Author Topic: Is a Recovering Player "defenseless?"  (Read 20482 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline blandis

  • *
  • Posts: 181
  • FAN REACTION: +3/-4
Is a Recovering Player "defenseless?"
« on: August 04, 2014, 03:10:51 PM »
   After going over the "new" definition of the same old rule in our first meeting of the season this play came up that is done a lot by one of our local teams. An onside kick that is driven hard into the ground so that it rebounds high into the air about 15-yards down field with a member of the receiving team, at this point a potential "recovering" player, not a receiver by rule, is in position to recover the kick. He is looking up at the ball and is then drilled with a legal shoulder-to-the-chest hit blocking him away from the ball so that it may be recovered by Team K.
   Does this meet the definition of a defenseless player? Some think it now does. By rule he is NOT a receiver and anyone who is trying to recover the ball can be legally blocked away despite the severity of the legal hit, in my opinion. Anyone else seeing this?

Offline Curious

  • *
  • Posts: 1314
  • FAN REACTION: +36/-50
Re: Is a Recovering Player "defenseless?"
« Reply #1 on: August 04, 2014, 03:33:36 PM »
Agree.  As presented, I would not call a foul.

That said, I can see where 9.4.3 COMMENT(g and j) may cause others to think it is.  Our friends in Indianapolis haven't done us any favors with this one either.

The last sentence of this rule gives an "out" either way: "The game official must draw distinction between contact necessary to make a legal block or tackle, and that which targets (there;s that word again) defenseless players".

Just ambiguous enough for me >:D 

Offline AlUpstateNY

  • *
  • Posts: 4846
  • FAN REACTION: +344/-1001
Re: Is a Recovering Player "defenseless?"
« Reply #2 on: August 04, 2014, 04:12:35 PM »
Keeping in mind that no two football plays are EVER identical, the ambiguity provided allows for and accommodates the judgment of the covering official ruling on a specific occurrence.
« Last Edit: August 04, 2014, 04:14:57 PM by AlUpstateNY »

ECILLJ

  • Guest
Re: Is a Recovering Player "defenseless?"
« Reply #3 on: August 04, 2014, 04:14:52 PM »
   Does this meet the definition of a defenseless player? 

The speaker at the clinic I attended simplified this into a simple question. Is the hit on R by K intended to help K get to the ball (legal) or is the hit by K intended to punish R (illegal)? They went on to say that the plays that blow up a defenseless player MUST be penalized.


Offline blandis

  • *
  • Posts: 181
  • FAN REACTION: +3/-4
Re: Is a Recovering Player "defenseless?"
« Reply #4 on: August 04, 2014, 04:24:02 PM »
So are we going to start suspending rules that allow for a player to be legally blocked because he somehow chose to make himself defenseless? This player does not have a special right to the ball like a receiver does. Is there a certain amount of kinetic energy we are going to allow and not allow? We need uniformity on this and this will clearly get coaches and fans with their hair falling out! This play, although rare, does occur at crucial points in games and usually can decide a game. Are we going to take away this legal play because of what may or not be defined as defenseless or the impossible consistency of saying you hit him legally but too hard? That's impossible to define in a uniform code as what you think is hard may be weak to someone else!

Offline Rulesman

  • Past Keeper of the Keys
  • Refstripes Hero
  • *****
  • Posts: 3839
  • FAN REACTION: +65535/-2
  • Live like tomorrow never comes.
Re: Is a Recovering Player "defenseless?"
« Reply #5 on: August 04, 2014, 04:27:06 PM »
So are we going to start suspending rules that allow for a player to be legally blocked because he somehow chose to make himself defenseless?
Do you really believe a high school player is intentionally going to make himself "defenseless" in order to try and draw a flag? Some of you guys are reading far too much into this than it is.
"Gentlemen, we are going to relentlessly chase perfection, knowing full well we will not catch it, because nothing is perfect. But we are going to relentlessly chase it, because in the process we will catch excellence. I am not remotely interested in just being good."
- Vince Lombardi

Offline blandis

  • *
  • Posts: 181
  • FAN REACTION: +3/-4
Re: Is a Recovering Player "defenseless?"
« Reply #6 on: August 04, 2014, 04:28:32 PM »
These players need to be protected from "illegal" hits. To change it so that players are protected from "legal" hits means the suspension of rules that I think was never the intent of the committee.

