 2nd  = 5 yards > 3rd = 15 yards USC > 4th & more = 15 yards USC + Disq.
(2) [VOTES 11-4] Any colored towels = OK
(3) [VOTES 2-7] Expand list of illegal equipment.
(4) [VOTES 12-0] Leaping OOB player is still OOB until landing IB.
(5) [VOTES 12-3] Clock starts on RFP after OOB unless under 2 min. in half.
(6) [VOTES 2-10] If K/A subs, R/B can sub prior to snap.
(7) [VOTES 6-8] Forward fumble > OOB > spot of fumble.
(8) [VOTES 9-4] Only the player that takes snap can legal IG.
Why is this safety related for a QB and not for a player receiving a pitch on a halfback pass option? What's good for the goose is good for the gander, IMO.

(9) [VOTES 5-6] After ball goes beyond LOS, can't have forward pass.
Why would this not be unanimous? Do coaches have a secret "You run past the line, then retreat 10yds like Tecmo Bowl, then throw the bomb"-options in their playbook? Shutting off the option to pass once the ball goes beyond the LOS is a simple adjustment that makes officiating easier by turning everything binary.

(10) [VOTES 5-7] IG only LOD at spot.
(11) [VOTES 4-11] Legalize 'pushing the pile'.
(12) [VOTES 0-15] Legalize hurdling.
(13) [VOTES 3-7] Strengthen 'defenseless player'.
(14) [VOTES 11-3] Hands to the face = 15 yards.
This didn't/doesn't need amendment or addition. It's a PF as currently worded.

(15) [VOTES 2-13] AFD/LOD if PF.
(16) [VOTES 5-9] AFD if USC by B.
(17) [VOTES 6-5] Coaches bail moat on RFP
I sincerely hope nothing was added to assist grown men with when they're supposed to be behind a big white line. Enough with this coddling. Do they get to a stop sign and put their car half out past the stop sign? Do they rub nuts-to-butts when behind someone in line at the bank? Please. They know when and where to get back, but they don't want to. Period.

(18) [VOTES 7-8] Previous spot if foul by A behind LOS or by B if run ends behind LOS.


Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: HLinNC on January 13, 2023, 08:53:20 AM
Quote
It's a PF as currently worded.

It's actually IUH = 10 yards.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: jason on January 13, 2023, 09:06:32 AM
It's actually IUH = 10 yards.

I'd argue most of the contact of this manner skips right past 9-2-1 (I assume that's what you're referencing), and easily fits into 9-4-3g.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: ncwingman on January 13, 2023, 08:26:37 PM
(9) [VOTES 5-6] After ball goes beyond LOS, can't have forward pass.
Why would this not be unanimous? Do coaches have a secret "You run past the line, then retreat 10yds like Tecmo Bowl, then throw the bomb"-options in their playbook? Shutting off the option to pass once the ball goes beyond the LOS is a simple adjustment that makes officiating easier by turning everything binary.

I would argue it's easier to officiate as currently written. The only thing that matters is where the player is when the pass is thrown. It's easy to beanbag that spot and double check later.

You're right that it's not likely somebody will retreat 10 yards then throw a pass (good luck keeping those linemen upfield...), but the play where the QB gets right up against the line and maybe takes a step over, then retreats is the one that's harder to call. When it's clear the QB is going to run, my focus (as a linesman/judge) shifts ahead of him looking for holds and I lose his relative position to the LOS as he's scrambling. The white hat would keep focus on the QB, but has no perspective on the LOS and the U us probably watching for men downfield prior to the pass.

Give me a seven man crew where the HL/LJ stay on the LOS and don't shift focus downfield, and we can have a different discussion.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: refjeff on January 14, 2023, 08:48:36 AM
Back from Indy with the new rules, as in the past , they remain top-secret until the NFHS press release. The timeframe is usually around 3 weeks. You then will able to tell us how S/S (smart/stupid) we were  :)

Thank you, again, for your opinions . That was valuable.  :)
                                                                                       Ralph  tiphat:



You could tell us.  We promise not to tell anyone. 

Honest.
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: Ralph Damren on January 14, 2023, 10:52:24 AM
You could tell us.  We promise not to tell anyone. 

Honest.

I can share this ...rules that have NOT changed : a TD is still worth 6 points, the field is still 100 yards long, the goal posts are still 10 feet high, the end zones are still 10 yards deep, the game is still referred to as FOOTBALL....oh, yes we have six new rules....stay tuned...... ::)
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: Tom.OH on January 14, 2023, 10:59:26 AM
I can share this ...rules that have NOT changed : a TD is still worth 6 points, the field is still 100 yards long, the goal posts are still 10 feet high, the end zones are still 10 yards deep, the game is still referred to as FOOTBALL....oh, yes we have six new rules....stay tuned...... ::)

Ralph, I heard the 1.35 billion dollar mega millions was won in Maine, was it you...
Title: Re: SANTA'S WISH LIST .....2023 VERSION
Post by: Ralph Damren on January 14, 2023, 11:14:05 AM
Ralph, I heard the 1.35 billion dollar mega millions was won in Maine, was it you...
The winning ticket was sold at a convenience store near the NH border. On occation I'll buy a scratch-off ticket. I once won $15. I don't recall how I spent it  :o ??? ::)