RefStripes.com
Football Officiating => National Federation Discussion => Topic started by: BigWill on August 17, 2022, 12:19:53 PM
-
A running back who has received a handoff from a QB can legally ground the ball if he throws it anywhere beyond the neutral zone expanded? T/F and why!
-
The way you worded it - it is false. He has to meet all the requirements, be out of the FBZ and throw the ball away, past the LOS. If he does those things, then True. He is a "PASSER" once he throws a legal forward pass that meets the exceptions, all's good. As long, as no lineman is illegally downfield....
-
why!
Why? I don't know. I think the NF has needlessly opened a can of worms.
I don't think coaches are going to teach their runners to throw a pass OOB if threatened by a tackle for loss, but I've seen weirder things happen.
-
Why? I don't know. I think the NF has needlessly opened a can of worms.
I don't think coaches are going to teach their runners to throw a pass OOB if threatened by a tackle for loss, but I've seen weirder things happen.
We have seen QBs do that in NCAA football. They take off running and see they won't even get back to the NZ, so they throw the ball OB beyond the NZ. But, in NCAA, the 'receiver of the snap,' i.e., the first player to hold and control the ball from the snap (usually the QB), is the ONLY player that has this legal ability. I would expect a/some player(s) that has/have received a handoff in NFHS to do this in the near future, and the NFHS will then adopt the same NCAA rule regarding the receiver of the snap. Just a prediction. May not come true.
-
wouldn't the handoff have to have been received behind the qb?
i don't know why I thought this but i guess i have never seen a quarterback hand the ball of to a player who then tries to pass the ball. I have seen a qb throw a pass backwards or pitch the ball backwards and the player who then receives the ball attempts to throw a pass. I have seen a quarterback hand the ball off to a running back who then pitches the ball back to the quarterback also.
I think the idea of running back who let's say is running a sweep just wouldn't have enough time to realize he was going to be tackled for a loss and so then he decides to throw the ball away to conserve yardage.
I could see a designed play where a qb lines up as a running back and takes a handoff and then tries passing but I haven't seen that either. Granted this is now my 4th year of officiating so I definitely have NOT seen it all.
-
This reads like the prototypical NFHS exam "reading test". Depending on who wrote the question and the answer key, it could be True, or it could be False; although I would go with RefMike22 's answer of false because of the lack of all of the elements in the question that would make it a legal play. Those tricky so and so's at NFHS exam HQ really want to make sure all your cogs are turning.
However for the umpteenth time, let us review. The Fed purposefully left the term PASSER in the new rule. They don't care if it is the QB, the HB, or the freaking LT. If he and the ball have been outside the parallel boundaries of the FBZ at some point during the play, he can chuck it to Saturn as long as Saturn is at or beyond the NZ. This new rule is all about SAFETY. We want our passer, any passer to be SAFE, the NCAA not withstanding. Guidance I have seen here and elsewhere has indicated that we are to be liberal with the idea that the passer has been outside the FBZ and that the ball reaches the NZ.
There have also been varying discussions around the Interwebs that we probably need to ignore the big boys who waywardly might have slipped on downfield given that A's passer is giving up the down.
-
FDR once said "The only thing we have to fear is fear itself !" When we removed AFD from DPI, I and many feared some D-backs would be coached to tackle whern beaten by a reciever in goal -to- goal situations. That was in 2013, and so far that 'fear' hasn't became reality. If it OR a running back dumps a pass then we can tweak it. I asked a coach how he was going to train his running backs with this new rule. His response was : " I TEACH MY RUNNING BACK TO LOOK FOR AN OPEN HOLE, NOT AN OPEN RECIEVER. THEY WANT TO GAIN YARDAGE, NOT THROW AN INCOMPLETE PASS! " I feel nearly all coaches will take the same attitude.
-
There have also been varying discussions around the Interwebs that we probably need to ignore the big boys who waywardly might have slipped on downfield given that A's passer is giving up the down.
