Author Topic: Fair catch question  (Read 13179 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline CalhounLJ

  • *
  • Posts: 3044
  • FAN REACTION: +141/-1010
  • Without officials... it is only recess.
Fair catch question
« on: August 10, 2022, 06:44:30 AM »
A signal given by R behind the neutral zone on a scrimmage kick is an illegal fair catch. True or false?


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Offline HLinNC

  • *
  • Posts: 3491
  • FAN REACTION: +133/-24
Re: Fair catch question
« Reply #1 on: August 10, 2022, 08:13:09 AM »
False  2-9-5 "An Illegal fair-catch signal is any signal by a runner: a) After the kick has been caught. b) After the kick has been recovered."

Offline ilyazhito

  • *
  • Posts: 468
  • FAN REACTION: +14/-24
  • Without officials... it is only recess.
Re: Fair catch question
« Reply #2 on: August 10, 2022, 10:51:09 AM »
For the answer to be true, the question would have to be "A signal given by R behind the neutral zone on a scrimmage kick is an invalid fair catch".

Offline refjeff

  • *
  • Posts: 620
  • FAN REACTION: +22/-33
  • Without officials... it is only recess.
Re: Fair catch question
« Reply #3 on: August 10, 2022, 11:30:04 AM »
For the answer to be true, the question would have to be "A signal given by R behind the neutral zone on a scrimmage kick is an invalid fair catch".
It's not a foul of any kind, illegal or invalid, and he doesn't get protection if he catches the ball.

R.B. 2.9.3-5 and 6.5.1

C.B 6.5.2 Situation B
« Last Edit: August 10, 2022, 11:34:41 AM by refjeff »

Offline CalhounLJ

  • *
  • Posts: 3044
  • FAN REACTION: +141/-1010
  • Without officials... it is only recess.
Re: Fair catch question
« Reply #4 on: August 10, 2022, 11:33:08 AM »
I don't think it is a foul of any kind, illegal or invalid.

2.9.3-5 and 6.5.1

Me either. I think it's a valid signal at a spot on the field where we can't award a fair catch. We blow it dead for safety's sake, and R gets the ball there, but do not have the option to try a free kick for a field goal from that spot.

My guys have been answering "false" on the test, but that answer is being graded incorrect...

Offline HLinNC

  • *
  • Posts: 3491
  • FAN REACTION: +133/-24
Re: Fair catch question
« Reply #5 on: August 10, 2022, 09:37:41 PM »
My guys have been answering "false" on the test, but that answer is being graded incorrect...

I think I missed that one myself.  It wouldn't be the first time the Fed screwed up a test question.

Offline ncwingman

  • *
  • Posts: 1518
  • FAN REACTION: +79/-22
  • Without officials... it is only recess.
Re: Fair catch question
« Reply #6 on: August 10, 2022, 10:19:08 PM »
For the answer to be true, the question would have to be "A signal given by R behind the neutral zone on a scrimmage kick is an invalid fair catch".

I don't think that's even true. There's nothing in the rule about where the fair catch signal may be proffered, only that it is not a fair catch if the catch is made in/behind the neutral zone since K has the right to recover and advance a kick in that area.

If an R player makes a good signal behind the neutral zone, and then an R player catches the scrimmage kick beyond the neutral zone, I don't see that being a foul.

Offline Tom.OH

  • *
  • Posts: 410
  • FAN REACTION: +9/-0
Re: Fair catch question
« Reply #7 on: August 11, 2022, 04:51:35 AM »
My guys have been answering "false" on the test, but that answer is being graded incorrect...

I think I missed that one myself.  It wouldn't be the first time the Fed screwed up a test question.

Way back in 1999 when I was taking my class exam our instructor told us to stop for a second. He told us to go to question 26 and mark it true. We all know the correct answer is false but the test has true on the answer sheet...
"Outside of a dog, a book is man's best friend. And inside of a dog, it's to dark to read."
Groucho Marx

Offline HLinNC

  • *
  • Posts: 3491
  • FAN REACTION: +133/-24
Re: Fair catch question
« Reply #8 on: August 11, 2022, 05:28:07 AM »
Quote
I don't think that's even true. There's nothing in the rule about where the fair catch signal may be proffered,

Here is the discussion that we had in our local meeting as to the basis of the question.

 2-9-1 defines a fair catch.   2-9-4 states "an invalid F-C signal is any signal by a receiver before the kick is caught or recovered: a) That does not meet the requirements of a valid signal."

