Thanks for your well thought out answer. I will ask for the third time: When does a pass, when thrown downfield from behind the NZ actually become ILLEGAL. What are the accepted mechanics that you are using, and how do you handle a forward pass play when the R has a flag down for roughing the passer long prior to the end of the play?
I think we all should lower the temperature on this thread.
Answers to your three questions:
Question 1 - "When does a pass, when thrown downfield from behind the NZ actually become ILLEGAL"? The better question would be "When a pass is thrown downfield from behind the NZ, when is it determined to be LEGAL or ILLEGAL?
Answer 1 - In this answer we will talk specifically about Intentional Grounding (an Illegal Fwd Pass) thrown from behind the NZ. In as much as one can say that an Intentional Grounding is not identified until it is determined that there are no eligible offensive receivers in the area ... the same can be said that we don't know (at the time the pass is thrown) that there ARE eligible receivers in the area to make the pass Legal. We won't know either until the pass ends. When the pass is thrown, it is not, by default, a Legal Fwd Pass and then subsequently changes to an Illegal Fwd Pass when it is determined there are no eligible receivers in the area ... nor does it start off as an Illegal Fwd Pass then subsequently changes to a Legal Fwd Pass when it is determined that ther ARE eligible receivers in the area. It just starts off as a pass ... and the end result of the pass play will determine the legality of the pass ... whether it is legal or illegal - in it's entirety - starting back to when the pass was thrown ... that is the answer. In order to be a Legal Fwd Pass, it must meet the requirements of 7-5-1 plus, as we know, there must also be an eligible receiver in the area. If it meets the conditions of 7-5-2, then it's an Illegal Fwd Pass. This is a similar reguritation to what BSRef stated in his post.
Obviously, if it is a pass thrown from beyond the LOS; a second forward pass during the down; or a forward pass thrown after a change of possession, we will know immediately that it is Illegal and should have a flag down immediately. However, this specific thread answer the Intentional Grounding (Illegal Fwd Pass) thrown from behind the NZ ... per your request.
Question 2 - "What are the accepted mechanics that you are using?"
Answer 2 - It is a long-standing mechanic (since before I started officiating in 1996) that the Intentional Grounding foul belongs to the Referee and once it is determined by his fellow officials that there is no eligible receivers in the area, the Referee will drop a flag after the play. If I have a suspicion that there may be Intentional Grounding, I will drop a bean bag at the spot where the pass was thrown then confer with my covering officials and, I'll drop a flag once we determine it is Intentional Grounding.
The
NFHS 2026-2027 Football Game Officials Manual pg. 146 states: "Only the Referee flags Intentional Grounding, but because he won't see where the ball landed, he’ll need help from another game official. Other members of the crew should immediately volunteer information regarding whether or not the ball was thrown into an area occupied by an eligible offensive receiver. If the Referee does not throw his flag and is told the ball went into an area not occupied by an eligible offensive receiver,
it is appropriate to throw a late flag, which should be “soft tossed” to the spot of the pass”.
Question 3 - How do you handle a forward pass play when the R has a flag down for roughing the passer long prior to the end of the play?
Answer 3 - This answer is a hybrid of answers 1 and 2. When the Referee sees the roughing he gets a flag down for RTP. After the play the covering official brings the Referee the information that there was no eligible receiver in the area … making the pass Intentional Grounding. Now, we don’t have RTP because the QB was not a passer (a person that throws a legal forward pass). So, we only have Intentional Grounding. In this specific scenario, I wouldn’t drop a second flag only to wave off one of them … instead I would simply announce that the pass was an illegal forward pass therefore there is no RTP … followed by the signaling of the ING.
As stated before in a couple different posts, you can’t have RTP on an Illegal Fwd Pass. However, if the contact by the defender rises to a PF, you could certainly charge the defender with a PF. If that is the case, you now have a double foul situation and will replay the down.
These are, what I believe to be, correct answers to your questions. Perhaps Ralph would care to opine on this.
Now, we would like to see your answer to Steely Dan’s request: “Please cite the rules or case book references that discuss the legal portion of an illegal forward pass”.