The NCAA has got a handle on that, too. By rule, if the pass crosses the NZ and lands near the sideline or OB, then there can be no ineligibles downfield. Perhaps NFHS will consider this in the future, too.
-
The NCAA has got a handle on that, too. By rule, if the pass crosses the NZ and lands near the sideline or OB, then there can be no ineligibles downfield. Perhaps NFHS will consider this in the future, too.
I think there is high percentage change there are ineligibles downfield on a play that was designed to be a run. So even the it was a legal forward pass by the running back throwing the ball away there could be a penalty of 5 yards plus loss of down.
-
This is an actual test question what I'am looking for is how would you answer T/F to see what the consensus is... then a reason for you answer thanks....
-
This is an actual test question what I'am looking for is how would you answer T/F to see what the consensus is... then a reason for you answer thanks....
Then I would answer true and for the why I would add as long as the passer is outside of the lateral zone of free blocking which is 4 yards either side of the snap The potential ineligible receivers do not impact the whether the pass is a legal forward pass or not.
-
It seems this issue is more a language problem, than a logic problem. The Key word in both NFHS: 7-5-2-d & e is INTENTIONAL. This revision suggests "allowing" 2 specific circumstances (the pass occurring outside the FBZ & ultimately reaching beyond the LOS- extended OOB). Meeting these exceptions eliminate the consequences associated with an "Illegal FP". However, I don't think the intent was (should have been) to legitimize (or legalize) a basic principle causing such a pass being Illegal, rather to simply exempt such a pass from carrying the consequences normally associated with it being "illegal", much as is the case currently of 7-5-2-e.
It seems by removing such a pass from that of being "Illegal", in the existing description exposes it to all the requirements now associated with a forward pass being LEGAL, which include the penalty for being an Ineligible receiver downfield, which DOES NOT seem to be the intent.
Unfortunately, the current format seems destined to be a recurring "What if" scenario, and source of argument & confusion in it's present presentation form, needing some careful editing to accomplish it's apparent intention, to clearly define it as being exempt from "Illegal Forward Pass" penalty, while retaining it's status as an, otherwise, "Illegal Forward Pass"., so as NOT to automatically revert to all the established rules designed for a "Legal Forward Pass".
May require some serious "Wordsmithing".
-
wouldn't the handoff have to have been received behind the qb?
i don't know why I thought this but i guess i have never seen a quarterback hand the ball of to a player who then tries to pass the ball. I have seen a qb throw a pass backwards or pitch the ball backwards and the player who then receives the ball attempts to throw a pass. I have seen a quarterback hand the ball off to a running back who then pitches the ball back to the quarterback also.
I think the idea of running back who let's say is running a sweep just wouldn't have enough time to realize he was going to be tackled for a loss and so then he decides to throw the ball away to conserve yardage.
I could see a designed play where a qb lines up as a running back and takes a handoff and then tries passing but I haven't seen that either. Granted this is now my 4th year of officiating so I definitely have NOT seen it all.
Whether he could or would is irrelevant. The simple fact is that he is allowed to do so legally under the current rule. In fact, there is nothing wrong with a WR receiving a backward pass outside the hash, and then, seeing no opening, or open receiver, dumping the ball Oob.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
I think there is high percentage change there are ineligibles downfield on a play that was designed to be a run. So even the it was a legal forward pass by the running back throwing the ball away there could be a penalty of 5 yards plus loss of down.
Ineligible downfield does not carry loss of down.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
Ineligible downfield does not carry loss of down.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
my bad, you are correct. illegal touching carries the loss of down. Thanks for pointing that out!
-
wouldn't the handoff have to have been received behind the qb?
i don't know why I thought this but i guess i have never seen a quarterback hand the ball of to a player who then tries to pass the ball. I have seen a qb throw a pass backwards or pitch the ball backwards and the player who then receives the ball attempts to throw a pass. I have seen a quarterback hand the ball off to a running back who then pitches the ball back to the quarterback also.