ECILLJ

  • Guest
Re: Is a Recovering Player "defenseless?"
« Reply #7 on: August 04, 2014, 04:28:41 PM »
  Are we going to take away this legal play because of what may or not be defined as defenseless or the impossible consistency of saying you hit him legally but too hard? 

I guess that is why they pay us the big bucks. LOL

On a serious note, I do not believe this call will be that difficult to officiate. After much discussion at our clinic, we were finally told. "Guys, you know the blow-up play when you see it and we want it cleaned up."

Offline blandis

  • *
  • Posts: 181
  • FAN REACTION: +3/-4
Re: Is a Recovering Player "defenseless?"
« Reply #8 on: August 04, 2014, 04:29:38 PM »
His choice was go try to recover the ball. His other choices were to block or let the ball go by. You read that wrong.

Offline COLOUMP

  • *
  • Posts: 23
  • FAN REACTION: +0/-1
  • Without officials... it is only recess.
Re: Is a Recovering Player "defenseless?"
« Reply #9 on: August 04, 2014, 04:30:38 PM »
This does raise a good point. Applying the definition of a defenseless player to the "recovering" R player does seem appropriate, since his concentration is likely on the ball which is hovering over him and not on the K players charging his way. At the same time, page 74 of the Case Book, 9.3.8 Situation B (c), addresses the situation you describe. While no mention of a defenseless player is made, the Case Book does state that K may contact R. Assuming K's hit is a legitimate block, and not an unnecessarily punishing blow, I agree with you, blandis; my flag would stay in my pocket, and R's coach would likely greet me with his warmest tidings. I know that a "unnecessarily punishing blow" is ripe for interpretation, so the hard part for me would be to make the call or no-call with as much consistency as I can and be ready for criticism.

Offline bama_stripes

  • *
  • Posts: 3209
  • FAN REACTION: +126/-29
Re: Is a Recovering Player "defenseless?"
« Reply #10 on: August 04, 2014, 05:07:37 PM »
The speaker at the clinic I attended simplified this into a simple question. Is the hit on R by K intended to help K get to the ball (legal) or is the hit by K intended to punish R (illegal)? They went on to say that the plays that blow up a defenseless player MUST be penalized.

Agree.  We can tell when a player is trying to make a legitimate play, or whether he's trying to "blow up" an opponent.

Offline Rulesman

  • Past Keeper of the Keys
  • Refstripes Hero
  • *****
  • Posts: 3839
  • FAN REACTION: +65535/-2
  • Live like tomorrow never comes.
Re: Is a Recovering Player "defenseless?"
« Reply #11 on: August 04, 2014, 06:28:37 PM »
Agree.  We can tell when a player is trying to make a legitimate play, or whether he's trying to "blow up" an opponent.
+1
"Gentlemen, we are going to relentlessly chase perfection, knowing full well we will not catch it, because nothing is perfect. But we are going to relentlessly chase it, because in the process we will catch excellence. I am not remotely interested in just being good."
- Vince Lombardi

Offline Magician

  • *
  • Posts: 1084
  • FAN REACTION: +257/-8
Re: Is a Recovering Player "defenseless?"
« Reply #12 on: August 05, 2014, 08:40:06 AM »
The defenseless player only applies to helmet-to-helmet fouls that can now be considered flagrant.  I don't see where it creates any situations where something that wasn't a foul last year is a foul this year.  The confusion I think comes from the use of defenseless with the targeting rule in NCAA.  Since NFHS came up with rules this year that involve defenseless and targeting people assume they are connected.  For now they are not.

In this situation, if the block involves the helmet of both players it could be a flagrant foul and warrant an ejection.  The only new thing is if the K player initiates contact with his shoulder, arm or hand above the shoulders of the R player, you can now have a targeting foul.  That is independent of whether or not you consider him a defenseless player.

I am a strong advocate of getting rid of the unnecessary blow-up hits.  Clocking a guy in pursuit when he doesn't see the hit coming is unnecessary.  But if he's close to the runner, it's hard to call it a foul based on the current rules unless it involves the head.  Blowing up a defenseless player in and of itself is not a foul.

