RefStripes.com
Football Officiating => National Federation Discussion => Topic started by: Ralph Damren on February 17, 2023, 12:45:14 PM
-
Back in 2003, when I was on the NFHS Editorial Committee, I wrote then Case 9.9.3B dealing with : "...actions or verbiage designed to confuse the defense into believing there is a problem and a snap isn't imminent is beyond the scope of sportsmanship and is illegal." It is now 9.9.1B and states that it is a dead ball USC foul. I had a grudge against one such that happened to me back when I was a mere lad in 1963.
SCENE: Maine Central Institute vs Skowhegan High School
Skowhegan had the ball at 50, 1st & 10.
I was outside linebacker for MCI
ACT I : Skowhegan stayed in huddle and drew a DOG ^flag
ACT II: They stayed in huddle and appeared oblivious to the penalty being enforced ;).
ACT III: When they broke the huddle, the QB yelled, "HOW DID THE BALL GET BACK HERE :o ???" The snapper responded, "I BET THOSE GUYS MOVED IT :o !" while pointing at us :-X .
ACT IV : 7 of their players were standing at the LOS when the QB said to the snapper, "GIVE ME THE BALL, I'LL GIT THOSE BACK... yEs:"
ACT V ; Snapper, while standing, smoothly picked up the and handed it to the QB :P .
ACT VI: QB began to strool over the LOS as we giggled :D , thinking of the trouble P_S he was going to get into.
ACT VII : Once he got to our safety, he broke into a gallop tiphat:.
ACT VIII: We then decided to chase.. :!# he had too much of a headstart ^good
ACT IX : Our coach, nicknamed "The Bull", began to scream at the z^ z^ z^ z^. They explained it was legal.
ACT X : The Bull then began to scream at us :puke:...
iT TOOK ME 40 YEARS TO GET EVEN 8] ...
You guys have probably been involved in or seen some trick plays from those days of yesteryear....let's hear 'em :sTiR:
-
Just goes to show, the "CREATIVITY" of the American Teenager is BOUNDLESS, and they've only gotten better at it in recent decades. The same likely applies, perhaps at a lower rate, to those former teenagers who have chosen to pursue Coaching careers.
-
I don't know how many coaches I've HACKED off because I've told them that this play is illegal and they can't run it.
I had one peewee coach asked me about 4 or 5 trick plays (this play was number 1), all of which I shot down.
coach: Then what are we supposed to do?
me: Play football.
Thanks Ralph!
-
Not yesteryear, but happened this past season to a crew in my chapter (not me). There was a concerted effort by sideline staff/coaches to distract officials as an illegal snap occurred. Simultaneously, coaches on one sideline came running up to the H and S, waving their hands, yelling Johnny, Johnny, wait, etc. - enough to make them look away. It was a big enough hoopla that the opposite wings even took his eyes off the line, and they were able to some kind of weird snap done, with no flags.
-
Not yesteryear, but happened this past season to a crew in my chapter (not me). There was a concerted effort by sideline staff/coaches to distract officials as an illegal snap occurred. Simultaneously, coaches on one sideline came running up to the H and S, waving their hands, yelling Johnny, Johnny, wait, etc. - enough to make them look away. It was a big enough hoopla that the opposite wings even took his eyes off the line, and they were able to some kind of weird snap done, with no flags.
The reason we don't provide a list of '100 illegal trick plays' is a creative coach would invent 101. IMHO, your play could have been shut down (9.9.1 unfair acts ) , ruled USC on head coach, tack on 15 and clock adjustment if needed.
-
The reason we don't provide a list of '100 illegal trick plays' is a creative coach would invent 101. IMHO, your play could have been shut down (9.9.1 unfair acts ) , ruled USC on head coach, tack on 15 and clock adjustment if needed.
They didn't shut it down, because all that they knew was that the ball was snapped, and they didn't have eyes on it. They officiated the rest of they play, and then after it was over, they still knew something wasn't right, but it wasn't until video was sent in that they truly realized what had happened.
-
They didn't shut it down, because all that they knew was that the ball was snapped, and they didn't have eyes on it. They officiated the rest of they play, and then after it was over, they still knew something wasn't right, but it wasn't until video was sent in that they truly realized what had happened.
This reminds me of a pee-wee trick play I had several years ago. I was white hat on that fateful day and had two wings working with me (3 man crew, R/H/L, no U).
Ball at the B-3. Center "snaps" the ball, QB turns to hand off to the RB, I'm watching the handoff to ball carrier... and realize the RB doesn't have the ball. Good fake by the QB... wait.. the QB doesn't have the ball either! Where's the ball??? Neither of my wings had any idea either.
Next thing I know, A is celebrating in the endzone with the Center holding the ball above his head. I kill the clock, call my wings over and say "That wasn't right... what happened?" Eventually, we deduced that the center snapped the ball, touched the QB's hands but never let the ball go and then ran it in the end zone himself. I then threw the latest flag in the history of late flags, 5 yard penalty on A for the snap infraction and replay the down.
The coach very calmly came over and asked "Wait, we can't do that?" No yelling or screaming, and just accepted my explanation that the center has to let go of the ball after the snap.
-
This reminds me of a pee-wee trick play I had several years ago. I was white hat on that fateful day and had two wings working with me (3 man crew, R/H/L, no U).
Ball at the B-3. Center "snaps" the ball, QB turns to hand off to the RB, I'm watching the handoff to ball carrier... and realize the RB doesn't have the ball. Good fake by the QB... wait.. the QB doesn't have the ball either! Where's the ball??? Neither of my wings had any idea either.
