The thread has wandered from the original question. I can understand the player vs QB difference and really don’t have a problem with it. The frustration I’m having is that while the rule serves a purpose, the introduction of the rule and the information provided was not comprehensive enough for us to adequately officiate it on the field. We just got the exception in the rule book with no explanation on what to do if the pass is tipped, or we have a foul, etc.
It’s been the same with the last couple rules changes and or additions.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Sure, I understand. I mostly work games with other rules. But I do observe and also work a few subvarsity games when I can. So I understand your frustration.
Sooner or later, you should get official guidance from your state/interpreter/etc. In the meantime, here's how I propose handling this new rule:
- You can't have DPI when the passer throws the ball away. You can have one or the other. It was DPI or else he threw it away.
- However, you can certainly have a Defensive Hold before the ball is thrown.
- If the pass gets within a half yard or so of the LOS, then it's made it. (You will see this called much tighter in college though this year. Due to Replay and all of the cameras, they have to make the line.)
- And in 5-man mechanics, when in doubt, it's made it.
- If an offensive player is clearly blocking downfield, then you could go with OPI. But an IDP (ineligible downfield) might be more appropriate since they ended up dumping it, and that would be my recommendation.
- If somebody other than the QB throws it away, and you have ineligibles downfield, call them for that IDP.
- If the QB legally throws it away, and you have ineligibles downfield, then you have a decision that is going to require a consensus in your state or area. In college, if the QB dumps it out of bounds or near the sideline, IDP is ignored. I like that. But others might disagree for the high school game and say make them do everything legal.
- Remember that if the passer legally throws it away, it doesn't have to go out of bounds. If he gets outside the free blocking zone, he can dump it 40 yds straight downfield.
Well, those are my suggestions. Like I said, sooner or later you're bound to get some official guidance.