Replay

[TxSkyBolt]

I'd like to see it on a limited basis.  Catch/no catch, fumble, all turnovers and all scoring plays.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

[TXMike]

Only if they guarantee guys who worked HS all year are the onfield officials

[JasonTX]

Only if they guarantee guys who worked HS all year are the onfield officials

You would see a mass walkout of HS officials if they took away the championship games from us HS officials.

[TXMike]

Roger that. I can find another way to waste. 30 hrs a week

[TxSkyBolt]

It's immeasurably more important for the RO to know replay rules than the on field officials. I'm sure they'd use a college RO, field officials would be HS. 


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[TXMike]

Disagree.  If you do not adjust the way you officiate some plays you effectively limit IR ability to help

[TxSkyBolt]

I'm gonna boo you again.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Timer]

IR is certainly going to get a lot of discussion in the off season.
I think that if IR comes "only" to a certain game, i.e. the SC's, the rules committee would write exceptions to simplify the process.  But, as we know from college IR, it can still get messed up.
In the Argyle/Navasota game how would IR have ruled on:
1.  the fumble into the EZ
2.  the TD catch

1.  Touchback
2.  Incomplete pass

[clearwall]

Yep but none of them have the connections to UIL and TASO that would be required

The SEC does...

[Welpe]

You would see a mass walkout of HS officials if they took away the championship games from us HS officials.

No you won't. There are plenty of officials that know they'll never work a state final and won't want to give up their regular season varsity schedules. It is every man for himself out there and seeing who signed up after the UIL demanded registration before that all got cleared up was proof of that.

I have no doubt IR will be here soon. There's too much on the line and too much money involved for them not to implement it.

[Coby]

Go pros on helmets every member of crew wears them.  Recorded to iPad on sideline.  Streamed to TxMike house where he can decide the outcome.  Then he text the crew the answer.  It will be quicker then the time it takes to reset the game clock.

UIL and Taso can then sale the viewing rights over an app and make lots of money.  Coaches will like the camera angles from oline dline play.

[Etref]

No you won't. There are plenty of officials that know they'll never work a state final and won't want to give up their regular season varsity schedules. It is every man for himself out there and seeing who signed up after the UIL demanded registration before that all got cleared up was proof of that.

I have no doubt IR will be here soon. There's too much on the line and too much money involved for them not to implement it.

I didn't sign up and most I know did not

[TXMike]

Agree. The numbers who signed up were miniscule. More than I would have wanted to see but still miniscule.  For me it is not about taking away any chance I have of getting the state game. I know I do not have that chance anyway for a variety of reasons.  For me it is about respect.  By summarily throwing our guys to the side they would be showing huge disrespect to all that we do YEAR ROUND to make Texas HS football what it is.  That may not affect some folks, but for me it is inexcusable. 

Dallas Morning News article re replay for HS :   http://www.dallasnews.com/sports/high-schools/headlines/20141220-debate-for-instant-replay-at-uil-state-finals-continues-after-several-controversial-game-impacting-calls.ece

[TXMike]

I don't see us being able to stop this train.  Hopefully we can help guide it but it is coming unless coaches beat it down.   

[Birddog]

Watch them implement IR but not require that a 7 man crew be used. 

[TXMike]

That would definitely be par for the course.   I am more concerned that they will require 7 man crews but require they have had experience all year working in IR games.  Read between those lines.