I think the idea of running back who let's say is running a sweep just wouldn't have enough time to realize he was going to be tackled for a loss and so then he decides to throw the ball away to conserve yardage.
I could see a designed play where a qb lines up as a running back and takes a handoff and then tries passing but I haven't seen that either. Granted this is now my 4th year of officiating so I definitely have NOT seen it all.
I have.
-
This reads like the prototypical NFHS exam "reading test". Depending on who wrote the question and the answer key, it could be True, or it could be False; although I would go with RefMike22 's answer of false because of the lack of all of the elements in the question that would make it a legal play. Those tricky so and so's at NFHS exam HQ really want to make sure all your cogs are turning.
However for the umpteenth time, let us review. The Fed purposefully left the term PASSER in the new rule. They don't care if it is the QB, the HB, or the freaking LT. If he and the ball have been outside the parallel boundaries of the FBZ at some point during the play, he can chuck it to Saturn as long as Saturn is at or beyond the NZ. This new rule is all about SAFETY. We want our passer, any passer to be SAFE, the NCAA not withstanding. Guidance I have seen here and elsewhere has indicated that we are to be liberal with the idea that the passer has been outside the FBZ and that the ball reaches the NZ.
There have also been varying discussions around the Interwebs that we probably need to ignore the big boys who waywardly might have slipped on downfield given that A's passer is giving up the down.
No it's not. QB's get hit a lot harder when they are blindsided standing in the pocket. If they are outside the pocket and have time to throw they ball where they want to they aren't going to be hit very hard. If it was all about SAFETY the QB in the pocket would be allowed to throw the ball away, and he isn't.
-
No it's not. QB's get hit a lot harder when they are blindsided standing in the pocket. If they are outside the pocket and have time to throw they ball where they want to they aren't going to be hit very hard. If it was all about SAFETY the QB in the pocket would be allowed to throw the ball away, and he isn't.
This is so true. If they were completely honest, the coaches driving this change are much more concerned about being able to escape loss of yardage than getting the Passer hurt.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
No it's not. QB's get hit a lot harder when they are blindsided standing in the pocket. If they are outside the pocket and have time to throw they ball where they want to they aren't going to be hit very hard. If it was all about SAFETY the QB in the pocket would be allowed to throw the ball away, and he isn't.
I agree. Using the “player safety” rationale is merely a red herring designed to pass a rule that greatly benefits the offense without a corresponding offset for the defense.
-
I think there is high percentage change there are ineligibles downfield on a play that was designed to be a run. So even the it was a legal forward pass by the running back throwing the ball away there could be a penalty of 5 yards plus loss of down.
For NFHS - and that is what y'all are talking about, I know - that is probably true (except the LOD part). But, I was making the point that the NCAA has already resolved this issue, by eliminating IDP - by rule - when the pass is legally grounded near the sideline or OB. And, that is something the NFHS should consider, particularly if they are going to allow any player to legally ground the pass. (In NCAA, if the player that throws the pass isn't the 'receiver of the snap,' then that would be an illegal forward pass, which also obviates IDP, since that requires a legal forward pass).
I guess I'm just making the point that the NCAA has already resolved these issues related to legally grounding the ball. So, if the NFHS is going to allow grounding - which, I know, is a sore subject among many NFHS coaches and officials - then adopt the NCAA rules. Just my thoughts. I'll go away now.
-
wouldn't the handoff have to have been received behind the qb?
i don't know why I thought this but i guess i have never seen a quarterback hand the ball of to a player who then tries to pass the ball. I have seen a qb throw a pass backwards or pitch the ball backwards and the player who then receives the ball attempts to throw a pass. I have seen a quarterback hand the ball off to a running back who then pitches the ball back to the quarterback also.
I think the idea of running back who let's say is running a sweep just wouldn't have enough time to realize he was going to be tackled for a loss and so then he decides to throw the ball away to conserve yardage.