If you link back to 2-9-1- "A F-C is a catch by a receiver.......or of a scrimmage kick beyond the NZ to the receiver's goal line, after a valid signal"....."  In our efforts to try and figure out the reasoning of the test writer(s), we surmised that they must be trying to say that the signal did not meet the requirements of a valid signal based on the location it was given and the type kick that it was.  Tortured reasoning, yes; but we all know that Fed tests have been reading exams for years.  None of this meshes with the fact that has nothing to do with an illegal signal anyway.

There have been occasions when our state has eventually tossed out a question or two based on the number of appeals it got.
If one is in a state that doesn't require a closed book test, have a group with half answering true and half answering false and see what happens.  It could very well be the NFHS Kobayashi Maru.
« Last Edit: August 11, 2022, 05:33:00 AM by HLinNC »

Offline refjeff

  • *
  • Posts: 620
  • FAN REACTION: +22/-33
  • Without officials... it is only recess.
Re: Fair catch question
« Reply #9 on: August 11, 2022, 06:18:19 AM »
I read and thought about that too but,

6.5.1  Any receiver may signal for a fair catch while any legal kick is in flight. 

The language is very clear.  it says any legal kick.  It does not say where the kick has to land.

Offline CalhounLJ

  • *
  • Posts: 3044
  • FAN REACTION: +141/-1010
  • Without officials... it is only recess.
Fair catch question
« Reply #10 on: August 11, 2022, 06:18:21 AM »
Here is the discussion that we had in our local meeting as to the basis of the question.

 2-9-1 defines a fair catch.   2-9-4 states "an invalid F-C signal is any signal by a receiver before the kick is caught or recovered: a) That does not meet the requirements of a valid signal."

If you link back to 2-9-1- "A F-C is a catch by a receiver.......or of a scrimmage kick beyond the NZ to the receiver's goal line, after a valid signal"....."  In our efforts to try and figure out the reasoning of the test writer(s), we surmised that they must be trying to say that the signal did not meet the requirements of a valid signal based on the location it was given and the type kick that it was.  Tortured reasoning, yes; but we all know that Fed tests have been reading exams for years.  None of this meshes with the fact that has nothing to do with an illegal signal anyway.

There have been occasions when our state has eventually tossed out a question or two based on the number of appeals it got.
If one is in a state that doesn't require a closed book test, have a group with half answering true and half answering false and see what happens.  It could very well be the NFHS Kobayashi Maru.
I see the “tortured reasoning,” but consider this. There are two elements to consider on this topic- the signal and the actual fair catch. One can give a valid signal in an area where a fair catch can’t be awarded. In at least two places- in or behind the neutral zone, and in the end zone. We’ve discussed the neutral zone, so let’s think about the end zone. A player standing in the end zone can give a valid signal, but cannot be awarded a fair catch because the ball is dead once it crosses the plane.

In the same way, a player can give a valid signal behind the nz and still not be awarded a fair catch. Nothing about the place makes the signal invalid, and certainly not illegal.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
« Last Edit: August 11, 2022, 06:20:26 AM by CalhounLJ »

Offline HLinNC

  • *
  • Posts: 3491
  • FAN REACTION: +133/-24
Re: Fair catch question
« Reply #11 on: August 11, 2022, 07:25:01 AM »
Occam's Razor- Fed screwed the pooch.

Offline refjeff

  • *
  • Posts: 620
  • FAN REACTION: +22/-33
  • Without officials... it is only recess.
Re: Fair catch question
« Reply #12 on: August 11, 2022, 07:34:24 AM »
Occam's Razor- Fed screwed the pooch.
Yep.  It happens.


Offline CalhounLJ

  • *
  • Posts: 3044
  • FAN REACTION: +141/-1010
  • Without officials... it is only recess.
Re: Fair catch question
« Reply #13 on: August 11, 2022, 07:45:24 AM »
Occam's Razor- Fed screwed the pooch.
“Like”
“Thumbs up”
Man, I wish we had buttons.



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Offline Ralph Damren

  • *
  • Posts: 5165
  • FAN REACTION: +876/-28
  • SEE IT-THINK IT-CALL IT
Re: Fair catch question
« Reply #14 on: August 11, 2022, 09:18:23 AM »
I once had a coach present this trick play to me....

COACH : "We've a player whose sole talent is kicking the ball straight up in the air. From punt formation he'll do just that. A blocking back will yell and signal 'FAIR CATCH, FAIR CATCH'. Once he's caught the ball, he'll say : "Let me just give the ball to mister back judge"...and begin to stroll dowfield until he can break for a touchdown."

