Situation 1 -
Prior to the snap, B12 immediately attempts to leave the field when he is substituted for. When the ball is snapped B12 is on the field 3 yards from B's sideline and on B's side of the NZ. B12 exits the field and does not participate in or affect the play.
What's the call? This is illegal substitution per the rules book 3-7-3 and the case book 3.7 Comment #1. The foul occurs simultaneous with the snap.
Situation 2 -
Prior to the snap, B12 immediately attempts to leave the field when he is substituted for. When the ball is snapped B12 is on the field 3 yards from B's sideline and on B's side of the NZ. B12 exits the field and does not participate in or affect the play. A1 receives the snap and runs outside the FBZ. From behind the LOS A1 throwns a forward pass out of bounds to an area not occupied by an eligible receiver. When the pass is released A77 is 5 yards beyond the NZ (3 yards beyond the expanded NZ). The ball lands beyond the neutral zone extended.
- Doesn't A77 presumably know the play and therefore shouldn't A77 know not to go beyond the ENZ?
- Is it fair if only the B12 foul is called?
- If the pass is considered an illegal forward pass, then in addition to DPI and IDF not being applicable, wouldn't Roughing The Passer also not be applicable? And wouldn't the inapplicability of RTP be contrary to reasoning for the new rule?
What's the call? It seems to me this is a legal forward pass, and there is a foul on each team which would offset. The down is replayed.
A final situation to think about -
- Ten seconds remaining in the game. A is losing 21-20.
- A's ball 3rd and 15 at B's 20-yard line.
- A attempts a pass play. A1 receives the snap and runs outside the FBZ. From behind the LOS A1 throwns a forward pass out of bounds to an area not occupied by an eligible receiver. When the pass is released A77 is 5 yards beyond the NZ (3 yards beyond the expanded NZ). The ball lands beyond the neutral zone extended. There are 3 seconds remaining in the game.
- If IDF is not called, it will be 4th down and 15, and A will have time for one more play from the B 20-yard line. A play option would be a FG try of 37 yards.
- If IDF is called, it will be 3th down and 20, and A will have time for one more play from the B 25-yard line. A play option would be a FG try of 42 yards.
Under NFHS Rules, I don't see the justification for ignoring IDF (and not giving B the option to accept or decline the penalty). The guidance by KWH is spot on.
The previously provided and future feedback and commentary on this topic is very much appreciated. Thank you.