RefStripes.com

Football Officiating => National Federation Discussion => Topic started by: refjeff on December 18, 2022, 03:21:30 PM

Title: OT
Post by: refjeff on December 18, 2022, 03:21:30 PM
The Jaguars just beat the Cowboys with an OT pick 6.

In NFHS the ball is dead.

I hate that.  It changes a fundamental rule and the balance between offense and defense.

THAT is a rule change I would love to see.
Title: Re: OT
Post by: Badger1 on December 18, 2022, 04:02:26 PM
In Wisconsin we follow the NCAA overtime rules so it would be a TD here.
Title: Re: OT
Post by: AlUpstateNY on December 18, 2022, 05:52:51 PM
The Jaguars just beat the Cowboys with an OT pick 6.

In NFHS the ball is dead.

I hate that.  It changes a fundamental rule and the balance between offense and defense.

THAT is a rule change I would love to see.

NFHS rules provides EACH team an equal opportunity to score in each  of THEIR OT sequence of plays.  A change of possession ends the sequence, after which the opponent is given the same opportunity.  When each team either doesn't score, or one scores more than the other, in the same sequence, the game is decided, If not, another full OT sequence begins.

NCAA, NFL, other Rule codes offer their own options.
Title: Re: OT
Post by: Ralph Damren on December 18, 2022, 07:02:40 PM
See how you can lose in OT without going into OT :puke: WATCH PATRIOT/RAIDER FINAL  :puke: tR:oLl tR:oLl tR:oLl :puke: pi1eOn :!#
Title: Re: OT
Post by: refjeff on December 18, 2022, 07:32:18 PM
NFHS rules provides EACH team an equal opportunity to score in each  of THEIR OT sequence of plays.  A change of possession ends the sequence, after which the opponent is given the same opportunity.  When each team either doesn't score, or one scores more than the other, in the same sequence, the game is decided, If not, another full OT sequence begins.

NCAA, NFL, other Rule codes offer their own options.
Yeah, I know the rule.  I hate it.  It changes a fundamental rule of football and the balance between offense and defense.
Title: Re: OT
Post by: refjeff on December 18, 2022, 07:33:17 PM
See how you can loose in OT without going into OI  :puke: WATCH PATRIOT/RAIDER FINAL  :puke: tR:oLl tR:oLl tR:oLl :puke: pi1eOn :!#
That was brutal.
Title: Re: OT
Post by: bossman72 on December 18, 2022, 07:44:08 PM
NFHS doesn't want to get into the business of what you do with fouls after a change of possession in OT (and on tries for that matter).  You'd need a bunch of exceptions, account for A-B-A, etc.  Just make it dead and keep it simple is their philosophy.
Title: Re: OT
Post by: refjeff on December 19, 2022, 04:31:42 AM
NFHS doesn't want to get into the business of what you do with fouls after a change of possession in OT (and on tries for that matter).  You'd need a bunch of exceptions, account for A-B-A, etc.  Just make it dead and keep it simple is their philosophy.
That makes sense.

I still hate it.

Title: Re: OT
Post by: Ralph Damren on December 19, 2022, 04:36:52 AM
Remember, guys, each state can write their own OT rules. The NFHS only provides a framework.
Title: Re: OT
Post by: NVFOA_Ump on December 19, 2022, 06:23:06 AM
Remember, guys, each state can write their own OT rules. The NFHS only provides a framework.

In Massachusetts the MIAA has adopted OT rules more similar to NCAA OT rules.  The ball stays live during all non-try plays following COP on the last play in the 2nd series (the last play of 1 overtime period).  For penalties on A after the COP B has the option of enforcing the penalty and running 1 play from the succeeding spot.  But Bossman is right, penalty enforcement can get a bit dicey.  Here's the full paragraph from the MIAA 2022 handbook:

69.3.1.4. If there is a change of team possession during the last play of an overtime period (second series), live ball personal fouls or live ball unsportsmanlike conduct fouls by opponents of the team last gaining possession, that occur after the change of possession, gives the team in possession the option of putting the ball in play, where the penalty leaves the ball, for one down free of penalty or penalize as a dead ball foul at the succeeding spot in the subsequent overtime period. This option is exercised only if the team last gaining possession is free of foul during the down.
Title: Re: OT
Post by: AlUpstateNY on December 19, 2022, 02:54:23 PM
Yeah, I know the rule.  I hate it.  It changes a fundamental rule of football and the balance between offense and defense.

What about the fundamental; Each team is provided with 4 downs to outscore their opponent.  COP rewards the defense for accomplishing THAT objective, but they still have to SCORE (on their own).
Title: Re: OT
Post by: refjeff on December 19, 2022, 04:56:01 PM
What about the fundamental; Each team is provided with 4 downs to outscore their opponent.  COP rewards the defense for accomplishing THAT objective, but they still have to SCORE (on their own).
  Well if the defense scores then that team would score on their own, except the rules eliminate that fundamental part of the game.
Title: Re: OT
Post by: AlUpstateNY on December 20, 2022, 12:19:45 PM
  Well if the defense scores then that team would score on their own, except the rules eliminate that fundamental part of the game.

