RefStripes.com

Football Officiating => National Federation Discussion => Topic started by: TSHunt on December 30, 2022, 11:58:39 PM

Title: Illegal Kick Question
Post by: TSHunt on December 30, 2022, 11:58:39 PM
Hey all,

Was doing some study on kick plays and ran into this post from 2017:

UNDER LAST FRIDAY NIGHT'S LIGHTS......

3rd & 10 @ A's 3 when :

(1) A turns K and tries to quick-kick from own end zone;
(2) B/R blocks K's punt;
(3) kicker kicks bouncing ball in end zone again;
(4) the illegal kick goes OOB @ A's 7.

^flag YOU MAKE THE CALL ^flag

The two options listed in the post were safety by penalty or 1 & G for B at A7. My thought process goes:

- Legal scrimmage kick occurs with the first kick.
- Second kick is illegal and in EZ (Illegal kicking flag down, ball retains previous status of a legal scrimmage kick)
- The kick ends OOB at A7. This is the succeeding spot if penalties are declined.
- 10-4-2 EXCEPTION allows the succeeding spot to be chosen as the basic spot if:
        - Legal Scrimmage kick occurs on the down: YES
        - Foul by K prior to end of kick: YES
        - K not next to put ball in play: YES (Decline creates 1 & G for B/R)

What makes it so that we cannot enforce from the succeeding spot for 1 & G at A 3 1/2?
Title: Re: Illegal Kick Question
Post by: HLinNC on December 31, 2022, 08:40:46 AM
Because you pulled up a 2017 post.  The 10-4-2 Exception was not implemented until 2018.
Title: Re: Illegal Kick Question
Post by: TSHunt on December 31, 2022, 01:36:43 PM
Because you pulled up a 2017 post.  The 10-4-2 Exception was not implemented until 2018.

That would do it. Sometimes the solution is easier than you think!
Title: Re: Illegal Kick Question
Post by: Ralph Damren on January 02, 2023, 07:48:26 AM
That would do it. Sometimes the solution is easier than you think!
The solution wasn't that easy for me that night in Houlton,Maine,USA  pi1eOn . I just ruled safety, let's kickoff from the 20  pi1eOn pi1eOn. No choices we offered but 6-2-7 sez' I should have as ,depending on game situation, taking the ball at the OOB could have been a better option. As HLin NC explained , the 'tack on' rule didn't arrive until the following year.

MOTTO: LEARN FROM YOUR MISTAKES, NOT TO MAKE THEM AGAIN.  tR:oLl