RefStripes.com
Football Officiating => NCAA Discussion => Topic started by: JasonTX on November 19, 2011, 04:36:07 PM
-
TXMike or someone. With around 10 mins. left in the 3rd qtr. there was a flag thrown by the U for a false start. Line judge comes running in and call was changed to defense offside. I'd like to see that again if someone can post the video.
-
Berry berry strange....
http://youtu.be/BOVJQ3VmRdM (http://youtu.be/BOVJQ3VmRdM)
-
False start. The B player wasnt a) in the neutral zone and b) not close enough to the A player to have drawn him to move.
-
Same official had a similar call in the Texas earlier this season.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
I'd agree that this is not offside by B. The B player who "moves early" does not encroach in the NZ, and the A player who moves is not by rule a threatened player. Can't the U help out here with some advice if the wing officials think that the B player actually did enter the NZ?
(Corrected - had a late night and my vision is impaired. 8] ;D)
-
I'd agree that this has to be offside by B. The B player who "moves early" does not encroach in the NZ, and the A player who moves is not by rule a threatened player. Can't the U help out here with some advice if the wing officials think that the B player actually did enter the NZ?
Is this a typo or is it just too early up there? How is it offside by B?
-
Same official had a similar call in the Texas earlier this season.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I remember the earlier one as well from that Texas game. I think it is posted on refstripes as well.
-
Looks like the DE is more than 4-5 yards outside of the G who reacts.
-
I remember the earlier one as well from that Texas game. I think it is posted on refstripes as well.
I think this is the thread you are referring to: www.refstripes.com/forum/index.php?topic=8525.0
There is speculation in the first post that the Big12 may have a little different philosophy on this type of play.
-
I think Grant is right, it's a Big 12 philosophy over riding an actual rule. When the defense moves and offense reacts, stick the defense with offside. Watch a lot of Big 12 games and this is a common occurrence.