Offline HLinNC

  • *
  • Posts: 3491
  • FAN REACTION: +133/-24
Re: Is a Recovering Player "defenseless?"
« Reply #13 on: August 05, 2014, 10:29:02 AM »
Quote
The defenseless player only applies to helmet-to-helmet fouls that can now be considered flagrant

I disagree Magician, defenseless applies to more than helmet to helmet hits.


ART. 16 . . . A defenseless player is a player who, because of his physical position and focus of concentration, is especially vulnerable to injury.

I.e.  Receiver, overthrown pass, DB blows up.  WR can be considered defenseless absent any helmet contact.

Targeting & Defenseless are not mutually inclusive as I understand it.

Offline bkdow

  • *
  • Posts: 239
  • FAN REACTION: +9/-3
  • Striving for the impossible level of perfection
Re: Is a Recovering Player "defenseless?"
« Reply #14 on: August 05, 2014, 11:34:03 AM »
I disagree Magician, defenseless applies to more than helmet to helmet hits.


ART. 16 . . . A defenseless player is a player who, because of his physical position and focus of concentration, is especially vulnerable to injury.

I.e.  Receiver, overthrown pass, DB blows up.  WR can be considered defenseless absent any helmet contact.

Targeting & Defenseless are not mutually inclusive as I understand it.

I believe Magician is correct.  The rules do not state what contact against a defenseless player is illegal.  We spent last year in NCAA talking about lowering the target zone, not lowering the level of contact.  The overriding principal that I am going to apply is 9-4-3-g.  Hopefully that will clarify things in my own mind.
"Don't let perfection get in the way of really good." John Lucivansky

Offline AlUpstateNY

  • *
  • Posts: 4846
  • FAN REACTION: +344/-1001
Re: Is a Recovering Player "defenseless?"
« Reply #15 on: August 05, 2014, 11:36:13 AM »
Blowing up a defenseless player in and of itself is not a foul.

Therein lies your problem, "Blowing up a defenseless player" is not only a foul, it's been a foul for the last 50 years.  Doing so is often referred to by it's other name, "Cheap Shot" and is, and has always been something the game does better without. 

It's a problem rule makers have been trying to highlight since the days of leather helmets.  This year's Points of Emphasis explains the effort to correct "Cheap Shots" as, "It is imperative to implement rules that place restrictions on hits to players who are not is a position to defend themselves . It goes further to clarify enforcement stating, "The game official must draw a distinction between contact necessary to make a legal block or tackle, and contact that targets defenseless players."

To assist us, they have provided broad definitions of "Targeting", "Defenseless Players" and added "Flagrant", "Spearing", "Butt Blocking" and "Face Tackling" a few years ago as examples of specific behavior that is simply UNACCEPTABLE.  However, still and likely always to be, the ultimate decision will be made SOLELY by the covering game official who observes the contact.

Along the same lines that the covering official (alone) decides if contact was "avoidable" or whether some behavior caused an "unfair" advantage/disadvantage the decision as to whether the UNIQUE contact YOU are observing was legal/Illegal, necessary/unnecessary, excessive/reasonable and/or rises to the level of being flagrant, or not is all part of the decision YOU, and only you, are responsible to make.

We all know the consequences some of those words create, and that is also part of the instantaneous consideration we are responsible to make.  A "Cheap Shot", however is a cheap shot we are all required to recognize and deal with.  Few things can turn a well played football game into an escalating competition of terror tactics and riot, than an unpunished, or ignored, "Cheap Shot".

This year's Official Manual sums it up clearly, under it's Points of Emphasis"; "Unwarranted and unnecessary punishing of an opponent has become a style of play which is specifically condemned."  Deciding when/whether some behavior is unwarranted, unnecessary, excessive, inappropriate is STILL a decision made (alone) by the covering game official, the language of the rules keeps adjusting to help that decision process.  The Manual also reminds us, "The number 1 responsibility for game officials must be player safety" to help guide our decisions.

