Author Topic: Concussion symptoms and 3-5-10  (Read 8944 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline ncwingman

  • *
  • Posts: 1518
  • FAN REACTION: +79/-22
  • Without officials... it is only recess.
Concussion symptoms and 3-5-10
« on: July 26, 2022, 06:50:18 AM »
In reviewing for rules tests, I had a thought of a possible scenario that doesn't really have coverage in the book for when it's violated.

A player is clearly exhibiting concussion symptoms and we stop play and remove them as per 3-5-10b. By rule, the player is not to return to the game until cleared by a health professional. However, what happens when the player comes back on the field two plays later and it appears evident that the player was not properly evaluated?

If he's still exhibiting symptoms (which is likely), we could send him off again, but it seems likely he'd be sent right on back a play later.

The underlying problem is that we don't really know if he was evaluated and cleared by a medical professional, even if it seems obvious that it did not occur. Additionally, there's no mandatory rules coverage for medical evaluation, only suggested protocol. Can we disqualify a player for medical reasons? I could twist "failure to follow a game officials request" into fitting in the scenario, or maybe give that USC foul to the head coach that keeps sending him back on. That feels rather God Rule-y, and I don't like it.

It's certainly a situation I hope I never see, but it just occurred to me there's no direct enforcement teeth beyond making the kid run back and forth to the sideline every other play -- which he probably shouldn't do if he's got a concussion.

Offline AlUpstateNY

  • *
  • Posts: 4846
  • FAN REACTION: +344/-1001
Re: Concussion symptoms and 3-5-10
« Reply #1 on: July 26, 2022, 08:15:48 AM »
In reviewing for rules tests, I had a thought of a possible scenario that doesn't really have coverage in the book for when it's violated.
A player is clearly exhibiting concussion symptoms and we stop play and remove them as per 3-5-10b. By rule, the player is not to return to the game until cleared by a health professional. However, what happens when the player comes back on the field two plays later and it appears evident that the player was not properly evaluated?
If he's still exhibiting symptoms (which is likely), we could send him off again, but it seems likely he'd be sent right on back a play later. The underlying problem is that we don't really know if he was evaluated and cleared by a medical professional, even if it seems obvious that it did not occur. Additionally, there's no mandatory rules coverage for medical evaluation, only suggested protocol. Can we disqualify a player for medical reasons? I could twist "failure to follow a game officials request" into fitting in the scenario, or maybe give that USC foul to the head coach that keeps sending him back on. That feels rather God Rule-y, and I don't like it.
It's certainly a situation I hope I never see, but it just occurred to me there's no direct enforcement teeth beyond making the kid run back and forth to the sideline every other play -- which he probably shouldn't do if he's got a concussion.

I don't think "DISQUALIFICATION" is the appropriate consideration to this type of exceptional situation.  Considering that NFHS Rules & Protocols cover multiple levels of both HS and "Youth" football, which may provide different levels of "Appropriate Health Care-Professional" expertise, additional discussion & consideration is appropriate.  Even in such an unusual situation as described, common sense and possible player safety must prevail. 

As suggested, when actual symptoms and/or behaviors indicate ANY potential for the presence of a problem, the player should be prohibited from  participation.  This may, or when necessary should require, at least, the total dissipation of ANY symptom/behavior causing alarm and if necessary additional , specific, evaluation and approval by additional "Appropriate HealthCare-Professionals " to verify the medical authorization of fitness to continue, Until appropriate medical confirmation of the player's fitness to continue is assured, the player should be restricted from further participation, but is not "Disqualified". 

A detailed explanation of this situation should be included in a formal Game Report.

Offline CalhounLJ

  • *
  • Posts: 3044
  • FAN REACTION: +141/-1010
  • Without officials... it is only recess.
Re: Concussion symptoms and 3-5-10
« Reply #2 on: July 26, 2022, 08:33:18 AM »
In reviewing for rules tests, I had a thought of a possible scenario that doesn't really have coverage in the book for when it's violated.

A player is clearly exhibiting concussion symptoms and we stop play and remove them as per 3-5-10b. By rule, the player is not to return to the game until cleared by a health professional. However, what happens when the player comes back on the field two plays later and it appears evident that the player was not properly evaluated?

If he's still exhibiting symptoms (which is likely), we could send him off again, but it seems likely he'd be sent right on back a play later.

The underlying problem is that we don't really know if he was evaluated and cleared by a medical professional, even if it seems obvious that it did not occur. Additionally, there's no mandatory rules coverage for medical evaluation, only suggested protocol. Can we disqualify a player for medical reasons? I could twist "failure to follow a game officials request" into fitting in the scenario, or maybe give that USC foul to the head coach that keeps sending him back on. That feels rather God Rule-y, and I don't like it.

