My first OT game in college lasted 2 plays (interception for an TD). I was disappointed because I wanted to work some more.
My first high school OT game ended in two plays, too. Team that went on offense first scored on the first play. The other team fumbled the ball, and Tugboat from the now-defense jumped on the ball. And, since this was a JV game out in the country, we took changed our shoes and got in the car.