Offline FBUmp

  • *
  • Posts: 546
  • FAN REACTION: +77/-38
Re: Is a Recovering Player "defenseless?"
« Reply #16 on: August 05, 2014, 09:23:59 PM »
   After going over the "new" definition of the same old rule in our first meeting of the season this play came up that is done a lot by one of our local teams. An onside kick that is driven hard into the ground so that it rebounds high into the air about 15-yards down field with a member of the receiving team, at this point a potential "recovering" player, not a receiver by rule, is in position to recover the kick. He is looking up at the ball and is then drilled with a legal shoulder-to-the-chest hit blocking him away from the ball so that it may be recovered by Team K.
   Does this meet the definition of a defenseless player? Some think it now does. By rule he is NOT a receiver and anyone who is trying to recover the ball can be legally blocked away despite the severity of the legal hit, in my opinion. Anyone else seeing this?

According to play #20 of the OregonHSAA Targeting video, you can have a defenseless player foul when a player is attempting to recover a fumble or kick. That's not say your specific example is a foul.

Offline Magician

  • *
  • Posts: 1084
  • FAN REACTION: +257/-8
Re: Is a Recovering Player "defenseless?"
« Reply #17 on: August 05, 2014, 09:44:58 PM »
Sorry Al.  That's not entirely true.  An example of a defenseless player is a receiver who has just caught a pass or just missed a pass.  If get's blown-up, it's only a foul if the contact is helmet-to-helmet per the rules.  He's not obviously out of the play so you don't have the general UNR.  The defenseless player is defined, but it is only reference in the rule about illegal helmet contact fouls that could be considered flagrant.  It has nothing to do with targeting.

One example of a play I think should be a foul is the blindside hit on a pursuing defender when the hit is excessive (vague I know).  The hit from the Big Ten Championship game a couple years ago is a good example. It was flagged and supported but many argued it was a legal hit because it was shoulder to chest.  The head was not involved.  It would have taken only slight contact to take the defender out of the play, but the blocker saw an opportunity to blow someone up.  I think we are moving toward that type of play being a foul, and I'm glad the calling official was supported.  But based on current rules that is not a foul.

Offline HLinNC

  • *
  • Posts: 3491
  • FAN REACTION: +133/-24
Re: Is a Recovering Player "defenseless?"
« Reply #18 on: August 05, 2014, 09:48:06 PM »
Magician, you keep saying defenseless only applies to helmet to helmet contact.  The NF rule I copied says no such thing.  Where is this interp coming from?

Offline Magician

  • *
  • Posts: 1084
  • FAN REACTION: +257/-8
Re: Is a Recovering Player "defenseless?"
« Reply #19 on: August 05, 2014, 10:06:40 PM »
Other than the new definition of a defenseless player, the only other place it is referenced is 9-4-3i Note 3.  The notes are the list of illegal helmet contact that are considered flagrant.  It states: "Illegal helmet-to-helmet contact against a defenseless opponent."  It has nothing to do with targeting or other contact on a defenseless player.

Offline Rulesman

  • Past Keeper of the Keys
  • Refstripes Hero
  • *****
  • Posts: 3839
  • FAN REACTION: +65535/-2
  • Live like tomorrow never comes.
Re: Is a Recovering Player "defenseless?"
« Reply #20 on: August 06, 2014, 07:42:07 AM »
An example of a defenseless player is a receiver who has just caught a pass or just missed a pass.  If get's blown-up, it's only a foul if the contact is helmet-to-helmet per the rules. 
Rule reference?
"Gentlemen, we are going to relentlessly chase perfection, knowing full well we will not catch it, because nothing is perfect. But we are going to relentlessly chase it, because in the process we will catch excellence. I am not remotely interested in just being good."
- Vince Lombardi

Offline COLOUMP

  • *
  • Posts: 23
  • FAN REACTION: +0/-1
  • Without officials... it is only recess.
Re: Is a Recovering Player "defenseless?"
« Reply #21 on: August 06, 2014, 09:40:20 AM »
Slide 15 of the 2014 NFHS Football Rules PowerPoint offers this (the bold-underline-red is my emphasis on the original words)...

"Rules 2-32-16 (NEW); 9-4-3i(3)
EXAMPLE: KICK RECEIVER
A kick receiver attempting to catch or recover the ball is considered defenseless."

This seems to read that protection is afforded, but I am still inclined to stick to the Rules and Case Books until our state rules interpreter says otherwise. Slide 2 of that PowerPoint states...

"Each state high school association adopting these NFHS football rules is the sole and exclusive source
of binding rules interpretations for contests involving its member schools. Any person having questions
about the interpretation of NFHS football rules should contact the football rules interpreter designated by his
or her state high school association."