It's certainly a situation I hope I never see, but it just occurred to me there's no direct enforcement teeth beyond making the kid run back and forth to the sideline every other play -- which he probably shouldn't do if he's got a concussion.

Used to be that a player exhibiting signs of a concussion could not return until a written note from a physician was presented to the Referee. That's been removed. Now the responsibility rests on the HC. If he sends the player back in, the assumption is that he's been cleared to the satisfaction of the HC. If he continues to show signs, we send him off again. If it becomes redundant, I'm going to have a talk with the HC.

Offline HLinNC

  • *
  • Posts: 3491
  • FAN REACTION: +133/-24
Re: Concussion symptoms and 3-5-10
« Reply #3 on: July 26, 2022, 08:50:16 AM »
If an official continues to detect symptoms, continue to send them off.  The onus is on the school personnel.

Losing your job or license to practice medicine is usually enough incentive for them to follow the protocols for a suspected concussion.
« Last Edit: July 26, 2022, 08:51:50 AM by HLinNC »

Offline Ralph Damren

  • *
  • Posts: 5165
  • FAN REACTION: +876/-28
  • SEE IT-THINK IT-CALL IT
Re: Concussion symptoms and 3-5-10
« Reply #4 on: July 26, 2022, 09:00:03 AM »
In our pre-game meeting with the HCs (home coach first), we always ask : "Is a 'health care proffesional' present ?" If his response is : " I'm it !" , IMHO , while I fear it's a conflict for + one to wear two hats ; HCP = saftey of players is top priority, HC = to win is top priority. By rule , HC/HCP is allowable. If the home team has a health care professional, my visit to the visiting coach would begin with : "They have a HCP here in case you don't, would you like to use him/her IF you don't ?" IMHO, that takes the coach from taking that is his duty off the table AND removes the gripe of : " ....BUT he/she is rooting for the other team !!". Most games have an ambulance present, most ambulances are operated by qualified health care proffesionals.....just thinking  8]

Offline ncwingman

  • *
  • Posts: 1518
  • FAN REACTION: +79/-22
  • Without officials... it is only recess.
Re: Concussion symptoms and 3-5-10
« Reply #5 on: July 26, 2022, 02:41:33 PM »
Most games have an ambulance present, most ambulances are operated by qualified health care proffesionals.....just thinking  8]

Do they though? Just sort of thinking out loud, but there are a wide variety of qualifications that allow you to work in an ambulance. Most are at the EMT level that are mostly just advanced first aid and can transport you to a hospital and real doctor quickly. They aren't necessarily qualified to officially diagnose problems like concussions. Even if there's a formal athletic trainer, they're probably more orthopedists or physiotherapists and major trauma injuries aren't in their realm of expertise.

However, I'm also envisioning more situations were a player is sent off and the coach/staff/whoever simply doesn't evaluate him and sends him back in for the next play. We officials aren't paying attention to what the trainers are or are not doing on the sidelines, so we can't confirm or deny what happened. It's not that the designated medical professional approved the player's return, it's that they intentionally didn't evaluate the player to avoid having to sit him out. If you stop testing, the cases go down, right?

Offline CalhounLJ

  • *
  • Posts: 3044
  • FAN REACTION: +141/-1010
  • Without officials... it is only recess.
Re: Concussion symptoms and 3-5-10
« Reply #6 on: July 26, 2022, 02:47:21 PM »
Do they though? Just sort of thinking out loud, but there are a wide variety of qualifications that allow you to work in an ambulance. Most are at the EMT level that are mostly just advanced first aid and can transport you to a hospital and real doctor quickly. They aren't necessarily qualified to officially diagnose problems like concussions. Even if there's a formal athletic trainer, they're probably more orthopedists or physiotherapists and major trauma injuries aren't in their realm of expertise.

However, I'm also envisioning more situations were a player is sent off and the coach/staff/whoever simply doesn't evaluate him and sends him back in for the next play. We officials aren't paying attention to what the trainers are or are not doing on the sidelines, so we can't confirm or deny what happened. It's not that the designated medical professional approved the player's return, it's that they intentionally didn't evaluate the player to avoid having to sit him out. If you stop testing, the cases go down, right?

i agree with all of this. I'm also ok with leaving that responsibility up to the coaches/school personnel. I do not want to be the concussion police. There's enough responsibility just having to determine if a kid is showing signs.