OT is different than regular game time.  Creating  a COP gives the Defense a "reward" by eliminating ANY opportunity for the Offence to score during their possession.  If the COP happened during the second hall of an OT session, where there NOT had been a score in the 1st half, the game is OVER, as both teams have had the same opportunity to score (or match scores). 

When the Defense causes a COP, the ball is DEAD, that OT opportunity is OVER for the Offense, and the Defense (becomes the Offense) & is awarded a set of downs to score.
Title: Re: OT
Post by: Ralph Damren on December 20, 2022, 12:58:15 PM
QUESTON: If first team on offense throws a pic-6, does the team that just scored still have to run 4 downs and take knees as the team now on defense could score,too?
Title: Re: OT
Post by: NVFOA_Ump on December 20, 2022, 01:04:49 PM
QUESTON: If first team on offense throws a pic-6, does the team that just scored still have to run 4 downs and take knees as the team now on defense could score,too?

:bOW - One of the more obvious problems!
Title: Re: OT
Post by: ilyazhito on December 20, 2022, 05:38:00 PM
No. As both teams have had one possession, and one scored on theirs, the game is over. Under NCAA rules, the answer would be the same. The rules say that "There shall be an equal number of possession series..., unless B scores other than on the try" (Rule 3, Section 1, Article 3 (f)).
Under NFHS rules, assuming that they do not change to allow B to score on the try, it would sound as follows "There shall be an equal number of possession series unless B scores".
Title: Re: OT
Post by: refjeff on December 20, 2022, 05:42:56 PM
QUESTON: If first team on offense throws a pic-6, does the team that just scored still have to run 4 downs and take knees as the team now on defense could score,too?
Nope.  They already had their offensive possession.
Title: Re: OT
Post by: refjeff on December 20, 2022, 05:48:14 PM
OT is different than regular game time.  Creating  a COP gives the Defense a "reward" by eliminating ANY opportunity for the Offence to score during their possession.  If the COP happened during the second hall of an OT session, where there NOT had been a score in the 1st half, the game is OVER, as both teams have had the same opportunity to score (or match scores). 
Hmmm.  A had 1st & 10.  B had 1 play.  That is not the same opportunity.


When the Defense causes a COP, the ball is DEAD, that OT opportunity is OVER for the Offense, and the Defense (becomes the Offense) & is awarded a set of downs to score.
Yes, we all know that.

I hate it.
Title: Re: OT
Post by: bossman72 on December 21, 2022, 08:36:14 AM
I'd be interested to see the full OT rules for states that do not use the NFHS recommended OT procedure, just to see what they do with fouls after a COP.

If anyone doesn't use NFHS OT, please post your state's OT rule.
Title: Re: OT
Post by: ElvisLives on December 21, 2022, 09:29:14 AM
In NCAA extra periods, we play until there is a winner. No ties. By what I was reading above, is it possible to have a final tie score under NFHS rules?

Quoting:
"If the COP happened during the second hall of an OT session, where there NOT had been a score in the 1st half, the game is OVER, as both teams have had the same opportunity to score (or match scores)."

Scenario: Antelopes had the ball for the first possession of an "overtime" period, but fail to score. During the Bears' possession of the same "overtime" period, they throw a pass that is intercepted by the Antelopes. Sounds like the down is over immediately upon Antelopes' possession. The score is still tied. Is the game over?
Title: Re: OT
Post by: Ralph Damren on December 21, 2022, 10:44:15 AM
Remember, guys. each state can decide if to play overtime and what format to use. Several states veer from the NFHS procedure and you may be able to start a grassroots movement to convince your state association to tweak your state's overtime rule.
Title: Re: OT
Post by: NVFOA_Ump on December 21, 2022, 11:16:05 AM
I'd be interested to see the full OT rules for states that do not use the NFHS recommended OT procedure, just to see what they do with fouls after a COP.  If anyone doesn't use NFHS OT, please post your state's OT rule.