I could see a designed play where a qb lines up as a running back and takes a handoff and then tries passing but I haven't seen that either. Granted this is now my 4th year of officiating so I definitely have NOT seen it all.
You've never seen the halfback pass? Or a wideout throw the ball after a fly sweep? Not every team does it, but it's a fairly common trick play.
I also think any "non-passer" who thinks to ditch the ball rather than take a couple yard loss is going to learn about the legend of Garo Yepremian real fast.
-
Seeing alot of comments would like if you would answer the question T/F as if you were answering this question if it showed up on a test that you are taking thanks
-
Seeing alot of comments would like if you would answer the question T/F as if you were answering this question if it showed up on a test that you are taking thanks
HLinNC nailed it earlier. It depends on the test writer and based on context of other questions on the test.
If the intent of the question seems to be "Can a running back utilize the new rule change?" then it's true. If the intent is to highlight all aspects of the rule, then it is false for omitting the FBZ requirement.
I'd probably err on the side of false as questions tend to be more overly precise, in my experiences. You cannot assume facts not in evidence, so if it is not mentioned then it didn't happen. Personally, I hate these questions that feel like they're trying to trip you up on a technicality of wording, rather than an understanding the of the rule.
-
Seeing alot of comments would like if you would answer the question T/F as if you were answering this question if it showed up on a test that you are taking thanks
Give us the reason behind the question. The reason for all the comments is because we don’t have enough info to answer the question as is, plus we don’t know the context behind the question.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
No it's not.
Considering Ralph has talked about it here and there was a video released by another state's rules committee member telling us the same thing, I'll go with their conclusion that it is what drove the rule change.
-
Give us the reason behind the question. The reason for all the comments is because we don’t have enough info to answer the question as is, plus we don’t know the context behind the question.
This is a actual test question is it T/F ?
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
Give us the reason behind the question. The reason for all the comments is because we don’t have enough info to answer the question as is, plus we don’t know the context behind the question.
Actual test question is it T or F ?
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
Actual test question all I'am asking is to answer T or F
-
As presented in the OP, it’s False. It’s only legal if the RB is (or has been) also outside of the FBZ, and that’s not given.
-
Well test results show this answer was T ! hmm
-
the answer they are looking for is TRUE....i am guessing that the test givers want to know if anyone can ground the ball or does it have to be the receiver of the snap....horrible question since they do not tell you from where the pass is thrown, within or outside the FBZ....my guess is that the question will, and should be thrown out..... hEaDbAnG
-
the answer they are looking for is TRUE....i am guessing that the test givers want to know if anyone can ground the ball or does it have to be the receiver of the snap....horrible question since they do not tell you from where the pass is thrown, within or outside the FBZ....my guess is that the question will, and should be thrown out..... hEaDbAnG
The question as worded has to be false as noted by several posters here. Not all of the conditions needed for the answer to be true are included in the stated question. We cannot assume the missing information.
-
That type of question can cost you on a passing grade on this test not fair based on the wording!
-
That type of question can cost you on a passing grade on this test not fair based on the wording!
I'm really not trying to be ugly here, but if this question costs you a passing grade on the test, you have bigger problems.
-
As written by the NFHS the answer is true. However, Iowa was a test state that past 2 years and we only gave (and will continue this year to give) the ability to throw the ball away to the person receiving the snap. so in Iowa the answer to this question is FALSE.
-
As written by the NFHS the answer is true. However, Iowa was a test state that past 2 years and we only gave (and will continue this year to give) the ability to throw the ball away to the person receiving the snap. so in Iowa the answer to this question is FALSE.
Goodness. Maybe the NFHS should have prefaced this change with the phrase, "By state association adoption, each state may write up a rule along with an interpretation of their choosing, that allows someone to throw the ball away under certain conditions..."
FWIW, sounds like Iowa has solved the problem..
-
That type of question can cost you on a passing grade on this test not fair based on the wording!
You've not been taking Fed tests very long, have you?