Offline HLinNC

  • *
  • Posts: 3491
  • FAN REACTION: +133/-24
Re: Concussion symptoms and 3-5-10
« Reply #7 on: July 26, 2022, 03:21:51 PM »
Quote
However, I'm also envisioning more situations were a player is sent off and the coach/staff/whoever simply doesn't evaluate him and sends him back in for the next play. We officials aren't paying attention to what the trainers are or are not doing on the sidelines, so we can't confirm or deny what happened. It's not that the designated medical professional approved the player's return, it's that they intentionally didn't evaluate the player to avoid having to sit him out. If you stop testing, the cases go down, right?

While not out of the realm of possibility, the amount of liability incurred and the amount of lawyers, judges, boards, commissions, politicians, and media scrutiny that would become involved would be staggering.  The guilty parties involved might get away with some scam for a while but the aftermath would be pretty staggering.  Are there people out there that stupid?  Nearly 30 years as a parole officer tells me "yes".  I just don't see it having much of a chance to occur at the scholastic level. 

Now youth league?  I think your odds of it happening increase.

Offline AlUpstateNY

  • *
  • Posts: 4846
  • FAN REACTION: +344/-1001
Re: Concussion symptoms and 3-5-10
« Reply #8 on: July 27, 2022, 08:53:57 AM »

i agree with all of this. I'm also ok with leaving that responsibility up to the coaches/school personnel. I do not want to be the concussion police. There's enough responsibility just having to determine if a kid is showing signs.

YES, the "ultimate" responsibility to determine a player's ability to continue play, after stoppage for "Potential" does rest with the team, and appropriate "medical health-care" review.  However that that review DOES NOT override/preclude the caution of a game official who observes CONTINUING/PRESENT behaviors/potential symptoms/continuing signs of concussion FROM HAULTING immediate participation pending additional "medical health-care professional" observation and/or further examination to verify/confirm the player's ability to SAFELY return.

Everyone's PRIMARY CONCERN is player's safety, especially at the Interscholastic level & BELOW and confirmation of the absence of "Warning Signs" , HOWEVER AND BY WHOMEVER should be an ABSOLUTE requirement prohibiting/delaying participation.
« Last Edit: July 27, 2022, 09:04:03 AM by AlUpstateNY »

Offline dammitbobby

  • *
  • Posts: 1822
  • FAN REACTION: +40/-12
  • Exceed the standard... or don't do the job
Re: Concussion symptoms and 3-5-10
« Reply #9 on: July 27, 2022, 09:38:45 AM »
While not out of the realm of possibility, the amount of liability incurred and the amount of lawyers, judges, boards, commissions, politicians, and media scrutiny that would become involved would be staggering.  The guilty parties involved might get away with some scam for a while but the aftermath would be pretty staggering.  Are there people out there that stupid?  Nearly 30 years as a parole officer tells me "yes".  I just don't see it having much of a chance to occur at the scholastic level. 

Now youth league?  I think your odds of it happening increase.

I agree, and at youth league level, I'm going to exert a lot more authority around this, if the youth league doesn't already have procedures around this - for example, one league around here, if a kid shows signs of a concussion, he's done until he goes to a doc and gets a note that he is medically cleared.  No ifs ands or buts, if he shows signs, he's done for the day.  I've had kids go off the field under this protocol (honestly I the kids is A-ok with it 99% of the time) and have never had any arguments from coaches, ever, around this.

If that kind of protocol isn't in place, and a coach wanted to send a player who showed signs back in, I'm going to have a conversation with the 'medical personnel' who thinks that's OK, and make a determination based on that.  Even if they didn't like it, and complained to the football board, congress, or whoever, limiting the play of someone at that age who showed concussion symptoms will always, ultimately be supportable.  And if it's not, I don't want to officiate that league and I especially wouldn't want my kids playing.

Offline AlUpstateNY

  • *
  • Posts: 4846
  • FAN REACTION: +344/-1001
Re: Concussion symptoms and 3-5-10
« Reply #10 on: July 28, 2022, 03:36:01 PM »
I agree, and at youth league level, I'm going to exert a lot more authority around this, if the youth league doesn't already have procedures around this - for example, one league around here, if a kid shows signs of a concussion, he's done until he goes to a doc and gets a note that he is medically cleared.  No ifs ands or buts, if he shows signs, he's done for the day.  I've had kids go off the field under this protocol (honestly I the kids is A-ok with it 99% of the time) and have never had any arguments from coaches, ever, around this.

If that kind of protocol isn't in place, and a coach wanted to send a player who showed signs back in, I'm going to have a conversation with the 'medical personnel' who thinks that's OK, and make a determination based on that.  Even if they didn't like it, and complained to the football board, congress, or whoever, limiting the play of someone at that age who showed concussion symptoms will always, ultimately be supportable.  And if it's not, I don't want to officiate that league and I especially wouldn't want my kids playing.