Here's the entire Massachusetts Tie-Breaker Rule from the MIAA handbook:

69.3 MIAA Tie-Breaker Rule. (Revised 4/13/22)
69.3.1 The MIAA Football Tie-Breaker Rule, multiple overtime periods: will ensure that the game will not end in a tie.
69.3.1.1 Additional overtime periods will be used if teams are tied at the end of regulation or succeeding overtime periods.
69.3.1.2 Each series shall begin at the ten-yard line unless a penalty overrides. First down chains will not be used. It is always goal-to-go. If penalty enforcement calls for an automatic first down, it will be first and goal.
69.3.1.3 For the first and subsequent tie breaking periods, any team that scores a touchdown must attempt a two point conversion by run or pass from scrimmage.
69.3.1.4 If there is a change of team possession during the last play of an overtime period (second series), live ball personal fouls or live ball unsportsmanlike conduct fouls by opponents of the team last gaining possession, that occur after the change of possession, gives the team in possession the option of putting the ball in play, where the penalty leaves the ball, for one down free of penalty or penalize as a dead ball foul at the succeeding spot in the subsequent overtime period. This option is exercised only if the team last gaining possession is free of foul during the down.

Example: Second Series - Team B intercepts Team A's pass and, during Team B's run back, Team A commits a personal foul.
Ruling: Team B has the option of extending the overtime period for one down free of penalty, with Team B putting the ball in play where the penalty leaves the ball, provided Team B has not fouled during the down. Or Team B may choose to penalize as a dead ball foul at the succeeding spot in the subsequent overtime period.
Title: Re: OT
Post by: Badger1 on December 21, 2022, 11:45:44 AM
In Wisconsin on a change of possession during overtime:
● The defensive team (Team B) can score–the ball remains live if team possession changes during a down.

17. FOULS BEFORE A CHANGE OF TEAM POSSESSION DURING A HALF INNING.
Fouls committed by either team or by both teams before team possession has changed during a down are enforced
as per National Federation rules. Fouls by both teams before team possession has changed are “double fouls.”

18. FOULS AFTER A CHANGE OF TEAM POSSESSION DURING A HALF INNING.
Fouls that occur after Team B gains possession are penalized as follows:
● After a change of team possession during a half inning [the set of downs by one team] distance penalties for fouls
by either team are declined by rule.
● Dead ball fouls, live ball fouls penalized as dead ball fouls, and flagrant fouls are enforced from the succeeding
spot.
● A score is canceled by a team that commits a foul during the down.
● The down is not replayed if double fouls occur, no matter whether one or both fouls occur after Team B gains
possession.
19. SCORING.
The offensive team can score a touchdown, convert a try, score a field goal and score via a safety.
The defensive team can score via a touchdown or safety.
Title: Re: OT
Post by: refjeff on December 21, 2022, 03:48:06 PM

 ^good   Seems simple enough to me.
Title: Re: OT
Post by: KWH on December 31, 2022, 09:39:56 PM
Me too!
 
If the defensive team gains possession the ball becomes dead immediately and the offensive teams series of downs is ended.

  ^no Seems simple enough to me?
Title: Re: OT
Post by: ncwingman on January 02, 2023, 12:45:52 PM
My concern would be a philosophical disconnect with a try down. Essentially, the OT is an extended try series. The team on offense has a chance to score, and the defense has a chance to stop them. The defense cannot score on a try.

In NCAA rules, the defense can score in OT, but they can also score on a try. If B gets the ball with clean hands, you play out the rest of the down, but then the OT series (or try) is over -- even if it's an ABA scenario.

If the rules were such that the defense could score in OT, which I'm not fundamentally opposed to, I would probably suggest changing the try rules to match. I'm not saying we should or shouldn't change the rules, but just that it should be consistent. I also fully acknowledge that this would never happen.
Title: Re: OT
Post by: ilyazhito on January 03, 2023, 02:19:05 AM
OT is only a try starting with the 3rd series under NCAA rules. Before.that, OT is a relatively normal series of untimed downs, with some special wrinkles (PSK rules do not apply, A-B-A ends the series, unless the line to gain is reached, or A scores). As a result, OT should not be substantially different from regulation.

If I'm not mistaken, that is the approach that the NFL takes. There, overtime is a 5th quarter, played under 4th quarter timing rules, with one fewer timeout than in regulation (2). The most salient difference is that the game ends if a touchdown is scored on either team's first possession. After that, any score wins.

I would also advocate allowing B to score on a try, but it is not really germane to the topic of overtime.
Title: Re: OT
Post by: jason on January 13, 2023, 08:38:25 AM
I've trained a bunch of officials and helped even more. It's amazing how difficult it is for the OT procedures to sink in, and it's precisely because of the differing versions at each level.

The concept of an XP vs. Try in different series is ridiculous to begin with.

And the way the amended OT procedures read in both Massachusetts and Wisconsin leave something to be desired.

Keep it simple. Defense gets the ball, it's dead.
Title: Re: OT
Post by: bama_stripes on January 14, 2023, 07:41:08 AM
If I'm not mistaken, that is the approach that the NFL takes. There, overtime is a 5th quarter, played under 4th quarter timing rules, with one fewer timeout than in regulation (2). The most salient difference is that the game ends if a touchdown is scored on either team's first possession. After that, any score wins.

Apparently, the NFL is changing that this year. Each team will have at least one possession.