ME: " While this is an invalid fair catch, once the catch is made, I would rule that his forward progress has stopped and the ball would turn over to R. I would apply rule 1-1-6. Unsure that this would have fooled the recieving team, but could be useful to the drama coach in a one-act play intitled: Mr. Touchdown.

Unsure if the coach ever did find a place for the kid that had that sole talent. tR:oLl


Offline ncwingman

  • *
  • Posts: 1518
  • FAN REACTION: +79/-22
  • Without officials... it is only recess.
Re: Fair catch question
« Reply #15 on: August 11, 2022, 02:04:19 PM »
I once had a coach present this trick play to me....

COACH : "We've a player whose sole talent is kicking the ball straight up in the air. From punt formation he'll do just that. A blocking back will yell and signal 'FAIR CATCH, FAIR CATCH'. Once he's caught the ball, he'll say : "Let me just give the ball to mister back judge"...and begin to stroll dowfield until he can break for a touchdown."

ME: " While this is an invalid fair catch, once the catch is made, I would rule that his forward progress has stopped and the ball would turn over to R. I would apply rule 1-1-6. Unsure that this would have fooled the recieving team, but could be useful to the drama coach in a one-act play intitled: Mr. Touchdown.

Unsure if the coach ever did find a place for the kid that had that sole talent. tR:oLl

To poke at an extreme technicality -- 2-9-4 clearly states that an invalid signal is one given by a 'receiver'. As far as I can tell, that word is not fully defined in the rule book, as it gets used both in the team definition of R relating to kicks, but also for members of both A and B regarding forward passes.

If the implication is that a 'receiver' is a member of Team R during a legal kick, then a member of K couldn't actually give an invalid signal.

However, I'd also buy an argument that, since K is allowed to recover and advance that kick behind the LOS, they could also be a 'receiver' in that scenario.

Anyway... long story short... week one can't get here fast enough.

Offline KDJBBBJ

  • *
  • Posts: 109
  • FAN REACTION: +1/-2
Re: Fair catch question
« Reply #16 on: August 11, 2022, 04:47:57 PM »
 
I once had a coach present this trick play to me....

COACH : "We've a player whose sole talent is kicking the ball straight up in the air. From punt formation he'll do just that. A blocking back will yell and signal 'FAIR CATCH, FAIR CATCH'. Once he's caught the ball, he'll say : "Let me just give the ball to mister back judge"...and begin to stroll dowfield until he can break for a touchdown."

ME: " While this is an invalid fair catch, once the catch is made, I would rule that his forward progress has stopped and the ball would turn over to R. I would apply rule 1-1-6. Unsure that this would have fooled the recieving team, but could be useful to the drama coach in a one-act play intitled: Mr. Touchdown.

Unsure if the coach ever did find a place for the kid that had that sole talent. tR:oLl


 I agree completely that this should not be allowed to happen.  Is there an invalid fair catch or just an invalid fair catch signal?

Offline CalhounLJ

  • *
  • Posts: 3044
  • FAN REACTION: +141/-1010
  • Without officials... it is only recess.
Re: Fair catch question
« Reply #17 on: August 11, 2022, 07:06:38 PM »
 
 I agree completely that this should not be allowed to happen.  Is there an invalid fair catch or just an invalid fair catch signal?
There’s no such thing as an invalid fair catch. It’s either a fair catch or not. Only the signal can be invalid.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Offline AlUpstateNY

  • *
  • Posts: 4846
  • FAN REACTION: +344/-1001
Re: Fair catch question
« Reply #18 on: August 11, 2022, 08:12:53 PM »
There’s no such thing as an invalid fair catch. It’s either a fair catch or not. Only the signal can be invalid
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Semantics aside, NFHS 2-9-1 & 3  details what is necessary to make a valid FC, and what constitutes a Valid FC signal while 2-9-1-4 details what constitutes an INvalid  signal
.

Offline Ralph Damren

  • *
  • Posts: 5165
  • FAN REACTION: +876/-28
  • SEE IT-THINK IT-CALL IT
Re: Fair catch question
« Reply #19 on: August 16, 2022, 11:49:02 AM »
My use of 'invalid' was a poor one. I should have just said : "...NOT a fair catch, but the K player yelling gave up his forward progress. This isn't football and 1-1-6 or 9-9-1 should treat it as such.

Offline KDJBBBJ

  • *
  • Posts: 109
  • FAN REACTION: +1/-2
Re: Fair catch question
« Reply #20 on: August 17, 2022, 04:53:15 PM »
NOT a fair catch, but the K player yelling gave up his forward progress. This isn't football and 1-1-6 or 9-9-1 should treat it as such.

Here Here!!