Absolutely agree, Lacking any such absolute league protocols such as you describe, the decision whether a player is allowed to continue is our responsibility, subject to hopefully helpful insight from available "medical personnel" (which unfortunately is presented in many forms).  Dealing with such issues from a maximum protective perspective, ESPECIALLY at the youth football levels, is an extremely important, potentially life altering matter, far above any issue relating to the game at hand.

Offline BIG UMP

  • *
  • Posts: 240
  • FAN REACTION: +10/-1
Re: Concussion symptoms and 3-5-10
« Reply #11 on: August 15, 2022, 03:35:56 PM »
We had a similar discussion at our meeting yesterday. 

We also ask if a health care provider is present.  If yes, we're out of any discussion on concussion.  If a player comes in 2 plays later and we question that, we are to stop the clock ask the coach if he is cleared?  if yes move on.  If no HCP is present when we send someone out he's out.

If a player continues to exhibit signs we continue to send him out.  Bet most HCPs won't send him back the first time unless they are SURE he is clear.  Liability is too high.

If a coach tells me he is HCP, I'm asking "certified"? If he says yes I'm good, but in TN our whole crew hears the HCP answer.
Big Ump


"EVERY JOB IS A SELF-PORTRAIT OF THE PERSON WHO DID IT.  AUTOGRAPH YOUR WORK WITH EXCELLENCE."~unknown

Offline KWH

  • *
  • Posts: 732
  • FAN REACTION: +641/-114
  • See it, Think about it, Pass on it if possible!
Re: Concussion symptoms and 3-5-10
« Reply #12 on: August 16, 2022, 06:40:39 PM »

The rules committee removed the Game Officials from any and all medical questions, requirements or liability except for the one that says,
If we see a player exhibiting signs or symptoms of a concussion we send them out and let the head coach know why. The player must sit the next play and (other than paperwork) our responsibilities are over!

If the player returns to play we simply start all over like he/she is a new player, and, unless the player exhibits the signs or symptoms, he/she remains a player.

Restated, The NFHS purposely took us out of the loop so lets not start inserting ourselves into situations that are NOT our responsibility.
SEE everything that you CALL, but; Don't CALL everything you SEE!
Never let the Rules Book get in the way of a great ball game!

Respectfully Submitted;
Some guy on a message forum

Offline CalhounLJ

  • *
  • Posts: 3044
  • FAN REACTION: +141/-1010
  • Without officials... it is only recess.
Re: Concussion symptoms and 3-5-10
« Reply #13 on: August 16, 2022, 06:45:57 PM »
The rules committee removed the Game Officials from any and all medical questions, requirements or liability except for the one that says,
If we see a player exhibiting signs or symptoms of a concussion we send them out and let the head coach know why. The player must sit the next play and (other than paperwork) our responsibilities are over!

If the player returns to play we simply start all over like he/she is a new player, and, unless the player exhibits the signs or symptoms, he/she remains a player.

Restated, The NFHS purposely took us out of the loop so lets not start inserting ourselves into situations that are NOT our responsibility.
I agree completely. Send him out, and if he comes back the assumption is he has been cleared by a HCP. If he exhibits signs, send him back out. That’s the way the rule reads.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Offline AlUpstateNY

  • *
  • Posts: 4846
  • FAN REACTION: +344/-1001
Re: Concussion symptoms and 3-5-10
« Reply #14 on: August 16, 2022, 06:59:48 PM »
I agree completely. Send him out, and if he comes back the assumption is he has been cleared by a HCP. If he exhibits signs, send him back out. That’s the way the rule reads.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

It's NOT a challenge to the HCP, or Coach (but especially at the Youth football levels), but, when a previously sent off player is cleared to re-enter, I'm going to subtly welcome him back in.  If he doesn't look right, or exhibits ANY signs of why he was originally sent out, he's going out again.

Offline RMR

  • *
  • Posts: 518
  • FAN REACTION: +10/-6
Re: Concussion symptoms and 3-5-10
« Reply #15 on: August 23, 2022, 09:38:19 PM »
In Louisiana, the following are qualified to evaluate a player for a concussion:
MD – A medical doctor licensed to practice medicine in Louisiana
DO -- A doctor of osteopathic medicine licensed to practice in Louisiana
PA – A physicians assistant licensed to practice in Louisiana
NP – A registered nurse practitioner licensed to practice in Louisiana
PM – A paramedic licensed to practice in Louisiana
AT – An athletic trainer licensed nationally or by the State of Louisiana

If no one meets these criteria, then it falls on the head coach.

If the officials send a player out to be evaluated and he is returned to play and he exhibits symptoms a second time and is sent to be evaluated, he id done for the remainder of that contest.
"Just because you don't understand it, doesn't mean it's wrong."