Recent Posts

Pages: [1] 2 3 4 5 6 ... 10
1
National Federation Discussion / Re: Intentional Grounding - Still Accurate
« Last post by NVFOA_Ump on Yesterday at 06:41:39 AM »
Grounding has moved away from "reserved to the referee" to be more of a committee call.  Also, this is incomplete because the out of pocket and line of scrimmage exception only applies to the guy who took the snap, so that should be added.


Agreed, but "moved away" isn't really accurate.  An intentional Grounding call has almost always required more than one official to provide information on the call, but the final decision and subsequent flag belong exclusively to the R.
2
National Federation Discussion / Re: Roughing The Passer, Or Something Else?
« Last post by BSRef on November 20, 2026, 02:35:50 PM »
This is where I am.  If a player earned a RTF, but it ended up being an illegal pass, he still earned an UNR foul.  I can't see a circumstance where I threw a flag for an earned RTF and then just waving it off.

I agree you wouldn't. The prohibition against RTP in 9-4-4 says you can't "commit any illegal personal contact foul listed in 9-4-3 against the passer." Everything in 9-4-3 is a PF and you'd call it a PF no matter who it happened to. Being against the passer just elevates the PF to an RTP and carries the eforced from the end of the run provision. So, if an IG negates the RTP, you still have a PF and should not pick up the flag.
3
National Federation Discussion / Re: Intentional Grounding - Still Accurate
« Last post by lawdog on November 20, 2026, 12:14:59 PM »
Grounding has moved away from "reserved to the referee" to be more of a committee call.  Also, this is incomplete because the out of pocket and line of scrimmage exception only applies to the guy who took the snap, so that should be added.
4
National Federation Discussion / Re: KCI or K ball
« Last post by SCHSref on November 20, 2026, 12:06:56 PM »
It’s not technically a foul (we drop a bean bag instead of a flag), but it acts like one.  Unless R subsequently fouls or there is an accepted foul on either team, R has the right to take possession at the spot.

So, if R fumbles and K recovers on an attempted return, R can still keep the ball.  Sounds like a penalty to me.

I'm just saying it's not a foul. There is no flag thrown and no warning or yardage. That's all
5
National Federation Discussion / Re: Roughing The Passer, Or Something Else?
« Last post by riffraft on November 20, 2026, 10:23:11 AM »
Thanks to Froggy and BSRef for taking the time to think this through.  This season, my 28th, I have got to see too many games from the clock operators view due to some health issues and have noticed at least 3 instances of "different" handling of RTP flags when we have a later IG call.  The play in this thread was one of them.  I note that in none of the 3 did the R "pick-up" the RTP flag, but in two of them the R simply announced offsetting fouls PF + IG.  I did discuss one of the calls with the R who has been a college official for years and has done division III championship games in the past and his view was that he is never going to "pick-up" the RTP flag.  His explanation was if the RTP flag was duly earned, then by rule it has to be at least UNR, as after the pass if the "PASSER" is no longer the "PASSER" then he fits the player obviously out of the play definition.  Just trying to sort out how other R's handle this since it seems to happen rarely.  Thanks again, and when hopefully I'm back in the R slot next season, I have a better handle on this.

This is where I am.  If a player earned a RTF, but it ended up being an illegal pass, he still earned an UNR foul.  I can't see a circumstance where I threw a flag for an earned RTF and then just waving it off.
6
Texas Topics / Re: Proposal coming for home playoff games
« Last post by dammitbobby on November 20, 2026, 10:09:17 AM »
I would love that drive, by myself... I can certainly appreciate the value and importance of crew fellowship in driving to and from a site, but my favorite, most effective pregame is me driving a few hours by myself, listening to the now-defunct Rule 11 rules podcasts.
7
Texas Topics / Re: Proposal coming for home playoff games
« Last post by ElvisLives on November 20, 2026, 08:23:00 AM »
Back in my FBS days, I would usually have at least one assignment per season at UTEP in El Paso. That’s a 6-hour drive from my home. Considering there are no direct flights from here to El Paso, and, with a layover at DFW, the total time involved in the flying process was about the same as driving. And, if I wanted to get to El Paso early enough on Fridays to get in a round of golf, it was easier to just drive. And, that was back before I retired from my business, so I could still be reached (disturbed) by phone while sitting in the airports.
So, one trip, I decided to just drive to El Paso. Cell phone service was not as extensive as it is today, and I discovered that it was 6-hours of pure peace and quiet. I got to where I looked forward to the drives to/from El Paso.
Ah, the good ol’ days.
8
National Federation Discussion / Intentional Grounding - Still Accurate
« Last post by NVFOA_Ump on November 20, 2026, 07:14:17 AM »
The attachment is several years old and would appreciate feedback on it's current accuracy.  Thanks!
9
National Federation Discussion / Re: Roughing The Passer, Or Something Else?
« Last post by NVFOA_Ump on November 20, 2026, 06:29:58 AM »
Thanks to Froggy and BSRef for taking the time to think this through.  This season, my 28th, I have got to see too many games from the clock operators view due to some health issues and have noticed at least 3 instances of "different" handling of RTP flags when we have a later IG call.  The play in this thread was one of them.  I note that in none of the 3 did the R "pick-up" the RTP flag, but in two of them the R simply announced offsetting fouls PF + IG.  I did discuss one of the calls with the R who has been a college official for years and has done division III championship games in the past and his view was that he is never going to "pick-up" the RTP flag.  His explanation was if the RTP flag was duly earned, then by rule it has to be at least UNR, as after the pass if the "PASSER" is no longer the "PASSER" then he fits the player obviously out of the play definition.  Just trying to sort out how other R's handle this since it seems to happen rarely.  Thanks again, and when hopefully I'm back in the R slot next season, I have a better handle on this.
10
Texas Topics / Re: Proposal coming for home playoff games
« Last post by dammitbobby on November 19, 2026, 11:20:31 PM »
Oh man, not me, I hate being a passenger, LOL. I'll drive every chance I get, even if it's just me.
Pages: [1] 2 3 4 5 6 ... 10