Offline HLinNC

  • *
  • Posts: 3491
  • FAN REACTION: +133/-24
Re: Is a Recovering Player "defenseless?"
« Reply #22 on: August 06, 2014, 10:44:59 AM »
2014-2015 GAME OFFICIALS MANUAL
FOOTBALL POINTS OF EMPHASIS
TARGETING/PLAYER SAFETY/ILLEGAL PERSONAL CONTACT
A primary goal of the NFHS Football Rules Committee continues to be keeping the game of scholastic football as safe as possible. In doing such, a more diligent approach to player safety must be adhered to by all game officials, players, coaches and administrators in order to achieve this goal.
Unsafe acts and techniques cannot be tolerated by those administering and participating in the game of football. Coaches and game officials must act proactively and decisively to eliminate, to the greatest extent possible, threats to the welfare of the student-athletes playing football. Fundamental adherence to current and newly-adopted rules is absolutely required to eliminate negative effects that committing unsafe acts and techniques has placed on our game. Participants must be made aware of unsafe techniques and refrain from their use. Those responsible for the administration of high school football need to exercise leadership and active
supervision of the player safety aspects of the game.
We must recommit ourselves to the preservation of fair play which includes admonishing illegal acts both on the practice field and the field of play. Unwarranted and unnecessary “punishing” of an opponent has become a style of play which is specifically condemned. Illegal helmet contact is an act of initiating contact with the helmet against an opponent and remains a major safety concern in our sport.
The No.1 responsibility for game officials must be player safety. Any initiation of contact with the helmet is illegal; therefore, it must be penalized consistently and without warning. An enhanced approach to player safety is really a matter of attitude, technique, attention and supervision.
Some examples of fouls that merit our extra attention are launching, fouls against players obviously out of the play, helmet-to-helmet contact and fouls against defenseless players. No player shall target and initiate contact against an opponent with the crown (top) of his helmet, and no player shall target and initiate contact to
the area above the shoulders of a defenseless opponent with the helmet, forearm, elbow or shoulder. The launch occurs when a player takes a running start, leaves his feet and uses the helmet to strike the opponent or by crouching and using an upward and forward thrust of the body to make contact above the shoulders of an opponent. It is an extremely dangerous maneuver to both players involved and deserves strict penalty and possible disqualification enforcement if flagrant. The game official must draw distinction between contact necessary to make a legal block or tackle, and that which targets a defenseless player.
The NFHS Game Officials Manual Committee believes that renewed emphasis on getting illegal acts out of the game will greatly improve player safety and preserve the great game of football.

https://nfhs-football.arbitersports.com/Groups/105409/Library/files/2014-2015%20%20NFHS%20Football%20Game%20Officials%20Manual%20Points%20of%20Emphasis.pdf
« Last Edit: August 06, 2014, 10:48:41 AM by HLinNC »

Offline HLinNC

  • *
  • Posts: 3491
  • FAN REACTION: +133/-24
Re: Is a Recovering Player "defenseless?"
« Reply #23 on: August 06, 2014, 10:50:31 AM »
Then there is this- I'm a paid Fed member.  I'm not sure if the link will open for non-members.

http://nfhs.arbitersports.com/front/105401/Rules/Book?rulebookId=358927ac-f517-43ca-91b3-d9f9a43d5c5e&nodeId=b2e36d2d-cc0a-4a32-8af1-e6a0671c1c29

Quote
DEFENSELESS PLAYER
With the importance placed on risk minimization and injuries to the head and neck area, it is imperative to implement rules that place restrictions on hits to players who are not in a position to defend themselves.

In order to properly implement such rules, a new definition for a “defenseless player” was added. The committee has defined a defenseless player “as a player who, because of his/her physical position and focus of concentration, is especially vulnerable to injury.”

Game officials must diligently observe all action for contact against players who are deemed defenseless and penalize illegal personal contact. The game official must draw a distinction between contact necessary to make a legal block or tackle, and contact that targets defenseless players.


 

Offline Magician

  • *
  • Posts: 1084
  • FAN REACTION: +257/-8
Re: Is a Recovering Player "defenseless?"
« Reply #24 on: August 06, 2014, 03:48:52 PM »
I like it.  I just wish they had added some language on the UNR rule to specify this.