Next thing I know, A is celebrating in the endzone with the Center holding the ball above his head. I kill the clock, call my wings over and say "That wasn't right... what happened?" Eventually, we deduced that the center snapped the ball, touched the QB's hands but never let the ball go and then ran it in the end zone himself. I then threw the latest flag in the history of late flags, 5 yard penalty on A for the snap infraction and replay the down.
The coach very calmly came over and asked "Wait, we can't do that?" No yelling or screaming, and just accepted my explanation that the center has to let go of the ball after the snap.
Behold, the reason for reason for 7-3-2a. This was incerted in 1950 to prevent the 'center rush'. Over the years I've had several excited coaches call with their 'new play'. One of my favs was:
On a free kick.....
(1) 'Kicker' will tee up the ball so that it falls off the tee;
(2) He then asks a teammate to hold the ball on the tee so that it won't fall off;
(3) As kicker retraces his steps for his approach, teammate with ball casually drop kicks a grounder;
(4) Teammates rush down and recover grounder 10 1/2 yards beyond the kick.
COACH :" JUST LIKE QUICK-KICKING ON 3RD DOWN, HUH !" tiphat:
i explained that he should read Case 9.9.1 , as it would be treated as an unfair act, the play would be shut down as soon as it began, you would then kickoff from the 25 and the USC would be charged against him and he would be halfway to the school(bus) depending of if he was home or away.
He advised me that his kicker had been practicing teeing up the ball so that it would fall off all Summer hEaDbAnG. I suggested that his kicker should look for other things to do. nAnA.
-
I remember when I was in Pee-Wee football (A long time ago) we ran what we called the sideline special. It was the traditional send 2 players in and 3 players come to the sideline with one staying on the field like he was talking to the coach. I think we ran it twice that I can remember. Once it work and went for a TD, the other time our QB threw it over the WR's head.
-
I remember when I was in Pee-Wee football (A long time ago) we ran what we called the sideline special. It was the traditional send 2 players in and 3 players come to the sideline with one staying on the field like he was talking to the coach. I think we ran it twice that I can remember. Once it work and went for a TD, the other time our QB threw it over the WR's head.
The trouble with trick plays is IF they work the word will spread. Future opponents will be ready. I've told the story before of the need for 9-7-3, UMaine's fake field goal attempt with holder flipping a backward pass to the kicker who batted it into UNH's EZ with a teammate recovering it for a TD. With a few games still to be played before the rulesmakers could step in, Opponents would yell :"Watch out for the BAT !~" Whenever UMaine was in FG formation
Coach Jack Bicknell (later coached Doug Flutie @ BC) had a "plan B" .....
(1) Holder would flip a backward pass into the face of the kicker;
(2) Kicker would fake batting the ball;
(3) Holder would then rise, grab the backward pass and throw a forward screen pass to the TE.
Bicknell never was in position to use plan B.
Shortly after the season, both NCAA and NFHS made batting a backward pass forward illegal ^flag
-
The trouble with trick plays is IF they work the word will spread.
Such as a few years ago, there were a few viral videos of the "wrong ball" play and every pee wee team wanted to try it themselves, somehow forgetting that their opponents would be expecting it if we let it run.
My favorite variation was a coach explaining the setup pregame, but the QB was going to ask for a new ball because the ball was wet and needed changed -- also forgetting that we were in the middle of a two week drought and everything was bone dry and the local news was warning of fire hazards. But, yeah, I'm sure we just spotted the ball in the only puddle in a 10 mile radius. That seems plausible.
Fortunately, while the coach wasn't convinced of the rules violation, he was convinced that the "wet ball" wasn't a realistic deception on that particular day and didn't try to run it.
-
Such as a few years ago, there were a few viral videos of the "wrong ball" play and every pee wee team wanted to try it themselves, somehow forgetting that their opponents would be expecting it if we let it run.
My favorite variation was a coach explaining the setup pregame, but the QB was going to ask for a new ball because the ball was wet and needed changed -- also forgetting that we were in the middle of a two week drought and everything was bone dry and the local news was warning of fire hazards. But, yeah, I'm sure we just spotted the ball in the only puddle in a 10 mile radius. That seems plausible.
Fortunately, while the coach wasn't convinced of the rules violation, he was convinced that the "wet ball" wasn't a realistic deception on that particular day and didn't try to run it.
Had the "same" pee wee coach tell us in pregame they would run the wrong ball play. I quickly shut it down. I told him the league supplies the ball and it was in my hand as we spoke and it is correct...
-
The best time to catch and cancel these trick plays is in pregame when we ask : "Coach, do you have any plays that we should be ready for ?"
One that has came up several times is :
COACH : "My holder will be in a 'catcher's crouch' and will throw a backward/forward/whatever pass from it."
REF : "If his knee isn't touching the ground, than it is not scrimmage kick formation. You would lose protection for roughing the holder.snapper and the numbering exception."
-
The worst is the ole Annexation of Puerto Rico in PeeWee football. It's about near impossible to talk about numbering issues because they only have so many numbers to choose from and they don't always have enough players to cover all the positions without some iron-man football.
I think it might have been 10 year olds...playing on a regular sized HS field...can't make out anything in the scrum...next thing you know, #56 scored a TD. I scratched my head and then ran over to the U and asked if that guy really scored. "Yep". I said, "Isn't that illegal...he never turned his shoulders parallel to his goal line to receive a handoff. "Oops...yeah, I reckon so." Assistant coach for other team pointed that out too. GOod thing the mercy rule was in effect for that game. The other team didn't mind they scored an illegal TD.