This isn't an uncommon phenomenon with NFHS tests dating back before the online exams. I remember a year when NC actually threw out TWO questions on the same exam that were deemed improper or possibly a correct answer either way. One of our longtime officials who was a major D1 conference umpire and an asst. superintendent of our county school system frequently bemoaned the fact that more often than not it was a reading test instead of a test of our rules knowledge.
I agree with Calhoun. If one question is the make or break for someone passing or failing this exam, there are bigger issues at hand. I know every state and/or area is different in how they test but the online exam for us in NC is essentially open book and many of us get together and collaborate to take the exam. When I started, we took it in a school classroom and it was proctored by the school AD. Times have changed. I think the more common occurrence is a question like this can cause someone to make a 98 or 96 instead of 100 and that really is more a matter of pride than anything else.
In reality, I don't think we are supposed to be posting or discussing specific test questions until exams are complete. I think that used to be a policy here. I know that it is on one of the NFHS Facebook groups.
-
Back around the millennium I was on the Editorial Committee.The Editorial Committee writes the tests. A couple of 'walking rule books waiting to happen' (guys that know the rules but not the game) were adamant that a question wasn't just poorly worded but WRONG. I agreed and called our editor (then Jerry Diel). He agreed and said that when he and an EC member agree on a mistake,he will notify the state associations of the corrections.
I then notified the walking rule books that they now had 100 and not 99. Test results are part of our ratings, Tests were then on paper & pencil while being corrected by me with an answer overlay. The WRBs (walking rule books) wanted me to go in and change those others that had 100 to 99.
:puke: :puke: tR:oLl tR:oLl
I now take the stance that poorly worded questions are like some of our poorly made calls....we just live with 'em :o ??? 8] :!#
-
The question as worded has to be false as noted by several posters here. Not all of the conditions needed for the answer to be true are included in the stated question. We cannot assume the missing information.
this is a question on my state exam and the correct answer was TRUE....this test was given through the arbiter....i do not know where they get their questions...once again...horrible question since important information is missing
-
For NFHS - and that is what y'all are talking about, I know - that is probably true (except the LOD part). But, I was making the point that the NCAA has already resolved this issue, by eliminating IDP - by rule - when the pass is legally grounded near the sideline or OB. And, that is something the NFHS should consider, particularly if they are going to allow any player to legally ground the pass. (In NCAA, if the player that throws the pass isn't the 'receiver of the snap,' then that would be an illegal forward pass, which also obviates IDP, since that requires a legal forward pass).
I guess I'm just making the point that the NCAA has already resolved these issues related to legally grounding the ball. So, if the NFHS is going to allow grounding - which, I know, is a sore subject among many NFHS coaches and officials - then adopt the NCAA rules. Just my thoughts. I'll go away now.
In my opinion, which I am entitled too, people coming on to the NFHS Board to tells us all about the NCAA rules is quite frankly NOT HELPFUL at all. this is ESPECIALLY TRUE when NFHS officials are attempting to learn a brand new NFHS rule.
For clarification, under the new NFHS Rule, if the player who throws the forward pass has met the two requirements of 7-5-2d EXE 2a and 2b He/She has thrown a LEGAL FORWARD PASS.
Rule 7-5-12 tells us, If an ineligible receiver is downfield during a Legal Forward Pass play, it is a foul in under NFHS play! Don't really care what NCAA, the NFL, the USFL, NFL Europe, or the CFL does with this situation.
Reality check: If IDP is thrown during a play in which the passer chooses to Legally Terminate the play, their is a 99.99% chance this foul will be declined by B so as not to give A an extra down.
NFHS does NOT ignore any foul by A as, if their is also a foul on B, they will offset as a double foul.
Imagine having holding on B and an Ineligible downfield on A! Do we just tell the B coach; Yea we saw him down field but Elvis reminded us that NCAA doesn't call that so we are just going to enforce the foul against your team? Not real sure that would would fly.
Now I will go away.