Judson/Clemens end

[Reffan13]

Judson and Clemens played week 11 for the last playoff spot. Had a close play on a potential Clemens TD that was waived off. What do you think?

https://www.instagram.com/mrbowtie1982/reel/DQyP9HcCauI/

Have polled a lot of football officials and have a large split on it.

[Whodatboy18]

Touchdown. Don't see any evidence of the ball moving in the hands, receiver "sticks" the catch with his back foot in bounds.

Tough play from a positioning standpoint for the F, action is right at him even though he does have decent distance off the pylon. Significant body movement/rotation at the critical moment doesn't help processing the play. Would be curious if the L, who was in perfect position and should have a prime look at this, had any thoughts.

This is the type of play that get get missed at every level, nothing against these particular officials. That's why its nice to have replay to bail us out.

[dammitbobby]

First off, that dude is an idiot who posts a lot of nonsense... he did not poll his buddies that are HS, CFO, and NFL officials, and they most definitely did not unanimously agree this was an incomplete pass, there is no bobble whatsoever that I can see.

That said, with the hindsight of IR/multiple camera angles/slow motion, I have this as a catch, with his foot down inbounds... but I'm fine with the call on the field as well.

[Grant - AR]

First off, that dude is an idiot who posts a lot of nonsense... he did not poll his buddies that are HS, CFO, and NFL officials, and they most definitely did not unanimously agree this was an incomplete pass, there is no bobble whatsoever that I can see.

That said, with the hindsight of IR/multiple camera angles/slow motion, I have this as a catch, with his foot down inbounds... but I'm fine with the call on the field as well.

dammitbobby, I'm not sure if you have a personal problem with Reffan13 away from here or if someone just crapped in your Cheerios this morning, but we don't need this out here.  As officials, we are the only friends we have...let's keep it that way. 

Reffan13 only has 8 other posts on this forum and none of them would be considered "nonsense" like you mentioned above (in my opinion).  In the initial post in this thread, he stated that he had polled a lot of football officials.  He didn't mention polling CFO or NFL officials so I'm not sure where you came up with that.  Plus, he stated that, when he polled the other officials, they had "a large split on it."  Your response said "they most definitely did not unanimously agree this was an incomplete pass."  The original post has not been edited so nothing has changed since it was posted. 

So, I'm not sure if there is something away from this forum between you and him, but please keep it off this forum.

[Whodatboy18]

Grant,

He was referring to the owner of the instagram page that was shared. If you read the caption of the video you will see what his comment was based upon. It had nothing to do with what Reffan13 said in his post.

[Grant - AR]

Grant,

He was referring to the owner of the instagram page that was shared. If you read the caption of the video you will see what his comment was based upon. It had nothing to do with what Reffan13 said in his post.

That's fine, but comments on Instagram can stay on Instagram and not bleed over here.

[TxJim]

I was R in this game, so anyone here on RS is free to IM me about this play. BTW, it was 4/7@+10 4Q, 5:30ish, tie game, where A chose not to reattempt a FG after enforcement of DOF on the previous play.